Reader comments: FLDS grand jury indicts three people on felonies
53 comments | Read story
It is hard to read into this, but I was thinking that the strongest cases will be presented first. So, today could either be a continuation of strong cases or it could be the weaker cases. It seems that the number 10 has been floating around as the number of statutory rape or underage marriage cases, so today could be as heavy as the last grand jury day.
I would expect the next grand jury proceeding to be focused on local cases and not so much on the FLDS.
The case of Warren Jeffs is confusing to me. There is evidence that he married more than one underage girl. So, is he going to be indicted over a period of time for each criminal charge or is he just going to be indicted for the case with the most evidence? I would have thought that all indictments against him would come down at the same time.
There's no doubt abuse occurred. And if you think training your daughter to marry an old man isn't abuse, then you are extremely naive (and have a very warped sense of right and wrong...)
You are correct that there is evidence that Warren married 4 underaged girls between 2004 and 2006. However, only one of those underaged girls had a child. This is what Jeffs is being charged for. There is no proof that the other marriages were consummated, hence no charges at this time.
Simply fondling a child can be grounds for a conviction for felonious sexual abuse.
The women have no power and if they oppose their husband they could be severly beaten and, even worse, their eternal salvation can be taken away. They are just told just to "keep sweet" and do whatever they are told. this is a sick system that has become more and more perverse over the years.
The role Elissa Wall's mother played in the crimes that were committed against her is disgraceful. But, this poor women is also a victim. It's just a vicious evil thing that has been visited upon these people to the "third and fourth generation."
Something drastic needs to be done and it needs to include the women. But, we must remember, these women need help, too.
appear in Reynolds vs The U.S.
The Supreme Court created a problem that has resurfaced over and over, throughout the years. And
it will continue to do so.
Should old farts be doing little girls? don't make me hurl. But we have two issues here that need to be
intelligently addressed.
The one is at the end of a rope. The other will require a reversal by the Supreme Court. It won't do
any good venting emotional baggage. It is a time for cool heads, logic, and some good old Constitutional application.
I am not FLDS, and never would be, and disagree completely with their position. I do not believe all FLDS men marry underage girls, but cannot even begin to fathom men 30 to 40 years older than their 'brides' not being seen as abusers. That the women are indoctrinated to believe this is natural, normal or even a privilege is obvious. I have no idea what can change their mindset when they have lived through it themselves and witnessed it all of their lives.
I also believe that some of the actions of the authorities in Texas were not well thought out, and actually inflicted damage on the innocents, the children, and some of their mothers who seemed to be loving and caring toward their children. Separating mothers from nursing children was cruel and inhumane, for example. Taking the men out of the compound and letting the mothers/children live there under supervision I think would have been better.
When this is all over, assuming the evidence that was stolen and/or planted without a warrant even counts, Texas will have what, 2 or 3 convictions, costing 150 million or so? And that total doesn't count any Federal civil rights law suits judgments awarded to the innocent individuals and families from YFZ, that Texas wrongfully imprisoned, kidnapped, and abused.
Here's a tip for Texas: use a little logic in your thinking: Don't break the law to enforce the law. Weigh the pros and cons of your actions. Use Common Sense.
so perhaps the constitution doesn't cover pimping out a 12 yr old girl with the parents blessing.
but that doesn't make it any less sick.
I really don't think telling the truth was one of his options, and he probably didn't even considered it.
Go Texas Go!
BANKING ON HEAVEN
What a Documentary!
The part about the defected children being put away was so emotional.
No actor could fake that.
They really think their blogs are clever--they're finding all kinds of loopholes and dazzling everyone with their fabulous, brilliant logic. They think if they keep attacking it will somehow invalidate the truth--that somehow truth will fail and lies will become truth. No matter how much they scream, what they are doing is wrong and, worlds without end, it will never be right.
The mothers involved should be indicted, but we have to remember that they are victims, too. They have no rights and no power. They are just required to "keep sweet" and do whatever they are told. If they don't, they risk abuse and even loss of their eternal salvation. That's a pretty heavy threat. Elissa Wall's mother is a perfect example of a mother whose behavior was a complete disgrace.
Former FLDS now understand how they were brainwashed. They didn't until they escaped. It's going to take drastic action to help those still imprisoned in this tragic situation.
it's amazing what and who people will follow if convinced at a young age....
Patriarchal system or not - you cannot have sex with children!
You are right, we all need to wait and see how this legal situation unfolds. What will happen to each of these indicted individuals remains to be seen. But, there are many victims and there will continue to be until some decisive action is taken to protect them.
Unless you know the FLDS yourself? DO NOT judge the rest of us! Some of us know these deviates. Anyone who has sympathy for the devil deserves the same treatment.
Sexual abuse is sexual abuse.
Now, the local officials are proceeding slowly and cautiously, but they are identifying specific abusers and their victims. The process would have progressed more but for most of the FLDS men having avoided DNA testing. But, as happened with Keate, more of them will be forced to comply, resulting in additional indictments.
BTW, did anyone else notice how much alike the YFZ Ranch 'wives' in those photos look? These people are really tempting fate with all that inbreeding.
In short, the FLDS faith is largely misunderstood. The FLDS are full of good people and serve their neighbors better than most in the world today. They are doing the very best they can with what they have been given. I felt of this man's heartache as he opened up and told me about his trip to Texas and dealings with CPS there.
I thought about how many hundreds of Mormon's (which I am one), Christians, Catholics & others passed by on the freeway as I needed aid on the roadside. I will forever be grateful for the many wonderful teachings of the FLDS Church.
She was a theoretical member of the largest religious body in the United States, but as far as I know did not attend church regularly.
Then there is the North American Man Boy Love Association.
Having sexual relations with children is not the universal monopoly of small and hated religious groups. It is quite common in our society, with 13 year old girls on average having older sexual partners than 15 year old girls.
Considering how many girls in the United States get pregnant while in high school I have to wonder if some of the commentators here are from another country. Also, do not throw me a sop of "consensual" malarchy. A very large number of pregnant high schoolers had sex with men who were legally too old. Beyond this, the fact that the laws on sexual relations with minors very between states means that your rhetoric condemns as the ultimate evil an act that in some cases only a few miles away is legal.
There seems to be evidence that some of these "under-age" woman proactively wanted to marry these men, particularly in the case of Jeffs.
It is still an illegal act. However to use the term "rape" is to misconstrue the whole case.
There are gradients and nuances involved that many do not accept. This is not about physical force. If may be about people not having the ability to make fully informed choices, but their is no Elisa Wall in Texas saying that she was protesting the marriage all along.
Jeffs seems to have had inapropriate relations with a 12-year-old, but there is no evidence that she was any less willing than hundreds of other 12-year-olds across the nation that have sex.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
- Man still in hospital after Wednesday… 2:13 a.m.
- No gunman found after 3-hour standoff… 2:13 a.m.
- Police engaged in standoff 2:12 a.m.
- '24' is getting good again 1:12 a.m.
- Today on TV 1:12 a.m.
- Obama calls for bold moves 1:11 a.m.
- Utes 2nd in final poll 1:09 a.m.
- Utah should feel like No. 1 1:09 a.m.
- Collie to enter draft 1:07 a.m.
- 80 mph speed limit 1:06 a.m.
-
BYU's '09 football opener is…
186
-
U. season greatest in our history
146
-
LDS silent on issues
146
-
Shurtleff considers BCS probe
135
-
Official 2009 BYU football schedule
111
-
Polygamous leaders arrested
85
-
FLDS mother requests jury for…
83
-
Tough Jazz win a streak starter?
76
-
Question for BCS: Why not us?
76
-
Utah last in per-pupil spending
75
Justin, did you just seriously ask if Utah would be undefeated in the Pac-10? Our…
"While Mendenhall acknowledged there must be improvement, he said there are no plans…
ACCOMPLISHED!!! How FL is #1 when losing to an non ranked team at home is just…
If Utah was the bridesmaide this year then BYU was the ugly stepsister that gets…
What a great season!! All though I am disappointed we didn't make #1 my hats off…
Your comments make me sick. I served two tours in Iraq with the 5th Marines. Iraq…
There was only one perfect team and that was Utah. Ole Miss beat FL and was a good…
I think I have gone through the whole grief cycle this week trying to understand…
If Collie is not on on the 2009 team Max Hall's leading receiver just might be the…


