Reader comments
'Perfect storm' sobering for LDS, historian says

4 comments   |   Read story

Ken | 10:20 a.m. March 13, 2008
Man..... I read this article. It was awsome. I'm on your team. As they say on the street " You da man wit da plan!!!!!"
Bob | 10:54 a.m. March 13, 2008
Helen Whitney's question, "What can you say than can be used for the rest of the world?" God lives. Christ lives. They are as real as anything in this world. They are not an abstract theological philosphy.

The Heavens are open to anyone who will ask and respectfully wait for an answer. There are more things real than what you can simply see.
ElGuapo | 11:59 a.m. March 13, 2008
Is that a convincing approach to belief in Mormonism? It's like he's saying look, all the other Christian religions are crazy too. And Claudia's clever approach of showing them that other people believe the same things? There are larger groups who believe in more unlikely things, like UFOs.

I like Richard Bushman, but it's strange to see someone in his position believe and yet not offer anything better as justification for his belief. It seems he just accepts his Mormonism as an accident of birth. I'd love to ask him, "If you were raised Baptist and knew all that you know about the Mormon faith, would you convert?"
Comments continue below
Alan | 7:03 a.m. March 14, 2008
I enjoy most of what Bushman says and writes, but his quote in this article seems to blame Mormons themselves for their Christian identity crisis, saying we set ourselves apart (i.e. with the label on military dog tags) then complain when we are set-apart from the rest of Christianity. I disagree.

Dog tags aren't marked "Christian." They are marked "Catholic," "Protestant" and "LDS." Mormons never asked to be labeled as non-Christian. Few Mormons would object to being called "unorthodox" Christians. We are indeed outside of mainstream Christianity, and have no problem with that. But can anyone blame us for getting annoyed when others repeatedly deny that we believe in Christ?

It isn't a labeling problem. It's a misrepresentation of our beliefs ... a denial of the center of our faith. Bushman seems to say we are trying to have it both ways ... to gain admittance into the Christian club while retaining our uniqueness. I think it's simply about Mormons wanting to be seen for who they really are. We don't object to being different. What we object to is the idea that we must subscribe to popular Christian creeds in order to be Christians.

Add your comment

Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.

Words Remaining

E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.

Image

Richard Bushman

previousnext

Latest comments

Broncos make Aggies pay

These message boards are for trading insults.....so if you don't want to be...

Boys basketball rankings

Did JD Books change his name to Porkins? Easy there fella

BYU has slim shot at BCS

RE: BYU accounting grad. Most employers could give a hoot about your...

Best of luck to this young man. I do hope they get him out soon!

SUU falls to Tennessee Tech

This team plays with very little heart at times. They had better step it up...

Bill Clinton was the unknown man on the grassy knoll.

Utahn is starving herself for Kenya

Like in all honesty her starving herself is going to get govt officials in a...

Where do I need to go to sign this petition. It is long overdue.

I understand her desire to spread the word and make a difference, but I...

Preps of the week

Reading is fundamental. Selected by ESPN as top player in state and signed...

Advertisements