Reader comments
Long litany of legal disputes begins in FLDS raid

208 comments   |   Read story

Good for the goose | 10:17 a.m. May 14, 2008
When one 'renounces' their faith, it is not for the hope of getting their kids back from a force that is bound and determined to not give them back. When one joins the LDS church, catholic church, baptist church, they ALL 'roundounce'the other faith they just left, by the very act of leaving.

As my kids would say: DUHHH
Abe | 10:23 a.m. May 14, 2008
Hunh. I guess I missed the episodes of Larry King and Good Morning America where the mothers brought their birth certificates for their kids. Maybe I'll see that soon on Oprah.
Michigander | 10:26 a.m. May 14, 2008
When the raid happened there was mass shuffling around of children and no real ID of people given. It appears that it was the exception that one of the mothers had some ID, but since the rest did not or played musical chairs with names and ages, CPS had little choice to use their best judgment.
Comments continue below
Ekim | 10:32 a.m. May 14, 2008
I continue to be utterly amazed at all of the apologists for child abuse.

And these same people would be screaming to high heaven if nothing had been done.

Go Texas!!
Kevin T. | 10:34 a.m. May 14, 2008
To- John....

I WASN'T AWARE THAT NAZI-ISM WAS LEGAL IN AMERICA - that is until I saw what Texas has done.

Looks to me like one big Nazi game after another with the FLDS and Texas. If it isn't with the state of Texas, then NAZI-ISM is practiced within the walls of the FLDS compound. Two wrongs don't make any of this right. Slavery was abolished long ago. Truly, God has nothing to do with this insanity.
RE: PHIL | 10:40 a.m. May 14, 2008
Phil, you are.....well....an idiot! There is a rather large diference between losing children due to a natural disaster, than losing ones child due to physical, sexual abuse, in wich you are guilty of commiting. PERIOD.
Re: Abe | 10:39 a.m. May 14, 2008
Do your reasearch before you spread hate. These girls DID provide Birth Certificates. Texas thought them not legit until after their babies were born.
Freddie | 10:40 a.m. May 14, 2008
"The ones who should pay are the 60 year olds marrying 14 year old girls in the name of God. Please."

Not to worry. The 60 year old will likely be dead in ten years when the 14 year old is 24.
to sobbing child | 10:41 a.m. May 14, 2008
Amen!
The children have been damaged for life in an unloving foster care system. We should storm Texas and get them out so they don't suffer any longer.
As for the lack of proof of ages, how could they proof anything? CPS had their mind up already about the FLDS and nothing would have convinced them otherwise. Besides why would the FLDS expected to give information without speaking to an attorney first and by then, the documents had been confiscated by CPS. Texas will never admit any wrong doing and bring up more and more false claims while the children are crying for their moms.
mistereporter | 10:44 a.m. May 14, 2008
Abe writes, "In the United States I live in people have birth certificates."

Not to worry, Abe: Texas will prepare and issue official birth certificates when it puts the children up for adoption.
wrz | 10:49 a.m. May 14, 2008
"I have read a report that the service plans calls for them to essentially renounce their religion. I hope that is not true."

And if it does, you can bet your last dollar that the US Constitution's Bill of Rights is dead. Free speech is in the last throes of dying... so why not freedom of religion? As we march closer and closer to our conversion to totalitarian Nazi-ism. God help us!
oh bother | 10:52 a.m. May 14, 2008
There is a difference between forced marriages and arranged marriages. Odd that you blame the men and put the women as victims. It seem clear to me that if there are victims, both the males and the females are both equal victims growing up in the same cult.
? | 11:04 a.m. May 14, 2008
It's been more than a month since this all started and yet there are no charges being filed. I think that Texas better put up, or return the children. Where is the evidence that there was law breaking going on? Heaven help those that destroy families.
Action Committee | 11:06 a.m. May 14, 2008
I have just called Senator Hatch's office in DC and asked the office what the Senator is doing about what is happening to the children in Texas and they said he is doing nothing because it is in Texas. Please give him some help and explain this is a national crime being commited by the CPS.
Utah children are also caught up in this.
betty | 11:07 a.m. May 14, 2008
i have no way of knowing exactly where the above posters are but i would bet the farm that they are part of the public relations blitz that the fdls are pushing to the country.
the fathers are child rapists, stealing our countrys money, the mothers are aggreeing to the abuse of their daughters and sending their sons out to fend for themselves.
these are not mothers, they are baby making machines for pedofiles.
Possible answer | 11:16 a.m. May 14, 2008
I have seen a few posts asking, where are all The Fathers? I have a quick observation to make and a very probable answer to that question, in light of the fact that a legal battle like they are going thru is extremely expensive, I would guess that the fathers are busy working to raise the money to save their loved ones, and defend Your Constitution. Keep in mind; I like all of you am only Guessing.
Re: Wake Up | 11:16 a.m. May 14, 2008
With all due respect, I understand your position, but as many have shown this group is an entirely different culture. I know people who belong to groups not unlike this, not FLDS or LDS, and due to the way they raise their children they are more mature at that age. I had to grow up fast due to horrific family situations and I married young and I am very well adjusted and have children. I would not think most people my age would be ready, but these young girls (I am not condoning child brides but trying to take off egocentric views and cultural barriers) they may deem themselves to be. Forced early marriage is a whole different issue.
L. J. Hammer | 11:18 a.m. May 14, 2008
This outrageous injustice makes me embarrassed to be an American and I certainly am thankful that I'm not a Texan. Texas officials seem to make up the law as they go along. It is shameful . . . trying to save face at the expense of these innocent women and children. May God forgive you.
re: Bill | 11:17 a.m. May 14, 2008
To Bill, do you think the FLDS are going to release the photos of the 60 year old men and 14 year old "wives?" Of course not! They aren't idiots. This is a PR game. They round up all the "normal" looking photos and give them to the press. The press then use the photos and we sit there thinking, "Well, what a nice family. How dare Texas pick on these poor people."

The same goes for the videos on the websites. We see children happily playing on the ranch and then crying in CPS custody. It's all to draw sympathy for the FLDS. They may not be doctors and lawyers, but they certainly are apt at making things appear differently than they are. I don't trust propaganda. You always have to look at the source of the information. Everyone has an agenda.
Freedom for Americans | 11:21 a.m. May 14, 2008
I agree with "Proactive".
In the last few weeks have written about claims against Texas but we are on the wrong track. We see people on here who are demented and have no feeling for these children the only thing they know is stamping out polygamy. I'm not for it either, but...
We need these children free and today. We need these children back with their mothers were they belong.
We need everyone to contact their elected representatives and let them know how they feel.
The issues today are not the price of gas or the primary election but the real issue is these small children and their mothers.
This is a crime against American.
Anonymous | 11:20 a.m. May 14, 2008
Good for the goose -
To "duhhhh"
You are speaking from your Mormon upbringing saying you have denounced everything, (and I know where that comes from)
It may surprise you that in the Catholic tradition, if you believe in Christ, you are considered under the same universal umbrella (Catholic means universal).
So please speak for yourselves and not others.
Re: Where there's smoke | 11:22 a.m. May 14, 2008
I would have agreed with you until I read MHMR's rebuttal of such statements and I will believe them over a disenchanted book author or CPS anyday. MHMR was a third party observer and refutes your rumors.
Southern Utahan | 11:29 a.m. May 14, 2008
I've lived in Southern Utah my whole life, not far from Colorado City and I have to say that all of the FLDS women look young! Every single one of them! I just don't understand how Texas can say that she's still a minor when she's given them all the necessary proof to prove otherwise! How heartless can you be to take a 1 year old child from his mother? How would the CPS workers like it if someone took their child away after it's 1st birthday?
Against polygamy | 11:30 a.m. May 14, 2008
Yes, it's high time we asked the Supreme Court once again to rule on the legality of prohibitions against polygamy. This will happen only if Texas, Utah or Arizona start enforcing laws against polygamy. Mark Shurtleff, get off your duff and prosecute somebody. We'll then have a test case, and the polygamists will begin either to abandon plural marriage, or they'll move to El Salvador or some other country that will permit them to live as they please. If we don't do something now we'll have millions of polygamists in two or three generations.

Are you afraid your church, the LDS church, would reinstitute polygamy? No, I don't think you have anything to worry about there. It's hard enough to live Mormon rules without having to support and keep happy two or more wives.
Denise | 11:32 a.m. May 14, 2008
For those that keep hollering about WHY the FLDS did not show their "papers" at the beginning of all of this, remember they did NOT ask for any papers such as birth certificates, marriage licenses, driver's licenses at the moment they took the women and children into custody.

But the Police DID secure "More than 80 pages of items have been taken from the Yearn for Zion Ranch. Among the items seized were computer equipment, letters, school and medical records, including marriage and birth records."

Kind of hard to produce your "documentation" when the police have it all. I know if I lost my Birth Certificate it would take about 30 days for me to request one from New York and have them mail it to Texas.

And then it did not do the FLDS much good, because the Judge and CPS stated they WOULD NOT accept any "documents" from the FLDS because they might be forged.
Re: Possible Answer | 11:35 a.m. May 14, 2008
Your post in regards to that is the first unhate filled specualation. Why are we taught tolerance to Man Boy Love Association and other devient sexual behavior and all that is okay..even two daddies and no mommies are okay, but one father and two loving mothers is not. CPS claims this is child abuse due to underage marriages. They have yet to show a current young lady who, when in Texas, was pregnant under 16. So, unlike most of you posters, they are innocent until proven guilty (unlike CPS) and I cannot believe for a second that EVERY family is guilty of the said crimes. That is why CPS is grasping straws to find ANYTHING to claim all the children, even to the point of saying their religion is now abusive outside of what the law states is legal. Until a crime has been committed we have due process, which was denied. A lot of you here are still going off Rozita's madeup statement--why not give them the benefit of the doubt until you find a crime--then only spew your hate to the perverts--not the whole community.
re: Re: Bill | 11:37 a.m. May 14, 2008
Okay, so now you are saying because of the one or few perverted marriages, you are condemning these "normal" families and sobbing children who may not be a part of this. Even for those who are part of the perverted marriages, you are wanting to throw away the children's bonds to their mothers and condemn the mothers. You are heartless. Throw your passion into the 60 year old man you claim CPS has and leave the rest alone. You are "cattle call" ing like Walthers.
Joan | 11:43 a.m. May 14, 2008
Thank you Outraged Baptist.
Cheryl | 11:45 a.m. May 14, 2008
Quick question. On the FLDS website about their "captive children", I read about the daily schedules of the children. My question is, where do the fathers come into play? Not once does it describe an activity that the children do with the fahters, not even at bedtime....

I of course have a lot more questions, but I will start with one simple one.....
LDS convert | 11:49 a.m. May 14, 2008
I don't trust Texas CPS workers or foster care. I am convert, uphold LDS church, all doctrines, etc...but was raped repeatedly as a youth, (male) in foster care...it did not make me gay, but i have spent my whole life celibate now as I could not perform , with my wife...I am against abuse, but do not believe the children were abused...and I sure do not trust the state of texas...my foster care father who raped me was a man in government....Please pray to get the children back to the mothers. Now. Investigate the fathers, yes, but the children need their mothers. Please Deseret News put this in. In prayer children to be reunited with mothers.
Gentle folk | 11:50 a.m. May 14, 2008
I think we all know Pastor White from Chicago and his comments "God damn America" Undoubtedly, he is outraged at what he sees happening in America. I wonder how he views this raid in Texas?
The FLDS | 12:03 p.m. May 14, 2008
Need to stay away from the media. Sort it out with their legal counsel. Their PR campaign is getting ridiculous.

Can't believe so many of you follow the FLDS propaganda website and believe everything they say.
Educate me | 12:06 p.m. May 14, 2008
Bill of Rights. What does it say?
Constitution. What does it say?
????? | 12:14 p.m. May 14, 2008
Excuse me, but how freaking hard is it to determine a woman's age? IT'S CALLED A BIRTH CERTIFICATE!!! They've got all the paperwork... find her's, and move on! But no, they've got to drag it out, and insist, that they are right. Nevermind that fact most of their "credible info" has been wrong.
Constitionalist | 12:16 p.m. May 14, 2008
Everyone on here should memorise the Amendment IV of the Bill of Rights.
Start by looking at The Bill of Rights on your search engine
Birth Certificates | 12:16 p.m. May 14, 2008
My understanding is on YFZ Ranch/Prison there are doctor's facilities. The women who gave birth at the ranch used these facilities and did not go to hospitals or state linked facilities so I can see why CPS would question any "birth certificates."

Were the mothers born under similar circumstances? Something tells me few of these mothers were born in hospitals or by state sanctioned practitioners, so the validity of birth certificates is definitely a concern.
Deaf Words | 12:16 p.m. May 14, 2008
The debacle of Texas vs FLDS is just another sample of how government views the freedoms of We The People. Resistance against the State will not be tolerated nor unpopular beliefs, hence Waco tragedy and now FLDS. Our government is firing warning shots across our collective faces every day and we cower behind the "America can do no wrong" mantras we have adopted. Make no mistake people, America will fail unless we become ACTIVE in the cause against out of control government. Taking a stand against government tyranny isn't working against America its defending its existence.
BLF | 12:17 p.m. May 14, 2008
It's really sad to read a lot of the posts here. It's OK for men to impregnate girls young enough to be their granddaughters in the name of religion? This "religion" teaches hate for black people, hate for anyone who is different from them. Just because they speak softly doesn't mean anything. They literally worship the pedophile Jeffs who is in prison where he belongs. If he tells a father he must leave his family, off the father goes and the family is given to another man. These poor women have known nothing else and are nothing more than servants, sexually and otherwise, for the men they serve. I guess all you FLDS defenders also think it's OK that teenage boys are kicked out of the community, simply taken to town and left to fend for themselves? I do feel for the mothers, but should it just be allowed to go on indefinitely? The next step will be when many of the men are arrested. I look forward to seeing them get their just due like Jeffs did.
Sharon | 12:19 p.m. May 14, 2008
The family photo of Joseph and Lori Jessop is beautiful. Wondering to myself...if The State of Texas had not stepped in....would in years to come...little Ziana Glo end up a child bride...would the two little boys end up "The Lost Boys". I know many of you think it was wrong of Texas to take action against the FLDS, but I'd rather see Texas have custody of the children for the time being...then for a pretty little girl, such as Ziana Glo ...to end up with some dirty old perv in years to come.
Re: nantz | 12:24 p.m. May 14, 2008
Can't get through, to many LDS,FLDS posterson here,....go figure!!!!!

You obviously don't know enough about the LDS to distinguish between an LDS and a non-LDS poster.

What exactly are you trying to get through, to???
Re:Cheryl | 12:32 p.m. May 14, 2008
It's quite simple. The fathers don't interact with the children. It's the responsibility of the women to raise the children so the women do it. That's why you don't see interaction of children with fathers on the schedule.

The fathers don't come into play, that's why they aren't on the schedule. The fathers are there to rule over the family. They boss the wives around and the wives then boss the children around. It's a very hierarchical society. The husband and wives are not equals. They believe in order for a woman to go to heaven they have to be married and the men hold the keys to everyone getting into heaven. In oder for the men to obtain the highest level of salvation they have to have at least three wives. The more wives the more spiritual you are.
Anonymous | 12:34 p.m. May 14, 2008

What do the Bill of Rights and Constitution say?

What is DOESN'T say is it's okay to have sexual relations with relatives and children.
Phil in NC | 12:43 p.m. May 14, 2008
I am not an "FLDSer" but I have followed these events with great interest as I am a father of 9 homeschooled children. I have read everything on the subject from both sides of the fence and have called and talked to the FLDS families using the information on their captivefldschildren.com site. Given all of that, I just HAVE to ask, WHERE IN THE WORLD did "where there's smoke there's fire" get that ridiculous statistic about "half of the little girls were pregnant"? That is just the kind of gainsaying trash that feeds the fire of abuse against these people. When the Nazis came to Warsaw Poland and took the Jews away, they promised all of the mothers that they were just being relocated and that they would be able to stay with their children. We all know how those lies turned out. The Jewish children were farmed out to German foster homes where they could be raised "correctly" and the Jewish indoctrination could be purged from them. No one is saying the State is going to exterminate the mothers but, try to imagine what was on their minds when the armored personnel carriers and Storm troopers showed up.
transplant | 12:49 p.m. May 14, 2008
re: the article at USAToday by By Mary Zeiss Stange "....the American divorce rate, "serial polygamy" is closer to the norm � often culminating in precisely the pattern practiced by FLDS....
_________________

The difference in society at large is that women and men choose different partners at will at any time in their adult lives without having to relenquish their relationships with their children or family members. In FLDS especially but polygamy in general, it is only the men who can have multiple partners. In society at large it could be called serial monogamy. It is certainly not "serial polygamy". Divorce results in many relationships being severed but it's by mutual agreement by the parties involved. Not by the subdivision or municipality in which one lives.
Sharon | 12:51 p.m. May 14, 2008
Educate me 12:06 May 14,

Bill of Rights. What does it say ?...hummm RAPE? in the name of religion of course !

Constitution. What does it say?..huuuuuummmmm RAPE? in the name of religion of course.
Kris | 12:51 p.m. May 14, 2008
what I don't understand about all this is that if the men are the perpetrators why didn't the authorities come in and arrest all the men, instead of causing misery to the mothers and children? At least the mothers and kids would not have to have their lives turned upside down.
Phil | 1:01 p.m. May 14, 2008
RE: RE: Phil.....well, I've been called an idiot before and, since I cared nothing of the opinion of a stranger, it meant nothing to me. You say that I am guilty of committing physical and sexual abuse? Uhm, I am not FLDS and have only visited Texas twice in the last few years. Never heard of FLDS before this fiasco started. Makes me wonder .......... no, I'm quite sure... you are more the idiot than me.

FREE THE CHILDREN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Leroy G. | 1:05 p.m. May 14, 2008
April 4 or 5:
"Long described CPS interviews with seven girls, one of whom said she has two children but doesn't know her own age. Her 8-year-old stepdaughter, however, told CPS the girl is younger than 16 and has four children, the affidavit states."
Where is she? This would be CPS centerpiece if it were true! Evidently it was not true.
And now:

31 young women? - mothers or pregnant. 27 said they were 18 or older. What are the odds that all 27 actually are over 18? What if one by one they prove this?
Odds are that some of them must be lying about ages. But we do not know. It is possible that every one of those 27 are telling the truth. When CPS took the children, the mothers were allowed to go with them. It is likely that no pregnant women were left at the Ranch. It is also likely that no pregnant women were separated from children later on. CPS would have wanted their children and so would not have let them leave. The mothers would have wanted to stay with the children so there was no great incentive to prove they were 18.
Anonymous | 1:10 p.m. May 14, 2008
i just hope these young girls can get out of this abuse and be kids again and find some sort of normal life. I hope none of these so called parents even see there children again. The bottom line is that any adult male that can look at a teenage girl sexually is sick beyond words. I believe there is a special place in hell for these monsters that are hiding behind God.
Really Confused | 1:14 p.m. May 14, 2008
The State of Texas = Nazis? What about those who subjugate their free will; believing that another human being is the living prophet of God; speaking truths far greater than any other human can know? Or those who believe that they as a group are divinely chosen to be superior to other humans? Don't we all live among people who believe it is the work of the righteous to convert other misguided individuals into the "true" and "right" way of thinking and living? Don�t we prize ourselves on our lineage and heritage? Aren�t we convinced that those not in our tribe will experience annihilation? The State of Texas has subpoena power and the power to incarcerate the living. Other power centers (insert your favorite here) claim the right to determine a person's eternal salvation, damnation or coronation. It is just a question of selecting a particular dogma and surrendering your individuality. It's all about power. Those who would take yours might stand in front of a flag or an altar. Why are we so willing to chastise one while embracing the other?

Add your comment

Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.

Words Remaining

E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.

Image
Rene Haas

Clockwise from top, a family portrait of Joseph Steed Jessop Sr., Lori Jessop and their children; Ziana Glo Jessop, 4; Joseph Edson Jessop, 2; and Joseph Steed Jessop Jr., who turns 1 on Thursday. The FLDS family went to court to block the separation of the mother and infant child.

previousnext

Latest comments

I agree with the Anae supporters. He has been great for the program and I...

Gray dances away with dignity

I was sad to see her go home after what I considered one of her best...

Wow. What a concept.

To the little brother comment: BYUs most famous and successful person...

Classic Jazz.

"The Utes drew about 9,200 for both the Michigan and Oklahoma games..."...

BYU to wear royal blue uniforms

We have quit the childish bunch. BSU and Aggies fans are truly the baby...

Letters: Explaining Palin

@mark (snicker) 11:32 p.m.: "Yes, All Knowing (snicker) I have known poor...

Man lives in Moab cave

Wow, lots of hostility for the man. I wonder why? I don't think some of...

Stay the course with our president

You sure? What kind of oil can we cook with? What light bulb is "good"...

Advertisements