Reader comments
Utah Housing helping workers commute

2 comments   |   Read story

Michael T. Packard | 10:03 a.m. July 5, 2008
The only way even a small percentage will ride UTA is if it is FREE! Most of these 55 pass holders won't ride it.

Now UTA is trying to inflate FrontRunner ridership with the free-pass gimmick. But, FrontRunner costs many times more per passenger-mile.

Transit is not flexible, timely, available, or responsive enough to begin to compete with cars, even at $4 a gallon.

NEWS FLASH: Despite propaganda from UTA/APTA, only a few percent of trips that people have stopped making by car, switched to transit. See the "antiplanner blog" of Mr. Randall O'Toole.

UTA pumped TRAX ridership with about 70,000 free passes at the U of U , the University Hospital and other health businesses there, for government--church--and business users downtown, and free fare zones. There are also about 130,000 more--mostly free-- bus-pass holders at other colleges/ universities.

The RUDAT report for West Valley City in 1997, by the American Institute of Architects said it something like this. Transit is not a feasible or reasonable alternative, to the car, for 95% of us.



Most will pay for "free" passes with hundreds of hours of extra travel time each year. See the Census.

TRANSIT IS A TIME KILLER.
Utah Transport | 10:39 a.m. July 5, 2008
Running up the cost of transit....

About 17 employees used to ride in UTA supplied vans. Now some of those will switch to more expensive modes: bus, TRAX, FrontRunner. The cost structure has gone from most economical to more expensive. It is likely that executives/yuppies will get massively subsidized train rides; that has been the past experience with commuter train riders.

Bus and TRAX cost several times more per passenger mile than vans.

Frontrunner costs over ten times more per passenger mile than vans. (See the legislative UTA audit, Chapter 5).

When all costs are included, FrontRunner will need the most subsidy while vanpools need the least. FrontRunner has the lowest Farebox revenue as a percentage of TOTAL COSTS; Vanpools have the highest. (Figure 5.2: Subsidy Levels by Type of Service, page 65; also see page 61 for comments on Commuter Rail high costs),(FTA's 5309 New Starts Criteria analysis for North FrontRunner has more build/operating cost per mile data).

Pass programs like this allow UTA to mix in new high cost passes for their newest rail boondoggles with passes for the lower cost modes to hide the exorbitant high costs of big trains.

It helps them build their empire.



Add your comment

Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.

Words Remaining

E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.

Advertisement
previousnext

Latest comments

It's hard to factor in BYU stats when 70% of BYU students aren't actually...

Blow the dust off your specs. He's also 6-2 and weighs 235. Not like the...

Hey, Doug G., sometimes doing nothing is BETTER than doing something,...

Y. tight ends talented tandem

Bite your ute tongue!

One of the strange misconceptions people have on this site is the idea that...

So how is this this enforced? Young people with sporadic income and jobs, no...

First, Utahans...take this opportunity for NO TAXES on unprepared food. ...

Gays get Mormon support in SLC

["He placed thorns in my flesh to teach me humility"] wow. you should sue...

This is about Kelly, not Brady. Brady is playing with the Packers.

Gays get Mormon support in SLC

It's a start. Now keep going.

Advertisements
Advertisement