Reader comments
FLDS wife declines to answer questions at Texas hearing
52 comments | Read story
call us crazy.
why do you want them left alone? So more little girls can be forced into marriage and sex? Seems inappropriate to want that kind of thing to happen, but to each his own....
Children are citizens. If parents can't or won't protect their human rights, the state has to. By law. By state law. By federal law. By international law. We are a nation which lives by law. Laws which we make.
"Why can't they leave these people alone"? Because they are breaking the law and being non protective of their children...
Yeah right. CPS raided a community under false pretense, invaded homes without a valid warrant, ransacked a house of worship, took 440 happy, welll adjusted children and threw them into concentration camps, interrogated them, tormented them, fiddlied around with their private parts, and finally ripped them sobbing from their mothers arms and sent them to the four corners of Texas to live with strangers.
Way to protect the kids, Texas.
No amount of petty moralizing will hide the fact that she was firmly, unapologetically, on the side of evil, right up until SCOT released the kids back to their mothers, when she shut up and never mentioned the subject again.
Now she salivates at the prospect that at least eight of the little ones will soon be suffering again.
Gal50 absolutely reeks of evil. Makes my skin crawl.
why do you want them left alone? So more little girls can be forced into marriage and sex? Seems inappropriate to want that kind of thing to happen, but to each his own....
CPS is no longer alleging any of what you mention above. They are no longer accusing mothers of forcing girls into anything. They are accusing them of NOT FORCING them to refrain from contact with their fathers.
Your combination of ignorance, bias, and straw man attacks seem to be very common in Texas. That is, no doubt, why the illegal raid happened in the first place, and why your tax dollars will soon be funding a new and improved YFZ ranch.
Cheers!
obliteration of the fundamental constitutional right
to parent and to be guarenteed free process by the
state of Texas. Let us not be naive, state and local governments and a cadre of self proclaimed
experts have a field day in making money for treatment and so called protections...
Here is the list that benefits:
Counselors
Guardian Ad Litums
Other Attorneys
Psychologists
Psychiatrists
Major health care providers
Counties
Children and Youth Departments
Sheriff's Office
Mediators
Facilitators
Wise Person's
Investigators
Foster Parents in it for the money
The list goes on and on....everyone reaps the
financial rewards by keeping innocent families
in the so called 'safe system.'
While proof could be ascertained, there is plenty
of potential for judicial corrupt....All in the
name of ripping innocent children away from their
own lifestyle and religion that may be different than
yours.
Laws.........laws crafted with the sole intention of busting a church. Just ask the author........hildibrand has already made his intentions clear.
to anom: nothing has been proven
re to tigerlilly: nothing has been proven. they are doing this because the fld religion is different. the flds have a right to live their religion just like you and i do.
to transplant: again nothing has been proven against any of these people except warren jeffs. there is nothing wrong with a child having a relationship with their father. things should be proven against the men before cps even tries to take the children
post a relevant comment about the FLDS having their
civil rights violated and then have my freedom of speech squelched by the Deseret News..Remember you
only have rights, if the government or the newspapers
agree with giving them to you.
"The FLDS has already promised not to perform any more underage marriages."
Well, hey! That's surely good enough for me!
It's time to take your medicine like a man (or woman) and then move on and start over. You'll need to ditch the hierarchy that got you here (Jeffs, Jessop, etc) and go back to the basic tenets that are your true religion.
No one cares if you have 5 wives and 50 children, as long as you support them, ensure they have decent schooling, and give them the freedom to make choices in the future. And trading your daughters for favors with the leadership has got to stop.
This isn't rocket science. You know what you've been doing wrong, and you know what makes a good parent. You lost sight of both by allowing the likes of Jeffs and company to run the show.
You'll have to take the punishment doled out for your foolishness and indiscretions.
And you better watch and report abuse in the future, instead of hiding it under a rug. Don't be a coward, nor a sheep.
And tigerlily - these people turn little children into drones with no future. You really want to defend that? how sad. Tell us truthfully - would you want to be an FLDS child? I didn't think so.
same to sokol, joey, zxcvbnm, etc. You all go on about how the parents rights were violated, but say nothing about the little children raised with one purpose and no future. Some even find it amusing. Well, next time an FLDS girl wants a career instead of children (her right to choose) and she is forced (via coercion) to marry her uncle or stepfather, you can sit back and laugh.
land of the free - yeah, right. Not in FLDS...
And underage marriages is merely the tip of the iceburg. These parents train their children to be one thing and one thing only. Therefore, these children are in danger every day.
It is just like parents that teach their child that at a certain age they have to cut off their arms and legs. Pretty much determines their entire future.
So at what point does religious teaching flow over into abuse? I believe it is when free will and self-determination is taken away. That happens now in FLDS.
Someone said that teaching childen to break the law (polygamy) or to hide from the world was not child abuse. Only when the child takes the action does it become child abuse. I disagree entirely, since if the child cuts off their limbs it is too late. Same scenario.
It must be nice to feel the parents can teach their children anything they want. And I guess legally they can. So you all stand there crying "its legal" while all the kids get sucked into a life of repression and control. hurray.
Work for something, build someone up, do good for goodness sake!
We are focused on this little group because 1000s of children are losing all hope for a future of their choosing simply because their parents decided what they were going to be on the day they were born.
And what does video games and tv and substance abuse and sex have to do with anything? It's a parent's job to TEACH their children what is right and what is wrong. NOT HIDE THEM AND ISOLATE THAM AND KEEP THEM FROM HAVING ANY FUTURE IN THE REAL WORLD!! That's not parenting. That's slavery.
All that the FLDS way is telling me is that the parents are SO BAD at parenting, they have to hide and isolate and lie to their children to get them to act right.
Well, that's some pretty pathetic parents. And from them come pathetic childen - and the circle continues...
And we are doing something. We're hoping the FLDS parents will open their eyes and see just how unfair it is to pre-determine a child's future.
Sorry if you would rather we ignore the little prison camp thing going on here.
What is disturbing is 1) there has not yet been a single piece of evidence (at least released yet - usually the government releases some details of their cases, or the media get hold of something). And 2) the government is (or was?) required to show proof or cause to take away rights, yet CPS took away every kid.
Hold on there - I am not a polygamist. But what happened here is an affront on constitutionally protected rights. I can't CPS they had something on all 440 cases.
Thats the most real and uplifting statement that Ive' seen yet. Its nice to finally come across something worthwhile in the midst of hell.
Carolyn Jessop is not a witness to actions that took place in Texas and as Rios pointed out may have taken place twenty years ago.
So hey.....go after Dan Fischer for his multiple wives and child abuse years ago in a different state.........
A non witness testifies to non events that did not occur in the state of Texas much less at YFZ.......kinda like a non existant Sarah.........
How many more non witnesses will be put on the stand to testify to non-events?
Just for a little added non-event. Carolyn acknowledged that the accusations she made against Merril ....if they are true....occured twenty years ago.
None of the kids were born twenty years ago.......how can a man whos whereabouts are unknown be a threat to kids based on testimony of a woman who acknowledges the timeframe of her accusations does not include the children involved today?
If more people knew that, they'd consider joining the Amish or the FLDS, or starting their own separatist society.
I would like for all FLDS to consider this...statistics show that more boys are born into this world than girls...so how do you account for your excess of men in your community? Do you think that this is why in your community the men marry girls so young, robbing from the next generation? They do not have enough women to support the polygamist lifestyle!
Sure the world out here can be scary, but there are a lot of wonderful people who believe in the scriptures and they live by them. You really can live in the world, but not be of the world, so your argument that you can only avoid the evils of the world in your community is not valid. There are millions who are doing it out here in the real world.
The men are abusing your young girls. It is evil to the rest of us. It needs to stop.
These "poor" "single" women with all those children and no money wow are they.
Abuse and welfare fraud. They use the system expertly.
Warren Jeffs has caused much trauma and pain for this closed society, yet they still blindly follow.
FLDS is evil. If they want to break our country's laws then hide behind the skirt of the protections of the country they thumb their nose as, they need to think a little better.
Why not move to Mexico? Why here? The sense of entitlement despite unlawfulness is appalling.
So why has the CPS and Mighty TEXAS RANGERS incarcerated them in the first place???
You people will pay dearly for the distress you have caused these little ones.
Many of the comments do not make sense because you don't pay attention to what you are writing. For instance, you use pronouns without any indication of whom they refer to! "She" can mean Carolyn, Barbara, the judge, a lawyer, the Jessop girl who returned to the group, etc. Readers can only read what you post, not your minds.
To Out-of-stater:
What makes you think that everyone but you lives in Utah? I suspect that a good number of those who post are also out-of-staters. I also suspect that the very large majority who so staunchly defend the FLDS (certainly those who do it irrationally) do so because they, themselves, are FLDS.
Yes, mistakes were made in the way things were done. But to insist that there was NO evidence of ANYthing is to ignore the facts. Remember, law enforcement has journals, computer records, etc. We certainly don't know everything. Those who insist that there is nothing are really just saying, "I don't know of anything." Or, perhaps they are just blindly denying everything without stopping to think or reason.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Chicagoan charged in Mumbai attack 10:42 p.m.
- 1 in 6 U.S. workers is foreign-born 10:42 p.m.
- News briefs 10:41 p.m.
- Ruling appealed in teen beating case 10:39 p.m.
- New St. George courthouse to open 10:39 p.m.
- Charges filed in identity theft 10:37 p.m.
- NFL notes: Singletary still upset 10:37 p.m.
- Helicopters rescue stranded hikers 10:36 p.m.
- FLDS ask for new trust manager 10:36 p.m.
- Payson family loses home in fire 10:34 p.m.
- Letters: Liberal because LDS
278 - Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
260 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
203 - Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
191 - Aggies shoot past Cougars
179 - Cougars going back to Vegas
146 - Letters: Global warming a lie
145 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
134 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
119 - Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
100
For the latest news in the health care debate and how it affects you...
Amazon.com, Target.com, Sears.com, Walmart.com, Kmart.com and...
Glenn Beck, Keith Olbermann, Bill O'Reilly, Chris Matthews ... tune 'em all...
inspiring story. I'm sure there are many out there like my wife and I who...
I disagree. Max's childish outburst was directed at a specific target as were...
I wonder why no one will answer me this. Why is it so hard to understand the...
There was a time when buying our oil from the middle-east made sense. It...
RE: to Chad Alright, I'll take the bait. I have a BS Mechanical...
Chuck it out the window! Start from scratch with a playoff system.
TCU looks as good as any team in the nation and are currently undefeated....
Great article!
Dare I say it? -- The BCS is unAmerican. The question of who deserves to be...



Basically, these women lost their children to CPS because girls from some other families were married too early. According to these families, they are capable of preventing their underage girls from marrying.
So, I have to wonder if the families who don't want their underage girls to marry are upset with the families who married off their underage girls?
Hopefully, the remaining mothers can see that it is better to remove their children from these men than to put them back in CPS custody.