Reader comments
2 of 3 Utah congressmen vote no on bill
165 comments | Read story
While I agree that Congress is responsible for part of the mess in the 1st place, for requiring loans to higher risk homeowners, it isn't that simple. The Fed lowered rates for long enough for many people to get lower, variable rate loans, and then the feds raised the rates, 3% in a short few months. That caused many people to not be able to afford the loans. They started failing, and housing values, due to the forclosures, started sliding, which made it worse. Sub-prime mortgages, were like hot potatoes, and no one wanted them. Banks couldn't loan more, as they had these loans they couldn't even sell.
In Utah, that has started to slow down construction financing, and other business loans. When they can't get credit, the companies start failing. Other industries have been effected.
If they buy up the worst of the sub-prime mortgages, (There are reportedly $2 Trillion of them) and interest rates are kept low by the Fed, and most homeowners/taxpayers pay back the loans, the government and the tax payers will be OK.
Live within your means!
Thank you again
First off, let me just say that I think the whole bailout offer stinks from the inside out; however, the alternative to not bailing out the banks is a lot worse - the entire banking industry could completely collapse, along with the entire financial market. So, not only would the companies fail that made the made decisions, but many other companies would fail as well since they cannot borrow the money they need to carry them until payments come in. The borrow in the short run. But, if that money dries up, one of two things can happen - either they raise prices, or they close stores, which translates into lost jobs.
I agree people should live within their means. But, for better or worse, the US economy lives on credit.
It was really a no win solution I think. This is the very type of situation that requires our Representatives to put politics aside.
Oh wait, that's right we already did! smile.
Hurray for they house defeating this bailout!
I am a red republican, but Chris Cannon, I never voted for you... Your democrat predicessor was the right guy for the job.
I have usually voted Republican, however I have respected and voted for Matheson. His caving in here is causing me to re-think my vote. Pass the bailout!! If you have reservations, you can tweak it later on. We need this before financial panic sets in!
This is going to kill mainstreet.
As an average citizen we just cant say "wallstreet needs to take responsibility".
Wake up!!
When you don't have a job, or your small business can't get a loan, and your daily expenditures are still climbing in cost you will wish this bill was passed.
HUH??
This is mutiny and purposeful sabotage.
They should be all fired.
On economic policy, don't do what your constituents want. That's like a Calculus teacher dropping the curriculum because his 3rd grader doesn't understand what's being taught.
We aren't entitled to ANYTHING! Americans in general are spoiled brats, we need to learn how to live without mommy and daddy (govt) always bailing us out when we make mistakes.
GOOD FOR THE PEOPLE!!!
UTAH REPUBLICANS...DONT CRY!!! IT WAS BETTER, YOU WILL LEARN SOMEDAY!!!
Yes, the short term pain might be lessened by taking the "easier" road. But the long term consequences are far far worse. I would liken it to the quick buck or the quick benefit a lie can get you. But we all know it catches up and the consequences are worse when it does than the benefit will yield. To have "strong fundamentals" in the economy like they were saying a few months ago we have to build it right.
You can't build a good economy with shortcuts. We need to stand up, be men, and do the right thing. Let's go through this recession and have new industry players come in and clean up where the old/bad ones screwed up.
Print our way out of it and we'll be looking at $10 gasoline in no time.
Seriously, do any of you have any idea what is going on in the economy? A vote against this bill is a vote for a market collapse. Yes, the bailout stinks and the banks who would be bailed out really do not deserve to be bailed out; however, doing nothing will result in a complete collapse of the banking industry and the entire economy.
Most people do not want this bailout and are against it; however, those who are educated on the facts of the bill recognize what the result will be if we do nothing. Nobody wants this bailout, but most realize the need for the bailout. So, you swallow the bitter bill and move on.
Please understand the issues of the day before you make uneducated comments.
It would cost the same as the Wall Street bailout. And it would solve the mortgage crisis.
(Oh, I'm so confused! I'm on the Deseret News message board so I need to make a wild accusation about somebody, but I don't know who!)
It�s nice to see that there some in D. C. who understands that the "cure" is significantly worse than disease and that Congress is selling our financial souls to the Devil by passing this piece of criminal legislation. The markets must be allowed to work this issue out without government intervention.
Housing prices must be allowed to fall for economic health and long-term stability to be realized. If the market can set the price on the way up, it has to be allowed to set it on the way down.
Companies who aren�t leveraged to the hilt and individuals who can demonstrate an ability to repay their loan will be able to secure loans. That�s the way it should be.
This bailout will maintain inflated markets, broken financial systems, encourage reckless behavior, and create an even bigger problem in the very near future. However, a natural recession now will allow the market to purge and correct itself.
The Great Depression was not averted because of the lack of intervention by our government. Japan languished in stagflation for almost a decade because all they did is print money. Sweden actually did something very similar to our current plan and salvaged their markets.
I was glad to move to a more reasonable state that actually has common sense and political balance. It now pains me to see that the idiocy of Utah politics affecting the rest of the country.
A crunch will effect us all, but let's face it, we've been living on consumerism and trumped up paper profits for far too long.
Rice and beens 4 a year! No biggie!
Cannon, I voted against you in the primary and I look forward to you and your staff being unemployed in 3 months. Cannon the closet Democrat comes out finally he voted with the Democrats to protect the big boys and shaft us. Even Matheson listened to us the taxpayers and voted no.
I doubt a problem of this magnitude can be solved in three weeks. It requires more thoughts by the best minds out there in business, labor and the citizenry in general. This plan is happening too fast. The stock market drop, as well as this plan, just proves that we in America are reactive rather than (critically) proactive. We need to calm down and think this through and possibly proceed with a economic plan.
700 billion would only net 3-4,000 to each man and woman, not 300-400k. Do the math and start reading e-mail with the critical thinking switch turned on.
In Utah we've got food storage!
BANKING ON HEAVEN . COM
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- RSL trades Seitz to Philadelphia 8:44 p.m.
- World datelines 8:34 p.m.
- Muslim pilgrims face rain, flu threat 8:33 p.m.
- Israel offers short halt in building 8:33 p.m.
- 7 charged in Mumbai attacks 8:33 p.m.
- Obama to unveil Afghan decision 8:33 p.m.
- Taliban leader rules out Karzai talks 8:32 p.m.
- Dobbs weighs Senate run 8:32 p.m.
- Atlantis leaves space station 8:32 p.m.
- No bad side effects from vaccine? 8:31 p.m.
- Donny and Kym dance to victory
- Howard made the rivalry a rivalry
- Crews free man in Utah County cave
- Cougars cruise past Southern
- Loyal to Cougarettes, Crimson Line
- Twitterati to BCS: 'We hate you.'
- Y. focused on 10-win season
- BYU has slim shot at BCS
- Thunder rolls by Jazz
- Witness describes '99 killing
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
258 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?
227 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
207 - RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks
202 - Bronco, Kyle rubber match
139 - BYU records with win
133 - Letters: Rushing to judge Palin
129 - Boys basketball rankings
106 - Hall, Johnson matchup key
102 - Thunder rolls by Jazz
102
They (Utah and BYU), were both schooled this year by none other than TCU. The...
I don't want to see any emotional crybabies, after BYU gets their tails kicked.
Riverton has always been, that is why they worry about Bingham
They would both look better in red.
I wouldn't say BYU is scared to play in Logan, but I don't think they can...
What?? We haven't eliminated it yet? Well this certainly should work. On...
I use to go in mines all the time in Ut and I have been in that cave befor,...
Re: Bingham Fan You should rethink your title matchup, it will be...
Wow, I better go check the straightness of my license plate right now. Davis...
Hands down. He held No. 2 NFL draft pick Paul Kruger on the road in check all...



This bill was bad from the beginning. By killing it they force the House Democrats and our big government lov'n President to do something better.
The House GOP floated the idea of lending the money at a nominal 2% interest rate and let the banks settle their own bad debt. Or better yet, we do the bailout but NOT buy the debt, the US Treasury acts as an investor. Any profits goes right to paying off debt.
Best idea, let this settle itself out. Today we watched another bank go under, Wachovia. It did not get a bailout but instead was bought by Citigroup. Wachovia was one of the largest banks in the world, top 5 in the US.
Market forces have settled Lehman Brothers, now Wachovia, and even Wamu. These will work just fine.
The risk of the bailout is the complete failure of the dollar. In either case, people are going to lose illusory money based on home values that were never really there.
I want the Community Reinvestment Act ended.