Reader comments
Theology: LDS god is in harmony with the Bible
395 comments | Read story
Mitt's talk was awesome to say the least on a par with Reagan and George Washington I would say.
God Bless The Romney's.
You said, "We are forever his [God's] children and will never be his equals." That is neither accurate nor true.
You are a father today just as much as your father was to you, in every sense of the word.
Those who reach exaltation will be Gods to their children as much as our God is to us, in every sense of the word.
Our becoming Gods does not diminish His standing or capacity as our God any more than our becoming fathers diminish our fathers' standing and capacity as our fathers. We don't replace them, we join them!
I do agree with you on the point that more people need to attend their Sunday school classes--all of us!
What is the expression? If you want to know what a Mormon believes, ask a Mormon?
If you want to know what a traditional Christian believes, ask a traditional Christian. Not a Mormon.
I have a conversation on this very topic with a Traditional Christinas and he believed EXACTLY what Mr. Card said, so I think he did his research. Well done Orson!
Your definition does not make it so!
I had a conversation on this very topic with a Traditional Christian and he believed EXACTLY what Mr. Card said, so I think he did his research. Well done Orson!
To me, the only question of relevance in the debate about who is and is not a Christian is to what degree does one's concept of Christ influence his or her daily decisions. If my concept of Christ deepens my commitment to live His teachings, isn't that preferable to making sure your dictionary and my dictionary have the same definition for Christian?
When a Mormon kneels and pleads for divine guidance, I doubt she envisions a much different God than the Evangelist on his knees, and I doubt the God who hears their prayers applies the dictionary test in deciding whose prayer to answer.
Also in regard to Christianity and Christ, Christianity existed with just the Father, until the Latin church introduced the "filioque" which inserted the word "Son" into the already established Nicene Creed without permission, therefore causing the split between the Christian Orthodox and the Christian Latin church which continues today, which means any old mortal can change how and what we believe whenever they want, and we have seen a lot of that. Still, Romney's my man.
Please share with us the traditional concept of the Holy Trinity. I would like to get it correct.
Thanks
Please share with us the traditional christian concept of the Holy Trinity. I would like to get it correct.
Thanks
If you want to know what traditional christianity is, go to a church like Calvary Chapel and ask the pastor. Even if you don't agree with what they believe you are getting the information from a better source than someone from another team.
Btw, the plato arguement was weak and missinformed. I've never been to a christian church that "treated the biblical physicality of God as metaphor".
Have a great day,
Joel
Mitt is a classy guy and good Presidential material.
Our Presiden should be a person who can unite us in our common goals to do this. Our beliefs that drive us to be better are irrevelant so long as we have a belief that causes us to just be better as a country.
Mitt understands this as do other do other good candidates like Huckabee. So the issue of which religion or God should be a non-issue and the issues of the ability, competance and character of a candidate to lead the country to be better should be our focus.
I will join with any person who desires us to be better no matter what religion.
Genesis 1:26-27
Psalm 82:6
Romans 8:17
Revelation 3:21
Ephesians 4:13
Matthew 5:48
Luke 24:39
Love your books, but your article is a little misleading. To say that modern Christians have twisted Biblical doctrine because of Plato, is untrue. We believe that God is spirit because there are many Biblical references that say so. John 4:24 is one, "God is Spirit, and His worshipers must worship Him in Spirit and in truth." You now could argue all day about the context of this and what it really means, but to say that Christians are incorrect about God being spirit, and how it doesn't agree with the Bible, is a little short sighted.
--Jeremy
They believe the Christ is God and was once a man on earth subject to all the problems we have even sin (except he declined to participate). They further believe that Christ is now resurrected and lives in heaven in glory.
We are now on the earth as mortal beings and hope to be resurrected and live in heaven just like Christ. So, in that sense, the whole Christian world belives that God was once as we are and they we may become as Christ is now. They just don't realize it.
As for mortals' potential to become Gods: are we blaspheming the Ominpotent by saying we can be like Him? Absolutely not. "All that my Father hath" is promised to us. Mortal parents would give the world to their children. God, being perfect, is even more generous. Why would He deny us the opportunity to advance when He is merciful and loving?
Members should never be ashamed of our beliefs.
Thanks!
That fact is, godhood IS taught for exalted human beings. To say otherwise is to ignore Church President Lorenzo Snow, who in June 1840 stated: "As man is, God once was; as God is, man may become."
Or, consider Apostle Bruce McConkie: "Thus those who gain eternal life receive exaltation ... They are gods." (Mormon Doctrine, pg. 237).
What LDS faithful fail to acknowledge is their personal bias. Just as Evangelicals are convinced that any non-believer is either ignorant or decieved, far too many Mormons see their "friends of another faith" as tragically off track.
I fully acknowledge that as a former member, my bias leads me to give church doctrine the doubt of the benefit. But if my perspective of the LDS faith would be considered incomplete, how is a faithful follower's testimony any better?
On the other hand, Kathy, I think you are right. I have spent alot of time reading the literature of the evangelicals--alot of it is totally awesome, and I agree more than not, but the ideas are indeed varied. I wish more of them would read mormon literature and see what they COULD agree with.
Jay-I disagree with you on this part. While the faithful are promised "everything the Father has," they will never be "equal" with God. I may be a father, but I will never be equal with my father, and so on. I think Card is right on that one. How could we possibly be equal to God when he's already infinitely ahead of us in his progression?
I suppose that's a different argument though, i.e. is God still progressing or not. And there are plenty of statements from GAs on both sides.
I was a traditional Christian before converting to the LDS church.
As a Traditional Christian I was taught that the Trinity consists of three persons/beings in one God all three are distinct and co-eternal persons, and are of one indivisible Divine essence.
The Latter Day Saints believe that the Godhead consists of three separate beings, one in purpose. Not of one indivisible divine essence. This is all that the author was trying to say in a comical way.
I went to several different Protestant Churches growing up, and this is what I was always taught. The only church that I have attended that believes that the Godhead consists of three separate beings that are not of one indivisible essence was the LDS Church.
I do agree that if you want to know the full truth you should go to the source not go off your own definition, and in my case that is exactly what I did.
Kathy may very well have more opportunities with this type non-LDS Christian.
I liked the explanation. Written and clearly defined as only Bro. Card can do.
Where are the supernatural spectacles, the golden tablets, and the archaeological evidence of the American tribes?
I understand Orthodox Christian theology, and have not taken any college courses on the subject.
That is pretty good advice given that many (I hate to lump all people together) traditional Christians are pretty good at telling Mormons what they are (a cult) and are not (Christians) and what they believe and don't believe (i.e., correct vs. incorrect concept of Christ). Card got the nature and futility of the debate correct and THAT was the focus on his essay. As Christians (by either definition) and imperfect beings, mutual respect vs mutal agreement should be our goal .
And the discussion of the Trinity is completely off base. We're taught that God is three persons in one, lines and geometry don't have anything to do with it. One God, three faces, three functions. There is only one God, and no more. Belief in more than one God excludes a belief system from traditional Christianity.
You are free to worship and believe as you wish. I won't ever try to convert you. But you can't tell me what my beliefs are, or are not. And I ask you not to misrepresent them. I'll give you the same courtesy.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Muslim pilgrims face rain, flu threat 8:33 p.m.
- Israel offers short halt in building 8:33 p.m.
- 7 charged in Mumbai attacks 8:33 p.m.
- Obama to unveil Afghan decision 8:33 p.m.
- Taliban leader rules out Karzai talks 8:32 p.m.
- Dobbs weighs Senate run 8:32 p.m.
- Atlantis leaves space station 8:32 p.m.
- No bad side effects from vaccine? 8:31 p.m.
- A gift from the city: free parking 8:28 p.m.
- Granite employee accused of theft 8:27 p.m.
- Donny and Kym dance to victory
- Howard made the rivalry a rivalry
- Crews free man in Utah County cave
- Cougars cruise past Southern
- Loyal to Cougarettes, Crimson Line
- Twitterati to BCS: 'We hate you.'
- Y. focused on 10-win season
- BYU has slim shot at BCS
- Thunder rolls by Jazz
- Witness describes '99 killing
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
258 - Glenn Beck to enter politics?
227 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
207 - RSL wins MLS Cup on penalty kicks
202 - Bronco, Kyle rubber match
139 - BYU records with win
133 - Letters: Rushing to judge Palin
129 - Boys basketball rankings
105 - Hall, Johnson matchup key
102 - Thunder rolls by Jazz
102
Re: Bingham Fan You should rethink your title matchup, it will be...
Hopefully this game isn't a turkey. If you look at the differential box score...
1962 Utah 35 BYU 20 1963 Utah 15 BYU 6 1964 Utah 47 BYU 13 (Utah now...
Just drop the preseson polls. Start the polls around the sixth week or so....
Give me a break ! Rankings are based on last year's team, returning...
Don't get after Bronco for saying this is just another game. That apparently...
Remember a few years ago the teens who died in a cave because of gases...
If they just went forward now, by the time they finished it, the recession...
Its Bingham Head Coach Dubauch. They retired his shirt after they won the...
I would act like this in public and especially here in Salt Lake City.



