Reader comments
Prominent Dallas minister says Romney no Christian
221 comments | Read story
Come on, you've got to be kidding me. Comparing Warren Jeffs group to the LDS Church. Yes I guess there are some similarities...both have large memberships in Utah and both include the letters "LDS". I'm sure you meant to say Jonestown and the RFLDS Church have the "same controlling techiques" but even that would be a stretch. Yes, hometeaching and tithing are certainly precursors to Jonestown like behavior. We'd better alert the folks in Jackson County Missouri for this upcoming Jonestown like tragedy. Get your head out of those so called social scientists journals and start living in the real world.
is "revelant" [I believe you meant relevant, but maybe what you meant was a thinly veiled attempt at baiting] to this discussion?
Sorry for the misspell. I guess it seems like baiting if you think the answer would somehow be negative. My point is: If a man told you to do something that you vilify other LDS sects for doing, would you do it? I think that would really be a piece of information that could be used to evaluate whether the LDS church is a cult. I don't believe its a cult by the way. I believe though that the church attempts to exert an extraordinary amount of control over its members. I married a woman whose family was LDS and i speak of personal experience being harassed by visiting teachers/home teachers etc. I had one home teacher who I told was he was impacting my marriage tell me it was his duty to contact my wife. I also had an LDS friend and my LDS sister-in-law tell me they were asked this question in about 1995 as a home teaching topic. My SIL's response was she didn't have a strong enough testimony. I don't like the LDS church. I like the LDS people just fine.
Keep going, you have our vote!
Yes, your elder Holland officially mocked the beliefs of a number of Christian churches by attacking their beliefs in the Trinitarian doctrine. Clearly, he does not understand the doctrine, so he attacks it and condemns it, and makes the entire audience laugh at the beliefs of another faith. So this is the double standard we can expect from Mitt? When your leaders do it, it is OK; but when an Evangelical leader does it, it is bigotry??
I'm a catholic married to a non practising LDS woman. I've attended countless LDS services while living in Utah to support my in-laws. I was harassed repeatedly when first married. I actually contacted the local ward and told them to stop calling. I was told to have my wife have her name removed from the rolls of the church. We've never had a priest or a nun come to our door uninvited or otherwise. I would love to be your neighbor. I loved living in Utah. You know what's funny? All the time I lived in Utah the church never contacted me or my family in an official capacity. Only when living outside Utah. So I do apologize to all who are offended I don't believe or like the LDS church. I love the LDS people I know on a personal level.
First that will NEVER happen. Even nations of the earth where polgamy is allowed, a person cannot become a member of the Church if they particpate in polygamy. If a member of the church enters into polygamy they will be excumicated from the Church. We believe that Jesus Christ Himself directs the Church through His chosen servents, as He did when He was on the earth. he directed His Church through apostles and prophets that HE Called, we believe He does the same today. Wilford woodruff was instructed by Him that polygamy would never be authorized again. But even it was we are free to make our own desions about what we do. We do not follow blindly, I for one must be converted to a principle before I will accept it. Each individual is encouraged to search for the truth for ourselves and to accept it where ever it is found. good question!! I hope I have cleard it up.
Some people hate us because we do not subscribe to the false doctrine of the Trinity, which does not appear in the Bible. It is the direct result of an attempt to compromise with Greek philosophy, resulting in a concept of God that is indistinguishable from the idolatrous goddess Ashtoreth. Jesus subordinated his will to his Father's will. He prayed to his Father on several occasions, and God acknowledged Jesus as his son at Jesus' baptism. Stephen the martyr saw Jesus standing at the right hand of God.
Others hate us because we're bad for business. Jesus was hated because he didn't accept the restrictions of the Talmud and he was bad for business.
The last big reason that people hate us is that they don't want to be reminded that they can't do whatever they want and still go to heaven if they've given the proper lip service, "accepting" Jesus as their savior and continuing to do their favorite sins. Apparently we are not allowed to teach that we need to abandon our sins.
i'm inactive lds married to born again and her problem with mitt is he is mormon! she says otherwise but that is balony!
thanks for the answer. But let me clarify, if your prophet told God told him it was time to practise this proncipli again it would not be a valid revelation? I mean God told Josph Smith to practise it then told Wilford Woodruff not to. Can't he/she reverse themselves again? I thought, and I don't know this, that Woodruff's proclomation just said it wasn't to be practised "at this time"? That leaves it open to be practised again doesn't it? And just so no one thinks I'm being disingenuous (sp) I would think that practising polygamy by a modern LDS person just because the prophet says its okay would be a huge negative reflect, FOR ME, on the church.
Regarding Rev. Jefferies unschooled comments:
1. It's hard to hit a bullseye with a crooked arrow.
2. The Mission Statement for the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints is "To invite all to come unto Christ." Da?
3. The name of the church in which Mitt Rommney belongs is the "Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints" ... there is no Mormon Church, there never has been. If Rev. Jefferies church is Christ's church why doesn't he name it after Christ rather than calling it the Baptist Church?????
4. Father forgive Rev. Jefferies for him knows not what he says is false and full of hate not christain love. God is love not hate ... wow, what pastor Rev. Jefferies is turn out to be. May God bless him to see the light in to those who are not Baptists.
Catholic's aren't either.
They get to difine who is Cristian.
Isn't this sorta weird???
The Savior chose 70 men to go out and preach then come back and report. That is how you discover if things are going right or if they are going wrong.
Personal Preisthood Interviews (to you reporting) on home teachng when done properly is faith building and helps all involved. Don't blather about what you do no understand.
You who say a mormon will never be elected need to do your research.
A mormon is more likely than a minority or woman to be elected (according to research).
This press isn't bad though. Ever since the Church cut advertising we can take all the awareness generating press we can take.
For example, some Mormons still consider the Roman Catholic Church the great and abominable church. Until fairly recently Mormons were explicitly taught that protestant ministers/priests were on Satan's payroll, and that teaching has never been rescinded. Mormons are the most aggressive religion with regard to proselytizing, soliciting people on the street, and knocking on people's doors mostly without invitation and informing them that "Mormons have the only "true" church". If you do not consider that invasive and obnoxious consider if the Catholics were doing the same to your household. Let us not forget that non-Mormons are addressed as "Gentiles", hardly a compliment in that context.
In conclusion, there is long standing suspicion and mutual mistrust between Mormons and some other Christian churches. Mitt Romney's candidacy only brings it to the surface.
Jonestown? Jim Jones was a sick, mass murder.
I have known many "Born - agains". Have been to services, funerals and weddings.
Talk about a cult. They are all over each other, loving them in, invading their every act.
How many of their ministers are "telling" them how to vote, something the LDS has never done while around me?
Go back to your true "Christianity". I love my Lord, and "My" brother Jesus just the way they are.
Hey, answer this though... If I go to a church named after Christ, have many statues and pictures of him in the house, read scriptures of him every night, Sundays I take the sacrement to remember him, and have his spirit allways be with me, end all of my parayers in his name, lead a life that invites his spirit into my life...
Why again is it that you can self righteously tell me I am not cristian, and keep my four year old daughter out of a christian pre-K program, and yet you accept children of atheist parents? How can you say I'm not christian and after doing that to my daughter and me, then call yourself a christian?
I'm confident Rev. Jeffress didn't mean any harm, either. He was not "mocking" any Mormons. He simply repeated certain teachings and creeds on Christianity and used Mormons own doctrines and interpretations to explain why his church has a different understanding than the Mormons do. Just because Mormons get offended, does not mean he is a bad person. -- Baloney! Elder Hollands talk was an explicit attack against the Trinitarian faith and tradition, one that has been around almost 10 times longer than the Mormon faith. You Mormons have such a double standard it is astonishing. You can dish it out, but you can't take it. Holland's sermon was absolutely NOT given as "an attempt to defend our faith a clarify our doctrines." How could it be? Nobody has ever accused Mormons of being Trinitarians!
On Elder Holland's talk, he taught something that's in the bible, but didn't say that X church is evil because they don't believe the same we that we do. He taught doctrine, and leaves it up to others to research and see if what he taught matches up with what they're being taught by others.
You also don't see in our sacrament meetings a preacher getting up and telling you who to vote for or not vote for in an election. Of course, there may be some crazy old lady that says something about how she supports a certain candidate, but a random member getting up and saying something is different from one of the church leaders doing the same.
Something else to consider is that is many of the Christian churches, ministers are paid, and need to perform by getting people out to church and getting them excited in order to keep their jobs. Mixing politics in with preaching is a sure way to do that.
Because your definition of Christian is distorted in a self-serving way, just as all the doctrines and history of the Mormon Church are. What it means to be a Christian comes from the Christian Tradition, not from a silly dictionary, nor from an individual judgement you make about others. Being Christian does not mean a person is "nice" - it means they are part of the communion with the Father, Son and Spirit. That is not possible when you Mormons do not believe in that essential Trinitarian communion. Hence, you are by your own doctrines, NOT Christian. Sure, there are some "nice" Mormons (you don't seem like one of them), but that is not the point. The Rev. Jeffress was not "being mean" when he said what he said. He was simply stating an axiomatic fact that necessarily follows from the Christian tradition. It is the Mormons who are playing word games and being deceptive in order to try and be legitimate instead of a "cult" (yes, in the Jonestown sense).
He is being hateful and needs to step off his high horse.
Simple. Like This: Mormons are not Christians. Their theology is an entirely different theology than what the Christian Theology has been for 2,000 years, and it is entirely different than the Theology contained in the Bible. Therefore, the Mormons' Jesus is not the same Jesus that Paul preached, nor even the same Jesus that Jesus WAS (historically). Not the same Jesus = Not the same Christ = NOT Christian.
I have been a member of the LDS Church for only about 5 years. Prior to that I was of another faith (Trinitarian in doctrine). I must confess to being bothered by Holland's talk. It sure seemed like an offensive attack on the faith of others, many of whom I still associate with and love. Those who heard it (because I am LDS) were offended. But I also notice that in almost every Sunday School class or Priesthood meeting each week, someone makes an attacking comment about another faith. It is as if we can't believe our Church is true without attacking other Churches and beliefs. I haven't seen how all wards work, but it sure seems like that attitude is Churchwide, not just here and there.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Sp. Fork man arrested in thefts 4:17 p.m.
- Nurse charged with abuse of teens 4:15 p.m.
- Downtown plans three-day ""Eve"" 3:44 p.m.
- Small-business conditions improve 3:41 p.m.
- Pair arrested in Provo burglary 3:36 p.m.
- Summit Co. appoints first manager 3:24 p.m.
- Man sentenced to 7 years in death 3:21 p.m.
- Senate Dems at odds over insurance 3:20 p.m.
- U.S.: $3B to end tribe royalty dispute 3:09 p.m.
- Police seek missing WVC woman 3:06 p.m.
- BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
- Yet again, we learn BCS is a big joke
- Witness: Mitchell stalked victims
- Williams' late jumper tops Spurs
- Storm pounds Utah for 2nd day
- Cougars in better mood about bowl
- Ranking the bowl games
- $2M error could mean layoffs
- Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
- BCS reform still needed
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
274 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
203 - Letters: Global warming a lie
199 - Cougars going back to Vegas
147 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
144 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
141 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
119 - Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
101 - Harpring's NBA career is over
98 - Revive full food tax?
86
For the latest news in the health care debate and how it affects you...
Amazon.com, Target.com, Sears.com, Walmart.com, Kmart.com and...
Both teams will be motivated. these are 2 highly ranked teams trying to show...
Justice was long in coming.
Spend our way out of a financial crisis? Hey that's terrific financial...
"Where I come from, a wise person does not necessarily have any formal...
Several of you have mentioned Glenn Beck. Glenn is a great role model, if...
He has a home in Park City. He comes to Utah fairly often. But the...
I just shoveled 6" of global warming off the driveway this morning.
can't wait for a repeat title in 2010. Go Frogs!!!!
Iowa is a good team, but their conference is weak, weak, weak this year. You...
To hiker's friend: I had the pleasure of being around SAR at a nearby area...


