i was there. east snatched defeat from the jaws of victory.. in more than one
way. and it was a penalty. easy call
For those of you that are crying about the helmet to helmet call have to fall
into one of two categories: 1) Don't understand football or 2) Are East fans
and are looking for something to make them feel better about losing the game.
Have you all looked at the replay? Clearly helmet to helmet - no question! If
you want to question a play that could have changed the outcome of the game -
look to the decision to punt on 4th and 1. Ya - it would have been a gutty
call. Ya - would have given Logan the ball in field goal range if they don't
get the 1st down. But - with athletes like Cook and Molisi - I would take my
chances with them getting 1 yard versus giving the ball back to Logan...
P.S. Braxton, decided the outcome of the game... that play was on a 3rd and 6 as
I recall. To follow your inductive logic, Logan still had at least another down
and who is to say that the TD pass wouldn't have happened on the next play?!
Dumb comment Braxton. The ref saw and called a helmet to helmet. Would you
rather him not call it? A no call would have been inappropriate not the fact
that he called an infraction of the rules right in front of him. You would hope
that call would be made 10 out of 10 times. For all of you fixated on one call
in view of this entire game, I'll bet most of you have found one event in your
lives that you have pin pointed to blame all your woes on. Sad commentary for
The bottom line is, this game will always be tainted because of the call. Most
people I have talked to (even some in Cache County) believe the ref made a very
bold call that 7 out of 10 times the call would not be made. The fact that it
decided the outcome of the game, (without the call, the game belonged to East)
The game will always be tainted. And that is a shame to both sides and more to
I keep hearing about the cheap shots, I would like to know when? There were two
that were called on east, one on a kick-off that a player drilled the kicker
when the ball went out of the end zone, and the other on the last play. I
didn't see the hit or what led up to it, but I did see Logan's #56 go flying
long after the pass was made. I am one that hates seeing cheap shots, so if you
could point out where that would kind of clarify things.
Logan won. Twice. You can argue better team lost or referees, but those are the
arguments of losers.East was good and played their best possible
gameplan as best they could. Logan was outcoached. East deserved to
be there. But Logan was the better team.
The call was a personal foul for a helmet-to-helmet hit. The ref called what he
saw and since he was 10 feet away, I'm going with his view and his opinion of
the helmet-to-helmet contact over a fan that is 50 yards away and probably
doesn't have technical understanding of the rule. These are the
best HS officials calling the game, so unless you are saying that underneath the
striped referee shirt, the ref had on his LHS t-shirt and was a plant by the
UHSAA to make sure that Logan won, then I don't really know what you are
saying.Perhaps you are just saying that East deserved to win because
they shut down one of the great offenses in the state. Perhaps because they held
Logan under 20 points?On the other hand, East never found the end
zone and had the ball for 33 of 48 minutes, but in the end went 3 and out and
gave Logan the ball a midfield with 2:09 to play.Who doesn't think
Favero wins if you give him that? It never comes down to just one
play or just one call.
This definitely was a great game. Both teams played hard. But to say that East
is the better team and should have won doesn't make sense. I was at the game and
saw the helmet to helmet hit live and it was the right call to throw the flag.
If that play had happened in the first quarter and a flag was thrown would
people have complained about it? Probably not. If you'd call it in the 1st
quarter you have to call it in the 4th quarter. But just like others have said,
after that penalty East still let Logan get behind their defense and score on a
deep pass. Who's to say Logan wouldn't have done that if the penalty wasn't
called? There are so many plays that can be scrutinized and say what if, but
that's why you've got to finish out the entire game. East played great, but give
Logan credit for fighting to the finisha and making the plays when it counted.
grizzpapa I'm not here to discredit East but as a fan who showed up and saw the
end of the East-Logan game I should point ot one glaring thing. Logan would have
lost the game if it hadn't been for the roughing the passer against DJ Nelson.
That was not roughing the passer. For crying out loud the defender was less than
a yard away when he threw it and all he did was shove him out of the way. Logan
is amazing but East deserved to win. No doubt about it.
No one should be discrediting the effort and quality of this terrific East team
by blaming this on the refs.East came to the game as well prepared
as any team Logan faced all year. Their defense gave the Logan offense fits all
day long and very nearly shut them down.The story here is the Logan
defense. They also came to the came incredibly prepared and the executed
perfect assignment defense against the East triple option all day long.Logan Defense:1. On the field for 33 of the 48 minutes of the game and
never gave up despite the offense putting them in bad situations time after
time.3. Holds East out of the end zone despite the fact that East had
scored no fewer than 3 TD's every game this season.4. Holds the tandem of
Cook and Molisi to a combined 40 carries for 86 yards. That is a 2 yard average
per carry compared to both of them averaging 6 yards per carry all season.5. Gave the Logan offense a chance to go win it at the end.Great
battle by two great teams!
Logan football team: you guys came into the game thinking you were going to
smash East like the 1st time, but when it reality ya'll didnt! Yes you may have
WON! but in this case EAST is and will ALWAYS be the better team! sorry about
Jo Momma,All 3A schools best chance of winning against the top4A or 5A schools are the beginning of the season. If Huuricane played any of
the finalists in the other games, they would have been blown out. Fremont and
East would have pounded worn them out on the ground by the 3rd quarter where as
Logan and LP would have hung 40 by halftime.Ursua had 10 times the talent
and coaches at Westlake and he never got out the first round in 4A. He almost
singlehandedly won 3A on his own.With enough film on these 3A teams at
seasons end, even aherriman would beat Hurricane by at least 2 TD's at season's
end. It's the same as college when 1-AA teams surprise bigger schools. It
wouldn't happen at year's end.
The out come of a game is never in the ref's hands, with that said if a game is
that close that a single no call or bad call can impact an out come then that is
on the team for keeping an opponent within close striking distance to win.To certify an unquestionable victory one needs to separate convincingly
on the score board dispelling all doubt on the games outcome. That
did not happen and Logan prevailed.East you guy's are a terrific
team and your season was awesome. Nothing here at all the be ashamed of. The Grizz are 14-0 enough said.
East in man coverage with less than a minute to go....???? Wow
re: jo momma, DH would lose by 3-4 TD's to East or Logan and by much more to
Fremont. Lone Peak would beat them by as much as they wanted too. DH is
big....and slow. And the "Cedar should have won it all" makes me think
fondly of Uncle Rico :)
I took my dually to watch all of the games Friday. I tell you what, Desert
Hills could have competed with any of the 4A or 5A teams. I think the DH line
would out weigh the 4A or 5A lines. Hurricane could have beaten them all this
year. Probably not any other year, but this year.....yes. Cedar should have
won it all.
Dr. Rush, Thanks! I didn't want to check what little humor I've got.
To the people saying that the helmet-to-helmet foul was not really dangerous and
shouldn't have been called, how is a ref supposed to judge if a particular hit
is dangerous or not? The only logical call a ref can make to 1) protect both
players and 2)discourage these kinds of hits, is to call the foul when it
happens. The ref made the correct call. What happened after the
call you can chalk up to a great play made by a great team. Congrats to Logan,
especially the defense. Great game by by both teams.
"whoisthisguy"you complained, lastly: "Lastly i couldn't
help but notice Logan's quarterbacks Dad and Brother roaming the sidelines.
Imagine if every player on the team's family felt it was there privilege because
of who they were to be on the sideline. Just some thoughts to consider. I'm much
more an east fan after thisgamethanaloganfan."Well, his dad is
an orthopedic surgeon and has helped care for the team, for free for over a
decade, and has roamed the sidelines for that decade. His older brother, Riley,
has been coaching him since they were kids--and has been on the sideline
coaching him every game this season that he could. That is part of the reason DJ
is so good. Do ya feel a little sheepish now? Like a whiner?I won't tell the East kids that the helmet to helmet call cost them the
game, instead, I'd give them a list:1. 0 touchdowns in four attempts in
red zone.2. 2 turnovers3. too many personal foul penalties4.
kept letting receivers get open behind them until Logan finally connected.5. They were playing the best team in the State.
whoisthisguySince I'm sure that "the qb's dad and brother"
won't bother to explain, I will. The QB's dad also happens to be a very fine
orthopedic surgeon. As well as his official capacity as team doctor he spends
countless hours providing (often free) medical help to these boys. He is the
first one on the field when one of these boy's goes down and I have watched him
leave games where his boy's are still playing to care for others. He has
performed countless operations on athletes at Logan High for years. We are lucky
to have him there. As for his brother. How could anyone not understand his
value to the team? As well as being an excellent role model, he is one of the
finest coaches and mentor any team could hope to have involved with their kids..
I think you are reaching when you try to make an issue out of
this. It was a tough game and either team could have won. It's always tough
when in the end things don't go your way. One team had to win. East kicked
field goals and Logan scored touchdowns when they needed them. Deal with it
Great game Logan you guys deserve it! The team with the least mistakes won the
game. Kind of hard to give East credit when a lot of people on here aren't
giving Logan any credit at all. That helmet to helmet was the right call, and
East had plenty of opportunities to score a touchdown but didn't. Logans
defense was very stout and was the main reason they won. Logan 2011 4A State
@whoisthisguy, its pretty clear that you weren't a Logan fan to begin with. I
don't think this game really changed anything. As for the penalty... If East
gets a first down the series before it doesn't matter, or if they put the ball
in the end zone on numerous opportunities it doesn't matter. A game never comes
down to a single call or play "anybody that has ever played football and
isn't completely biased knows that."
Wow! What an incredible game yesterday. Props to EAST! They really came to play
and played hard. Defense was intense. Great Job! Logan way to go!
Defense was incredible. Bend but don't break. Held East to no Touchdowns! Came
up with big plays to set up the O and stop Easts' drives. I was sure East had
pulled off the upset but The Logan O came up big time when it mattered most.
Great game both teams.IMHO the Helmet to Helmet call was the
correct call. I'm sure everyone has their own opinion but I'm not the one
wearing the stripes and neither are you.TO:1469CVSport- COOK did not
flop. The momentum of the play caused him to trip and stumble over the defender.
I agree it was a good no call but let's not accuse a young man of something he
didn't do.All the young men on both teams played a great physical
well fought game. WOW!Thanks for the battle.
lhs_grizz04 thanks for sharing with us all your many accolades. Your comment on
the helmet to helmet call is so much more reputable... Anybody that has ever
played football and isn't acting completely biased knows that was a terrible
call. I agree that dangerous blatant helmet to helmet calls should be called
regardless of the situation or time in the game. I watched that play on KJazz
and there was no dangerous play, he put his hands up to try and knock down the
pass and because his arms were up his facemask hit the logan quarterbacks
helmet. Blatant dangerous play... i don't think so. A gift undeserving to
logan, yes. Result "state championship." Those of you that think it
was a good call. Go tell the east kid his "blatant dangerous helmet to
helmet hit" cost his teammates and best friends their dreams of winning a
state championship. Lastly i couldn't help but notice Logan's quarterbacks Dad
and Brother roaming the sidelines. Imagine if every player on the team's family
felt it was there privilege because of who they were to be on the sideline. Just
some thoughts to consider. I'm much more an east fan after
@thpsic,Oh no I knew you were kidding,I was talking about tripleb,he was
serious,he was probably upset that they didn't have white shirts on too,lol.
Rodgers, just wishful thinking. I think (hope) we've got a talented QB coming
from California. I'll give the UTES time to adjust. USU is lucky to have such
talent. Dr Rush, it was just a joke...a response to an earlier comment. I
didn't realize we were supposed to be serious. I 'll try harder next time.
When you commit personal fouls and you let a receiver get behind you when you
know they have to throw the ball you don't deserve to win period,East had it won
but let it go.And who gets on here and talks about haircuts,too much.
thpslc, DJ has committed to USU not UU, just in case you were serious about
those season tickets.
Watched the game with my daughter, who has friends at East. I was hoping to see
a good game and certainly was not disappointed.DJ Nelson gave an interview
and used a lot of 'they and we' and not 'I'. He seems to be a real team player
and a stand up kid. I hope his career with the UTES is long and
productive. ;) DJ, give me a reason to renew my season tickets! Oh...and we
won't make you cut your hair.
Am I mistaken, or is this first time Logan ever even trailed in a game? I know
they were tied a couple of times in the first quarter or two, but was East the
first team all season to ever even hold a lead over Logan?
East outplayed Logan and out coached them. However, though the helmet to helmet
violation was a foolish mistake that allowed the game winning drive to stay
alive it did not guarantee nor execute a perfectly thrown pass to pull out the
win. Congrats to both teams on their efforts and seasons as well as the best
contest of the day.
Seems like the come from behind game is not only allocated to the Aggies. Way to
go Grizzlies.Now Aggies, don't wait til the last minute to put the Vandals
out of their misery. Take them out early!
Congrats to both teams, truly a great game. The referees were a non-factor,
with missed calls and non-calls on both sides. Cook had a great flop in front
of his bench trying to implicate the Logan defender, what a good non-call. Who
won? The team that scored touchdowns not field goals. Who won? The team that
had a few penalties, not multiple personal fouls (a trait of East High that
showed up at game's end). Who won? The team that executed when it mattered
most (4 and out for Logan's defense, then great blocking, a great pass, and a
great pass route for Logan's offense). The field is 100 yards long and the game
is 48 minutes, not 85 yards or 47 minutes 24 seconds. That's why I love the
game of football. Who played a great football game? Both teams. It truly was a
championship game. East should stand proud. Logan has every reason to celebrate
loudly and I'm sure is doing so. And who is the MVP? Logan's defense, every
last one of them.
Congrats to Logan High!!! State champs again all you east homers keep holding
until to 1996. We will be back next year take that to the bank!
I am from out of state and don't have ties to either program, but I got to see
the game live and both teams deserve credit. Good throw by the Logan
quarterback in a tough spot to win the game. Awesome to watch the East defense
shut down a team that scored in the range of 35 ppg all season. The refs had
some mind boggling calls and no calls. I agree that helmet to helmet is
roughing the passer but how is a Logan linebacker blowing up an east player 15
seconds after a play right in front of a ref not a penalty? Logan took
advantage of opportunities that were handed to them but some of their players
showed little to no class and they needed the refs to help them win the game.
I don't know if I have ever watch a more physical tough high school game.Hats off to the East players and coaches. They had a great game plan
and came in an executed it very well. LHS offense really struggled
to make much happen, but made huge big plays when they needed.The
LHS defense gets all the credit for this game, though.Go Grizz!
That game was exactly what a championship game should be like. No blowout, who
wants it more and who can execute when it matters. You could say it it was the
refs but if East takes care of the ball and scores at two touchdowns when in the
red zone then the referees calls would not have mattered.Champions
find a way to win.
Agree with SLCBOY, that punt decision lost them the game.
I am not for either team, but that penalty helmet to head on Logan QB was very
questionable. Cmon East. Play smart and you win that game East.
East outplayed Logan....but Logan got some breaks.
East4life I played football all my life including a state championship and many
awards if you lead with the helmet that's a penalty the ref called it perfect
What a physical, tough, gritty football game. Hats off to both teams it was a
pleasure to watch all of those kids compete their hearts out today.
East should have went for it (4th and 1) on the drive before Logan scored.
You know lhs_grizz04 we did not lose it for our selves the only reason you won
was becuase of the refs.
I am wondering did those kids who stole the articles from their fellow athletes
still get to be a part of this game? If so what a sad commentary, that sports
is more important than character. I still maintain they should have been kicked
off the team, then this win would have really meant something.
Where are all the East backers who wrote line after line about only playing JV
players in the first game and how East would rule in the rematch? Championships
are about leadership and will. The Logan QB was not going to be denied. Great
leadership, no quitting, no giving up . . that's what I saw. Logan had the will
to win.Sour grapes to blame a loss on the referees.
Way to go Logan! From a Grizzly for over 40 years, my hat is off to you all.
Give them a bad name come on football is about one word execution and Logan did
it when it counted bottom line
Yeah, No blowout. A surprise. Bigger surprise: who has the best defense?
Logan.East ground down the field, keeping the Logan offense off of
it. But, when it came to the red zone, all those athletic 250+ pound big East
boys couldn't punch through. 30:00 of offense= 9 points no touchdowns. Logan 15:00; 18 points, two touchdowns. Several very closely missed long
passes could have blown the game open...but perhaps they were missed because of
unusual pressure on the qb.East lineman and blitzing backs were all
over Nelson--props to them for outplaying Logan's O-Line, but, once Nelson
figured it out in the 4th quarter...lights out, his recievers do not miss
opportunities.Player of the game: Logan Defense.
Ihs_grizz04 its tuff to take you serious when you completely
contradict yourself. You say you are as good as published than you say that
east lost the game for themselves. when a team loses a game for themselves it
usually means the other team didn't deserve it. you're giving logan a bad
name. . . goll
time of possession: 34:28
13:32total rushing yards: 133 yrds. 71
yrds.total passing yards: 140 yrds. 135 yrds.It's to bad the referees have to put their mark on a game like this.
good game logan, good game east. i don't know who the better team was, but i
might know who was more deserving.by the way, i'm not affiliated
with either team but felt that i needed to say something.
Champ we are as good as published east lost it for them selves you need to play
smart at the end of a game go grizzlies but respect goes east a very tough bunch
Half the fun was seeing Logan realize they weren't as cool as they thought they
were.Logan is lucky the refs preferred seeing them win.
Tough hard played game. Wonder what the KJZZ camera man's obsession was with
#13 on East?
So much for the blowout Logan. I knew Easts D is for real after I saw them hold
TView to 10. Congrats Logan.
Congratulations. Now, based on the photo, it's time to celebrate with a round
of hair cuts.
Stang08, props to you man. East played a PHENOMENAL game defensively, they are a
fantastic program, great job to coach matich.. lot of gutsy (and good) calls by
him. with that being said! GO GRIZZLIES STATE CHAMPS 2011
Where is Kipp?
I may have been a loud mouth but I'll admit I'm proud of Logan. It was closer
then anyone up North thought it would be. Look at the score. But Logan was the
better team. Will the Logan fan's say anything nice about East. They put up a
huge fight and it could have gone to them. Great job Logan but we all know what
this means for next year.