Comments about ‘Brooke White is voted off 'Idol'’

Who is Brooke White?

It's about time. She was driving me crazy. I've never seen anybody who is so difficult in receiving feedback. Plus, she is the only contenstant who would start & stop songs. Making the top 5 is a HUGE accomplishment and there can only be one winner, but it's definitely not her.

Yea I'm So Happy! It was Brooke's time to Go!

This girl did a wonderful job in the face of such unimaginable pressure. Her talent is marketable and I hope we will see more of her as time goes on. I would buy her records for sure.

This show is wacky. Who does the voting anyway? Brooke was not the best but Jason Castro should have been gone two weeks ago.

How Jason even got into the top 100 yet alone the last four is absolutely beyond me. He seems like a nice guy but his singing is terrible. David will win, 100%. (I dont care which one :)

Brooke is awesome and we voted until we could no longer vote. Brooke is already somebody anyway so to all of you that leave nasty comments :) You just wished you were in her shoes. Brooke we love you here in Alabama!!!!!!!!!!!!

I agree with anonymous, Jason is dreadlocks and eyes, it has become a popularity contest that this boy surpassed her? It blows my mind! I will tell you though, David & David should be the final two. If David Cook wins, the best Musician will win, if David Archuletta wins then it is a half talent show, half popularity contest. Brooke can have a contract with a LDS record company hands down and sell CD's without a doubt, she is good, I like her as much as Marin Ord! I am disapointed Jason is still in it, I couldn't believe he was the first one called, and told he was safe, it blew my mind!

Yeah,i agree with you bro..jason castro has no passion
for music. Brooke is a good musician, she sings from
the heart.

I wish it wasn't Brooke that was voted off. I think her style is unique and enjoyable. She has a great voice and a ton of talent. I really don't see anything great in the remaining contestants. They seem to all be copies of those who have gone before. There isn't much unique about any of them. (Just my own opinion.)

I love the sound of Brooke's voice. It is unique and soulful. I look forward to hearing more from her, off the American Idol stage, where I think her style and talent were overshadowed. All that obnoxious glitz just isn't her. I don't think it's a coincidence that I enjoyed her performances a lot more when she sang and played on the smaller stage earlier in the season. Yeah, Brooke!

So Sad that Brooke is gone. She was a ray of sunshine each week and I love to hear her sing. I thought the first song she sang Tuesday night was great along with the 2nd song. Sure don't know what those judges want. What sound great to me doesn't suit them. We are the ones who buy the CD's. I was just hoping that Jason would go . He just sounds awful and I don't care for Syesha's singing. She is a very pretty girl but not as beautiful as Brooke. I voted for both Brooke and David A. each week and was so hoping Brooke with be there at least another week or two. She deserved it. It is just a lot of teens voting for the dread locks and the eyes and cute face rather than the talent and voice. David A has a wonderful voice and put his whole heart into his music and I can only pray that he will win out in the end. Everyone vote and vote next Tuesday night for David A. And just wish that Brooke was there too. So Sad.!!!!!

THIS is the top story on the home page of the Deseret News? Please, please, please...don't succumb to celebrity news! Let's keep the Deseret News a newspaper and not a gossip paper.

Jason should have gone before Brooke, and Carli should still be in the competition.

Brooke has a beautiful voice. And, in my opinion Jason should have been voted off. He has an I don't give a damn attitude if he wins or not. In fact he reminds me of Sanjaya and that's a BIG insult!!!

The only reason he remains on the show is because the girls think he's cute. But my yellow lab is just as cute and has more talent.

Brooke has a unique voice that will work very well in the studio. Archuleta may have a cleaner sound, and more raw talent, but Brooke is the one that can have a successful recording career.

The ones we'll still hear about in five years are Brooke, David Cook, and Syesha.

Brooke was good but this is about as far a she should go in the competition. Castro could have gone tonight but he and Syesha will battle it out for 4th place.

I see it's a popularity contest. The good ones have been eliminated, and it was definately Brooke's time. I like her personality, but her talent is not that big enough to be the idol. Jason Castro is unique and even prettier than a lot of women, but he is not the idol, either. As of now, I think it looks like a battle between 2 David.

I don't wish I was in Brookes shoes. 6 feet four inches, size 13 feet. That would hurt.

The truth is that Idol is boring and a big waste of time.

I love Brooke's soulful and unique voice. She is a good role model. ..dressing fashionably, yet modestly each week. I will miss her, and I will buy her CDs.