Reader comments
Rise of 'unknown' Palin is meteoric and historic

168 comments   |   Read story

Lew Jeppson | 1:08 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
This may be a masterstroke or a dud on McCain's part. Alaska has produced some mighty interesting (and high quality) politicos through the years - most recently Mike Gravel. This will be interesting.
JTM | 1:06 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I like Sarah palin so far. However, we're voting for president, and the top of the ticket is more important. I just don't know what the Republicans are offering. Seriously, does anyone know ANY of their ideas and plans? We need to switch things up in order to keep everyone honest, and that's why Obama is a better choice this time. If he fails in office, then we can vote him out in 4 years, but I think he's worth the chance.
Great choice | 1:30 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I know some Utahns will be disappointed with McCain's choice, but I think it will be a major boost to the ticket.

If Gov Palin can deliver even 10% of disgruntled Hillary supporters, that should be enough to win the election.

When the Democrats say she lacks the experience to be VP, they are digging their own grave for the even less experienced Obama.

When Democrats talk about creating equal opportunities for women, they will have to answer why Obama passed over several capable women and picked an old white guy to be his running mate.

If the Democrats point out that Palin comes from a small, obscure state, the counter is Biden is from Delaware.

There's also probably not a whole lot of dirt to be found on a newcomer from Alaska.
Comments continue below
Halloween... | 1:36 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Came early this year for liberals- BOO!!! An intelligent, attractive, articulate, genuine, red-blooded, American female swoops in to profit from the mess created by "The One" when he chose like-minded liberal Biden. The worst part for liberals: the more Americans get to know Palin, the more they will like her, unlike "The One," who has consistently lost popularity the more the public gets to know him. "The One" enjoyed a predictable bounce this week in the polls which will be permanently decimated moving forward.
Wasillan | 1:46 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Well written story and very accurate with the exception of the subtitle. It's been a little longer then two years since she was the Mayor. Alaska will miss her if she is elected.
Ridgerunner | 2:49 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Wow! What a woman! She reminds me of my wife!
From Alaska | 3:06 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Sarah has been a great govenor so far - the best we've had in years. I am glad to hear that McCain chose her. I am a Republican but was kind of disappointed when Hilary lost, simply because the idea of a woman president is historic. But this gives us someone who is young, bright and conservative. Who knows, she might end up in Washington for 4 terms. I overheard a fellow Alaska express to his friend over the phone today that Sarah could out-fish, out-hike, out-hunt, out-snowmachine, out-do any of those guys in Washington. He just might be right. Go Sarah!
rvalens2 | 3:11 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I like this pick by McCain. I've seen Palin speak on several occasions and she's an impressive lady. She's also a lot tougher than people think. (Think Margaret Thatcher here.)

Re: JTM

Voting Obama out in 4 years may be too late for US. We have some serious situations occurring around the World. I don't want to get in a fracas with Russia or Iran knowing we have a neophyte running things in the White House.
E.H | 4:27 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I would have preferred Romney because I believe he cares so much about this Country that he has willing to spend his time and resources to Elect John Mc Cain even though he done everything he could to derail Romney from getting the Nomination. He didn�t work alone Huckabee was by his side all the way. I do like Mc Cains choice because I heard her acceptance speech. I think she is serious about making big changes in Washington. Palin Has got it all together. She is a real conservative and John Mc Cain better be serious about straighten out Washington or he will have a real fighter on his Tail.
Palin Rocks! | 5:38 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I have admired Governor Palin for a short while now. It's interesting that McCain (or a savvy staffer) seems to have cued in that the libertarian swing vote is at least mildly important.

Obama just lost this one. Take a polaroid, B.O., cuz this race is over. It was a brilliant move by John McDull, something I did not think him capable of. This race finally got interesting.

Can we all hope that shortly after this election that McCain finds himself utterly unable to perform the office of president and that Mrs. Palin will lead America? Yes, that is all we can hope for at this point.
Well Played | 5:46 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
While I'm disappointed that Romney is not on the ticket; McCain well played his options and convinced me to vote for him this fall. He really showed hhis maverick image with Palin as his VP. From what little I know about Palin I find her a gutsy woman in the Orlene Walker mold and I loved Walker in her short time as our governor. The one item that I know of about her that made national news was her pregancy of her youngest son and she showed what she was made of because she wouldn't temporarally give up her powers as governor to have her baby. Woman who play the helpless female card and can't do nothing while they are with child is a real turn off to me. What she did while carrying her child and giving birth says a lot to me about her character.
lost in DC | 5:56 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
JTM, we know nothing of BO's plans besides generalities. If knowing what they are actually going to do is a reason to vote for someone, we have no reason to vote for either, beacause they are both short on specifics. BO says he's going to get us off foreign oil in 10 years. How? he's going to throw $150B of our money at it. He's going to reform health care. How? He's going to catch Bin Laden (you know, that guy the Sudanese offered to Slick Willy but Slick said no thanks) How? BO makes these great pronouncements but offers no idea how he's going to do them - probably because he has no idea.
Fairbanksan | 6:11 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Gov. Palin is a lot of things, most of them good, but one thing she is not: she is not the Republican candidate for president. Chances are good that Palin will have less of a say in a McCain administration than Biden would in an Obama administration. Her primary role will be to help McCain win the White House, not to help him govern the country.
Palin: smart but insufficient | 6:13 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
For McCain this was a smart choice. And yet many people--including myself-- see this as a cynical attempt at scoring vote of the disgruntled Hillary supporters. Palin's positions on the issues, however, are almost diametrically opposite to those of Hillary Clinton, so she might not really help McLame.

It should not go unnoticed that Palin is an evangelical, which should help McCain lock up the Huckabigot vote.

In the end, I believe the Bush administration's abject failure will be an albatross too heavy for McCain and Palin to bear. Obama wins this election handily.
Kat | 6:28 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I am thrilled that a real red-blooded, strong American woman is selected as VP. It really was a master stroke for McCain. When the Dems say that Repubicans do not understand the issues, like the war or abortion, because the have not 'been there or done that' their answer is a mother of a soldier and of a special needs child, who has had to make those tough choices of what to support.And a card carrying member of the NRA, that just aggravates the Dems to no end.I am so impressed that she can take her child to work and breastfeed her child and work hard to support our nation. They cannot even say anything about lack of experience, since she has about as much as Obama. I have been so depressed about our upcoming elections, and this has been the shot in the arm the republicans need to win this November.Someone not afraid to choose the right and strongly support her government.God Bless her family as she goes through the national political process.
Tooele Repub | 6:39 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Sarah is a great choice! I think the democrats are upset as the announcement took away Obama's thunder. She has more management skills than the top of the ticket on their side.
JTM....just go to McCain's site and read what his plans and thoughts are. As you heard from Palin, they are much more realistic than filling up our tires and tuning up our cars and pledging to be off oil in ten years....something that is ridiculous...Are Oprah and Obama buying America new cars too????
Sarah is the one to help John run the country and I can't wait to see her against Pelosi......RRRRRRRRowwwwww
MyKind | 7:07 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Now, that's my kind of politician - a real person with common sense. I wish she was the top of the ticket.
Realist | 7:23 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
From bad to awful.If the national news would quit harping on the phrase"Heros" the comments on the two candidates may be believable.McCain on his 5.5 years of captivity and her on rearing a Down syndrome chid.Neither one has any relevancy to running a great nation!
Pat | 7:26 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
JTM (above) asks what we know about McCain because it matters regarding what we can expect from him & what he plans to DO? AND suggests that Obama is so far a "better choice" because of that? It is obvious that JTM does not read much, does mot pay much attention to what these political people have DONE, fought for (not in the military aspect!) nor DONE. Over past DECADES McCain has LIVED a rare and lonely BATTLE in D.C. to STOP wasteful spending, crooked alliances and selfish "me first" individuals. anyone who has half-way kept up with our gov`t knows that even though McCain`s stands on things have made him VERY disliked in places, he has always been willing to BE the disliked one and openly defy wrong-doing. JTM (and others) shamefully are uninformed opinion holders! I hope enough people exist who KNOW what has actually gone on....There`s a reason, folks, for gov`t being considered corrupt! McCain has fought a good battle to try to keep it to a minimum!
Linguist | 7:27 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
"Great Choice" wrote: "...
When the Democrats say she lacks the experience to be VP, they are digging their own grave for the even less experienced Obama..."

With respect, it isn't Democrats who have been making the argument that "experience" is the primary qualifier for the White House. That's the argument that the REPUBLICANS have been making. They've been trying for months to claim that you can't qualify for President unless, mysteriously, you have a lot of years behind you in the government. After all, that's the primary difference between Senators McCain and Obama.

I doubt that any number of years or "experience" truly qualifies anyone to be president.

But the ability to lead does. And so far, it's Senator Obama who is winning THAT argument, hands down.
Dave | 7:33 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
As far as experience goes, Obama and Biden have no experience standing up to corruption and government waste. Even one year of doing the right thing trumps decades of doing nothing!
Alaska, finally | 7:46 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
We finally have a credible, visible voice from Alaska that can talk about how Alaskans support ANWR drilling, and how the 'footprint' from such action is very very small.

And someone who can - and will - talk about how the polar bear population is thriving in the midst of the global warming issue.

Lee | 7:51 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
John McCain has demonstrated that the Republican party is also a party of change. A great choice, and one I think the majority of the party will be happy with, and can win with in November.
embarassed republican | 7:54 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
aint that a kick in the head! what was mccain thinking! as if we werent already scared about mccains inadequacies as president: Age, weakness on economy etc. lets find for his running mate someone who has even less experience or knowledge. Heck, if George W. can do it, anyone can. i can no longer support mccain in this embarassment and will be forced to vote for obama. Thanks mccain for making the decision of who to vote for easy.
Bob | 7:56 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
This is a woman who has been there when the phone rang at 2 in the morning and she knew what to do in a crisis. Call the park ranger and get the baby bear off the sundeck.
re: JTM | 7:58 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Here are my democratic concerns.
Hillary says (eight moths ago when she was running against him) "Obama does not have experience" today she says, "He's the man".

Obama says "I'm cutting taxes" then in the same speach he says, "I'm spending 1.9 billion dollars for..." He can't spend and cut at the same time. We all know that he is only speaking so he can get elected. I still haven't heard his great "CHANGE" he keeps talking about. The only change I've seen is his removal of the American Flag from his plane.

The Republican party has the experience. They stand strong and not wishy-washy. Palin shoots an Automatic Rifle. She is for gun control in the right way. The only thing I don't like about her is that she is from Idaho, which is where my ex-wife lives, but I'll over-look that.

Hang in there JTM and other because in a few days we will hear their side and what their plans are.
SparkyVA | 8:05 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Good choice, lets get more extraordinary normal people into Washington. No Harvard degree with a life time of plotting to become a political hack, just a gifted normal person like the rest of us. We might have to go back to George Washington to find someone else like that.

As for her lack of foreign policy experience, would you rather have an inexperienced vice president who is a learner, or an inexperienced president who knows it all?
michaelh | 8:08 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Extremely poor written screed, F- for journalistic content, probably plagiarized from the Obama campaign. Managed to miss every single achievement of this amazing woman. Her rise to power was due to her talent, character and ability. Facts totally missed by the substandard reporting of the Desert News. No wonder news papers are losing readership.
George | 8:11 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Absolutely terrific choice. Now, I am energized about McCain..much more thanif Romney had been selected.
Harry | 8:14 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I know Mitt Romney and Sarha Palin is no Mitt Romney.
Tyme | 8:20 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Obama fightens me. He is not a safe choice or the choice of change unless we mean choosing lower moral character change. . .look at the people he chooses to run around with. The Church leader who preaches hate and the running mate who is not honest. He consistantly runs with people who have low or adverse character which is an indication of his mind set to me. We may not know the Govenor from Alaska but I am interested . . . because she seems to have values, character, and strength. lets see how it plays out.
kathyn | 8:22 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Palin is a wonderful choice. Mitt would have been a bit divisive just because he's Mitt and people either love him or hate him. (Unfairly.) Once people get to know Mrs. Palin, they will understand she's a great choice.
Veni vidi vici | 8:23 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I watched her on television and absolutely love her. However, I do not think she is ready to be just one heartbeat away from the Presidency, particularly given McCain's old age and health histoy. Therefore, I do not plan to vote for McCain-Palin. I think the country is more important than personality.

P.S. Wouldn't it be refreshing to see someone young and articulate like her become President of the LDS church?
Re: Great Choice | 8:24 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I whole heartedly agree with you. I like Mitt, but not for the ticket this year. The more I learn about Palin the more I like the pick. She has 2 years experience in executive leadership, which is 2 years more than Obama and Biden combined. But the Democratic Party has to attack her...it's the political way.
Just a mom | 8:24 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
who is thrilled that someone like Sarah Palin was chosen to be McCain's running mate. Love what she stands for, love how she walks the walk and doesn't just talk the talk. LOVE that she can and does take on the good ole boys club and WIN. She makes me feel much more comfortable that it won't just be "politics as usual" back in DC. What a breath of fresh air. And for all of Obama's talk of change, who did he choose? A white male DC insider. No change. I agree with Halloween - he got a small post-convention bump, but I bet we'll see a steady decline in his ratings. And btw - as his ratings drop (which they've been doing), he just gets nastier and nastier. Sad.
Recently Retired | 8:27 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Wow! Since learning that Gov Palin was selected, I have been researching her over the internet. I must say that I was not aware of her before yesterday, but so far I am impressed.
She appears to be an independent thinker who stands for what she believes in. She can clearly identify with "working class" Americans and understands how the economy is affecting us. She does not have the years of experience in various areas of politics that others do, but judging from her performance in Alaska, she knows how to work with advisors that do.
I have been watching this election closely because I'm not sure who I want to support. Both parties have views I agree with and views that I don't agree with. But now there is a person in the race that actually lives her beliefs. Do you want to know her views on something? Look at her life, you don't have to listen to words and try to "find the truth".
I will continue to research both men and their VP choices before I make up my mind but the Republican ticket just took a major step forward in obtaining my vote.
Himself | 8:28 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
The choice of Palin is stunning, in the same way getting hit in the head with a 2x4 is. It has come down
to the insanity of a reality TV show, "Who Wants To Be The Leader Of The Free World?".

Did McCain make this decision alone?
Were all the other potentials voted off the island?

Stupid. Insulting. Frightening.

Who will be the Secretary of Defense?


Anonymous | 8:28 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
You're doin' your best to but a brave face on this. But the veep you want to send with the 72 year old who looks more frail every day has the foreign policy experience of a fish catchin' hockey mom. Biden is looking better and better.
All Saints Day | 8:31 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I can appreciate the abundance of conservative comments in response to an article published in a conservative paper. Whether or not you like Obama, you have to acknowledge that this is a dangerous 'maverick' choice of McCain. Her lack of knowledge of so many demographics across the country, coupled with her total lack of foreign policy experience only reflect on McCain's propensity to do whatever the h*** he pleases without regard for the consequences (the dreaded heartbeat from the presidency, etc.) I plead with you to count the cost of how this attitude from our current president has isolated us from the world at a time where international cooperation (not compromised sovereignty as some right-wingers feign) is essential to global, and yes, domestic security.
Cabinet Pick | 8:35 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Palin would do well in a cabinet position, perhaps even secretary of energy. But vice president? If anything happens to 72 year old John McCain, she would be next in line to stare down Russia, North Korea, Iran. She has a fabulous story, really. But do we want to risk the security of our nation on a great story?
Anonymous | 8:44 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Man is she beautiful. She looks like a Relief Society President so well Utah is going to go out and punch the straight ticket in record numbers.
Easily Swayed | 8:48 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
What is politics all about anyway, issues or something else?

Most of us really cannot describe why we support Republicans or Democrats -- just a gut feeling. That is why some of the Founding Fathers didn't want the populous to vote because they were not informed about things that really mattered.

Heck, I might vote Republican for the first time in 20 years because she (Palin) appears to be so charismatic (cute).
Good Grief | 8:49 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
You people that want another 4 years of a republican administration must not get it at all. If you are really better off now than 8 years ago you must be in the small minority of business people. The big picture is for all of us to compare 8 years ago to today, and don't bring up that weak excuse of the Dem controlled senate has screwed things up this past 20 months. This mess lays in the laps of this administration just as it should be. Lying, cheating and decieving has come home to roost. It's time for a change.
A closer look | 8:53 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Anyone who is planning on supporting this ticket should take a few minutes and visit the website of the FCA (fellowship of christian athletes) and see if you can still offer your support.
Debbie | 9:03 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
What are they going to do about health care? I want to vote Republican - I really do, but they are just spouting unrealistic rhetoric when it comes to solving this national crisis. The solution must be bi-partisan (or non-partisan) and they must come together to get universal coverage. Are they studying countries where this is working? All we hear are out-dated horror stories. What we have here in America is a horror story of its own and putting another bandaid here and there will not do the trick.

Obama is not afraid to tackle this one but he comes with a package I can't support. So what will McCain and Palin do? I'd like to see something!
Mark | 9:05 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
How funny! McCain is so desperate that he has to chase disgruntled Hillary supporters! Way to go for the GOP!

So can McCain now attack Obama on his inexperience when he chooses someone for VP who a little more than 2 years ago was the mayor of a town of only 7,000? Nope!

She is cute. She could do well with the male 40+ crowd who would rather watch her than Joe Biden.

Funny liberal spin | 9:08 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Every article published on this site is accompanied by a comment from some pro-Obama liberal pretending to be a conservative. In this article, for example, "JTM" lamented "does anyone know ANY of their ideas and plans" and decided ... what the heck ... we should all give Obama a chance. How confident are Dems when they have to resort to these kinds of tactics to get people to vote for their candidate? How worried are they about Palin when they have to lie and attack? And to JTM ... what in the world do you know about Obama besides rhetoric and platitudes? Good grief! Obama's speech on Thursday showed me all I will ever need to know to decide which candidate to NOT vote for. That speech was a mile high but only an inch deep.
Backgroud | 9:08 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
I would ask anyone who is considering supporting this ticket to review the FCA (fellowship of christain atheletes) website.
Miyaka | 9:09 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
One heartbeat away from the most powerful person on in the world. Very nice person but come on the potential leader of the free world at any moment?
ST. GEORGE | 9:17 a.m. Aug. 30, 2008
Think about this?

DID BUSH, GOP AND BIG OIL pressure McCain to select Palin to get her out of the way in Alaska?

Add your comment

Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.

Words Remaining

E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.

Image
Mario Tama, Getty Images

Presumptive Republican presidential nominee John McCain stands with Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, whom he has selected as his running mate, at a rally in Dayton, Ohio.

previousnext

Latest comments

Jeff is absolutely correct...this team has moved beyond JT. Davies is the...

It's ironic that this letter was published on the same day when it was...

Letters: No man-made warming

Repeat after me: There is no man-made global warming! There is no...

When M. Russel Ballard says, "There is no need to argue or contend with...

Editorial: Leave the economy alone

Does anyone question what the President was 'hinting' at when he said this...

Congress mulls college playoffs

I think its funny that people question congress getting involved. First of...

Locke thinks he is doing tv and not radio. If I could see the game, then his...

Why are most of the comments for man-made warming sarcastic and dismissive?...

Congress mulls college playoffs

Take a look at the money involved in this monopoly. Don't for a second think...

Haws playing like a veteran

Nice game Tyler! So glad you came to BYU!

Advertisements