Comments about ‘BYU football: Cougars' last 3 losses to TCU have been ugly’

Return to article »

Published: Monday, Oct. 24 2011 9:00 p.m. MDT

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Lake Elsinore, CA

I have wanted Heaps in there. I think his QB style matches the BYU system more than Nelson.

However, Nelson has been very impressive and has been deserving of the ball each week. If Nelson can lead BYU to a win against TCU, then I am officially sold and suggest that Nelson is the 'starter.'

At that point, it's time for Heaps to redshirt next year.

Eagle Mountain, UT

I'm not real confident BYU can with this one but I think Nelson gives them as good a chance as they could hope for. His passing has improved quite a bit in 3 weeks and his scrambling and running abilities should drive TCU's defense nuts. The BYU defense is going to have to have their best game of the year to get this done.
Go Cougars

South Jordan, UT

This game will be ugly. Should play them better than Utah, but could turn bad.

the boonies, mexico

The only difference between this year and the past three years is that TCU is not as complete of a team on both sides of the ball as they have been in the past. But that will make no difference this year because quite frankly BYU isn't exactly a world beater either. This lasest hype over the turncoat QB Nelson won't help either because quite frankly TCU has too much speed and athletism to let him have any success against their defense. A pinpoint passer would seem to be the only way to have a chance against them and Nelson doesn't qualify as that. Another loss "wonderful ones" is evident!

Saint George, UT

The early judgement against Riley was that he was not an effective passer. I have been very impressed by his confident ability in the past five games. This game looms as the best competetive game of the year--eveN better than the Univ of Texas game, which we should have won. GO COUGARS!

Junction city, Oregon

Tcu will put a beat down on them.


I'm not sure what to expect. If SMU's undersized line can come in and control the line of scrimmage I don't see any reason why BYU shouldn't be able to the same and then some. I also don't see TCU doing well against a running QB but, the game is in Dallas.

BYU +10 looks good to me

Chandler, AZ

Looking at those stats over the past 3-years you have to notice the turnovers. BYU - 8 TCU - 1. If BYU can hold onto the ball, i.e., if Nelson can hold onto the ball when he gets smacked after running for first downs, and if Doman makes sure he doesn't call a 2-yard pass to the far side of the field -- see pick-6 against OSU, then I think BYU will be fine.

Hopefully, they will be hyped and ready to go for this game, unlike in years past when it was, "just another game." After 3-years of beat downs, it is not "just another game" it is time that this game get personal and that the BYU players respond to the challenge.

Go Cougs!

Boise, Id

It will be interesting to see if the coaches can come up with a game plan that will give them a chance against TCU. The TCU players and coaching staff have owned the cougars that last three years. Rise Up coaching staff, to here Bronco say that this game is just another game is very disappointing. This is not just another game it is the only game left on the schedule that will provide any credibility with a 4-2 TCU team. A win by BYU will go a long way for both Riley and Bronco.

Orem, Utah

Good point about an inept run game in those TCU losses. Shouldn't be an issue this time with a mobile QB and several capable RBs.

Even last year when TCU was so hot, BYU played them close a lot of the game, but faltered when BYU's QB was inept.

So, I believe BYU's defense and better offense gives the Cougars quite a good chance of winning this one.

However, get another beat down and I doubt BYU will beat Hawaii and end up 8-4. That's still a respectable year considering how it started.

Frisco, TX

A month ago, I would have put the probability of BYU beating TCU at 10%. Now I put the probability at 40%. TCU still has to be favored, but I think the Cougs have a legit shot at a W.

TCU has not been as dominant as I thought they would be, and BYU keeps getting better each week. They are both ranked in the "others receiving votes", which is about where both team should be based on how they've played.

If the game were being played in Provo, I'd put the probability of a BYU win at 50%.

There are several keys to the game, but ball security is number one. If the turnover margin is equal, both teams will likely be in the 20's. I'm biased, but I'll predict BYU-27, TCU-24.

I don't sse this one getting away from the Cougs. I think the outcome will still be in question with 5 minutes remaining in the fourth quarter.

West Jordan, UT

I agree that the jury is out on Nelson until Friday night. Beating a 3-4 San Jose State, a 2-5 Oregon State and a 1-5 Idaho State proves nothing. If he can do it against TCU then he is legit and deserves to take his place as starting QB, and Heaps will either red-shirt or transfer (I hope he chooses to stay and red-shirt).


I don't see TCU dominating like they did the past three years. Nelson brings a different look that TCU has not had to prepare for against BYU. As good as Max Hall was, he couldn't scramble like Nelson. TCU will not be able to pin their ears back and blitz as Nelson scrambling ability will make them pay. Nelson is criticized for his accuracy, but he puts the ball where players can make plays. If we win the turnover battle, we beat TCU.

Big Hapa
Kaysville, UT

@ Cali Cougar

I do not understand, what BYU system are you talking about ? Norm Chow has been gone for many years, the coach Edwards era has long since passed. I am not sure what you mean.

The current style is a balanced between rushing and passing. This has been Bronco's stated goal.

The only change up in the offense has been the insertion of Riley Nelson as QB1. Riley with the same talent around him that Jake had has been the difference an exponentially phenomenal one.

The quicker reads, quicker foot work and the over all athleticism that Riley has, has inspired the running backs, lineman , TE, WR's to step up and improve there individual game.

The SJSU was more then likely not a complete week of solid Riley prep I am sure Jake may have been in the mix for game prep, however for OSU Riley perhaps had his first full week of practice reps and had the offensive scheme built around him.

With all that said, TCU has been a formidable nemesis to say the least.

Salt Lake City, UT

Not only have they been ugly but last year was just totally awesome!!

Big Hapa
Kaysville, UT

I am still baffled by all the legit talk about Riley ? Weird double standard .

What is legit about Heaps ? What has Jake done to be qualified as legitimacy ? Jake wins have all been games against all sub-60 rankings and this makes him legit ?

There are no highly ranked teams that fill up Jake's portfolio of amazing wins that legitimize his game. So why is there a double standard ?

So if Riley can not do the job against TCU every one here believes that Heaps can come in and win it ? Really ? I don't think so.

What is legitimate this year in the game with TCU is at least Riley gives the BYU a fighting chance against a very nasty foe. I would jump into a fight with Riley on my side any day. Let me ask you all a question, would you all go into fight with Jake ? Answer no.

Saint George, UT


Nelson is a competitor.

Is he Tim Tebow?


But like Tebow, when Nelson gets in the game, BYU seems to play harder.

I agree the wins over SJS, OSU and ISU do little more than add wins to the win column. However, at this point in the season, who couldn't use an extra three wins?

Urban Meyer once said the key to developing a program is to control your schedule. No one gets to be Florida by playing Alabama every week. You schedule an FCS, some Non-AQ's, add in Mississippi, Vanderbuilt and then roll the dice against the big boys on the schedule.

A win against a "soon-to-be BCS" TCU would be huge, even though TCU is in a down/reloading year. TCU has already lost two "statement" games (Baylor/SMU) this season. TCU has two more statement games in BYU and Boise State.

It would be hard to imagine TCU not bringing their A game Friday night.

Coach P should be amazing.


TCU did have a difficult time with a run first QB (Baylor) who could also pass.


If BYU turns the ball over, it could get ugly...again...fast.

Roy, UT

Coaches must teach better how to recognize defenses, and Cougs must lay it all on the line...

Watch out for TCU tricks...they may try to mess up your communications, will do anything to beat the Cougs...

eat some green jello, green jello is like poison to horned frogs, so smear some on your forearms Cougs, its time we put them in a bottle, screw on the lid, and cast them into the sea!

Mcallen, TX

Ugliness preceeds the dawn of victory.

salt lake city, utah

Look for TCU to sneak their linebackers up to 3-4 yards behind the line of scrimmage, constantly threatening blitz, but rarely doing so. They really will just be there to contain Nelson.

That will challenge Nelson to throw over a large offensive line on 10-15 yard throws behind the backers. TCU will almost completely give up the 25+ yard routes in order to effectively smother everything underneath, because it doesn't think Nelson can consistently make those deep throws.

BYU will struggle to rush the ball outside of Nelson's impromptu scrambles.

If Nelson can complete a couple of deep passes early, establishing an accurate pass threat to open up the running lanes (counter-intuitive), BYU's offense will score, its defense will remain rested, and BYU can hang in the game.

If Riley doesn't capitalize on those deep passes early, BYU goes 3 and out often, it's defense wears down, and TCU will roll.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments