Reader comments
East Carolina Pirates storm Top 25; BYU drops and Utes stay at 22
116 comments | Read story
- Page:
- < Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next >
each undefeated, only one will be in a BCS game while an unranked ACC team and 2+ loss teams from the SEC and PAC-10 get in.
Unfortunately, the six conferences run the BCS system to keep the money not to reward the best teams or to crown a true champion.
unfortunatley i think utah is going to hammer usu by a score of 68-10.
but ill still be there cheering the ags on
GO AGGIES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I don't know why people are complaining about PAC 10 officials...they are blatently biased and everyone who plays against a Pac 10 school knows it. This why in the days of the Big 10 - PAC 10 Rosebowl they had to us officials from another conference.
Too bad BYU fans have to live in that magical world. What will they do when the curtian is pulled? When last minute/second plays fall together.
Both Utah and BYU just need to keep winning, and maybe running up the score a little, and the rankings will take care of themselves. Fans of each school should at least hope that the rival school continues to win. It will make the victor of the November game that much more impressive. Go UTES!!!
2. It's too bad UCLA fell out after a bye week as a top 25 win Saturday would have helped our cause.
3. Let's ease back on our famous persecution complex Cougs - we stayed at 15 (USA Today) and dropped in the same way Ohio State did (AP) after what in reality was an unimpressive first 2 games. We were lucky to stay at 15.
4. Our offense could move against ANY team in the nation. But our offense still needs to score more points to keep a step ahead of a young and growing defense. Just like last season, our scoring lags behind our offensive statistical domination thanks to penalties and untimely turnovers.
5. Our preseason ranking reflected respect for our program. But the success of East Carolina, Fresno State, Utah and TCU means we can't continue to just squeeze out a win (Washington) or play below what we should (NIU). Dominate UCLA!!
U of WA should win 3 or more games this year (look at their schedule). U of WA also was not a good match up for the BYU Defense as it spread them out and took away the team aspect of the Defense. Further, Locker had no one with direct coverage for just him.
MI looks weak and no reason to believe that UT is better than BYU. There are a lot of teams ahead of both schools in the polls who will lose 2 or more games.
BYU almost always starts slow. They do not seem to be dominating like the some of the Edwards teams but they are managing to win. Consistently winning will carry you a long ways in the polls.
Further, parity tends to make it very hard to consistently win. A lot of Big Name teams lack depth and will lose as they get injuries.
I watched a so-so So. Florida demolish WVa and Pat white last year, so why should WVa be ranked 8th this year?? And now, why should theeee OH-state-U be ranked 5th if they barely beat a crappy school that U-Wyoming throttled the week before??
Go UTES (figure the consistency thing out, pleeeeze) and Go Cougs until Nov22!
So much for that high and lofty goal. BCS is simply BS.
Let's take take care of business and take it to UCLA next week. Ohio State will have to prove itself on the biggest stage yet.
We all have to realize that at the end of the day, in order to be a BCS buster, you have to go undefeated. So far BYU, Utah, and Fresno St., are on their way. We will have to see if Utah can get past the month of October without losing a game (since they usually lose atleast one in October). I think that with each game BYU's defense will improve. They are young on that side of the ball. Definately their offense needs to carry them.
So, give it a rest!
You have beaten nobody. Michigan could barely pull of a win against Miami of Ohio and you could only score three points against them in the second half. Then you stunk in the 1st half against....UNLV?!!! You haven't put a "top 25" game together yet.
At Washington that ball was launched so high, Locker had time to chest bump one player and hug another before it came down and hit him on the shoulder. What's so funny is that exact celebration is spelled out in detail in the rules, Lockers celebration was a model for what the rule book was warning against. The real lesson is that Locker made an inexperienced error and cost his team a chance at overtime.
I don't think the Y should have moved up but definitely not down. But keeping yapping utes, saying stuff like after you beat USU you'll be in the top 10. Man you guys get full of your selves fast. And you haven't even won the conference title in three years. You really stink.
Um, why would the Utes get invited to the B(S)C dance if BYU runs the table? How would a selection committee ever justify taking the Utes over the undefeated team that beat them in the last game of each school's season? That makes zero sense, wouldn't you think?
BYU moved up last week because some of the teams ahead of them lost. This week they move down because a lot of media types don't understand the rule book and the difficulty of playing in front of 75000 screaming fans. I was listening on the radio and I could tell before the announcers said anything when something good happened for Washington. It was that loud. Playing on the road is always tough in college football. The media types forget that and get too focused on the "superiority on paper" stuff. Good teams find ways to win. BYU did that on Saturday; and, if they keep doing that, the polls will take care of themselves.
1st: BYU just barely beat Washington, so a little drop may in in order
2nd: I don't like the announcers saying BYU won by a penalty. If the PAT fell short, then you could make that call. The PAT was blocked! If it was made from the 1 inch line, the result would've been the same unless the kicker moved up some for fear they couldn't make the kick. As that kick is still pretty much a "chip shot", I'm betting he was just as far back from the line of scrimmage as he normally is. BYU won the game fair and square.
I'm a Ute fan by the way. I like to see the MWC do good. I do think BYU should've made a more convincing win. They probably had their "heads in the clouds" thinking it was going to be a "walk in the park". Better luck on UCLA.
The thing that mystifies me, however, are the Ute fans posting on this thread. One major difference I've noted over the years between Ute fans and Cougar fans: Cougar fans recognize that it's in our best interest for Utah to win every game up until the big one, climbing in the rankings the whole time--that way when we beat them, we climb higher in the polls. I cheer for Utah every game and love to see them stomp their opponents until they come to us--then it's pure rivalry. In that sense, I don't discriminate between them and any of our opponents--I want them to win every game both before and after BYU. It's in the Cougars best interest.
Most Ute fans, on the other hand, would rather cut off their nose to spite their face. They allow their hatred for anything BYU to get in the way of boosting their rankings. How dumb is that? (And what a sour way to live your life--go figure...)
The Utes have beaten the spread in both games. Thus, they've done more than expected. That's why they are climbing and you are falling. Get used to it.
Last week all we heard was that BYU would dominate and that Locker wasn't anything special. Blah blah.
The fact is, the best team with a shot at BCS is East Carolina. They have a very weak schedule the rest of the season and are the highest in the rankings.
BYU fans better start cheering for Utah to do very well the rest of the year and hope they can beat the Utes on the road. That is their only chance for BCS this year.
Of course, after they lose to UCLA this week, it won't matter and all we will hear is how the Mountain West officials were awful and cost them the game.
Um....should I act shocked or should I laugh?
On a side note, I hope they do something to honor Norm Chow at the game next week. He's as legendary as LE here and should be the person to carry the flag with this new tradition, methinks.
Reading these posts is like listening to the game on 1160, hearing those whiney ex-zoobes cry about no-calls and bad calls.
I am sooo glad that this call was on Washington and did not go against the zoobes. You guys would have been calling your congressmen, crying in your funeral potatoes...
Control the things you can control, and let the rest of the world talk about them.
BYU held onto 14 in USA today.
It's still nice to be in the top twenty.
I do not like the call against Locker. I do agree that it should have been called because it is pretty clear in the rule book but I think it is a stupid rule and should be taken out. Why would throwing a ball into the air be unsportsmanlike? What if the guys runs to the stands and throws the ball to a fan? Is that a penalty? I don't think so. The call needed to be made but the rule needs to be changed. Great block on the PAT though!!!
1. Lou Holtz had plenty of reason to talk down BYU's squeaker on ESPN as it benefits his son Skip at ECU. Lou won a national championship at Notre Dame and played for two at Arkansas (The voters skipped Notre Dame past him once and he lost in the Sugar Bowl to Alabama) so he has real gravitas. Lee Corso can't make any similar claims. That being said, Lou is still biased against BYU.
2. BYU's win was a milestone, you have to start winning non-conference road games somewhere, sometime, and this win, while it was far from perfect, qualifies.
3. BYU fans shouldn't worry about Ohio State ranking - the pollsters know that the Buckeyes' measure will be taken in full next Saturday.
4. UCLA was penalized for not playing - BYU gets a shot at them. If BYU wins, it will likely make up lost ground in the polls.
- Page:
- < Previous
- 1
- 2
- 3
- Next >
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- SEC widens BofA, Merrill probe 1:48 p.m.
- 6 suspended in ignored patient case 1:37 p.m.
- New Irish coach Brian Kelly 1:10 p.m.
- Wall Street regulatory overhaul 1:08 p.m.
- Health care tab to keep growing 12:57 p.m.
- Dr. explains Mitchell review change 12:50 p.m.
- Choir event 'experience to remember' 12:48 p.m.
- Cable falls on I-80, closing lanes 12:36 p.m.
- Iraq blasted over Iran exile treatment 12:27 p.m.
- Draft: Rich nations' emission cuts 12:19 p.m.
- Letters: Global warming a lie
263 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
207 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
194 - Palin signs books, chats with fans
169 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
151 - Cougars going back to Vegas
150 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
142 - Nude bathers cited for lewdness
131 - Max Hall wants to look ahead
128 - Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
110
Jacoby Walker, a quarterback from Westfield High School in Houston, has...
Utah State signed three players a little while back and we've got some...
I think we all know the real reason that violence against women is such a...
@Agki 4:39 a.m.: "There are hundreds more that a short literature review...
"It's possible to be fooled. … I don't think it happened here," Skeem...
9?? did I read right, 9?? why was this guy ever let out after 4 or 5?
wow, that was intelligent. Radioactive material is responsible for a good...
#1 "The quickest and broadast tax cut ever" is the "Reinvestment and Recovery...
Apparently Skeem doesn't understand the role dishonesty and narcissism can...
@12:08 - The tithing of the church pays for buildings, teaching materials,...
Chuck said, "I would like to quote a simple verse from the Bible: "By...
I hate Max Hall. I hate everything about him. Touche

