Reader comments
Found alive: Kearns couple released from hospital after 10-day ordeal
35 comments | Read story
Tab L. Uno | 12:24 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Much and perhaps the only credit for this rescue appears to be on the part of
the victims and not much on the rescue teams which actually suffered
unfortunately one fatality. Resourcefulness, something which seems to be in
short supply for most lost victims who die, and luck in how they were discovered
are the primary reason for this happy ending. What went wrong? Why if the
rescue teams were looking in the right area didn't they locate these
fortunate victims. More troubling questions and important issues have been
raised for future searches. What about infrared, body heat seeking devices?
Human body warmth against the cold of ice and snow? What about marking disable
vehicles? What could have been done differently so that the chances of earlier
and more likely detection have occurred? The next time, the victims might not
be so resourceful or as fortunate.
Lassie | 12:40 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I'd have gone for help!
Fabulous! | 12:46 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Congratulations to this family!!
Comments continue below
okay | 1:59 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I am glad the Garners are well. I am an Eagle Scout too, but I don't know
if I could survive ten days. I don't remember much from those days.
Tab L. Uno | 3:12 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
The lessons being overlooked for future victims. It's both a relief and a
disturbing revelation that the victims were mostly responsible for their own
survival. Their ability to take care of themselves as well as a lot of luck led
to the great and happy outcome. What is disturbing however is that the actual
rescue parties failed locate the victims even though they were in the right area
and that one of them died in part due to his participation in this search. What
ever happened to heat-sensors to identity human heat signatures against the cold
ice and snow? What ever happened to teaching lost victims to put more effort
into creating location signs for help easily identifiable by air search craft.
The next victims might not be so lucky.
Sheila | 6:04 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Wonderful NEWS!!! I truly believe that God had a hand in their return. Prayer
works miracles.
Sahara | 7:22 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Thought inspiring story but why is Madussa at an animal shelter instead of home
with family members?
Rob | 7:23 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I am so happy that you knew so much to do to survive. I listened and learned in
case. Congratulations for a safe return for you and your family. Many people
were praying for you. Hey, write your story and it could save other lives. You
two were amazing.
steve | 7:34 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Thank God, it was He who saved them. And thank God that there are those who are
willing to lose their lives to help save others.
Lesa | 7:52 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
What an amazing life story. Prayers are answered. There is a reason why things
happen the way they do. Reflection on what was learned from this experience by
all involved, even those who are unaquainted with this amazing family and have
sent up a prayer, have the blessing of personal growth. The opportunity now is
to share what you've learned, how you have grown as individuals and within
your communities. Reach out, we are all on the path to be a better self. Shared
life experiences of others can help us see we are not alone, that we can have
hope, our lives matter, even a prayer is valuable. I am so happy for your
family, don't ever let the hugs stop.
Amazing story | 8:15 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
No way! No way!
No disrespect, but... | 8:25 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Obviously grateful things worked out for the best. But you saw the warning
signs!
Why do people think they are exempt from danger? These signs are not for the sceneries benefit. Same goes to skiers/snowboarders who CHOOSE to go into the back countries. Heed the warning signs. You'd be surprised how they may actually save your life!
Why do people think they are exempt from danger? These signs are not for the sceneries benefit. Same goes to skiers/snowboarders who CHOOSE to go into the back countries. Heed the warning signs. You'd be surprised how they may actually save your life!
Heed the warnings... | 8:34 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Obviously grateful things worked out for the best, but you SAW the warning
signs!
Why do people think they are exempt from danger? These signs are not posted for the benefit of the scenery. Same goes to skiers/snowboarders who CHOOSE to go in areas of danger. Life is about taking risks, no doubt about it...but use your common sense once in a while
Why do people think they are exempt from danger? These signs are not posted for the benefit of the scenery. Same goes to skiers/snowboarders who CHOOSE to go in areas of danger. Life is about taking risks, no doubt about it...but use your common sense once in a while
Dakota Dumper | 8:31 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
The reason I got rid of my Dodge Dakota last year was because the thing could
get stuck on a popsicle and spin all day. I knew someday it would strand me
somewhere I didn't want to be stranded. I guess the seat cushions make
good snowshoes though! Congratulations to the Garners for their ingenuity and
will to persist, and condolences to the Search and Rescue who lost a member of
their "family."
K | 8:47 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Amazing! I thought the news must have gotten it wrong when I first heard
it!
Other newspapers and on-line are reporting that the Garners were "wearing only light jackets and levis". They make them sound dumb...They don't say a word about how resourceful they were, with the camper cushion "snowshoes" and all.
Way to go Garners...you are very determined (and blessed!) folks!
Other newspapers and on-line are reporting that the Garners were "wearing only light jackets and levis". They make them sound dumb...They don't say a word about how resourceful they were, with the camper cushion "snowshoes" and all.
Way to go Garners...you are very determined (and blessed!) folks!
Next Time | 9:28 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
The best thing is to not get into that situation. If you do, keep your truck
uncovered and brush on top of the white snow in a big, obviously man-made
pattern or the rescue crews won't have a chance.
Lost in Snow | 9:39 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Last Saturday I went up Mount Taylor near Grants, New Mexico. I was in a Ford
Explorer traveling with my 10 year old son. While traveling on a remote back
road at 9,300 feet we got high centered on icy snow. The snow was only 10
inches deep. In all we got stuck 5 times trying to retrace our path. Each time
I had to dig us out. It took us 4 hours to go 5 miles. That night a huge storm
moved in. If it weren't for the shovel my vehicle would still be in the
mountains.
Don't be too confident in a 4x4.
Don't be too confident in a 4x4.
Kathy A | 9:35 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
WOW!!!!!!!!! It's nice to hear good new this morning!!!!!!!
And may Heavenly Father bless the Davenport family...
And may Heavenly Father bless the Davenport family...
Scott | 9:41 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
It's a wondersful outcome, but how can anyone suggest that the rescuers,
many who are volunteers who put themselves at risk for others, have somehow
failed. I absolutely applaud their efforts and am thankful they do what they
do. Let's not forget this couple put themselves in this risky situation in
the first place and they got themselves out of it in the end. It's a
wonderful outcome full of lessons learned and will no doubt be a great binding
experience in their relationship.
Douglas Partlow | 10:25 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Tom and Tamitha,
I've been following this story and you have been in my prayers from Cincinnati, OH. How grateful I am for the tender mercies that have been extended to you both. A great sigh of relief came to see of your rescue. May God continue to bless you and keep you safe with Krystal. I miss you from our days in Kearns, but glad to know you are well.
I've been following this story and you have been in my prayers from Cincinnati, OH. How grateful I am for the tender mercies that have been extended to you both. A great sigh of relief came to see of your rescue. May God continue to bless you and keep you safe with Krystal. I miss you from our days in Kearns, but glad to know you are well.
gail | 10:40 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I also applaud the Garners for their resourcefulness and the efforts of the
rescuers who attempted rescue in severe conditions, and condolences to the
family of the rescuer who died. I also wondered why Medusa is in an animal
shelter. The dog likely provided additonal body warmth to the Garners, and
shared his food with them, according to the story. Seems a dog-loving rescuer
or family could rescue this dog from the shelter.
Discovery channel Rocks! | 10:43 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I knew I was doing something valuable with my time watching the Discovery
channel's Surviroman and man vs Wild.
Commentor | 11:02 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I was told a good rule to follow in driving 4 X 4's: When you've gone
as far as you can go in 2-wheel drive, put it in 4-wheel and turn around and go
back. (Don't put it in 4-wheel and keep going until you get stuck!)
Survival | 11:10 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
If God is to be thanked, why in the world did He let them get in that situation
in the first place? Silly.
Congratulations on getting out of that horrible situation YOURSELVES! The human will to survive has saved far more lives than any god; and god has been the excuse for killing far more than can be counted.
Count on yourself!
Congratulations on getting out of that horrible situation YOURSELVES! The human will to survive has saved far more lives than any god; and god has been the excuse for killing far more than can be counted.
Count on yourself!
the elderly woman | 11:18 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I think the unfortunate thing is that they didn't stop to ask the elderly
woman driver what the road conditions were like. It wasn't that they
ignored the signs, they assumed that because a little old lady was coming down
the road, the conditions must be safe (and honestly, I would have figured the
same thing).
That they survived their ordeal at all is indeed a miracle! I got goosebumps when I read this story...I'm glad that this family had a happy ending.
That they survived their ordeal at all is indeed a miracle! I got goosebumps when I read this story...I'm glad that this family had a happy ending.
TV watcher | 11:32 a.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Survivorman is one of my favorite tv shows!!! Now when someone says I waste to
much time watching tv, I can say "It's not a waste, I'm learning
important survival tactics!"
Old woman... | 12:16 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Question everything and think critically. Happy you made it out alive,
condolances to the family of the man who died searching for you, and yeah, where
were the heat sensors??? For whoever reads and considers all the variables of
this situation, I would suggest that any applicable lesson or wisdom you can
extract from the Garner's experience will be the happiest ending of all.
Anonymous | 12:18 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
congratulations to you both. I am an older female and spend most of my spare
time out and away from the every day world. My truck has good things stored in
it ,like water and food, a shovel,a broom, some flares and a pill bottle with
cotton balls that have been rolled in vasoline(great fire starter) even if your
tinder is really wet. I hope I never get as stranded as you two were, but if I
do, I hope I will think things through as well as you both did. You each have
all my admiration. quinn
Reader | 1:03 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Glad this turned out OK.
Why didn't they check the weather before venturing off road?
Why didn't they have enough food and water?
Why didn't they let someone know exactly where they were going instead of searchers looking over a huge area?
I consider them absolutely lucky to be alive. Next time, don't go, this is winter, you know.
Why didn't they check the weather before venturing off road?
Why didn't they have enough food and water?
Why didn't they let someone know exactly where they were going instead of searchers looking over a huge area?
I consider them absolutely lucky to be alive. Next time, don't go, this is winter, you know.
Incensed | 1:04 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I am so glad the Garner's were able to get out of this horrendous ordeal
and they are okay. Others haven't fared as well in circumstances like this,
but I feel I have to comment on Tab L. Uno's comments. Number one, how dare
you you attack the rescuers on this. Have you ever been in that area, and do you
know how many little canyons, and how vast the area is? Do you know anything
about the heat sensing devices? They only pick up what they can locate. They
aren't set up to pick up everything in a 100 square mile area. Thus, if
they aren't right in the area, they won't pick up anything. They also
pick up everything. If a deer was dead and rotting, they would pick up that
heat, if a rock was heated by the sun, it would pick it up. Have you counted all
the storms that came through the area? Not to mention the truck was buried, and
was grey in color, very able to blend in with the snow it was sitting on even if
it wasn't covered. Have you ever tried to fly and locate an object on the
ground?
Incensed | 1:25 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
more for Tab
Did you volunteer to help with the search? It's easy to have the choice to do nothing but sit back and criticize, isn't it? There was one life lost, would you have liked to have more die to make it a noble effort on the part of the rescuers? Most of them were volunteers, who had the choice of going out or sitting in their warm homes doing nothing. Utah has wonderful, scenic country, but it is very unforgiving if something goes wrong. Give us your expertise. What more would you have done? You seem to be the expert. There were thousands of miles searched, and thousands of manhours put into this. There was no definite plans and the Garners had been in alot of different locations, and no one knew where to look. Have you ever been in that part of the state? Until you are willing to participate in a rescue party, and until you can show your expertise, it's best in situations like this you just sit back, keep warm and keep your cheap shots to yourself, like you apparently did the 11 days the Garner's were missing.
Did you volunteer to help with the search? It's easy to have the choice to do nothing but sit back and criticize, isn't it? There was one life lost, would you have liked to have more die to make it a noble effort on the part of the rescuers? Most of them were volunteers, who had the choice of going out or sitting in their warm homes doing nothing. Utah has wonderful, scenic country, but it is very unforgiving if something goes wrong. Give us your expertise. What more would you have done? You seem to be the expert. There were thousands of miles searched, and thousands of manhours put into this. There was no definite plans and the Garners had been in alot of different locations, and no one knew where to look. Have you ever been in that part of the state? Until you are willing to participate in a rescue party, and until you can show your expertise, it's best in situations like this you just sit back, keep warm and keep your cheap shots to yourself, like you apparently did the 11 days the Garner's were missing.
Doesn't Make Sense | 2:13 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
Something about this story doesn't make sense. It's almost like the
Garners planned the whole thing to get on television. They were prepared enough
to have emergency blankets, yet not prepared enough to have food. Mr. Garner, an
eagle scout, had watched enough TV to use seat cushions as snowshoes, but was
inexperienced enough to get himself in a bad situation. I've spent
thousands of hours in the backcountry, and the first thing you learn is to stay
out of bad situations. Things just don't add up here...
Hey, doesn't make sense | 2:41 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
I have blankets in my car, I have a flashlight, I have handwarmers, but I
don't have any food. I've watched survival shows, what are you trying
to say? I'm looking for my 15 minutes of fame? I'm sure the
Garner's weren't looking for their own TV spot....
I'm just happy for them it turned out like it did, not a TV spot with the Medical Examiner's loading them up.
I'm just happy for them it turned out like it did, not a TV spot with the Medical Examiner's loading them up.
ed_schow | 6:51 p.m. Feb. 7, 2008
If it had been me, I would not have ventured into this unknown road near Panaca,
Nevada. I would have been very careful to avoid this dangerous situation. But
then, I grew up in Utah and know the situation well. I have made mistakes and
then had to walk out on my own two legs. I would guess that this couple were
very fortunate to escape death.
I think the reportage on this item is very level headed and worth the effort to read this item.
Thank you for your story.
I think the reportage on this item is very level headed and worth the effort to read this item.
Thank you for your story.
SJ Bobkins | 12:46 a.m. Feb. 8, 2008
I don't know how they did it. I don't think I could. Whatever they
used to maintain their faith had to have worked wonders.
I thought I was smarter than the road department once (in late January) and drove 130 miles on US 666, from Alpine, AZ to Safford, AZ, from 7600 feet to 5700 in elevation, ignoring the NOT MAINTAINED IN WINTER signs. For 10 hours I drove through ice and piles of snow before rounding a hill and seeing the lights of a copper mine. I was emotionally shaken and exhausted, sleeping for 2 days. Had I gotten stuck I would have been a goner, ground rescue would never attempt driving on this road, only brainless people like myself. Don't do it folks. Readers horrified as I was to read this will pay attention. Even if I spend lots of time in Hot-Zona I have food, tools, and blankets behind the third seat in my SUV. It's easy to do and cheap.
I thought I was smarter than the road department once (in late January) and drove 130 miles on US 666, from Alpine, AZ to Safford, AZ, from 7600 feet to 5700 in elevation, ignoring the NOT MAINTAINED IN WINTER signs. For 10 hours I drove through ice and piles of snow before rounding a hill and seeing the lights of a copper mine. I was emotionally shaken and exhausted, sleeping for 2 days. Had I gotten stuck I would have been a goner, ground rescue would never attempt driving on this road, only brainless people like myself. Don't do it folks. Readers horrified as I was to read this will pay attention. Even if I spend lots of time in Hot-Zona I have food, tools, and blankets behind the third seat in my SUV. It's easy to do and cheap.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
Related content
- 7 charged in Mumbai attacks 11:38 a.m.
- Energy prices rise despite supply 11:27 a.m.
- Toyota to replace 4M gas pedals 11:23 a.m.
- Lampropoulos in Senate race 11:19 a.m.
- Fed tightens conflict of interest rules 11:18 a.m.
- NATO offers troops for Afghanistan 11:16 a.m.
- A vote for McCoy for Heisman 11:14 a.m.
- Stocks rise following jobless news 11:12 a.m.
- Man who killed friend seeks parole 11:03 a.m.
- Obama to outline U.S. climate goals 10:15 a.m.
- Witness describes '99 killing
- Utah, BYU are top choices for bowls
- Donny and Kym dance to victory
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
- Howard made the rivalry a rivalry
- Cougars cruise past Southern
- Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
- Police increase presence at Skyline
- Mitchell lawyers lose motion to leave
- Loyal to Cougarettes, Crimson Line
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
249 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?225
- RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks202
- Protests against Phoenix LDS temple197
- Bronco, Kyle rubber match138
- BYU records with win133
- Letters: Rushing to judge Palin125
- Hall, Johnson matchup key102
- 4A: Timpview wins 4th in 4 years95
- Cougars turn focus to dreaded rivals90
Latest comments
And Toyota is no longer the #1 selling brand in the world..... the wheeels...
Which Hall will show up?
Global warming has never been about science. It's been about global...
Anyone who knows video games knows that the movie Ninja Assassin is loosely...
I lived in Hawaii. We used to visit a particular cove on the ocean. In only a...
Several of the pros are from Utah too.
You're 100% right about the huge waste of money an EIS would be. If it's not...
That's what I'm saying, Because the conservative right can't think for...
taylor swift
Go Texas and Colt McCoy!
Advertisements