Quantcast

Comments about ‘Brad Rock: NBA playoffs prove that there's no conspiracy’

Return to article »

Published: Tuesday, May 10 2011 11:18 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
OU812
Layton, UT

Go ahead, keep your head in the sand. We're not buying it. You can tune into ANY game and see calls that are biased. Even players know when calls are being biased. Its not rocket science. When there are opportunities to make millions to hundred millions in revenue if certain teams make it and certain teams do not. What way do you think any right minded CEO is going to tilt the table? It doesn't have to be a conspiracy, it only has to be slanted.

Bugoff
Houston, TX

The big market bias comes indirectly thru the lack of a hard salary cap. How many championships has LA bought? Ditto for CHI in an earlier decade. BOS also paid tons in lux tax for their championships. They are at 77 this year.

POR could afford to buy one if they were run well. SA has a great organization and built around Duncan. They are at 70 Mill.

The Mavs salary is at 88+ mill. Cuban may have finally luck out by spending for years. LA is at 91.

The Jazz are at 76 Mill and have a losing record to show for it. That mainly reflects bad contract management decisions in the past, dreadful drafting and a Vet bias that was very expensive. The Vet bias is being reversed as AK and Okur come off of the books and as the Jazz add two lotto picks.

The Jazz will contend when they max out the team WP48 for reasonable cost. OKC is at 57+ and MEM is 70 mill. Both used the draft and some FA/trades to build contenders for reasonable.

The Jazz are fixable but it will take the right players and time.

peter
Alpine, UT

Sorry Brad, man may have walked on the moon, but Oswald was only a decoy, a distraction, from the real culprit behind the Kennedy assassination. And you will never convince me that the NBA officiating is unbiased as long as big money is involved.

yarrlydarb
Ogden, UT

Your poll questions are skewed as the great majority of Utah fans would make hardly any of the forced choices you have available.

You have a biased sample from the start; hence, your results are unreliable.

In order to do valid research, you MUST have randomization to eliminate bias.

Your results on this poll, such as with all "journalistic" polls, are meaningless.

Any pollster who conducts legitimate survey research follows correct sampling principles.

ECR
Burke, VA

So are youi suggesting aliens really didn't crashed at Roswell in 1947?

Lone Star Cougar
Plano, TX

Brad, If you saw the Dallas Mavs and the Miami Heat finals 4 or 5 years ago you cannot deny there is some sort of fixing going on in the NBA.

I think it has to do more with who causes the most problems for the league and for the officials. Mark Cuban used to rant about the officiating and be fined. He wouldn't care, he had plenty of money. So, the NBA and officials fixed it where the Mavs would not win in the playoffs. Great seasons - then out in the first round.

This year, Mark Cuban has been quiet and all of the sudden we beat the Lakers in 4 straight. Some argue that the officials didn't like the Lakers coach because of what he says about the league. They are out in 4.

Add to this the imprisoned ref caught cheating and he says that the other refs controls who wins and it seems pretty clear to me. The NBA looks fixed to me.

DH48
West Jordan, UT

The conspiracy is more from the players than from the NBA. SO many of the players want to be in the big markets. Free agency allows them to gravitate to a few select teams such as the Lakers, Chicago, Boston and Miami. Small markets can pick up players and have a couple of good years but eventually those players will move to a large market with other top players. This is why certain teams, primarily the Lakers, can be good year after year. They can always attract the top players. The big name players do not want to be in no name cities.

This is the very reason why I have come to despise the NBA. Free agency has made it a joke and greatly reduced the ability of small market teams to be consistently competitive at a high level. San Antonio with Tim Duncan, and Utah with Stockton and Malone being exceptions to that.

Richard Saunders
Provo, UT

Mr. Rock, I don't think most fans believe that the NBA decides the outcome of every game, but this playoff is an exception to the rule that the big market teams and the stars are favored. Have you heard of Tim Donaghy? Two teams have won more than half of the championships, Boston and Los Angeles. Watch the calls made against an Earl Watson compared to the calls against a Dywane Wade and tell me the game is absolutely fair.

As a side note, just like the NBA, the Federal Reserve should be held more accountable. When people believe everything is okay just because the most ridiculous conspiracy is untrue, than we have a real problem.

5
Orem, UT

If there is anyone who believes that officials don't favor certain players I would like to meet him or her. It is a fact that superstars get better treatment than either a lesser know player or a rookie. That being true, how can you how believe that favoring players does not favor the teams for which they play? This is not a conspiracy from the league, but it happens because everybody knows that superstars and dynasties attract more fans, or as commentators say "put more seats in the seats". Officials do this on their own because they know more money for the league means more money for them. They have gone no strike for more pay. Occasionally the league polices this to try to tone it down, but it is their best interests as well. Who wants to reduce the money coming in. The NBA has not been called a sport for years. It is called even by the players themselves a business, and entertainment. The officials are just the choreographers.

DEW Cougars
Sandy, UT

I said it before and will say it again - David Stern is really not happy with LA Lakers. LOL, love it! Go Oklahoma City!

USAlover
Salt Lake City, UT

Cute article. What the Rockmonster doesn't realize is that the conspiracy is not against cities and teams but favors INDIVIDUALS. I quit watching the NBA 10 years ago because stars get all the calls and are protected. A foul on Michael Jordan was different than a foul on Craig Ehlo. The day Stern decided to market the league with the faces of individuals (ie Jordan, Hakeem, Iverson et. al.) is when the NBA went from first to 5th in viewership, now currently behind NASCAR and the PGA.

The NFL is king because it markets "teams" over "individuals". If Jordan had played in Sacramento, the conspiracy would simply have taken place in Central California instead of Chicago.

We the People
Sandy, UT

Let us look at some past travesties that show the NBA is rigged:

2002 Western Conference Finals. I do not have space to describe how badly that series was rigged for the Lakers.
2006 NBA Finals. Ditto, but for the Heat.
1998 NBA Finals. Jordan no-call, three point shots called as 2s for the Jazz and 2s called as 3s for the Bulls.
Donaghy fixes games.

Other questionable instances:
Cleveland conveniently receives the number 1 pick when local star Lebron James is projected to go first in the draft.
Patrick Ewing to the Knicks.
Lakers trade virtually nothing for Kobe Bryant.
The NBA allows teams to assemble ridiculous teams (Heat, Lakers, Boston).

Commentators all make comments about how rookies and veterans are treated differently with regards to fouls called. Superstars get passes while the Adam Keefes of the league get hammered.

Is the NBA rigged? With billions of dollars at stake each year, you had better believe it.

Hellooo
Salt Lake City, UT

I agree with you Mr. Rock. I, also, enjoy the similarly to the NBA unbiased professional pro-wrestling matches.

yarrlydarb
Ogden, UT

Claiming "Playoffs prove ... there's no conspiracy" is naive in the extreme.

One would has to be brain-dead not to see the preferred treatment of superstars as opposed to that of the role players.

The NBA, as well as all other professional sports, is solely a money-motivated business enterprise from top to bottom, including league management, teams, officiators, and most players.

Fans love sports but they are incurably naive, just like those of professional wrestling, roller derby and "reality" t.v.

bricker
pleasant grove, ut

How about LA 17 titles and Boston 18 title for a little proof of the consiracy?
They can't tilt it every year but just about. The superstar treatment will evetualy kill the sport.

mulrich
Provo, UT

Their are no conspiracies in the NBA. People who say otherwise are just whining because their them lost. Are their poorly officiated games? Yes. Are their bad calls? Yes. Do these impact the outcome of a game? Rarely. Are there people that don't actually watch the league but still think they know what they're talking about? Yes.

If you watch enough games you'll see that bad calls go in-favor of both big and small market teams in equal quantities. You'll notice that superstar players get more calls because they get fouled more often or know how to sell a foul. Rookies don't get calls because they don't know the tricks of the trade; how to foul without being noticed, how to draw attention to contact, etc. Superstars know the tricks and take advantage of them.

Basketball is one of the hardest sports to officiate yet the NBA refs still make most calls correctly.

redcliffs
Ivins, Utah

I'm going to play devils advocate here a little. While I do believe there is some star treatment that goes on in the NBA, I don't think it's a much as some people make it out to be. What I see constantly is fans see referees calls with their hearts, and not their heads. I see plays all the time where the Jazz fans boo a ref's call on a Jazz player where I can see (especially in slow motion) there was a foul. Fans boo alomost every call a ref makes against players on the home team so you know there is not a lot of objectivity there. I feel in most games there are bad calls made agains both teams in the course of the game. Let's face it, it's pretty hard for the ref's to see everything going on at the speed of today's NBA games. So while there is some star treatment that goes on, you also have a lot of fans that are watching games just looking for a call against their favorite player or team that they can boo the ref's on.

byronbca
Salt Lake City, UT

I don't think that there is an NBA conspiracy, but I do believe that some refs like Dick Bavetta and Joey Crawford are company men, meaning that they will sometimes ref games based on what they think is best for the NBA and not necessarily what is the fair call.

Usually reffing biases manifest themselves in a disproportion of 50/50 calls going to a team with a superstar that people want to see.

The most biasedly officiated NBA series I have ever seen was the Mavs VS Heat finals. Mavs were up 2 to 0 when it seemed like the NBA made guarding Dwayne Wade illegal and the Heat went on to win the series 4 to 2. The last Jazz/ Bulls series would be #2.

Silly Rabbit
Magna, UT

Well Brad why did Jordan retire the first time at the prime of his career, well he didnt retire, but how does the NBA suspend the face of the league with a huge gambling problem which was making the league look bad. Well MJ was suspended its oblivious, all of this was after the strange murder of his father, gambling debts maybe? The league had to do something, was it a conspiracy no they just had to save face and not embarrass the entitled face of the NBA. Remember at one point MJ thought he should get paid by all teams in the league a cool million a year, and Larry Miller and other owners balked and spoke out against that.

Well Brad I don't believe in conspiracies either but there is defiantly covert stuff done at the high corporate level of the NBA, to make sure the money keeps rolling in. Who in the nation would watch the Utah Jazz play the Washington Bullets/Wizards in the finals?

So Brad thanks for the distraction Ill get back to my UFO, Roswell, Kaspun Yar, and this Obama birth certificate research, good article though keep it up.

SportsFan101
Bountiful, UT

Anytime huge money is involved, you better believe something else is going on behind the scenes.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments