Quantcast

Comments about ‘Jason Reid: If Shanahans go all-in with John Beck, they're taking a gamble’

Return to article »

Published: Thursday, May 12 2011 2:34 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Chris B
Salt Lake City, UT

Shanahan digging his own grave

Jonas
Denver, Colorado

Hmm...he is concerned about how John Beck will handle being the starting QB in a fish bowl in DC where the Redsking QB job is high profile?

Yea, I can't imagine how John will handle that...except for the fact that he handled it here for four years will complete class. Yea, except that.

Papa Smurf UTE
Herriman, UT

Ultimate fail! This article should go on the Fail Blog. Let go by Miami. $th string in Baltimore, and then traded for nothing. Has not started a game since 2007, and is already 30, with very limited experience. How does any of this make Shanahan think Beck should be the starter. Like ChrisB said, he is digging hisown grave, and this will most likely fail, and he will get fired.

IDC
Boise, ID

I for one hope Beck gets a chance and I can't wait to see what happens. If Shanahan asks me my opinion, I am going to tell him to go for it.

DC
Alexandria, VA

Being a Redskins fan, and after having to live through the trash that has been called our past few seasons, I really, really want Shanahan to work out. But, and I like Beck - thought he was a great QB at BYU - he's not cut out for the NFL. He's too timid in decision making and he doesn't handle pressure well, which is why he is a great scout team QB - no pressure.

Hopefully this will work out. At least Beck has been given some time under one system (if one year is enough time in the NFL) and has a better chance of success with the Redskins which he didn't have in Miami, which isn't saying much about either team.

Starfarer
Mesa, AZ

Gotta love Ute trolls who...

are not in the meetings,
not at practice,
not seen him work,
not seen anything but a game or two,

are the experts on whether or not this kid can succeed.

Good grief, if you know so much go get a coaching job, and quit armchair quaterbacking.

I'll take a head coach with a lot of experience over the whole lot of you.

EdGrady
Idaho Falls, ID

It could be worse, Shanahan could trade for Alex Smith.

CougarBlue
Heber City, UT

Chris B he will do as well as Alex Smith.

hedgehog
Ann Arbor, MI

Shanahan is offically on the hot seat. Look for a coaching change my mid November.

junkgeek
Agua Dulce, TX

@Starfarer - And you have witnessed this greatness? The fact that Shanahan likes him (given his recent record) is enough to make someone run for the hills.

As a Redskins hater, this is great news for me...

Keisels Beard
Overton, NV

"He's too timid in decision making and he doesn't handle pressure well..."

Sounds like his first couple of years at BYU. But I think he got that figured out in time. Give him a chance and he might just surprise some people.

Or he could fall flat on his face. But you will never know until they actually run him out there.

And his showing in Miami doesn't mean a whole lot for what type of QB he is, by the way. Hard to do anything when you are constantly on your back because the line couldn't even stop a pass rush by Richard Simmons.

supainthehills
Cottonwood Heights, UT

In the fall my blood definitely bleeds blue for my Cougars and my Boys in Big D! Granted, Beck did have a great senior year at BYU. I'll never, EVER, forget being in the north stands at Rice-Eccles when he completed the touchdown to Harline as time expired. It was, without question, one of the happiest 'sports moments' so far. In fact, it was so good that it ALMOST made up for the complete and total frustration I had with Beck his first three years as quarterback. His ability to consistently throw a ball (albeit on a line) three yards over his receivers heads was a rare 'gift'. I was surprised that Miami took him in the second round, but I thought he could do okay in the right system. Unfortunately the game just seems to move too fast for him...which it does for many. I hope he hits his stride in Washington, but hope even more that my Boys hit him in stride...HARD...and FINALLY start making some noise in the playoffs again. The three championships in the 90s are almost as far away as the 84 NC for BYU! :(

Jimmy James
Salt Lake City, Ut

Wow. Good for Beck for keeping at it and earning the respect of the Shanahan's. Win or lose, you can't disrespect a guy for going after his dreams full bore.

I would love to see both Alex Smith and John Beck find their place next season and turn some heads. Unfortunately, the reality for that happening does not look quite as good. I really hope both those guys can prove the critics wrong.

BluCoug
Provo, UT

"Shanahan digging his own grave'

Just as Nolan and Singletary dug their...

BluCoug
Provo, UT

Beck > Smith

WestGranger
West Valley City, Utah

NFL QBs have to be in the right place at the right time in order to get a proper chance.Otherwise Montana was just a scrawny short guy. Beck is no Montana of course. However just because he hasn't had a chance doen't mean he can't be very good.

In My Humble Opinion
South Jordan, UT

Steve Young turned 30 -- his first year as the starter at San Francisco.

Utes, Jazz, and RSL Forever
Taylorsville, UT

No Mike, don't do it. Quick, name someone else as a starter quick before Beck ruins your career. A former Kitty quarterback who hasn't played much in 3 years is NOT the answer to the Redskins problems.

Idaho Coug
Meridian, Idaho

I would love to see Beck get a real shot. But the more likely scenario is the Redskins sign a solid veteran who starts and insert Beck as a solid #2. Which, if he held onto that role for the next 5 years would still let him walk away from the game a very rich man.

Hopefully Hall impresses enough in AZ to stay on as the #3 QB there. He was a disaster as a starter but he can be great value as an undrafted emergency QB.

BluCoug
Provo, UT

@ Utes, Jazz, and RSL Forever,

Quick! Name what Smith has done in 6 years in San Fran... tick tock, tick tock... buzzzzzzzzz. Nothing! Oh my bad, collected a pay check for nothing.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments