Reader comments
New Harmony: Current focus concentrates on retaining LDS members
506 comments | Read story
We arrived early and sat in a very conspicuous location in the chapel. I spent time in the military and have moved around alot since. The wards that succeed in activating and retaining people who have fallen away have a, "no one leaves a stranger" attitude.
That is the attitude of my current bishop and it works.
Maybe that's why I'm back. I wanted to come back.
Would you advocate that church leaders reinstate the excommunication of Helmuth Hubner because he was clearly breaking the law in Germany?
Should we deney temple recomends to anyone who has ever exceeded the speed limit?
Just some questions that might start to broaden your mind. Do you want to take the gospel to every people, or do you feel that a white church is the best option?
Reading LDS members write in to the Deseret News. The Mitt event was a prime example. I realize I share not the thinest tread of commonality with Mormon Culture. It's too insular, mean spirited and petty for my liking.
I prefer sinners to saints. In my mind, man can't be god. I'm not in to decorum ether. God created man in his image, so god has a sense of humor. I'm more in to colorful tropical floral pattern shirts that gray stuffed suits.
I can see why Jesus sought out people full of imperfections. You can understand the nature of a tree by the fruit on its branches. I find the fruit of Mormonism too bitter for my tastes. I'm not seeking god's only true church. By definition that would separate me from the rest of humanity.
I was dipped in water at seven through intimidation. It was not my choice. It was not a legal contractual agreement. Please, leave me alone!
If the holier than thou members really want to search their scriptures, I have an assignment for you. Search out the prophecies that refer to a cleansing of the church which is to come.
I would guess that God's judgement will come for lots of things and that a lot of regular self-righteous attenders are in for a surprise. That's why I pray everyday, be nice to my neighbors, and don't tailgate, so maybe I'll be on the Lord's good side.
The church did not teach so called "racist garbage". There was never any teaching of the church that anyone was less able to be saved. Just because some general authority said something does not make it church doctrine.
The temple ceremony changes and the Book of Mormon changes I think both strike at a problem of not realizing that God speaks to man in his own language.
I have to admit that one of the changes in the temple ceremoy I have seen alleged to have taken place for years I thought it must be untrue because it seemed the alleged non-present item was still there. I hope I have not been too explicit in what I said.
Besides that I think people need to remeber the Book of Mormon and the temple ceremonies are meant to be understood by us. As our culture and language changes so at times the words have to change. I think most of the claimed outrage changes in the Book of Mormon have to do with new meanings for words.
I'm informed here that my decision to be protective of my family's privacy means I have been "offended". Calling those who wisely do what's best for their families the "offended" is just another variation on the blame the victim mentality.
Attenders and non-attenders are neither one perfect, however, the judgementalism, self-righteousness, dogmatism and clannishness lie primarily with the clique. Choosing to avoid untrustworthy people who will gossip behind your back is completely rational and the wisest course of action for any self respecting person.
I will say that I feel the church leaders may not have gone far enough in excommunicating people in the early 1990s. It is one thing to have doubts, but to come out any accuse the church of keeping members in slavery? I can't even see how people who have such views are willing to participate in the church at all.
Really, I thnik the church leaders do a good job at keeping the church in order. However, sometimes I think the doctrine of the church is threatened by having so many people with such strong hate for the truth of the restored gospel.
I also have to say that most of the people who harp on the "historical problems of the church" have no historical sense. Yes Joseph Smith married a 16 year old, but so did Wilford Woodruff. For that matter so did hundreds of people. This was acceptable then, we can not judge them on our culture.
Back people were worthy of the priesthood before 1978. They did not recieve the priesthood but that was not based on not being worthy. Women do not recieve the priesthood, but this is not a reflection of their worthiness.
God's ways are not our ways.
Also, to the person who said there are two churchs, you preach false doctrine. On one hand I have lived in and out of Utah and can testify there is good in both places. On the other I would have to say you are like those who speak of being one of Apolos and another of Paul who are denounced in one of the Pauline Epistles. Stop trying to divide the church.
Yet, I do not believe it. I have seen many people who were strong and faithful when baptized. Sometimes people are so on fire it is shocking when the fire burns out. Satan tries extra hard on people after baptism.
Head President Hinckley's call of giving people "A Friend, A Responsibility and Nourishing by the Good Word of God". Stop just claiming that because people fall away they were not fully converted.
That is a bunch of hog wash. The changes, the isolation from friends, the commitment that the church requires are hard. People need support, not judgement in these cases.
Diaries only prove what the authors feel. I would like to know what diearies the person refers to that refute polygamy.
It is a dangerous subject to bring up. The spirit will not testify of its truth. I have to say that too many people spend too much time spreading their own personal interpretations of it. I am half tempted to do the same. No one has ever claimed it was an easy doctrine to live. However I am not sure when a 35 year old became an "old man".
I also think a lot of people confuse the actions and practices of polygamous cults today with the historical practice of polygamy.
One more comment: Just because a writing is contemporary does not mean it is true. A journal is not neccesarily true, let alone an item presented as a journal.
I first read about multiple accounts of the first vision in the Ensign. And what about the article about the Mountain Meadows Massacre in the Ensign?
There are certain core doctrines that church members should hold. If people do not think that the Book of Mormon is the word of God, then what are they doing in the church?
It is odd that when people try to act out of love they are greeted with so much hate.
To the person who griped about supposedly being baptized at age seven, go contact your local bishop and have your name removed from the church records if your want the church to stop contacting you. If you don't do that we will continue to try and reach out to you in kindness.
In finding fault, also consider this:
By the time Joseph Smith was 38 he had set the foundation for one of the most successful Churches in U.S. History. Sure he made some mistakes along the way - he was human. He had very little education, and very few resources.
Today I am 40. I have a very good education. Have a written a book and published it? no. Have I started a new church? no. Have I founded any new cities? no.
Don't just compare yourself to the faults of another, also compare yourself to their accomplishments. If you do, you can't deny that Joseph Smith was a great man. The church he founded is a miracle in many ways.
It's no wonder why people abandon their faith in light of science and fact. You better bring the facts and not the fluff if you want to compete :)
There are things the church does right. There are things the church does wrong. Many people simply can't hold themselves to be an active part in any organization that falls down in some of the areas the LDS church falls down.
By and large these people are not "bitter" or "selfish". You don't have to be selfish or bitter to cut your losses and leave when you see that the salespitch you were given throughout your youth or conversion process has no basis in reality.
You might be surprised if you knew just how many former Mormons left for reasons involving their own integrity, not because they were selfish or offended. These are people who left because they found the church was not an institution worthy of their time and resources, for any of a thousand reasons. Yet leaving is a painful decision, one not taken lightly. It has awful repercussions within our extended families. It often means being abandoned by friends. It means leaving behind a way of life that was familiar and comfortable. But it also means finding a new path that works for us, that makes us happier, more fulfilled, better able to raise our children and participate in our communities in the way we think is right.
If you're happy in the church, then super! I will neither judge nor malign you for it by reducing your decision to a harmful stereotype. Please extend me the same courtesy.
Either you desire a testimony, or you don't. Quit attempting to justify your lack thereof by seeking validation in this kind of forum. Furthermore, if you spent more time serving others and less time stewing over your own shortcomings, maybe your challenges would seem less unsurmountable.
There is plenty of intellectual freedom in the church. But, if you don't have a testimony to start with, it just becomes a slippery slope. If people had "Proof", it would be called Knowledge, not Faith. Quit wasting our time with intellectual mumbo jumbo. If you don't want to be a member there is a simple method to request that your records be expunged.
While, It is disappointing that you no longer desire to be amoungst the Saints, you will get no validation here. Everyone has challenges to overcome and, "Stories" of how someone at church was a big stupid meanie.
To-6:11 You look like a selfish lesson for everyone to stay away from. Criticize if it makes you happy! Know though that you are wrong. If the shoe fits wear it!
This is not true. I think you forgot about Jane Manning James. She was Joseph Smith's housekeeper and was denied the temple ordinances and admittance into the Celestial Kingdom (the highest level of Heaven in LDS theology for those unfamiliar) because she was black until 1894. On 05/18/1894 she was granted the temple ordinances with one caveat : She was sealed to Joseph Smith as a "servitor in eternity" ( eternal servant).
Church leadership subsequently revoked her temple ordinances and blessings on 08/22/1895 due to her "negro blood". They reinstated her servant status and sealing to Smith in 1902.
and they'll come home
wagging their tails behind them.
Announce over the pulpit that those who wish to no longer be members of the church have the option of resigning. Tell them how. Tell them what it does.
Bam! We instantly have full disclosure that people *can* leave if they wanted to and there's no wasted resources on futile missionary efforts. And trust me they *are* futile to those who tell the missionaries and ward members "No thanks".
GET A LIFE!
� It continues to focus on numbers in its missionary program. That focus will always yield converts who are pressured or tricked into joining. Inactivity in such a situation is almost inevitable.
� The church refuses to reform. It needs to be honest about its history and stop hiding and twisting the truth.
� Finally, church needs to be fun again. There's too much focus on obedience and not enough on the atonement.
As Fawn Brodie put it so elequently, it felt like taking off a heavy woollen coat during the summer. I am now much happier and much more comfortable than ever before. I would highly recommend it!
Perhaps we truly miss what we once thought we had. Perhaps we're hopeful that some day meaningful changes might be made, and our input might actually help.
Perhaps we still love and care about the members we left behind and wish only to enlighten them and help them to discover "the truth."
"Retention" is a bad term. It is like building a dam to prevent the water from escaping. Developing and maintaining true conversion is a responsibility not just of the currently active members but of all who join. Many members of record have grown up in families that were not active, having received little training or introduction to the church while growing up, and are somewhat like non-members in their knowledge of the church.
I went inactive years ago because I grew tired of feeling guilty every week for my desire to frequent massage parlors and look at porn on the Internet.
I left the church entirely after our Bishop told my wife it was okay to divorce me because of my habit to look at porn and to go to these massage parlors. What gave him the right to tell her that? I still loved my wife and kids, and still provided for them.
Anyway, I have no desire to go back, and my friends, neighbors and family don't seem to realize that it's okay for me to not go to church and I'm totally fine with not going.
Also, tell me o' wise one - are you saying the only celestial marriage is plural marriage? And how is celestial marriage no longer eternal? If you want plural marriage, I know of a town along the Utah/ Arizona border that will accomodate you.
To: Anonymous (5:03 2/14) you are the kind of Mormon I would want to associate with.
As for how easy it is to remove your records...
A letter to your bishop is all it requres. I know, because I did it. I found Mormon theology and my personal theology did not mix, so I sent the letter.
The Bishop called...pleaded and reminded me that I would loose all my blessings promised in the temple.
I said thanks for your concern, please remove my name and that was that.
By Law..the church HAS to remove your name if you request it. The LDS church has been sued enough times in the past for this issue, that they don't play games much anymore.
My reason for being here....Therapy. I have anger towards the 45 years that I "feel" were wasted and talking about it and seeing others who have had simulare experences helps to reduce my anger. Angry Mormons like John Lambert help fuel my anger...but Loving Mormons like Anon 5:03 2/14 help remind me of how it SHOULD be....
p.s. there no such thing as purging the rolls.
Sometime before you die, ask yourself, was it worth the effort I went to distance myself from all? Then live and die with your answer and I hope you're right.
John Lambert, I will pray for you. You need the prayers of many people.
I encourage all Saints to consider a life of freedom outside the LDS.
Given the number of inactives living and dead that have not hit 110 from their birthdate, one can only assume that the 12 million member number thrown about by the church is off by a bit.
2) Good people will leave the church for many reasons...and they will still be good people. Church activity doesnt change that. There are many, many non-members and less active members that lead more Christ-like lives than 'active members'. Dont confuse activity with a relationship with Christ.
3) Quit carring what other people think. Didn't care what non-members outside of Utah thought and don't care what members here in Utah think. I choose to associate with those (member or non member) that bring happiness to my life and help me draw closer to the Savior.
4) Less active members, hope to see you at Church. Be great to have you. Smell of smoke? No prob, you're welcome to sit with me and my family. We wont judge you. We've got our problems, you've got yours. Maybe we can help each other out and both be the better for it in the end.
But I don't miss the unnecessary guilt. I don't miss the arrogance. I don't miss the rigid requirements. (I mean, am I really a sinner if I love to wear flip flops, and I ABSOLUTELY HATE panty hose?)
But most of all I don't miss having to apologize for the unkind actions (excommunications, firing professors, hiding the truth, etc.) of my Church, because I no longer see it as "my" church.
How could I ever go back?
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Disappearance called 'sususpicious' 7:00 p.m.
- Depleted uranium OK'd for storage 6:51 p.m.
- Snow may fly with weekend warm-up 6:33 p.m.
- ATK to cut 800 jobs 6:11 p.m.
- Cops: Artist's son swipes paintings 5:57 p.m.
- Incentives to create new jobs 5:51 p.m.
- Teen to be tried as adult 5:45 p.m.
- Study: 5 steps to creativity 5:44 p.m.
- Former CEO is Entrepreneur of Year 5:40 p.m.
- Calendar of events for December 5:36 p.m.
- Nude bathers cited for lewdness
- Few details on missing W.V. mom
- Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
- Crash landing next to I-15
- Defense witness goes on offensive
- BCS = power conference monopoly
- Palin signs books, chats with fans
- I-15 expansion barreling south
- 5 officers lose their certification
- Y.'s Emery bruised, but rarely beaten
- Letters: Global warming a lie
254 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
206 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
193 - Palin signs books, chats with fans
158 - Cougars going back to Vegas
150 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
149 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
142 - Max Hall wants to look ahead
123 - Nude bathers cited for lewdness
117 - Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
108
ESPN's Mark Schlabach ranked the Las Vegas Bowl as the seventh most...
I agree with Wright's suggestion. Don't take babies and small children into...
the magic man!! ronaldinho!!!
The free market is why your kids aren't starving to death and you have color...
Aren't addictions wonderful? And so are women who just shamelessly throw...
Depleted uranium gets more radioactive over time, but I guess the Governor...
When people are paying double or triple for their electricity and having to...
enough said...
How telling that while most would recognize the stuffing of the ears as...
On ESPN radio today in LA, John Ireland said of the game last night; "The...
all of you who are arguing feel real big and powerful. You are all sounding...

