Reader comments
Pills for pain put BYU star in a tailspin

86 comments   |   Read story

dl | 1:26 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
poor dude. hope he and his wife git over the problem for good.
Big Problem | 2:23 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
This is a big problem. The pressure to perform as a college athlete must be huge. I am sure it is just as bad at BYU as at any other school with the reward of millions of dollars if you make it into the NFL, I am sure many do whatever it takes to get back on the field. I would hope there is much oversight by coaches and trainers to help these young men/women athletes avoid such addictive pain killers such as OxyContin which is the number one fastest growing drug of choice among teens in Grade school on up. My hopes and prayers are with those suffering with this terrible addiction, as well as with their families.
rick | 2:45 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
my son passed away from od on painkillers this is something that got to stop we need rehabs not jail time if it as easy or a dr to write out the scrip then it should be easy to send to rehab the drug company pulled a fast one over on the drs saying great painkiller with little or no addicive properties now we have a generation of young dying on painkillers
Comments continue below
GO Red Sox | 6:06 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Although I like sports, I have always felt the football program at BYU should be scaled back. Even when I went there it produced more embarrassing moments than any other sector of the school, and I bet that was all other sectors combined. In my day it was McMahon, but it seems like it is always someone doing something that gets there names in the paper or is common knowledge around town. I do like sports, but maybe not to this extent at BYU. I say we need a medical school and more music.
Camille | 6:51 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I'm sorry for them. But, I don't think a sport is worth putting your health at risk or lowering ones morals. Nobody is immuned to addiction, not even an athlete. But, part of the blame has to be on the coaches, forcing them to perform before they are ready and have healed. Healing takes time. Let the athlete heal properly without the painpills.
Anonymous | 7:10 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
thats too sad....i hope that he gets help as well as his wife...i honestly think we fall into the same catorgory....just some of us can control it....but in anycase its good to know his family is supporting him with this. im still a "BYU FAN" all the way!
JB | 7:35 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I know Bryant from school. He is a top notch kid who made a couple of mistakes that led him down the road of addicition. It could happen to anyone. I am so glad to see that he has picked his life up and seems to be fairly happy again. There needs to be a lot more monitoring of pain pills by these Doctors. It's playing with fire.
Anonymous | 7:46 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
people are quick to blame others for their childrens choices and mistake they make. He put the pressure on himself not the coaches, trainers and doctors to play!
Chris | 8:18 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
The sad thing is this is not limited to College and Pro sports. This is very rampant in High School football also.
KP | 8:19 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Thank you for this article. This is a big problem in our commmunities. It has been around for years. I have had two friends pass away due to complications caused from addictions to pain killers. Both played college sports (two different institutions). Both were injured in college, as was the case in this article.

Thank you for sharing your story.
ryansutes | 8:21 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
A tremendous thanks, to the authors of this piece and to the Atkinson family. It took a tremendous amount of courage on thier part. This is an extremely important topic. As a physician I have seen this story played out numerous times. And it is the main reason I am extremely guarded to prescribe opiates for chronic pain. Obviously this problem exists at all schools and in the professional sports. Years ago, Brett Favre admitted to a similar addiction. Team physicians and coaches need to be more aware of the demands they put on players. It sounds like the Atkinson's are a terrific family and I wish them luck in recovering from this horrible addiction.
mike b | 8:34 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
This is an important wake-up call to a growing problem in Utah County. I knew both of them while at BYU. They are good people trying to become better. I am happy that Bryant and Mindy are making good progress and working to get their good lives back. I am very grateful that both sets of parents have worked to stay close to them. I admire the strength and times of tough love that helped them make the progress they needed. This is a hard thing to go public about and I am proud of Bryant and Mindy!
BlueBoy | 8:36 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
This article ought to be required reading this weekend for all BYU athletes and coaches.
Anon | 8:38 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I knew Bryant for a little while when I was on the BYU football team. He's a good kid and it's hard to believe that was going on. Just shows that it can happen to anybody. My prayers go out to him and his wife.
Joel | 8:44 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Coaches and administrations, at every level, treat kids like puppies. If this batch doesnt work out there is a new batch on the way. Coaches only care about them while they are playing well. The kids have the rest of their lives to live their respective failures, successes, pains and injuries.
Anonymous | 9:16 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
pressure from a football program, lifes demands, survival of the fittest, media,not feeling like you meet up to the demands of every day pressures, It can lead to self medicating, an escape from it all.

It's not the answer, having a wonderful wife and oldest son with this addiction, but now clean, As a husband and father of addicts, I would suggest you seek help, because there is help out there.
Not Surprised | 9:30 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
This whole issue Re this one and others are a BIG COP OUT. Go back years ago to Golden Richards days and others of that generation and see if these Prescription and Illegal drugs are not well documented, as to use and to health, and social penalties for users. Warnings and life issues for use have been shown, brodcast, and printed forever. Why do people think they are different and can get away with things that are proven they can!t. Sorry is sports more important than life and health, I don!t think so. Same old story, if your going to dance you gotta pay the FIDDLER.
johnny cobert | 9:32 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I was a adult probation officer for some 25 years in texas. During those years I saw many good decent law-abiding people fall into a downward spiral because of drugs. Our prisons are full of people who would otherwise not be there if it were not for drugs/alcohol. This young man and his bride are going to make it because they have family supporting them (not enabling them) but showing tough love. To any parent who reads this, who has a child with a drug/alcohol problem, take a deep breath, get on your knees and plead for courage, then get up and do what you know you must do, report them to law enforcement. You will later thank God you did.
Me | 9:46 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Sports is very demanding, but I've got a problem with the father blaming it on the program. I'm guessing the father pushed his son as much as anyone until he got to college.
Who is to blame | 9:47 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Scott says he blames his son and BYU. This type of problem happens at high schools and universities and the pros everywhere. Is it the coaches and the schools that make the decision for the player to keep pushing himself/herself in spite of the physical pain that is telling the athlete to stop? Athletes need to take ownership of their situation and not blame coaches. It can be a tough decision to walk away from sports when there are pressures and expectations from friends and family to continue, but it is still the athlete who makes the final decision on whether to take painkillers or walk away. It's surprising to me that even with all the education that goes on about the addictive qualities of painkillers it still happens to people. Of course, some people also still choose to smoke in spite of all the education and evidence against it. People gotta have their drugs, I guess. But it still comes down to the fact it was their decision, not some school or a bunch of coaches or anybody else.
Jason | 9:50 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
These two are very lucky to be doing well after addition. They seem to have a strong family backing them, which is invaluable. Crazy as it seems, this couple as the potential to do great things once they have fully broken their addition. I think it was healthy for the parents to let them spend time in jail.

I don't see BYU's program as being at fault. It seems that a lot of the abuse happened from doctors who weren't associated with BYU. When he says that he searched out doctors who didn't ask questions, the real problem becomes available. Bryant could have quit after his first knee injury, but HE choose to continue. He could have quit after his second injury. It wasn't until the third injury that is addiction began (according to the article). Taking pain killers for that long increases the risk of addition. I believe that if BYU had told him to quit, his family would be screaming that BYU was being too extreem. Bryant was the only one in control, and I admire the way he has taken responsibilty and improved his life.

Maybe a dad, pushing him hard into football is the problem?
pb | 9:56 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
When people become addicted they will always look for excuses. I am glad to see that Bryant and his wife and taking most of the responsibility but I feel that BYU should in no way be accused. College athletics are competative. Players are supposed to give their best. Same within a working environment. Coaches and schools are not to be blamed for this addiction.
judy allred | 10:21 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
What about the Doctors who keep writing these prescriptions. Shouldn't they be held accountable too? I know several people who's families have been destroyed by Oxycotin and they were all getting them from their doctors. One of my friends husbands went to his doctor for help and came back with a higher dosage.
Dean M. | 10:28 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I've known Scott and Mary, Bryant's parents, for years. You will never meet a better, kinder, more God-fearing couple, in this world. Their son, Bryant, is the same way. Bryant and his wife, Mindy, aren't looking for excuses nor are they asking for anyone's sympathy. They're just looking to go forward with their lives. It's too easy to judge people without knowing the facts. One thing that this article doesn't address is the tremendous pressure college athletes get put upon them to succeed NOW in behalf of the school. But when injuries and complications arise, too often the athlete is pushed aside in favor of someone else. Good luck to you, Bryant and Mindy. Our prayers are with you.
Football Dad | 10:30 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
As I write this I am sitting next to my son who is recovering from his second operation on his knee in two years. Two years to the day as a matter of fact. Both surgeries were major. No one pushed him to play football. No one pressured him to compromise his health and shorten his recovery. It all came from within. He pushed himself for the love of the game he enjoys soo much. He has plenty of other abilities so that his whole life isn't wrapped up in sports. But it is the thing he loves the most. We had already decided before the surgery to very carefully manage his pain, but this article made my wife and I even more vigilant.
KC Fan | 10:32 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
BYU is NOT to blame. That young man is right to shoulder the blame and, at least for the moment, he's showing better judgment than his father.
Mike | 10:34 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I personally am aware of several people who are or once were addicted to some kind of prescription medication. This is a huge problem due to the internet. People can buy any prescription they want over the internet. It seems this is huge problem among church members in general. Perhaps it is time the Word of Wisdom is updated to include the real, current and serious issue of prescription abuse and addiction - taking the place of which grains are good for man versus animals perhaps?
TO: JASON | 10:37 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Do you remeber the percidan issues in the 80's??? BYU SHOULD accept some of the blame. There not the only ones out there doing it. It's not a 'byu' problem, it is a society problem. We do all sorts of things to tell these kids from 2nd grade on that it the BEST is you play sports. Just quit trying to rationalize byu involvement, it makes you look silly.
Hmmmm | 10:41 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
So he was taking 10 pills a day valued between $400-$600.00

And who was paying for these?
kk | 10:54 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I agree with Whose is to blame and Jason but want to add that each situation is unique. My son had knee surgery in June following his junior year of high school by one of the BYU associated ortho specialists. My son was not a star athlete but was a respectable player with potential. The doctor strongly recommended he not return to sports for 8 months missing his senior year. He told numerous stories of athletes at all levels including pros that tried to get back on the field to early. Some did ok but most did not. The situation with this family and player is not the same as ours though the injury and the perscribed pain killers the same. My son chose to follow docs advise and get off the pain meds asap. The temptation was great to not follow the docs advise and I can only imagine how hard it would have been if he had been a star player. I have one child that had a drug problem and a sister as well. Please don't judge this great family and couple regardless of your experiences. Pray that all of us can resist the temptation of drugs.
positive experience | 11:10 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
My son had surgery with BYU football and never was once pressured to hurry back, in fact the opposite. They did not want him around to get hurt again and told him to attend the therapy sessions and stay out of the weight room. He was told by all coaches to leave the pain killers alone and get off fast, and never once was oxycontin even prescibed. They gave a minimal amount of hydrocodone to get through the first few days. Alot of the emphasis is on the athlete and their support system in the way they handle it. I think great strides have been made at BYU in controlling problems.
TN | 11:12 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Best of luck to the Atkinsons, but to hold anyone responsible besides Bryant and Mindy is ridiculous. I hope BYU steps in and helps in whatever way they can, but the Dad is way off in suggesting that they should be responsible when Bryant admits to not following prescribed dosages, gave pills to teammates without notifying the team, didn't tell the coaches or trainers about his pain, quit the team thereby losing contact with the school, and hid his problem from everyone around him. (And the fact that Bryant can't remember how he paid for the pills is very suspicious).

I suspect the dad is feeling some guilt himself for not realizing what was going on, and for no doubt pressuring his son to perform on field.
Accountability All Around! | 11:13 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
As a former BYU football player, both the player AND the program must stand accountable for what went on here. Anyone suggesting that all of the pressure to play only comes from within is a lie. Every week, coaches ensure that you know that your scholarship, starting position, and acceptability or "toughness" is on the line. There is external pressure to be on the field. An injured player is of no use to the program, once you're injured, chewed up and spit out. At the same time, as a player you must decide how far you're willing to go in order to be on the field. Thus, accountability for what happened here must be taken by both the program and the player. I'm just glad I got out when I did, although it still might have been too late, seeing I have to deal with injuries incurred at BYU that have permanently altered my physical health. I wish Bryant the best, and all other players who have suffered similar injuries/ situations.
Old Coug | 11:14 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
This is a sad tale, but one wonders if the drug/painkiller habit for this poor kid didn't start earlier. High school athletes can get drugs just as easily as college athletes can. I wouldn't be surprised if this kid and his wife dabbled in painkillers as high school athletes, too.
Don't flush pills down toilet | 11:20 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
This is a sad story, although one that hopefully will have a happier ending than what happened to Brad Martin. But please don't flush medication down the toilet! Now those 400-500 pills are in the water supply, along with other medications flushed away by everyone else. Water treatment plants can't filter it out.
J.S. | 11:21 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
You CANNOT blame BYU or Bronco Mendenhall! The burden of responsibility must be shouldered on the player (and his wife) and his doctors. Bronco does truly care about his players. He always has and always will. Any pressure the players "feel" to get back out there before they are ready is peer pressure, not from the coaching staff.

I have played collegiate football and I am a fried of Coach Mendenhall. I had knee surgery earlier this year....I was on the phone with Bronco the day before my surgery and he warned me as a friend to be careful with the pain meds. He realizes they are needed to properly recuperate, but offered me a stern warning to get off of them ASAP. We talked about the programs available to the players in the program to help them recognize the warning signs and give them the tools to manage and avoid potential problems.

I do feel badly for the athletes that are dependent upon pain meds to be able to function. But the blame must be placed where it is appropriate...With the individual. There is a reason Bronco preaches personal accountability above all else, and he practices what he preaches....
Mr. M | 11:26 a.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I'm glad to see that this young couple are changing their lives around and seem to be on the right path. I just can't believe that something like this could happen at a place like BYU where I have been told everything and everyone are as clean and white as the wind-driven snow. All of my BYU fan friends and neighbors keep telling me that things like this only happen at other schools where people of "lesser quality and spiritual integrity" attend and play sports. I just can't believe this could happen at BYU. I thought Elder Bronco had returned the program to glory and was fully invested in the program. I thought this type of evil only happened at places like the U of U where everyone is always drunk or high (tic)!

In all seriousness, this should be a wakeup call for everyone. This can happen anywhere and to anyone and many share the blame... athletes, parents, coaches, doctors etc.. Even at a perfect place like BYU. The win-at-all-cost mentality can and does destroy lives.
Hmmmmm | 12:07 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I had surgery to fix a broken nose a few years back, and didn't take anything for the pain. I was prescribed pain medication, but it didn't hurt too bad, so I didn't take any and threw them all away a few days later. Last year I had a roomate who had knee surgery to repair a torn meniscus (sp?). He didn't take pain meds, either. I know he was hurting quite bad for a few days, but he made it all right (he was back to playing soccer and hiking within a few months). I know there is a proper place for pain medication, but I'd rather suffer through a little pain (or even a lot) than risk becoming addicted.
JPC53 | 12:41 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
For all of you who say that the sports program shouldn't be blamed, or that they would never force someone to do this. You are living in a dream world. In division 1 athletics winning is the only thing and schools recruit over kinds constantly. If you can't make it they have others in the wings waiting to take your place. That is the psychological pressure that coaches and programs put on individuals. Combine that with the players love for the sport and you have a prescription (pardon the pun)for disaster. For anyone that still thinks that programs wouldn't give athletes painkillers to improve their performance, all you had to hear was Bonnie Brillstein on the sidelines before the Rutgers game today. When talking about the Rutgers quarterback's bad hand she said she was told by the coaches that he would take a painkiller, have it wrapped and be ready to go. Unfortunately this happens all the time.
fellow drug addict | 12:43 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
As a recovering drug addict with over 1 year in sobriety and a health care provider, it is possible to overcome the bondage of addiction. This is a DISEASE that can best be overcome with 12 step programs. I am happy to see the LDS Church has finally embraced these 12 step programs like Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Anonymous. As a fellow addict, I'm happy to see this couple in recovery.
dyc | 1:04 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
As I read the comments I notice everyone seems to be busy saying who is or is not to blame. We don't have enough facts to know that, and I don't think that is the point of the article. After reading this article, what I hope happens is that all people who read it will learn from the story. Parents need to help their minor and young adult children understand what they need to do to protect their bodies if they are playing sports. The student athlete needs to understand that no sport is worth destroying your body, and the coaches need to do everything in their power to protect the athletes for whom they have stewardship. Most important is that Bryant and Mindy need to be commended for turning their lives back around and being brave enough to share their story with the rest of us. I doubt that I would be brave enough to do that.
Can't blame football | 1:25 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I know many addicted to pain killers who don't know a thing about football. This problem extends to all levels, all religions, races, sexes, and situations. Some are more succeptible to chemical addictions. I've had to take pain killers many times for different reasons and have never been tempted. But I'm far from perfect in other areas of my life.

Good luck to the young couple.
Been there... | 1:35 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
Good luck to Bryant and Mindy, I wish them the best. The pressure to perform doesn't stop after football, it is part of life, so there could always be someone else to blame. Bravo to Bryant for taking responsibility for his addiction. It is the first step in recovery. I can understand Scott Atkinson's feelings...looking for a reason and something to blame. But I wonder if he has taken into consideration how many parents may be blaming Bryant and Mindy for their child's addiction problem. It happens to the best of people. Parents and kids have to meet the problem head on and not pretend it isn't there or that it is someone else's fault.
Dr.'s share blame | 2:00 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
When are we going to start holding physicians accountable in our society. Too many physicians don't take the time to ask the right question and follow up with their patients. I know that some physicians suspect abuse but they are too worried about losing a patient and so they continue to prescribe. If our society wants to work on this problem we need to attack both the supply and the demand. The supply of these pain killers is way to easy to obtain!
Matt | 2:35 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
To Dr.'s share blame,
As a medical student we have discussed ad naseum about how to determine whether or not a patient is drug-seeking. Dr.'s aren't worried about losing patinets, they have plenty to go around, but they are worried about giving someone something they don't need. If you read the entire article you will notice that he started getting pills from other sources, like his wife and on the internet. Granted, there are some doctors who are bad, but don't blame the entire profession for a person who lied to get drugs and found illegal ways to maintain his addiction
johnny cobert | 2:40 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
After reading the submitted comments I want to say one thing more. Listen to "fellow drug addict" who is in revovery. Doesn't matter if it is a legal or illegal drug, the brain responds the same way. If you have never dealt with addiction ( yourself or a significant other in your life) then you have no idea of the monster it is. It does no good to point fingers. You have to get off your backside. admit that you have lost control of your life and say "I need help" and mean it. Unfortunatly, the disease of addiction can never be healed. Once established, it has to be dealt with the rest of your life. Only those in recovery know what I mean when I speak of "triggers" and how they show their face when least expected and how you have to be prepared to deal with them. The best program on earth to help deal with these "triggers" is a 12-step group and program. So, don't use your energy placing the blame, get your loving family member into a treatment program. And with it, tough love is essential. These programs work.
Narcotics are difficult | 3:55 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
As a medical doctor, I along with all of my colleagues prescribe medications including narcotics.
No doctor in Utah should lack for patients to the point of prescribing medications for pain without concern and without careful consideration. We are all busier than we want to be without trying to drum up business in that way.

I do have patients who require long term pain medications for many types of illnesses: rheumatoid diseases, cancer and other painful chrnoic illnesses, auto injuries and sports injuries to name a few. A patient on scheduled chronic pain medication must sign a contract to get his pain medications only from one doctor and one pharmacy. The prescription must be followed correctly and filled at the appropriate time. If it is done fraudulently or early, the patient may then be dismissed from the practice.

We are very careful about this.

Many patients are dishonest and deceptive about there narcotic use and will doctor "shop", claim fake injuries, use different aliases, pick up precriptions in someone elses name.

Once addicted, using the medication as a high instead of for pain, Oxycontin and heroin are injected, percocet, lortab illegally obtained from the street.

Be careful with narcotics!
JEB | 5:34 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I am proud of Mindy and Bryant for having the courage to tell their story. I hope that it can help others who may be at risk for developing a similar addiction to pain medications.
Football Family | 5:45 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
BYU coaches would never push an individual to this end. The boy admits he did not tell the coaches of the pain.

I am quite confident there are a hundred individuals in this valley that have become addicted to these pain killers for every one football player.

Mike | 5:54 p.m. Oct. 27, 2007
I think there are a lot of things in the world that people can become addicted to. That doesn't make them evil, or wrong. However, when those things take away our ability to act for ourselves or to be free, they cross the line. I agree that MUCH more education regarding prescription medication needs to take place. Hopefully, this article will get the right conversations happening.

Add your comment

Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.

Words Remaining

E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.

Image
Jeffrey D. Allred, Deseret Morning News

Bryant and Mindy Atkinson play Foosball at the home of Bryant's parents in Provo. They now look at their arrest last March on drug charges to have been a blessing.

Related content
previousnext

Latest comments

Riverton's defense downs PG

Great job girls keep up the hard work and you will have the same result with...

Incentives to create new jobs

Need to help all the poor rich people. Heaven forbid we have anaffordable...

LDS to emphasize helping needy

Better start believing!!! Those homeless are constantly being helped by the...

Jazz manage a magical win

The minute we take what rhetoric Chuck spills out of is mouth is the day we...

BYU football: NCAA awards

Thanks to Coach Edwards for bringing football to life in this state. Without...

No, the occurrence in Times Square is not because they are guns on the...

We tend to adjust our attitudes in light of what we see and hear going on...

Good for her!!!

Tiger just another game player

I can't really understand why these young gifted people are so self...

Isn't this a socialistic agenda? I figured most of you would be against this...

Advertisements