Comments about ‘U.S. Supreme Court uses corpus created by BYU professor Mark Davies’

Return to article »

His billion-word online corpora aid study of language, culture

Published: Sunday, March 13 2011 10:45 p.m. MDT

Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
caleb in new york
Glen Cove, NY

How is a corpus formed? This article didn't seem to address that key question.

Say No to BO
Mapleton, UT

This sort of reminds me of Richard Wirthlin's "Quantifiably Safe Rhetoric."
The whole dynamic changes when wordsmiths become spin doctors.
Too much analysis leads to political correctness over truth-telling.
And heaven knows we need more truth and less hype.

On the other hand
Spanish Fork, UT

Go BYU linguistics!

DerVerder
Paragonah, UT

I dig the stuff. (Get it?). My linguistics prof. Herr Ludvig would ask question from a German point of view. Kind of not important in the big picture, but really interesting,
Most annoying and over used phrase of 011? "going forward".

thebig1
SLC, UT

I'm just trying to make enough money to feed my family and pay tithing so I can fund this program at the Y

FrazzleDazzle
Provo, ut

Yep I thought about all of these things in jr. high. But I wasn't married. Don't you have loved ones to spend time with? Shouldn't they be receiving every free moment of your time? Analyze this for three hours, miss another three hours with the person who chose to marry you.

Hank Pym
SLC, UT

As I understand it, Professor Davies is trying to understand words by the context they are used?

Interesting endeavor. Best of Luck.

agkcrbs
Holladay, UT

Davies makes his corpora by downloading and scanning texts from various sources (in the olden days, they had to be hand-compiled), categorising them by genre, and feeding them into his software that tags all the words. The resultant database can then be searched, though it leans a bit toward the technical side.

Political spin? Yes; by default, the media data include media-preferred language. Spin is two-edged, though. A common anecdote of Davies is the negative traits associated with "Republican" and the positive ones with "Democrat" that showed up in the news data, instantly exposing its bias. Fiction would be closer to language on the ground. Spoken data goes both ways, since it's largely from national television transcripts. But the assumption that overanalysis obscures the truth is backward here.

Tithing? BYU did buy some extra hardware, but most support came from the NEH. Still taxpayer money, anyway.

A time waster? Well, we all have our hobbies that our busy-body neighbours might tell us to abandon to spend more time vegetating with family. Seeing that language is man's interface with God, family, and the world, I wouldn't overlook the importance of understanding it better.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments