Reader comments
News analysis: Cannon: Disunity besets U.S., Utah GOP
139 comments | Read story
Then this year there was a primary in February. Why can't we consolidate and organize the Primary election confusion?
Maybe more people would vote if things were consistent!
If they don't want any voters, they got what they wanted this year!
Congratulations!
Cannon lost for two reasons: dissatisfaction with all things D.C. nowadays, and illegal immigration. GOP voters have spoken.
Mr. Cannon provided a lot of service and was a decent representative for a dozen years. But he made a few mistakes, and you can't please all the people all the time. I wish him well in his future.
Citizens live our lives. We elect congressmen to serve our interests. If those congressmen don't understand why citizens are upset then it's their fault, not ours.
Those "boorish" booers at the state convention? They get maybe one chance every few years to speak directly to their supposed representatives, who in turn speak TO us constantly in a fawning Utah press uncritical of incumbents.
Years ago a guy named Ronald Reagan remade conservatism and the Republican Party by making a deal with Americans: if you're honest, play by the rules, work hard, and make wise choices, you'll be able to provide for your family and maybe have a little extra for fun. The current GOP leaderhip has completely abandoned that. The blue collar Republican voters - the ones who compete at work and in their neighborhoods with illegal immigrants - are leaving the building in droves.
The man is in total and complete denial. Every negative aspect of the man is coming out in the post-election news. He's disturbed, disrespectful, deceptive and meanspirited. In 2004 his defeated primary opponent, Matt Throckmorton, immediately endorsed Cannon in his concession speech. Jacob did the same in 2006. But Chris Cannon has yet to endorse Cahheftz ffor November, and is even suggesting (which probably means hoping) Chaffetz will lose.
The excuse of low voter turnout just doesn't play. In pre-primary polls of the whole district he was barely tied with Chaffetz, and 16% were undecided - which in a year as bad as this won't break for the incumbent.
Low turnout? What's a "good turnout" year - 2006? In 2006 14,000 more people showed up than Tuesday. Chaffetz won by over 9,000 votes. So the only way Cannon would've won with 14,000 more people at the polls is if 11,500 of them (82%) voted for him. Sure, Chris.
No Chris. The reason you lost is because of your wishy-washy position on illegal immigration. Utah voters want firm and decisive action. They want illegal immigration stopped! They want illegals kicked out. The border fence is not the way. Absolute enforcement of illegal immigrant labor laws is.
Utah is tired of putting up with 5 to 7 cable channels carrying Spanish programs. I'm paying for TV channels I can't understand. Utah is tired of the presence of Spanish written everywhere you look. And tired of providing free education and health care for illegals and their children.
That's why you lost, Chris.
I could easily see Bennett getting ousted in two years, especially if he continues to ignore his constituents and vote for things like the massive immigration amnesty proposed by McCain/Kennedy last year.
I went to his Provo office a couple years ago with some friends who were State delegates and his local staff was combative and rude to us as we tried to express our feelings about Bennetts' votes in favor of amnesties. Despite hundreds of calls and faxes, he still voted wrong on amnesty last year.
At least Hatch has enough political savvy to realize that Utahns are paying attention to immigration issues.
It's hilarious that Cannon wants to start his own version of grass roots efforts. He could learn a lot about that from Mr. Chaffetz.
"The Senate president said if the Republicans had lost a number of incumbents in the convention or primaries, it might signal a broader discontent"
Dear Mr. valentine, I think that the Republicans should be very worried this year and that Hatch and Bennett should look @ retiring The days of Curtis, Bramble and Buttars are nearing an end! Thank goodness.
"It has been said that politics is the second oldest profession. The longer I am in it, the more it resembles the first." Ronald Reagan
I just hope that the anger this year won't cause voters to head in a direction that will be seriously damaging to our country. Let's all support Jason. He will need it.
Hmmm. And why can't we win elections in California aymore?
One-third of the residents are Democratic-leaning Hispanics. Only 47% of California voters are white. 27% of Californians are FIRST GENERATION immigrants. Throw in their kids and that's well over half the population. Middle class whites who want to raise families - that is, CONSERVATIVE whites - have had to flee the state for more affordable places.
California is lost BECAUSE of the idiotic immigration policies embraced by Chris Cannon, George W Bush and their ilk.
As for Virginia? My aunt and uncle have owned a home outside of DC for the last 40+ years. They've witnessed firsthand the rapid transformation of Northern Virginia thanks to - what? - immigration.
So surprise! Mass immigration by people who come from socialist cultures is not good for the conservative party.
Chris Cannon talks about Republicans winning elections. I don't care if Republicans win if conservatives aren't winning. Thanks to mass immigration that's happening less and less.
Maybe, if he had done the job he was elected to do in the first place and found out what his local constituents were concerned about, he would not have to resort to name calling. He no longer represented us but rather represented Washington interests(see where his campaign contributions came from).
Also, low voter turnout was not the reason for his 9,000 vote loss. His voters who were "at the lake" obviously were not enthused to show up for him. He seems unaware that the last three primaries he has been in, have all been well under the capacity of Lavell Edwards Stadium(65,000 capacity). In fact, his 2004 Primary against Throckmorton had almost the same number of voters as this years. Strange how he didn't complain back then about the 'tragedy' of the lack of voters.
2004 Primary voters= 47,335
2006 Primary voters= 59,023
2008 Primary voters= 45,374+ (one uncounted pricinct)
They worried about a career president and the power of one so popular as rosevelt that they fainaly put term limits on the presidency
2) Americans (including Republicans in the Third District) who do not vote in all elections they are entitled to, should realize that by not voting they allow minority special interests to become the majority and win elections -- and the majority will find they are losing their freedoms. I understand that apathy is a symptom for ignorance: ignorance of the issues and candidate positions, and ignorance of what freedom is based on.
3) Those who believe they are religious, and who do not exercise their freedom to vote, are living a contradictory delusion.
Vote out all incumbents unless the other option (Obama) is not really an option.
Any polititian who was pro-voucher needs to go.
Any politician who has been in for two terms needs to go.
I am solidly conservative but I think this state needs to be inoculated with a strong dose of liberalism for at least four years.
Finally, Mr. Hatch needs to brush up on his song writting. I see unemployment in his future.
Ok all you ultra-conservative, Utah county, Orthadox Mormons; let me have it!
There is nothing as constant as change.
Sad what we've allowed politics to become and it is up to us to clean it up.
Senator Hatch's statements on this issue are not "conservative."
The Citizens are tired of GOP BIG OIL POLICY, we don�t want to drill in ANWR, it won�t help anyone but your BIG OIL supporters.
We want CLEAN RENEWABLE ALTERNATIVE ENERGY, made right here in the USA!
We are tired of GOP INFLATIONARY SPENDING, Military, Police, Homeland Security, etc. that adds more money to our economy, but does nothing to increase the amount of goods and services available for our purchase.
We want projects like NAWAPA, MAGLEV trains, that will create good paying jobs in the USA!
We are tired of hearing that these things can�t be done because of the environmentalists.
YOU FAILED TO DO YOUR JOB ---- GO MAKE MONEY IN THE PRIVATE SECTOR AND LEAVE THE POLITICS TO HONEST PEOPLE!
BEING A CONGRESSMAN IS ABOUT SERVICE, NOT ABOUT A CAREER!
HATCH, BENNETT, SHURTLEFF, AND HUNTSMAN NEED TO GO AS WELL!
VOTE ONLY FOR THOSE WHO PLEDGE TO END THE OIL BASED ECONOMY.
As for blaming "low voter turnout" let's look at what causes "low voter turnout" -- very few primary races. Almost all races ended at the Republican convention, carefully controlled by party insiders with their automatic delegates (oops ex-officio delegates), appointed replacement delegates, discretionary delegates and "ballot box antics", all carefully used to insure incumbents a speedy return to office without primary contests, and the unhearalded result is "low voter turnout".
Why just Republican primaries? Where are the public able to help choose the Democrat candidates, Constitutional party candidates? Why should everyone else participate in the Republican failures of control by party bosses?
Anyway, that same "low voter turnout" so carefully managed by party insiders may have resulted in the loss of one of their own at the top of the ticket? Maybe somebody might get a clue.
Yes, there is a split in the Republican party, and Steve White nailed it, those who do not support all the deficit spending and other failures of the Bush leadership have voted for someone new. Good for them!!!
You can't speak for everyone. Yes, there are immigrants here and they are here illegally. That needs to be fixed. But Hispanic people are welcome here, as are the signs they read and the stations they watch. The whole world isn't white and everyone doesn't speak English. Open your mind and start seeing what the future holds - a beautiful mix of all cultures where we can learn from each other and enjoy each other's cultural diversity.
Most telling was Cannon's remark that now that he is no longer restrained by his elected position, he can talk candidly about what is wrong with Utah and the US. Hello, Mr. Cannon, didn't Utahns elect you to speak candidly about these problems in the first place? Why did you get to washington and swallow your tongue? Was it more important for you not to offend your collegaues there by exposing their graft than it was to represent the true interests of your constituents and "tell it like it is?" The fact you can only now speak out about our problems speaks volumes about why you were defeated. Since you've been sitting on this information about what ails the country and the state for so long, you've lost credibility to bring it forward now. You had the chance to make a difference and all you gave was more of the same.
And as for low voter turnout, just imagine what a few primary races in the Utah House and Senate would have done for the turnout. If Shepherd had had two more votes or Houskeeper one more (two were rejected by Monnahan & Company as missing an unknown cutoff date), or if Bramble himself had faced a primary race, the turnout would have been much larger.
Instead, our party bosses chose to have no primary contests, so the turn out was low. One might said they did it to themselves as they got almost everything they wanted at the bottom of the ticket and lost one of their own at the top of the ticket because of "low voter turnout".
And, what of the Democrats and Constitutionalists? Why no primary races there either?
The Republican Party is now the Democratic Party, growing government into this monster that usurps all power, redistributes all wealth removes all incentive to create and excell.
Now we have a bankrupt nation that cannot even defend itself because it owes it's very soul to China which has financed our massive debt.
This country has long since abandoned the principles on which she was built and blessed. Now we get to reap the rewards of our stupidity.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Lawmaker warns of budget shortfall 11:09 p.m.
- Fewer H1N1 cases reported in S.L. 11:09 p.m.
- Conference touts locally grown foods 11:08 p.m.
- Sports briefs 11:08 p.m.
- Refinery video to be released 11:07 p.m.
- Weber's Toone gets another honor 11:06 p.m.
- Activist's necessity defense barred 10:58 p.m.
- National news capsules 10:54 p.m.
- World datelines 10:53 p.m.
- Gunmen abduct, kill 13 in Baghdad 10:50 p.m.
- MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight
- Relieved Cougs prep for Falcons
- Wounded Utes limp home
- Jazz rookies had to grow up quickly
- Big games keep UHSAA coffers full
- Barzee is expected to plead guilty
- Sloan misses practice
- RSL surprised by Chicago's Fire
- Low in vit. D? Beware heart disease
- Jazz notes: Young bigs ride bench
- TCU creams U.
233 - BYU happy to escape with victory
232 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
226 - Will state consider gay rights law?
162 - RSL heads to MLS title game
134 - Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?
133 - MWC expand? Get rid of deadweight
122 - TCU stays 4th in AP; Y. 19th, U. 23rd
115 - 5A: Bingham rolls to title game
108 - Bennett at center of GOP storm
89
The Gateway, 400 W. 200 South, will kick off the holiday shopping season...
I was a bit under the weather last week, which gave me some time to...
We are so proud of the team, GO RSL !!!!!!!
I'm not giving up on CJ just yet... by all accounts it looks like he has...
I personally think lineman make or break a team. If you have a good back but...
Second thoughts: Exchange Wyoming and New Mexico for Boise State and...
at TCU so the 1-A/2-A finals could have been hosted at Rice Eccles. I agree,...
I WANT DONNY OSMOND & KYM TO WIN THE CHAMPIONSHIP ON DANCING WITH THE STARS,...
I have been advocating exchanging Wyoming for Boise State for some time now....
Why is it always a religion's fault? get off that tired narrow minded kick!!...
So, most of the time I hear QB's defending the O-Line like their own mother....
I have always been taught that Christ did visit all major populations, we...


Cannon stopped listening to anyone who disagreed with him a long time ago. He could have held on to his seat if he would have humbled himself, taken responsibility for some of his gaffs, and tried to change some of his undesirable attributes.
Cannon is a nice guy, and actually did a pretty good job for us in D.C. His main problem was that he was unable to communicate with his constituents and make them feel good about themselves and his representation of them.
I wish Cannon well, and hope he will swallow his pride and endorse Chaffetz (who has a little too much pride of his own).