Reader comments
Dick Harmon: Pac-10 will snub BYU, Utah
324 comments | Read story
Scheduling? BYU and the MWC should eliminate playing teams that seat less than 30,000 fans.
Wyoming and CSU to the WAC, ASU and AZ back to the MWC. Get a REAL BOWL $$$ set up for the MWC Champ!
Set up a playoff game with the WAC.
Coincidence? I don't think so.
I am sorry to say it but BYU is in no way shape or form ever going to be part of a progressive organization like the PAC 10.
I know this with every fiber of my being.
1. FIrst not every member is a football fan.
2. Not every member is a BYU fan.
I think your stating this just because the whole state of utah practically follows BYU football like some cult and you presume it must be like this elsewhere too.
done!
There is no way BYU and Utah would ever want to be part of the look-down-your-noses, elistist, snobbery of a backwards-thinking organization like the PAC 10.
Deep down,
I know this with every fiber of my being.
WSU and OSU basically are the poor relations of Washington and Oregon. Neither have the resources to stay competitive in the Pac-10 and the gap between them is growing.
The real question about BYU and Utah is, can they match the sorts of money USC, UCLA, Cal, Stanford, ASU, Oregon and Washington can generate? Arizona is in the same predicament Oregon State and Washington State are in, but it has such a prominent basketball presence that it will never leave the Pac-10.
NBC Sports says BYU, Utah top threats to be this year's Hawaii.
"Don't be surprised if in the next 10 years, the BCS finds itself opening doors wider and wider to accommodate schools, primarily those currently in the Mountain West Conference (MWC) and Western Athletic Conference (WAC), who are every bit as potent as the traditional powers."
"Six of the past 14 NFL MVPs played at one of the 52 non-BCS FBS schools (Steve Young, BYU; Brett Favre (3), Southern Miss; Marshall Faulk, San Diego State; and LaDainian Tomlinson, TCU)."
The BIG 12 doesn't have any of these squabbles with any other conference.
And yes, we have heard the rumours and gossip about BYU replacing Baylor and joining our conference.
From what I have seen, BYU would definately be a better choice for the BIG 12 than Baylor. BYU would bring in much more money than Baylor.
The only issue I can see about BYU joining the BIG 12 would be not playing on Sunday. However, the BIG 12 seems to be a little more understanding of religious differences than the "liberal" PAC 10.
There's no need for BYU and Utah to remain in the same conference to continue their rivalry.
Iowa-Iowa State
Florida-Florida State
Georgia-Georgia Tech
Kentucky-Louisville
to name just a few, are all teams from the same state, but in different conferences, who have maintained their rivalries.
But, there is a substantial fan base of BYU football fans in California, Arizona, Nevada and other places outside Utah.
BYU had over 15,000 fans (filled the entire end zone) at the USC game a few years ago -- most of them did not come from Utah. Arizona sold out their game against BYU two years ago with a huge block of BYU fans, most of them from Arizona.
BYU regularly draws large contingents of fans to games at San Diego St., UNLV and TCU. Most of those fans are local to the area.
BYU lost to them last year in the regular season, and this year they will beat BYU.
This story is almost as funny as those that think Utah and BYU will be undefeated when they meet!!!
BYU will lose 2 + games even with their cupcake schedule.
I'd like to see a Division 1A playoff. That would make this whole point moot.
All of this "Lucky" talk is getting old. A blocked field goal is not luck, if anything it is evidence of extreme "HEART" and "EFFORT". It shows a team that doesn't give up just because the chips are down (Utah defense -- are you reading any of this?)
Hall to Collie's 4th and 18 was not luck. It was a play BYU called effectively throughout the year, accounting for a touchdown vs. CSU. If the Utah coaches had watched the video, they would have known and put in coverage against it.
BYU still had to complete the drive, and Unga ran up the middle 10 yards through Utah's "Charmin" Red Zone defense.
Beck to Harline, if someone from Utah had been within 20 yards of Harline, the play would never had happened.
BYU's only luck is that the Utes hired a Defensive Coordinator as head coach who doesn't understand how to play defense.
As soon as you poor little Ute Fans realize that your team loses it's heart playing to a half-empty stadium, you'll be able to get on with your lives.
And Pitt deserved to be in the Fiesta Bowl the night of your greatest glory???
But now you can all say that one year, you ended up ranked #6 in the NATION, with a Mythical "Bowl Buster" trophy.
"We're #6, We're #6!!!"
It just doesnt have the same ring to it as "We're #1, We're #1!!!" now does it?
I'll bet the Red Sweatshirts and Popov are flying off the shelves right now as I am typing.
Go Utes, Go reality!!!
Utah brings nothing to the table, and more often than not the Utah team's only real game the fans have even cared about was BYU.
The MWC is the "black hole" of football, carried by BYU. The only reason DirecTV picked up the MTN was because there are so many BYU fans around the country. Raise your hand if you think it was the Utah fans making all of those calls.
Any conference BYU ends up at will see an increase of interest immediately. The same cannot be said for Utah. If BYU and their fanbase leave the MWC, the conference will lose Comcast and DirecTV, and fold within five years.
Let's see if Utah can stand on their own. If BYU left, and did not agree to a home and home with Utah, you would see more tumbleweeds in RES than red sweatshirts.
Face it Ute Fans, you need us more than we need you.
You better be nice to BYU, or your main rival will be Weber State.
What does that have to do with anything?
Why was it necessary to include that in your post?
Why not include your race, or your gender?
Does it give you any extra objectivity to be a "wild rebellious" Ute Fan. Being a fan of BYU is not part of the LDS doctrine, although it is nice to go to a sporting event in the United States where they don't have beer on tap.
Go to whatever church you want, cheer for whatever football team you choose, no one cares.
BYU has the better athletic program, whether you are LDS or not.
Cougar fans are also so jealous that the '04 Utes' season was LEGITIMIZED by a relatively COMPETITIVE schedule (as opposed to the cupcakes THEIR team faced 20 yrs earlier), and the sheer DOMINANCE the Utes demonstrated over their opponents (as opposed to the number of opponents THEIR team had to squeak past) that they cling to Utah's REGULAR season-ending "BCS" ranking (there IS no POST-season BCS ranking) of #6, since that is the lowest value they could assign. They know full well the Utes finished the AP and Coaches poll at #5 PRIOR to the Fiesta Bowl, and moved up to #4 thereafter, just as they know that had OK or WA played as soft a schedule as the cougars, BYU wouldn't have defaulted to #1.
Poor us cougs.
How difficult was your schedule '04 again?
How difficult was your season again last year? Third in the MWC? Are you now an official "3RD
IN MWC BUSTER's?"
Score on UNLV (sheer DOMINANCE), and then talk smack.
Learn to cover recievers, and then talk smack.
Give your coach an opportunity to earn some respect in the MWC, before you look for National Respect, you can't even earn it in the "Des News". Read what sites like ESPN say about Bronco and Kyle, then talk smack.
Til then, you are wannabes with heavy "Little Brother Syndrome", wannabe where BYU's been.
BYU's best road wins in history are probably vs. Texas A and M in 1978 (the Aggies were much better than), UCLA in 1983 w/Steve Young(Bruins much, much better back then), PITT in 1984 (Pitt was bad that year but ranked #3 at the time which catapulted BYU's National Championship season). BYU has had some near misses of note vs. Georgia in 1982 (probably got screwed by the refs/Georgia returning national champs led by Herschel Walker) but as you can see BYU's road wins against national powerhouses are a bit lacking...the ND game was in the mid 1990's...
In reality BYU/Utah if they played their cards right could be above average in football in the PAC (third to fifth placeish) and every once in a while contend for the confernce title. Utah a couple of years back probably would have lost to USC but the Trojans would have had to work hard and many of the BYU teams of the early 1980's would hang tough...
BYU and Utah don't being any more money. They don't bring a big market. They don't bring added respectability or prestige. They don't help the PAC-10 better counter the SEC or the Big-12.
There's no compelling reason for the PAC-10 to add Utah and BYU and more than a few reasons why they wouldn't want to.
Stop the inane chatter already!
You conveniently ignored the fact that the very next season, 1985, BYU pummeled that same supposedly superior Washington team, 31-3.
BYU's 1984 team did all that can be expected of a team.
They beat every team they played.
They finished the previous season ranked #7 in both polls with an 11-1 record. They started the 1984 season beating the #3 ranked Pitt Panthers on the road. They finished the season on a 24-game winning.
In 1985, they beat Washington, 31-3, and lost close games to UCLA, 24-27, and Ohio State (Citrus Bowl), 7-10. (Bosco played most of the season with a shoulder separation, which was a factor in the 3 passes that were intercepted and returned for TD's in their 3 losses.)
BYU's 7-year record (1979-1985) surrounding their 1984 National Championship was 66-11 (86%).
All four starting quarterbacks -- Marc Wilson, Jim McMahon, Steve Young and Robbie Bosco -- went on the play in the NFL, with two of them leading their teams to Super Bowl wins.
1984 was no fluke. BYU was fully capable of beating ANY team in the country.
A marketing survey showed that most fans preferred a darker shade of blue to a lighter shade of blue. So BYU chose to adopt the darker shade of blue as the standard for all teams.
The ONLY people who have a problem with that are a few of the old-timers at BYU who liked the lighter shade of blue, and some of our friends up north who are suffering from a slight case of little-brother syndrome.
And about those bowl wins - they were conference championship teams beathing 5th place teams. oooo, impressive. I also remember Ty Detmer's BYU team coming to Eugene in 1990 and getting whipped pretty good, if you want a cherry-picked argument.
Typical mentality of most BcS team fans. We won't play non-BcS teams at your place. We won't allow your best non-BcS teams to play our best BcS teams in a bowl.
Then, we'll use your non-BcS team losses at our place, to prove our superiority. And we'll minimize your non-BcS team bowl wins over our BcS teams as illegitimate, because your team only beat a lower-echlon BcS team (even though, in our self-absorbed BcS minds, even our lower-echlon BcS teams are vastly superior to ANY non-BcS team.)
Stop and smell the BcS you're shoveling.
So BYU beat WA in 1985. So what? The '84 and '85 Huskie teams were DIFFERENT teams. Graduation takes its toll every year.
In 2002, the Utes finished 5-6. In 2003 they finished 10-2 (ranked #23). Those teams, separated by only 1 year...were DIFFERENT teams despite still being Utah. In 2004, the Utes finished 12-0 (ranked #4 and #5 in the AP and Coaches poll) with a large-margined victory over North Carolina. In 2005, they lost to the Tarheels, and finished 7-5, (unranked). They (UNC and Utah) too were DIFFERENT teams.
You have no point little sister.
Big Deal, Utah won the "Johnny-come-lately award in 2004"...Even a blind hog finds and acorn...Get it!!!
But have you been ranked 15 times, have you had the ESPN staff speechless with the come back victories and a legand on the sidelines...What'da say pilgram?
The vision of BYU Football developed the entire HS football Program in the State of Utah!!! The University of Utah owes it's "moment in the spot light" to the development of the states high school system.
You've proved your point; Utah 2004 was a one-hit-wonder, fluke.
BYU 1984, with 6 top 20 finishes in the surrounding 7 years, 7 conference championships, an overall 66-11 record (86%), and one National Championship, was legitimate.
In reviewing Utah's 5-yr record they've averaged over 9-wins/season. That demonstrates SOME sustainability.
BYU fans are the ONLY ones who don't believe there's an asterisk next to their '84 season. They're also the only ones who DO see one next to the Utes' '04 team.
Good thing nobody back East cares about BYU football. Otherwise, they would've watched last year's Las Vegas Bowl, and torpedoed the cougar's preseason hype.
The loss to UNLV in 2002 was by the worst BYU team (5-7) in almost 40 years. You have to go all the way back to 1970 to find a BYU team with a worse record (3-8).
The win over Michigan was accomplished with a quarterback who played the entire second half on an injured leg that he could barely stand on, let alone play quarterback against a swarming Michigan defense on. Robbie Bosco put on one of the gutsiest performances in NCAA bowl history in pulling out the win by one touchdown.
BYU finished the season on a 24-game winning streak. When was the last time Utah won 24 games in a row?
BYU would have been more than willing to play Oklahoma in a bowl game, but Oklahoma and the New Years bowls refused to make a deal to make it happen.
btw, Michigan 1967(4-6), 1965(4-6), 1963(3-4-2), 1962(2-7) and many other teams would probably be considered worse teams than the 1984 Michigan team that beat Miami(22-14)(ranked 14/1), Wisconsin(20-14)(16/-), Indiana(14-6)(14/-), Northwestern(31-0), Illinois(26-18), and Minnesota(31-7), and only lost to Big Ten champion/archrival Ohio State(6-21)(-/11) by TWO touchdowns; OSU lost to USC(20-17) in the Rose Bowl.
"above the rim." But now he lives in Gainesville, Florida theaching those guys the same tricks.
BYU had a coach that ran off the best runnibg back in the schools history, and drug in some new uniforms.
Times have changed, the cougars back on top and will be for a long time. Also, look for the Falcons to be back in the Top 20 where they belong.
After years of mediocrity, Utah finally rediscovered how to play football. 9 wins a season for 5 years is a decent record
But, that record has to be tempered by the fact that it's the most wins Utah has had in a 5-year period, ever. In fact, Utah has only had 3 double-digit win seasons in their history, 2 of them during the last 5 years.
BYU has had 13 double-digit win seasons including the last 2 seasons and 3 in the last 7 years.
Utah has averaged 9 wins a season since 2003.
BYU has averaged 9 wins a season since 1976.
They did watch the game and they voted BYU #14 in both polls after all of the bowls had been played.
No preseason hype needed from BYU fans. Sports fans, coaches, writers and prognosticators from across the country know what BYU is capable of doing this year.
The same people who think that Utah has a chance of having a pretty good year themselves.
BYU will be ranked in the top 15 to start the season.
Utah might slip into the top 25 to start the season, but will more likely be high in the list of other teams receiving votes.
No hype. Just the facts.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Vegas, Poinsettia bowls or bust 2:01 a.m.
- Wildcats face tough defense 1:59 a.m.
- Aggies look to Idaho for an example 1:58 a.m.
- Aggies host Southern Utah 1:53 a.m.
- Cougars turn back Wildcats' 1:44 a.m.
- Cougar women lose at home 1:41 a.m.
- Sloan's two point guard lineup 1:39 a.m.
- BYU football: 5 keys to victory 1:36 a.m.
- RSL's Movsisyan departs 1:36 a.m.
- Glover gives Utes last-second upset 1:27 a.m.
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
265 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
211 - Thunder rolls by Jazz
136 - Letters: Rushing to judge Palin
133 - Boys basketball rankings
128 - Editorial: Poor welcome for Palin
112 - Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
109 - Letters: Trump card for believers
93 - Rivalry Week is highly profane
85 - Utah, BYU are top choices for bowls
75
It's finally time for the game that everyone has been waiting for all...
I could tell BYU was ready to play Saturday afternoon even before the...
Carlos Boozer denied that playing so well against the Chicago Bulls held...
Score more points.
When the coach is organized and runs the team, there is consistancy. When...
Hello Anonymous...you chicken to let us know who you are? What is wrong with...
Speed kills. Utes win.
Coach Whittingham!
And Y'all thought BYU football was Bi-Polar? Somebody get these guys some meds!
Instead of getting rid of football let's get rid of the crap that you teach...
Speed kills, as we have seen with TCU and Florida St. Utah is faster and more...
Kudos to the Utes on a big win. It makes the Aggies loss to you hurt just a...
is why we're so up and down. I think they will be solid by conference play....

Like say the SEC with:
The LSU Tigers and the Auburn Tigers
AND
The Georgia Bulldogs and the Mississippi State Bulldogs