Reader comments
Dick Harmon: Pac-10 will snub BYU, Utah
324 comments | Read story
BYU, btw, has a very well-respected Track program with many athletes who have also competed, and won, in the Olympics.
As far as being deserving, the state of Utah is the largest state in the country that does not have a BCS school. I went to Pullman, WA to see the Utes beat those cougars and found it interesting and fortunate for WSU that they are big time PAC 10 and not WAC member Idaho that is 10 miles away.
As far as comparing the performance of the two schools vs PAC 10, even that is not as valid considering the millions of dollars those schools get to use toward upgrading their programs; facilities, coaches, etc. BYUTAH loses a lot of recruits based on conference afiliation.
From Wikipedia, "Research I university was a category used by the Carnegie Classification of Institutions of Higher Education to indicate those universities in the United States which received the highest amounts of Federal science research funding." It had nothing whatsoever to do with the adademic/teaching quality of a school.
"The Carnegie Foundation has updated this terminology noting:
Doctorate-granting Universities. With this edition, doctorate-granting institutions are once again differentiated based on an explicit measure of research activity. We now use a multi-measure index rather than the single measure of federal funding used in previous editions [...] Using the new methodology, we have identified three categories of doctorate-granting institutions. Because of these changes, the new categories are not comparable to those previously used (Research I & II and Doctoral I & II; and Doctoral/Research�Extensive and Intensive).[1]
References
^ Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. Basic Classification Description. Retrieved on 2007-11-25.
See also
Carnegie Classification of Institutions of Higher Education"
Bob Wilson
Pullman, Washington
Add to this the fact that BYU is not a research university and you've got a solid case for rejecting them from the league.
The concept that sharing a much bigger pie with everyone, meaning that they would actually make more money than they are now, is more than their tiny, self-absorbed brains can handle.
The same thinking that has kept the PAC-10 from taking advantage of an opportunity to expand by inviting two very good universities to join their conference.
The PAC 10 recruiting advantage of being in a BCS conference with a big TV deal and great bowl tie-ins will be moot. BYU and Utah have seen numerous recruits slip away for this very reason.
The fact is that if BYU and Utah entered the PAC 10 as it is today they would have a significant boost in recruiting ability. This in effect would result in a direct negative impact on teams like WSU, UW, Oregon, OSU, ASU, and Arizona that don't have a distinct reputation advantage that the 4 cali schools have.
This is a greater reason for these teams to oppose expansion than anything because this is where the real revenue impact will be for those schools. Teams like WSU, OSU and UA can barely get people to go to their games as it is. This would put their programs in severe financial trouble.
The ultimate answer is for both the Utes and coogers to succeed in actual competition by winning games against all comers both at home and on the road. Boosters at each school need to root for their rivals when they face out of conference opponents. They should hope that all conference titles must pass through either Utah or byu. They must wish for each school to do well in NCAA events so as to raise to profile of both that school and their conference rival. They must upgrade their schedules so as to play against the BSC conferences consistanly and win those games.
GO UTES!!! and byu too!
BSU, find Papa Smurf and see if you can play???
BYU LOL!!!!!
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!
A national championship playoff is coming to college football; the PAC-10 and Big Ten will either jump aboard the bandwagon or be left behind.
The majority of fans cannot be ignored forever.
The perfect storm is coming.
There's a thought: IMPROVE COMPETITION in the Conference in which you reside?!?!?!
If the Utes and Cougars would just get over their small town rivalry for five minutes, they would realize that the Mountain West Conference really isn't such a bad deal; and it could be a lot better, if it were to stop comparing itself to "bigger schools" after every mediocre season beating up on San Diego State and Wyoming!
So to all fans from the glorious state of Utah: Swallow your pride, Get over your monstrously huge egos, and find a way to make the conference better! Bring everyone up, and then we won't need the Pac-10 to come crawling our way!
("I have a dream... that one day, USC will ask for an invite into the MWC!")
UT,A&M,OU,KU,TT etc. and in basketball and other sports. BYU fnas enough already! Stop emberassing your school,self.
You know the real reason why the PAC-10 doesn't want BYU and Utah? I think you do. FEAR!
Fear that schools from little ole' Utah will improve and continually compete at your level. Fear that another school from little ole' Utah will be able to win a national championship against the high and mighty schools of the west coast.
We BYU and Utah fans read the Internet too. We know how many of the national commentators were disgusted when Ty Detmer won the Heisman Trophy, and when Alex Smith was drafted #1 by the 49ers. We know how all of you hate seeing the underdogs beat your precious big shot colleges. And we also know how much you hate playing by the rules.
One example of this is the University of Oregon, who recently hired a wealthy booster, with no college degree, as its new athletic director. Talk about putting the FOX in charge of the HEN HOUSE!
Face it! Big schools DON'T want to play by the rules, they DON'T want to share the $$$$, and they DO want to keep everyone thinking, they and only they, know how to play sports.
The nay sayers were WRONG! Put the big fish in the big pond and see who emerges as the Top Dog! BSU has won more division one football games in the last 6 years than all but 3 teams (Florida, LSU and Texas).
My point is...BYU in the PAC 10 may have a rough road for a year or two, but they will start getting more money, better recruits and bigger prizes for winning bigger games. How many great LDS recruits have opted for BCS schools so that their path to professional sports is made much clearer?
If the invite ever came, we would be fools not to jump in the "big pond" of the PAC 10.
Utah last season however could not even get a victory over a lower Pac-10 school oregon state!
With that said, it would make sense to put together a strong football conference with the leftovers. Make it a requirement to fill at least 40,000 seats, have strong teams or bring something of value to the league. Utah, BYU, Fresno and Air Force all fill the requirement. Boise State is adding to their stadium. Hawaii is Hawaii. Everyone recruits in Hawaii and they have good teams. San Diego State is in California and would be a good rival for Fresno. The other unknowns are TCU with poor attendance, New Mexico with a small stadium and lackluster attendance, UNLV with their small stadium and poor attendance, UTEP is improving.
It would allow a better football conference and we wouldn't have to worry about being shut out.
ASU is classified as a Research 1 university (like MIT, Harvard, UCLA, Stanford, etc). Every year the Engineering and Education programs are in the top 20 best programs in the US. Not to mention the Business college programs are classified always top 10 in the US too.
The past few years ASU got more top academic scholarships nationwide than the likes of the Ivy League schools including Harvard, even more than Stanford (Pac-10 school).
Sorry, but BYU is more like our Mesa Community College (MCC) compared with ASU.
Compare BYU and Utah's combined record against ranked opponents to Oregon St. and Washington St.'s record against ranked opponents over the last 20 years (giving an extra bonus point to Oregon St. and BYU for each beating the number one team in the nation once during that time). I don't have the time to look it up, but if someone does, please post it and let us know. My guess would be that, percentage-wise, BYU and Utah have faired much better against top 25 opponents than half of the teams in the Pac-10.
Part of the problem with using "when has"'s argument is that top 25 teams often don't play BYU and Utah, because both have (at different times) been known to be far better than most mid-majors. Its a lose-lose for a good BCS school to play a good mid-major: You win...you were supposed to. You lose...it looks awful.
Oregon St. finished 6-3 PAC-10; 9-4 overall.
UCLA finished 5-4 PAC-10; 6-7 overall.
BYU/Utah get's to continue on their path of doing everything they can to win whos put in front of them and play each other in the Holy War. And turn this rivalry into a Ohio St. vs Michigan type match up.
Why not make this the elite conference? Where BCS wants to invite the whole conference rather than spliting it up again and again and again.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Man accused in mugging 7:41 p.m.
- Four Jazzmen out for tonight 7:40 p.m.
- Defense witness goes on offensive 7:21 p.m.
- Pitta doesn't win award 7:20 p.m.
- Disappearance called 'sususpicious' 7:00 p.m.
- Depleted uranium OK'd for storage 6:51 p.m.
- Snow may fly with weekend warm-up 6:33 p.m.
- ATK to cut 800 jobs 6:11 p.m.
- Cops: Artist's son swipes paintings 5:57 p.m.
- Incentives to create new jobs 5:51 p.m.
- Nude bathers cited for lewdness
- Few details on missing W.V. mom
- Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
- Crash landing next to I-15
- Defense witness goes on offensive
- BCS = power conference monopoly
- Palin signs books, chats with fans
- I-15 expansion barreling south
- 5 officers lose their certification
- Y.'s Emery bruised, but rarely beaten
- Letters: Global warming a lie
255 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
206 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
193 - Palin signs books, chats with fans
158 - Cougars going back to Vegas
150 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
149 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
142 - Max Hall wants to look ahead
124 - Nude bathers cited for lewdness
117 - Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
109
When the 2008-09 season wrapped up, the Aggies had a 30-5 record and...
ESPN's Mark Schlabach ranked the Las Vegas Bowl as the seventh most...
2009 would have been a daunting year for ANY president trying to keep/get...
'Do you want more?' - 7:16 p.m. I'm sorry if I was being unclear Ash. You...
The state of Mississippi gave ATK $25 million to build a new factory in Iuka,...
Aliens ... Aliens ... Aliens Entering our system through a black hole.
I think Harline was better, don't get me wrong, Pitta is a great TE, But...
I am speechless. It is difficult to understand how the TE that is leading...
So Cincinnati will be playing in the Sugar Bowl without a head coach. I...
While I agree that it's ridiculous he didn't win, I don't think it has...
To "what????" at 5:52 P.M., the original headline read: "Officer kills...
I would love to know the directions on how to make the heart. Anyone know?


The dark days ended in 2005 when Bronco took over the program.
BYU is already well on its way to returning to its glory days.