Reader comments
Suit may destroy UEP Trust of FLDS
83 comments | Read story
The FLDS do need to make changes. It is wrong that they kick young teen boys out before they are able to make a living on their own.
What kind of religion is this?
Sounds like a terrible religion to me.
They all claim to own nothing, have no income or assests that you could garnish or attach liens to because it is all in the trust.
None of the homes, companies, or vehcile or any other property is in individuals names. It all belongs to the trust.
There is no other way!
I dont agree with polygamy but understand that some do and it is part of their religious beliefs. We should be protected under the constitution with freedom of religion. If people want to have this in their religious beliefs then they should be able to do so.....Unless they infringe on the rights of others.
Justthefactsmaam
When finances are intertwined it leaves you exposed to this sort of thing.
Those people who are part of the UEP trust have their entire life savings in it. Many of them are victims just as much as those who file suit.
Allowing the UEP to be pilfered by lawyers will create far more victims than we now have.
I strongly disagree with the FLDS religion and as an member of the LDS faith would dearly like to see them go away. I am not willing to deal unjustly with them to gain that end.
I doubt that Isaiah was talking about this specific situation; however, it does seem applicable.
Jonathan: Yeah, right! Her past actions YELL otherwise.
And no, I am not FLDS and I don't live in Utah.
My latest statistics on child rape show that out of a population of 700 on the ranch, there are 3 girls without children, 5 girls with children, 15 women with children and about 9 women that may have been raped but don't have a child to prove it. The grand total is about 32 child rape victims out of 700 people. Applying percentages to a population of 10,000, there may be 448 rape victims. If this is true, I question whether adults who failed to protect so many children should be entitled to keep their homes.
No decision is going to be fair. Not everyone can prove what they put into the trust. Divide the trust into three portions. The first portion gets divided evenly among the 10,000 members, the second portion gets divided proportionately based on what people can prove they put into the trust and the third portion gets divided among the identified victims who desire compensation. Since the trust represents the assets of the FLDS organization, the victims should be entitled to some compensation, but it shouldn't be disproportionately large.
I agree with just about everything you said (or implied through sarcasm) except you're missing one thing.
The FLDS certainly DO infringe on the rights of others, especially their followers, and most especially the children.
Of course, this has nothing to do with polygamy, but I thought I'd throw it out there anyway.
I still don't understand why people are so against polygamy. I understand being against religious extremists like the FLDS, but polygamy is probably their least intrusive practice.....
Even if that WAS in fact the correct number, it is still lower than the national "normal" statistics of 1 in 4 girls will be a sexual victim before age 18 and 1 in 5 boys will be sexually assaulted before age 18.
So far, after two months of having the children in foster care being interviewed by some of the "best" investigators Texas CPS had to offer, not one single boy has been found to be a victim of sexual assault by an adult.
Compare that with 1 in 5 boys in the USA.
At the end of this report it quotes her attorneys saying, and i am quoting the report:"Elissa Wall has made it very clear she is not going to keep any of the money should it be awarded to her".
Now if her representaion is saying that publicly how can you call her greedy? She wrote a book? Well now, how dare she!!!
How dare she share her story and shed light on the horrors that happen to small children, and young girls in the FLDS! Sure smells like greed to me. She deserves whatever she can get, and the more truth put out the better. How quickly people are willing to forget about what she went through is astounding to me.
It certainly wasnt run like a church,, it was run Like HITLER would of run the SS.
Its never been registered as a Church.
Just because they've tied up all of their assests in a trust doesn't mean that they are immune from having to compensate the victims of their abuse.
I don't have a problem with polygamy. I do have a serious problem with the many of the other illegal practices the FLDS have used to maintain their polygamous lifestyle -- the coersion, the brainwashing, the denial of rights, reassigning families, kicking young boys out of the community, forcing young girls into marriages, and welfare fraud.
Every single person who "presently reside(s) in houses on Trust property" is breaking the law by living in polygamy.
really? Everything I've read suggests that more than half of the men have ONE or ZERO wives and only a select few that are high up in the church have more. Elisa Walls book tells of a monogamist relationship with her cousin/husband.
"Acountability, it is about time" sounds like he is just as brainwashed by his religion as the flds-ers are by theirs.
Has any one watched "girls next door" Hef practices polygamy, doesn't even call them "wives" and nobody says he is breaking the law. I know he isn't married to the girls but legally the flds men aren't married to their wives either, except one. That being said, child rape should never be tolerated.
Let justice be surved.
I guess the FLDS should have used a few 401Ks' then they could be as broke as every other american.
Poor Elisa won't use any of the money for herself though......she'll set up her own trust and manage it for the good of others.........yep..then she can control a trust.
It's about the money and all the good intentions and saving the children rhetoric will only leave the children without homes and the gossip mongers in control of the very people they pretend to save.
The illegality and impropriety occurs when there are very young and/or under-aged girls involved and where men exercise undue influence over these girls due to their positions of religious authority. These men are being prosecuted under rape statues not bigamy statutes.
The trust is at risk because of a doctrine called collateral estoppel. If the judge finds that the trust is liable to Miss Wall for her injury, then based on that finding any woman similarly situated to Miss Wall could sue and recover from the trust. Since that group is probably quite large the trust could easily be drained of all assets.
Yes, lawyers are likely to make a good deal of money from this. But, who else is qualified to clean this up?
So What?: Right on.
These are all adults who have made choices. Now they are faced with the consequences of supporting their lifestyle. They are no different in that respect than people who followed the brown spot into subprime mortgages.
The super righteous will agree that taking the FLDS trust fund is another lap of the World.
Now, Elissa Wall retires wealthy.
This puts her written works in a solid Gold financial frame.
When will we wake up and let them know if they choose to live this lifestyle great but we will not pay for it.............Miffed
And it certainly had a negative effect on me, my self image, and my emotional life--but I GOT OVER IT! And without any million dollar settlement. No one went to jail either.
I am not alone--there are many of us, and we heal, unless someone convinces us that either we can't or that there is something in it for us if we don't. It can become an excuse for lots of things, if we want it to. Or it can simply become a terrible wrong that we overcame.
There are many, many young women aged 14 and over who are sexually active in this country, many of whom also have babies. They are not being forced, and we don't know that all the FLDS girls are being forced either. Those who have been--yes, let's treat this as rape. But those who choose should be treated no differently than we treat any other sexually active teen in America.
For people who run the FDLS its all about money, That is what will hurt them the most.
TAKE IT ALL!!!!
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Dungy can see Vick playing for Bills 9:27 p.m.
- Lambert surprisingly tops news 9:24 p.m.
- MLS: Dynamo, Galaxy advance 9:21 p.m.
- Utahns split over war in Afghanistan 9:21 p.m.
- Probe heating up in the rampage 9:16 p.m.
- Health-care bill could sink in Senate 9:15 p.m.
- Hope for single moms 9:14 p.m.
- Utah Jazz Extra: Starting Five 9:12 p.m.
- Photos: Fall fun in the sun 9:12 p.m.
- Utah Jazz Extra: Whose hot/not 9:11 p.m.
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
216 - House passes health care bill
195 - Lobo suspended
173 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
150 - Speed has never been BYU's game
136 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
125 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - Thousands protest health bill
102 - Provo company innovating engines
99 - BYU cuts Women's Research Institute
88
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
NASA's Stardust probe continues to bring new knowledge about the nature...
TCU 45 Utah 6
But, if you think TCU will score 49, you are completely underestimating the...
Banks should tighten underwriting guidelines, to be sure, but they have gone...
Utah Alum cheering on home town TCU. The earlier poster Metroplex poster is...
Hey High Noon, you have a great team. Hope you and the other 25,000 fans...
Keeps telling opponents that there are safegaurds in place to protect the...
I thought they had fixed all their defense problems this season? Actually,...
Doesn't if make you feel the least bit guilty to force your neighbors to pay...
The latest affirmative action election is a painful lesson. Next time let's...
Fool me once - Shame on you Fool me twice - Shame on me Fool me three times...


