Reader comments
LDS reassign Russia-bound missionaries
124 comments | Read story
Unless you don`t have a green card you are supposed
to leave the US within 90 days too.
Please correct me if I`m wrong.
So what`s wrong with the Russian policy anyway?
However, there must not be such areas, or we would probably be doing just that.
Are you suggesting they're running out of soldiers to blow up in Iraq and we should send more? How can you say that anything is a useless, especially in comparison to the war in Iraq? I don't know if you've noticed but everyone hates the president over it
Many LDS servicemen and women are serving in Irag and elsewhere so that the freedom you enjoy "to vent" can be available to others not so fortunate as to have been born in the U.S.A. A number have even laid down their lives...don't denigrate their service and sacrifice or what you don't have a clue about...
Immaturity sadly results in ignorant acts such as the altar incident and conduct unbecoming a member results in the Church discipline you refer to...but please don't display such ignorance as to portend all LDS or anyone else for that matter condone such behaviors as the altar incident and leave it those of the LDS faith to manage their own membership...
You seem to delight in selective dart throwing...a lesson in tolerance might help you...maybe a little...
So all that time spent preparing to serve a mission in Russia is now all for naught? I feel bad for the elders and sisters whose time was wasted.
I remember when I was one, and we were all told that when Russia was opened to 'the gospel' it (the 'gospel') would explode and there would be tremendous growth.
Correct me if I'm mistaken, but it never happened did it?
The mormon church's growth in Russia was second only to Y2K as the biggest non-event I can think of.
So in this case, those training to serve in Russia are being RECALLED. So, by the specificity of the church's own words, the prophet must have been wrong in calling those elders and sisters to serve in Russia who must now retrain to serve somewhere else.
Just thinking outside the box.
The problem with Russia is that the country is so large a trip to a neighboring country can be much further than Thailand missionaries dealt with (except for the period of time Thai missionaries flew to Malaysia).
Russian leaders make money anyway they can. Requiring travel every 90 days, at western currency rates, makes for good government income.
I've met our missionaries in Russia in the past and they are very dedicated and loving of the Russian people. The work is VERY difficult as nearly all men smoke and drink. I watched ten-year-old boys openly trying to buy cigarettes; and fifteen-year-olds fall-down drunk on the sidewalk of a major street.
Male self-respect is challenging to attain when the government provides food, housing day care and orphanages!
The Church has made an impact over these past 18 years and it will continue with missionaries and leaders from other areas.
Why would God tell the presidency to send missionaries to the MTC to be trained to go to Russia when he knew that they wouldn't be able to go?
My answer:
Because we need people to go there until they can't anymore. Knowing the exact minute when this would happen is not needed here, especially since all that needs to be done to fix the problem is to reassign them.
A knowledge by revelation that we need to preach the gospel in Russia is sufficient enough of a revelation for me to move forward in the work. The point is that the missionaries go where needed. I went where called, and I'll do so again. I went to New Jersey and could have been transferred any old place. I served and was blessed for doing so. It wouldn't have mattered where I was sent. The Lord made my mission experience what it became.
Did it occur to you that maybe, just maybe, God can reveal something at one given moment, like calling worthy individuals to serve in Russia, and then later decide that based off conditions beyond the control of Church Leaders, He can then provide direction and inspiration to have them serve elsewhere?
The point is, individuals are called by Him to serve as missionaries. If He decides to later change where He sends missionaries (for whatever reason), isn't that His prerogative?
Missionaries don't "retrain". There is not a different set of teachings or belief taught in one area of the world in comparison to another. The only difference is going to be the language they learn (if any). I personally don't see any disconnect between the validity of a call issued by the Prophet of God and the destination one fills that call in...
Don't get me wrong; I think it is good for the church to be fleible enough to change with the political tides. I just think that it seems odd that the worthy members called to serve in Russia must now learn another language because "someone got it wrong" the first time.
And, since God is all-knowing, He didn't get it wrong, so it must have been the prophet, right? Or were they both wrong together?
You are wrong. I had four companions on my mission (in Nevada) who were foriegners and none of them ever had to go and renew their visas.
One there was an elder from somewhere in Latin America (it might have been Argentina or Guatamala) who had to go to his country's consulate in Los Angeles to renew his visa, but we never had any missionry have to leave the country to renew their visa.
At BYU I knew many foriegn students. I think I knew two who because of various circumstances had to leave the country to renew their visas, but in general they were able to stay here for a year or more on one visa.
There are large Russian speaking population in Kazakhstan, Ukraine, Belarus and the Baltic States. However there are lots of logistical issues in arranging for cross national missions, especially since all these areas have major issues with Russian imperialism. I know when the church opened a mission in Poland the government required that the church make Poland a seperate mission and would not let it be part of a mission based in a foriegn country and they also specifically banned the church from apointing a German as mission president.
"The root of my point is that God is supposed to be all-knowing. God should have already known what Russia was going to be doing. "
Knowing what Russia was going to be doing doesn't mean that the prophet needed to know the exact minute when it would happen. Until the restriction arrives, you still need to preach the gospel and you still need to call missionaries there.
A knowledge by revelation that events like this would take place factor instead into the long term planning of missionary work, such as the allocation of missionaries.
The prophet is inspired with what he needs to do to move the work forward. Those who are being reassigned, while I am sure there is a little disappointment at not being able to go where they anticipated, serve no less honorably by reassignment than missionaries who were called and spent their entire missionaries in one mission.
Look, I spent years learning German, requested a foreign mission, and was sent stateside. I was disappointed at first, but served and count it among the greatest blessings of my life.
What makes you think that the time planning to serve in Russia was for nought? There are hundreds of things that may result. Anyway it did not say where the missionaries will be sent. Maybe some of them will go to Eastern Ukraine where most people speak Russian or to serve among Russians in Latvia and its neighbors. Maybe they will get sent to state side mission and manage to teach recent immigrants from Russia. Maybe they will go to Western Ukraine and teach in Ukranina which is not very different from Russian.
There are a lot of other possibilities. I have known many people who had their mission calls changed due to visa issues. Just because the Lord wants someone to be called somewhere does not mean he wants them to go there.
Two issues. One, I am not sure why you are acting like 20,000 members is nothing. Two, what you meant by "Russia" in that day was the Soviet Union. There are over 10,000 members in Ukraine, 2,000 in Armenia, and well over 1,000 in the other former Soviet nations. This is not counting the members in Eastern Bloc countries or in Mongolia, which both also opened up because of the fall of Communism.
You are not thinking outside the box but inside it. You assume that a call is unchangeble and irrevocable and that if it is not fulfilled it is wrong.
You have also confused an attempt to explain normal procedures with the actual situation. I knew a lady who was reassigned from being a deaf missionary in Pheonix to being a deaf missionary in New York City. I have known missionaries that due to illness or other issues have been reassigned to finish their missions off state side after they were in a foriegn country. I have known missionaries who have served in one mission for several months before they are able to get a visa to somewhere else.
Your basic problem is that you do not understand callings in the church. We are called all the time. People are called as bishops, elders quorum presidents, choir leaders and on and on, and then they are released. A mission call is the same way, you can be released or reassigned from a mission like any other call, that does not negate that you were meant to recieve the initial call.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Stocks rise following jobless news 2:56 p.m.
- BLM delays Nevada horse roundup 2:55 p.m.
- BYU campus briefs 2:34 p.m.
- Utah Utes campus briefs 2:33 p.m.
- Weber State campus briefs 2:32 p.m.
- UVU campus briefs 2:31 p.m.
- Citadel faces tough future 2:30 p.m.
- Holiday television program listings 2:26 p.m.
- Somalia: 2 kidnapped journalists freed 2:15 p.m.
- U. puts Universe Project on hold 2:02 p.m.
- Donny and Kym dance to victory
- Howard made the rivalry a rivalry
- Witness describes '99 killing
- Cougars cruise past Southern
- Crews working to free man in cave
- Loyal to Cougarettes, Crimson Line
- Twitterati to BCS: 'We hate you.'
- Y. focused on 10-win season
- BYU has slim shot at BCS
- Thunder rolls by Jazz
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
256 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?
226 - RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks
202 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
201 - Bronco, Kyle rubber match
138 - BYU records with win
133 - Letters: Rushing to judge Palin
127 - Hall, Johnson matchup key
102 - 4A: Timpview wins 4th in 4 years
96 - Boys basketball rankings
91
'Marry Me City'. Dude, that's CLASSIC! Go UTES!
Really? "one of its most beloved holiday traditions"? Seriously? This is a...
Remember the Brad and Judy Wardle story well. They now have a child married...
To "Dave M | 2:05 p.m." it depends on the employer. Some have waiting...
Put that dog to bed. Students don't need any more obstacles just to get to...
Cap and Trade will make Madoff look like a rank amateur and who's the front...
Wow, you can park downtown free for 2 hours!!! You better not stop for...
Best of luck to the Cougs and Utes for putting on a good show. GO Cougars!
At least JIMMY is not going to get fired.
Is that all Redshirt can do is play the ridiculous left/right game? It's all...



The Russian people are still eager to do business but the government is creating a strong environment of protecting their own interests (putting it mildly).