Reader comments: Chaffetz wins big He turns Cannon into a lame duck
176 comments | Read story
He was outspent. He ran his campaign with volunteers. He was very definite on the issues and struck resonant chords with the voters.
He was not endorsed by many of the prominent Republicans as was his opponent, but perhaps that is part of the reason that he won. People are not very happy with how things have been going and some of the things that are leaders have done.
The people have voted against the big-wigs of the parties and chosen a candidate more conservative or at least different than the incumbent.
Many people are still Republicans but fed up with the deficit spending, the power grabs by the President and the Department of Education.
People want to run their own schools and they want our government to live within its budget. They want less government and restoration of personal liberties.
They want change. And that is what they voted for.
Not many voted, but isn't that because there was almost nothing to vote for? Most of the contests were settled in the convention with its superdelegates and replacement and discretionary delegates and ballot boxes without poll watchers in attendance. We can do better. We should.
You were not "released," Congressman. This isn't a church calling. You were kicked out because you didn't serve your constituents; you betrayed them, actually. In your preferred terms, you failed to "magnify your calling."
Make no mistake: Cannon's defeat had ZERO NADA ZILCH to do with "low turnout." Jason Chaffetz won by over 9,000 votes. 58,000 people voted in the 2006 primary; 44,000 people voted in this year's primary (the rest couldn't afford the gas). If 14,000 more people had gone to the polls, raising turnout to the 2006 turnout level, 82% of them would've had to vote for Cannon for him to have won. Not likely.
*** "Chaffetz supporters [gathered] just down University Avenue and I-15 at the Camelot Village Clubhouse behind the Springville Wal-Mart." ***
Salt of the earth. My kind of people. I'm guessing that Arianna Huffington and the Duchess of Windsor didn't show for the party? I hope they never do...
Obama might be able to give McCain a run for his money here, unless McCain chooses Romney, which I think is unlikely. If Obama does decently in Utah, he will win the rest of the country in a landslide.
Chris Cannon's experience is irrelevant to Utah and actually damaging to the GOP. Leaders like him, Hatch, Bennett, Bush and McCain have betrayed the Republican brand. They have replaced Reagan's Coca Cola Classic with New Coke without the honesty of admitting it.
They have scared off the Reagan Democrats who helped the GOP win for years. The promise of Reagan's Republican Party was that if you were honest, worked hard, and made good choices in life that you'd be able to feed your family and maybe have a little extra on the side for some fun. The promise of today's GOP is to hammer the working class, devalue their labor through mass immigration, and give the spoils to the rich.
We are better off without the "experience" of Cannon and his ilk.
Hard-core conservatism is a false economy. Compassionate conservatism is actually better for our economy, our liberty, and our soul.
Oh, and to the "Thanks Chris" writer... I'm glad to see you know so much about Jason Chaffetz who, by the way, was NOT fired from his last three jobs.
The bigger shame is that truly qualified candidates are not willing to undergo the mean, cruel, lame and often downright untruthful mudslinging that goes on in politics today (i.e., as with Mitt Romney) to win victory and use their valuable experience in leadership, their worthy personal record as an example and strong moral code to represent our interests. Chris won with big bucks -and what for? Just to win. Jason, you won because of a disgruntled public, not because you are qualified. Are you really so different?
We will know the truth if you really do step up and do the job - listen to the people, know what you are talking about, make a plan and mean it for the right reasons. Be a real public servant where you serve without grasping for fame.
I wouldn't be too proud, Mr. C. You could be ousted on the next round...we are already watching you.
May the success of this race have influence on others and help us oust more incumbents bent on doing the same thing in the same way while never solving the real problems. We need more 'out of the box' thinkers in congress- be they Republican OR Democrat. I hope what has been started here can be replicated elsewhere and just maybe the people will be represented again in congress.
Ah, yes - that old allegation. That would include the alleged firing from the Nu Skin job, which is why 2 Nu Skin executives, including Blake Roney himself, supported Chaffetz's campaign.
Electing a freshman republican in a democrat stronghold is like eliminating a republican vote altogether. We have lost a lot of ground tonight, Mr. ABC Guy. And for what? Jason Chaffetz? Good job Jennifer - NOT! We really needed that seniority for the next few years.
I think a warning shot across the bough would have been appropriate, but replacing a committee incumbant with a freshman lameduck under our current circumstances in the house, that is the true show of being "unsophisticated".
Did that ever occur to any of you voters? I bet not. Chris didn't sell us down the river...he just didn't take a strong enough stand. Okay, granted, he needed to improve, but the cost of this election goes beyond being simply unhappy with mediocrity.
Now we have Jason who has previously been pro-democrat, who has flip flopped across the isle...well, the dems ought to love you. This vote is a huge disappointment and a show of how backwards and unsophisticated Utahans can be.
Which Third World lives would be in need of saving - the ones from Mexico, average life expectancy 75.6 years (vs. USA's 78 years)?
In my lifetime - a brief span from the late 70s unto today - we've seen the rapid transformation in the fortunes of countries with 3 billion people: countries as small as Singapore and as large as China, with India, South Korea, Taiwan, and several nations of Eastern Europe in between. We improved these people's lives where they live, not by relocating them to the USA.
I found Mr. Chaffetz to be on target, with one exception: illegal immigration. He proposed new laws to address the problem.
New laws aren't needed; enforcement of existing laws is.
I hope Mr. Chaffetz is the constitutionalist he appears to be and does not get 'maneuevered' by the elite in DC. We don't elect leaders - we elect representatives. We are not a Democracy, we are a constitutionally-based, representative republic and there's a huge difference.
The 'people's will' is for a real border barrier. The triple-tiered fence between San Diego and Tijuana has been tremendously effective. Get the fence built rather than laws passed. The country will be better off and safer for it.
We have plenty of laws, but few committed to solutions. Despite what politicians say, our problems aren't complex and solutions are both plentiful and simply executed. All we need are committed patriots.
Congratulations, Mr. Chaffetz. You'll be in my prayers.
conservative, beat in his own back yard by a liberal?
What is happing to Utah County?
A "Right Winger" defeated. What's next?
1. The main "hit" was when Utah County was notified of
Cannon's "sellout" to Farmers Insurance Group in the Paul Drockton discrimination complaint. Why this hasn't been reported is no mystery. Joe Cannon controlled what made it to the papers.
This is what happens to people that choose money and power. God sends a humble servant for them to abuse. Looks like the Cannons underestimated the power of the internet and the telephone.
THanks to Mormons4Justice they won't be able to in the future.
Your comments smack of condescension and a complete lack of understanding.
There was no "downright untruthful mudslinging" in this campaign. Unless it was from the incumbent. Cannon's platform was a whining "Jason doesn't live in the district." Chaffetz' platform was all voting record, issues, charisma, and energy.
The better candidate won. I think we know who is better qualified to serve the 3rd district this term. Seniority doesn't matter one ounce if the rep doesn't do the right thing.
Congratulations Jason! May you always keep an ear to the ground and not let your supporters feel betrayed. The sun is rising on Happy Valley today.
But what you described was exactly the party I would support for the rest of my life. Unfortunately at the moment, neither party comes close.
There is a list of other RINOs, reconquistas and traitors who must also be voted out of office. This list starts with the following:
McCain
Obama
Ted Kennedy
Gov. Kaine (VA)
Gov. Corzine (NJ)
Mayor Tony Villar (Los Angeles, his real name, a former gang member)
Mayor Gavin Newsome (San Francisco)
Mayor Phil Gordon (Phoenix)
Rep. Flake (AZ)
Lindsey Graham (SC)
Gov. Napolitano (AZ)
Sen. Menendez (NJ)
Sen. Martinez (FL)
...and just about all Democrat Congressmen save for the Blue Dogs!
You got exactly what you wanted: A populist who will say anything to get elected. On one hand he wants tents for 20 million illegals during convention. Now he wants guest worker visas for the same 20 million for the primary. He is a con man but hey, he's your con man.
WE ARE SICK OF IT...
opposed to it. If finally caught up with him. His defeat is no loss.
Let's all give Jason our complete support. He will need it as he deals with a far-left Democrat Congress and all the serious problems facing our nation. I'm afraid the "throw-the-bums-out" mentallity will cause voters to make a serious mistake in the direction we go this year. Let's all pray!
VOTE. You have no place to gripe if you don't VOTE.
Three cheers for voter imposed term limits.
I don't know Chaffetz personally and have no emotional stake in him, but, congratulations to him and now let's get him elected, hold his feet to the fire by insisting he refuse to compromise with the liberals and left who are hell-bent on destroying our freedoms and replacing them with their commissar ways where they know how better to spend my money than I do.
Jason lives in Alpine, which is 11,000 feet from the district boundary. He has lived in Utah County for 20 years.
Gerrymandering in 2001 removed 4 Utah County cities from the Third District and combined them with the less conservative communities of the Second District.
The legislature has officially approved only one map for a Fourth District at this time. It puts Alpine back in the Third District.
Perhaps this will work..
Thank You Chris Cannon for all of your hard work. We are still counting on you for the next 6 months.
(No, I didn't vote for you).
I retain my cynicism about politicians. I want a change in the President, and I also want congress to WORK for a change--not only to work together, but also to put in the days at the office that they should be doing.
Hopefully Chaffetz can hold onto his idealism if he wins the election and be a productive representative of this state.
("Anti-invasion"--Nice! You guys crack me up.)
The Democrats offer more gun control, higher taxes and disarming America's national defense. Be careful what you ask for, you might get it.
I can't wait for Jason to go back to Washington and "change the world" and "stick it to the man." Too bad he doesn't know what he's talking about and that he doesn't realize that jr. Rep's don't get a whole lot done. But then again, as the lowest ranking member of several lackluster congressional committees, maybe he can make a difference. ;)
Anyone that thinks he's going to go back and change the system or be a powerful (and, more importantly, EFFECTIVE) advocate for his district is naive, unrealistic, and out of touch with the realities of politics and law making. I guess that describes most individuals in the general public.
what a dolt, lets pay the salary we do to this man so we can "put up with mediocrity' rather then exercise faith in the message of a new person who can perhaps energize america again. utah republican are to laugh at
"i rather have a republican half wit then any body who calls them selves a democrat"
One thing to remember - it's easier to remove a good democrat from the third Congressional seat than a bad republican.
I'll be voting democrat this November!
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
- You say you want a revolution? 12:35 a.m.
- 'Before His Manger' Ch. 3 12:35 a.m.
- Joseph Smith Papers, Volume I 12:34 a.m.
- President Monson to speak 12:34 a.m.
- Temples boost property values 12:34 a.m.
- Today in the Bloggernacle 12:33 a.m.
- Sports on the air 12:31 a.m.
- 10 Wildcats All-America 12:30 a.m.
- Burns. Ags toast N.M. St. 12:30 a.m.
- Weber gets road win 12:28 a.m.
-
BYU's '09 football opener is…
186
-
Utes No. 1 for Utahns
162
-
U. season greatest in our history
146
-
LDS silent on issues
146
-
Shurtleff considers BCS probe
135
-
BYU falters late against Wake
112
-
Official 2009 BYU football schedule
111
-
Bush is distinctly Bush
107
-
Polygamous leaders arrested
84
-
FLDS mother requests jury for…
83
If Texas is one missed tackle, Florida one missed extra point and USC one blown coverage…
I have called the BYU Athletic Department twice with this suggestion and NO return…
send us to the colliseum, send us to the swamp, send us anywhere to get tested. after…
We'll know "how well it worked" when the committee seriously looks into the Representative…
Mr. Turner's lesson -- which is a lesson for all of us -- is that when a police officer…
Why do people think they can get away with the insurance policy plot. NEVER WORKS…
I agree Utah had a couple close calls, but they didn't lose any. Can Florida say…
offices are located in Midvale. They have four Executive Directors and a couple…
Quick somebody, take a poll. Name the 5 toughest conferences in college football…
I apologize. I honestly thought that you are looking for a fair assessment of the…



Welcome to the public eye Jason. May you be scrutinized as negatively as you scrutinized Chris Cannon