Reader comments
Salt Lake powering a switch from coal to solar
27 comments | Read story
1) Coal is a constant requirement for coal burning power plants. 7 cents per KWH will go up with the cost of transport.
2) Solar panels do die, and require replacement, but the wiring should be good for decades. 10 - 13 cents per KWH should go down with the increase in manufacturing efficiency. The efficiency of the solar cells should increase as we learn to improve the technology and the solar power process.
3) Solar Power does not require long, ugly*, high voltage transmission lines. Each house or building can have its own power system. Crowded urban areas will give way to spread out areas each with its own solar power �farm� area.**
* As with beauty, ugly is in the eye of the beholder.
** Currently Sci-Fi, but it is the sensible way to go.
Solar is great source of power, except at night and on cloudy days. So it can not completely replace fossil fuels.
I think that more research needs to be put into bio-fuels. Yes they do contribute to pollution, but matter can not be created or destoyed, so they will not put anything into our atmospere that the plants do not first remove.
"The state has more than 300 days of sun a year. , said Sarah Wright, director of Utah Clean Energy"
Yes the State does have 300 days of sun a year it's called Saint George.
Most of Utah is not suited well for wind or Solar with the exception of a few counties like Washington for Solar. Modern US Nuclear is safe. I am all for renewable energies but lets be smart about it. Solar pannels in inversion bowl SLC will do much better in Washington county.
Ref:
http://www.worldfactsandfigures.com/weatherfacts/numbersunny_city_desc.php
http://www.wrcc.dri.edu/htmlfiles/westcomp.clr.html
Ideas like this are just the beginning. http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2007-08/uoia-sne082007.php
RocDoc is right, Solar is the most expensive way to generate electricity. Just because the government dictates it will not make it effecitent, cost effective and non-toxic. (Solar cells also contain arsenic.) The government screws up most everything it gets involved in. Let the marketplace dictate what fuels we are going to use. No some government worker on some kind of religious quest. As soon as Solar cells make economic sense, they will naturally start showing up where they are needed.
If you happen to believe in Solar Cells you have the right this very moment to buy the cells, batteries, wiring and hire a contractor to install them. Just don't ask me to pay for it.
In other words, if you believe that Solar is the end all to end all, put your money where your mouth is and install it now. Unfortunately that will never happen because the global warming crowd is unwilling to spend their own assets, they demand the money to fund their to come from someone else.
NEW CUE LAR power is the MOST EXPENSIVE power humans almost know how to make. The recently passed energy bill included 50 billion dollars for INSURANCE for nuke power plants because no "free market" insurance company will risk it. D"oh! And then there's that pesky waste material that will just never "go away".. get a clue.
Solar and wind and tidal power will be the big winners in the next few decades. Why? Because young people don't want to see their world destroyed by dirty, expensive, and dangerous fossil fuels or the even more deadly nukes. Your comments show that you have not studied the issues from all sides, but only from your personal bias. surprise!
Wonder where Rocky is on this? Oh, of course, he wants to preserve his precious RM Power frannchise tax the city collects.
Solar-is-fine, Rocky is in the same boat as the author of this article w/ the "snappy" first sentence in relation to coal jobs. It's been said that he's been know to invite homeless to sleep in his house...will he do that for currrent unemployed miners or are they only good for exploitation? As for bio-fuels, w/ what little is being used now the prices of things like milk is already taking a huge jump.
As referenced, What will be the impact of discarded solar-panels/batteries on the environment including water? Not good I'd say. The BIG push for the fluorescent light-bulbs (CFLs) over incandescent-bulbs is already seeing environmental problems (yes, small problems FOR NOW) b/c of the mercury in them. And their risk in homes...just ask the Bridges (See here: http://www.canada.com/nationalpost/financialpost/story.html?id=aa7796aa-e4a5-4c06-be84-b62dee548fda).
With the wind-power there is ecological damage to birds...I wonder if most homes would get solar panels how that would affect birds migration with the reflection lighting? ;)
As for Nuke-power: Examples...Ask the residents of Three-Mile-Island and Chernobyl and those 2 incidents happened BEFORE the current terrorism threat level AND that's also not taking into account the nuke-waste problem. See here: http://www.lutins.org/nukes.html
As for Three Mile Island, the safety systems worked!! No one was hurt, and no hazardous radiation escaped. Chernobyl doesn't compare with today's reactors. Believe it or not, there is a greater risk to life if one of the Nation's Hydroelectric dams should break than with a worst case nuclear accident. Should the Three Gorges Dam in China fail it would kill Millions!! Chernobyl only killed thousands. Nuclear or Coal power is not evil. It can be controlled and cleaned up. Use Solar as a suppliment. For most homeowners, (unless your are rich) Photovoltaics on the roof is extreamly expensive. The payback is in decades not a few years.
Engineers say a perfect solution rarely exists, it's all about trade-offs. Studying a diversity of approaches spreads our risk and multiplies our benefit. We should push every viable technology to it's limit. With continued development and reasonable safeguards we might experience a couple of "breakthroughs." Who knows where they will occur?
If wind, solar, tide, nuclear, coal or any other technology were perfect would we object? Heck no! So keep working. Maybe one day, one or more of them will be. In the meantime, don't ask me to predict which one it will be. And don't limit my opportunities by declaring any of them are not viable until the jury is through deliberating.
What about energy use reduction, though? How many of you folks went straight from winter heating to summer air conditioning (like my parents did)? How many take advantage of SLC's cool nights by opening windows and turning on a couple of fans? By cooling at night, and sealing by day, you can keep most houses pretty pleasant; it just takes a little more thought and execution than setting the thermostat. If you want the house to be 70 degrees year-round, it takes a lot of energy. If 65 to 75 is ok (we do 60 to 80: cozy wool sweaters in winter, and near-naked in summer), you go a long time in the spring and fall without having to use heating or cooling. It's great!
As a population, we've gotten pretty lazy and disconnected from our environment. It'd be good for most folks to get a little too hot in the summer, and a little too cold in the winter!
This is just another energy trend. What will happen 20 years down the road is the same enviromentalists pushing solar will find some danger in it's use and be screaming to find the next "trendy" energy project. Enviromentalism is an economy to itself and makes its money by scaring the citizenry.
Several Items to ponder. While I tried to read all the posts above, I do not recall reading one that suggested that we just use less energy. We leave computers, lights, HVAC systems on. We should look to use less
Be smart about your posts..most of the posts above are what I call zealotry...ademant about one side of the position. We need science and research to evaluate the needs of alternatives to non-renewable energy sources. I want someone to discover a way to turn corn into a robust, economical and emissionless way to run my car or power my home.
Innovation of this magnitude gave us many of the great conveniences that are in our homes today. I see people above complaining that solar panels have heavy metals in them, but they posted the comments via a computer that contains those same elements, but I don't here their rally cry for Intel to shut down.
EACH
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- I-84 crash closes lanes in Canyon 12:01 p.m.
- Prosecutors have Cardall report 11:58 a.m.
- Stocks jump to new highs 11:56 a.m.
- Gulf Coast preps as Ida weakens 11:50 a.m.
- Imam praises Ft. Hood shooter 11:47 a.m.
- High court won't stop execution 11:46 a.m.
- USU Press merges with library 11:20 a.m.
- GOP blasts Matheson after vote 11:19 a.m.
- Utah Jazz: Miles has cast removed 11:18 a.m.
- Ten Steps to a 30-minute garden 10:56 a.m.
- TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
- TCU showdown has big implications
- Seniors helped BYU regroup
- Hope for single moms
- Lambert surprisingly tops news
- Korver and Miles to be evaluated
- Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
- TCU moves into 4th place in BCS
- Teenager is critical after stabbing
- Water wars in Snake Valley
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
235 - House passes health care bill
211 - Lobo suspended
176 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
153 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
130 - TCU showdown has big implications
125 - Thousands protest health bill
104 - Provo company innovating engines
104 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
91
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
NASA's Stardust probe continues to bring new knowledge about the nature...
If the truth were know, Pelosi made a deal with Matheson on the Health bill....
As Joe Liberman and other senators have said this retarded Pelosi / Obama...
Uh, did you go to that game? Utah's defense played brilliantly, with the...
It's about time the LDS Church reinstitutes Plural Marriage. Too many good...
What would Ronnie have done. He was unlike anything else before or since his...
I am a Republican and I am proud of Jim Matheson. Jim did the right thing....
Woo-hoo!!!! Our big win over perennial power UNM helped keep us high in the...
The constant references in the media to homosexuals who have committed...
Well, we can listed to Glenn Beck about as easily as you can listen to Keith...
I thought this movie was pretty good. Jeff Vice is a fabulous reviewer.


