Reader comments
John Florez: Education system needs proper repair
11 comments | Read story
We don't need more people telling the time (i.e., that education needs broad reform not just little nips and tucks here and there). We need people of influence to actually offer up real lasting solutions, which right now may not be broadly popular.
Anyone with a pen can be a critic. Sticking your neck out and putting before the public real solutions takes courage that Mr. Florez seems unwilling to exert.
Creating community districts, who compete against each other, is the only "real" competition on an even playing field possible. Vouchers won't do that.
Will dividing into community districts immediately solve everything? No, but it is the only way to begin to solve the problems. That is why it is the MOST important single thing we can do to improve education. The problems are solvable, but only at the community level.
Mr. Florez, you can point fingers and name-call until the sun goes down, but what public education needs is, first, a plan to address the needs of a wide range of child demographics and disabilities and second, a substatial amount of new on-going money to provide the skills and people to make it work.
Behind all of this are two kinds of parents: those who can't or don't care to discipline their child's education, and those who are frustrated that THEIR children must attend a system that is forced to play parent to so many neglected students.
It's a societal problem, John. Put your pen in your pocket and do something constructive to help the state fix it.
That State Board of Education approved new math standards last week. It was a dismal failure that will only muddy the math problem in the state.
If every parent were to get their child tested right now for what math level they are performing on compared to children in the other industrialized nations there would be a revolution in this state. The new math standards was a step forward, but not near what the legislature asked for.
Taken a step further; The problem with Florez's platitudes is they fail to recognize reality. The precise problem is that there is NO consensus on what education should be or look like. You might as well look for consensus on what religion should provide. There is a very good reason we have so many different churches. Education is such an integral part in raising and rearing children to maturity there will never be consensus on what it should offer, when, or how. What one parent considers essential, another will consider immoral, destructive, or even false.
Take hot button issues like how and when (or even whether) sex ed should be handled or how evolution should be treated and it is clear that one could study and debate 'till the children were drawing their pensions and there would be no agreement. Even on issues not normally considered religious or moral there is no agreement.
Traditional or "discovery" math ala the Alpine school district. Should history present the U.S. as benevolent savior of the world during WWII and the cold war or as an imperialistic monster? Was FDR a man of great character and courage or someone who lied to the american people about his health and his willingness to let the soviets take over eastern europe? Should civics present an original intent view of constitutional law or a "living document" shaped by judicial opinion? Are the fine arts an essential component to education, or just a nice extra curricular? Should women and racial minorities be given equal space in the pages of history as the white males who made decisions?
Fundamentally, should education take an industrial approach of training workers or should it take a renaissance approach of imparting knowledge, morals, and wisdom for the sake of creating a better person?
There is no right or wrong answer to these questions. Only many varied personal opinions about how to raise children.
Competition is needed in education not only to provide impetus for improvements but also to cater to these varied opinions while avoiding needless conflicts. I get along fine with my neighbors despite many personal, religious, and other differences in how we live our lives because our choices don't affect each other too much. So long as we all keep up our yards and keep the noise down after dark we get along fine. I pray to my god and drive my choice of cars, buy my kids the clothes of which I approve and engage in the weekend recreation we enjoy while my neighbors make very different choices.
But force us to send our children to the same school for 8 hours a day simply because we live near each other and there will be conflicts just as if you said we all had to attend the same church or our choices of recreation and transportation would be made by popular vote rather than individual choice.
David Cox is right that smaller districts will help in this regard. He is wrong in suggesting that vouchers won't.
EVERY child deserves a good education. The State constitution requires the taxpayers to FUND that education. It does NOT require the State to run a single, monopoly school for every child or even 95% of all children. We have a wonderful higher ed system with vouchers (pell grants, GI bill money, student loans) available to the student regardless of which school he attends, government or private, secular or religious. The same system would do wonders at our primary and secondary schools.
Let parents decide what kind of education their children should receive WITHOUT being subject to political or majority vote of geographic neighbors. Every minute spent fighting over what a one-size-fits-all government school should or should not teach is a minute NOT spent actually teaching a child. Let the money follow the child and empower parents to decide for themselves (but not for others) what constitutes a proper education.
The fact is smaller districts help close the gap for minorities and lower socio-economic kids. See www.smallerschools.org. The rich, white kids are not hurt near as much by the big districts as the rest are.
QOTU, it is interesting that such a large number of parents are doing just what you suggest. They getting involved with teachers by creating charter schools where teachers and parents working together.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Canal company backs merger plan 1:07 a.m.
- Girl dies, others hurt in I-15 crash 1:04 a.m.
- Agency, firm agree on settlement 12:56 a.m.
- Creche convention opens in SLC 12:39 a.m.
- The number: The remarrying kind 12:16 a.m.
- German accused of extorting Crawford 12:13 a.m.
- Thousands pay tribute to Emperor 12:11 a.m.
- LDS Film Festival deadline extended 12:11 a.m.
- LDS Church receives award in Ky. 12:11 a.m.
- An interesting neighbor in Okla. 12:11 a.m.
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
311 - TCU showdown has big implications
195 - Senators want food tax restored
158 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
144 - Will state consider gay rights law?
137 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
119 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
119 - Utes remain silent about BCS
113 - S.L. vote pending on gay protections
110 - Celtics crush Jazz
103
Maybe someone out there can help me understand how raising the state...
TRASH TALKING IS CHEAP....LEAVE IT ON TH FIELD! CONGRATS TO BOTH...
I completely agree. I am a Utah State fan and we expect to win against Weber...
WILL ABOUT THESE COACHES, BUT GIVE THEM CREDIT....THEY DO IT RIGHT EVERY...
I just want to say thanks to everyone who has given support to my son and his...
Nice, Bronco made a funny! I don't even think he meant too: "Rocky...
first step by putting up the money. Now take the second step and get your...
This one scares me...but coach witt always seems to come out with a win....
Jordan Wynn, before its all said and done, will go down as one of the best...
If your thinking this is an exibition game your dead wrong. I mean, I guess...
that Sloan/KOC put in place and insisted on keeping in place. That is Sloan's...

