Reader comments
New Harmony: Current focus concentrates on retaining LDS members
506 comments | Read story
Stop making poor people pay a full 10%. Time donated should count toward a tithe, but that would hit the church's bottom line a bit too hard.
A guy who makes $30,000 a year is paying a LOT more than a guy making $300,000 a year.
Want to have higher retention? Give those of us with doubts and questions a place, give those of us who figured out a long time ago that God doesn't micro manage the church a legitimate opportunity, don't label us as worthless 'intelectuals' and show us the door.
I love the members of my family who still believe in the church and I am grateful they have the church because it makes them feel good. But my family members act nothing like many in the church who chastise and berate many on this message board (NOT A BLOG). My neighbors are great and always invite us to the summer neighborhood dinner, which I am sure they plan at church. I still look at my Mormonism as almost a race, and dont care if my name is on the roles or the elders come around. If I dont want to talk to them I will just tell them that.
The "truth" about the LDS Church, as many others have stated herein, is not to be found in some online discussion of Mountain Meadows, the 1978 revelation, or Joseph Smith's dabbling in the Masonic Order. It is that either you believe Joseph Smith to be a prophet or you don't. Either you have a testimony of the Book of Mormon or you don't.
If you have a testimony, then whatever the imperfect members of the church do or don't do, matters not one iota in the long run. Yes, it can sting - a lot even - to be rejected by dorks who don't offer a blessing if you're inactive, or who don't offer a sympathetic hug when you lose a loved one. For those who have had such experiences, you have my sympathy. But the decision to stand on your testimony is still yours and none other's, no excuses necessary. Hope to see you back soon!
Why not just concentrate just leaving them the (blank) alone?
Pls tell me you're kidding.....
If I was your home teacher, I'd come and visit, get to know you and your family, help you move, etc, etc. But, I'd be a pretty poor friend indeed if I never told you to quit acting like a slothful butthead and accept responsibility for your actions.
It's YOUR life, it's YOUR responsibility what you do with it. Please don't settle for less when you can actually have so much more. Good luck.
4. As others have said, I also see a great difference between the Church inside Utah and out. I hate being a member of the Church in Utah, it stinks. Outside, I love it!!
5. Are there any other churches that believe they are the 'one and only' or are we the only ones who say it so plainly? Isn't it kind of inherent in each church's doctrine that they are the right one?
I say to those who have been offended or have suffered loss that IME the best way to respond is to serve the Lord and those around you and forget yourselves. We all have trials whether they be physical, financial, emotional or spiritual. When we serve rather than judge our fellowman we lift ourselves and are more in-tune with God's will. There may be some here who have an argument with God and choose to vent by mentioning this doctrine or that doctrine or saying that 'happiness' is through rejecting the Gospel of Jesus Christ. As the Lord revealed in the Book of Mormon--'He gives us weaknesses that we may be humble.' Love rather than fear ought to dictate testimony!
I think the answer is towfold - 1) because the LDS Church is the only church that proclaims that they are the only true CHURCH on the face of the earth. Others may believe they are or that they teach the truth but it is not nearly as central or vocal or tied to a CHURCH as it always has been in the LDS Church. And 2) a central part of that only true church on the face of the earth is ACTIVITY in the Church - not just belief as found in other christian denomination - but activity.
I learned that the way to bear a testimony is NOT to (currently) tell someone (even yourself) how you feel about your revelation "now", but to instead tell the person "now" (meaning in the present) how you felt about the experience THEN. In other words, don't try to emotionally recreate the experience of your revelation when you first found yourself believing in the Gospel. What happened, happened. It is a matter of fact and history and nothing can ever, EVER change it. Not even God, for how can God change truth? So you have a great revelation but can't recreate it emotionally to believe again? That's OK. The fact is, your revelation DID occur and you KNOW it.
So...stick to your guns. Sure, delve further into your religion but ignore those who want you to deny what you know is true.
Why doesn't the LDS church publish a number of members scorecard each week in this paper?
Example:
A number of the faithful
A number of the not-so-faithful
A number of those who quit
And a number of those who quit but haven't been removed from the records
Number of dead people who have recently been baptized.
"We claim the privilege of worshiping Almighty God according to the dictates of our own conscience, and allow all men the same privilege, let them worship how, where, or what they may."
Good points.
Contrary to misleading posts here, people are welcome to ask tough questions and not face excommunication. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints wants to feed Christ's sheep and help us all come unto Christ. Sadly, some revile/advocate against the doctrine and dissociate themselves with the Church, until it reluctantly must consider their removal.
As far as 'the thinking has been done.' It's more accurate to say, God's truths are unchanging. The Church is run by God or else doctrine would be put to popular vote/thought. It is good to be an independent thinker, if it affords us more truth from God, but we have to be careful our thoughts are not independent of God, or it is not truth.
By all means, keep asking questions. God's gospel knows all. The prophet speaks for God. Hold him to it. But don't take truths out of context (ie. Animal sacrifices aren't necessary now, but they were in the Old Testament. Truth didn't change, but Christ's perfect sacrifice fulfilled that law). So don't hold the truths of one prophet to a changing context for another prophet. Some mysteries will always remain.
I feel badly for those who are not allowed to leave this group, and have to be pestered by members for the rest of their lives. I also feel badly for those who seem so frightened to think for themselves. So much fighting and squabbling over religion, which is supposed to make one's life peaceful. How sad. Good luck to all of you. Peace!
Joseph Smith claims to have experienced what I believe would be the two greatest events to occur on earth since the Savior's resurrection - that both Christ and the Father appeared to him and spoke to him and that the authority of the Priesthood was restored to him by angelic visitation.
Why then would not a SINGLE WORD be uttered (as far as anyone knows) or written about those two events until several years after they occurred AND several years after the founding of the Church? No journal entries, scripture, sermon manuscripts, letters, newspaper articles, even from those bent on destroying Joseph Smith and the Church mentioned the occurrence of these two supposed magnificent events until several years after their supposed occurrence.
The first time Joseph Smith did sit down and in his own hand write his history he said that Jesus appeared to him but not a word about the Father. Long articles and sermons were given by Joseph Smith and other leaders about the Godhead during these early years and yet no mention of the first vision. I truly do not understand this and it is something I struggle with greatly.
He said as a missionary he wanted one very badly so he read the Book of Mormon and prayed about it. No answer. So he read it again more intently and prayed more sincerely. Still nothing. This happened several times until he read the entire BofM in a couple of days. (Now that's really wanting to know!) He said that after reading the whole BofM in just a few days, as he was praying, he felt no emotional outpouring of knowledge but instead the thought entered forcefully into his mind and heart, "Marvin, you've always known the Church is true so get up off your knees and go to work!" And so he did.
Like Mormon says, "You receive NO witness until AFTER the trial of your faith".
Come on!, let's work! The answer WILL come.
It did for me.
Are you certain this is a LDS site? It looks more to me like a killing ground. It will be interesting to see how God will JUDGE EACH OF YOU.
WOWSERS!
Keep living in lala land if you want. As for me, I'm out of here.
It's because they have wasted more then enough of their time, sweat and effort, and their life, and refused to give thought and waste anymore of their precious life in giving even a single second to it. They don't care what the church does with their names, anymore, they're out, and want to stay out and not have anything to do with it anymore.
Having your name in the church is nothing more than having your name in a bank that you no longer use, it doesn't a difference to one's life.
"Too restrictive", they say. Led by a bunch of old men, they claim. "Out of touch" or "they just don't care about me", some say.
Joseph Smith saw in vision beforehand the apostasy of nearly 1/3 of the members while the Church resided in Kirtland, Ohio. A scene so frightening that he begged the Lord to close up the vision. The Lord did for a while but later showed him the rest. Joseph then went to the members and literally begged and pleaded with them to the point of tears not to abandon the restored Gospel. Perhaps a few listened. Many obviously did not.
Will we drop from 13 million members to 12 million? 10? 8? I don't know. But I do know this: the Church will grow and cover the earth like the waters cover the seas for God has said so.
The caravan moves on.
Are you coming?
Some lucky people make a very good living selling the church property, building the churches, etc.
What is needed is an honest and listening heart for the weary. So others doubt. We need to listen to them as to why. Answer their questions as best as we can and encourage them to go to the Lord through the scriptures and in prayer and fasting as well. Pray for them and love them with no less affection than if they were seated beside us in church each week. The Lord is indeed displeased with those of us who judge others harshly because of their struggles. Yes, sometimes we bring our problems upon ourselves but who are we to judge that someone is not worth a second try or they will "never" learn to live the Gospel?
Perhaps the person we will nurture today will be the very person who helps us when our own faith is lacking. Alma and his father were once what we often call "less active", weren't they?
Easier said than done? Sure, but the Lord loves them as much as he loves us. Unconditional love is an amazing thing. I don't fully have it for my fellow man yet, I admit, but I've felt it.
Great Hymn. Probably will appear soon in the latest authorized version of the latest Mormon hymn book near you. If it hasn't already.
Bring them in... bring them in...
he has story after story of being at the right place and at the right time to give a blessing, to say a few uplifting words...impressive and I hope to do my part
Yes, people can be mean, yes people can hurt you, yes Joseph Smith wasn't perfect, neither was Moses or Aaron.
But come on, leaving because of the "holier than thou" perception, just means the house wasn't built on the rock.
That said, can someone please tell me what possesses people to present themselves with a "church resume?" For those who leave the church, the extensive resume, and need to begin a paragraph with it, is even more pathetic.
If a homeless person started his life story with how he was born into a wealthy family, had access to the finest schools, and yet had somehow managed to direct his privileged path into a life of squalor, it would be sad. But when he says this proudly, the story becomes ridiculous. These are not stories that leave the listener inspired or impressed.
It is God who has said that the stone cut out of a mountain without hands would break down all earthly kingdoms of men and would grow until it literally filled the earth, so who are you or I to stop it? Don't believe it anymore? Fine. But yet it is true.
I am absolutely amazed at how many people I've "met" online due to Mitt Romney's campaign who do not have the foggiest understanding of "truth", ie, they honestly think that just because they believe something hard enough it must be true. That is simply not in line with reality.
If you leave the Church and don't abide by it's teachings, you will be held responsible when you die and the same goes for me.
Let us choose wisely.
How many of the posters in this group tonight are in that situation? How many of you had testimonies that were hanging by a thread to begin with? How many of you felt guilt for doing something that you knew to be wrong and now have found "proof" that you really shouldn't feel bad because, "hey, I just learned the Church isn't true anyway"? (Now before anyone freaks out and labels me as "mean" or "holier than thou", I admit that I have moments of weakness too and do things I know I shouldn't. The difference is I'm willing to admit "I'm" wrong and not "the Church".
So, people will leave due to the Romney experience but I know people will join due to the same experience too.
Please, please, "pray before you leap".
I have seen people retained in the gospel and I have seen people fall away. I have known people who came back to the fold when a loving reach and a helping hand came when they had previously been ostracized. I have known people who stopped coming to church because no one reached out to them in there new ward, and I have met people who referedto me as their son in a loving way from the first time we met.
I just think we need to remeber activity is not as much a measure of how often one goes to church, or even how often one reads the srciptures but how often one feels the spirit. We can not measure it, so all we can do is reach out with love and true concern and try to bless our brothers and sisters.
At baptism we accept to mourn with those that mourn and confort those who stand in need of confort, and that includes all people, not even just church members and definantly not just those who are our good friends because they are at church each week.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Summit picks up Polanski film 1:58 p.m.
- Penn fires basketball coach 1:56 p.m.
- Belichick has respect for Moss 1:55 p.m.
- Div. III colleges debate role of sports 1:55 p.m.
- Kansas, Texas still hold top 2 spots 1:54 p.m.
- Lindon man arraigned in fed court 1:25 p.m.
- D-Will is player-of-the-week 1:24 p.m.
- Congress wants to quiet TV ads 1:13 p.m.
- Group calls for deficit curbs 1:12 p.m.
- Study: Utah nonprofits on the edge 1:11 p.m.
- Wet spot found in Powell's home
- TV mom gives birth to 19th child
- D-Will treats military families to party
- Y. opponent nearly smelled roses
- Pace happy not to be noticed
- Maynor amazed by L.A. fans
- MWC looks better in basketball
- High school football: All-region teams
- Death of the Family Practice
- Jazz Extra: Starting 5
- Palin signs books, chats with fans
178 - Nude bathers cited for lewdness
149 - Gay-friendly curriculum phased out
129 - LDS to emphasize helping needy
120 - Jazz fall apart late at L.A.
110 - Unga might enter NFL draft
104 - BYU to wear royal blue uniforms
97 - TV mom gives birth to 19th child
95 - Disappearance called 'suspicious'
92 - Choir, guests unwrap musical magic
82
ESPN's Mark Schlabach ranked the Las Vegas Bowl as the seventh most...
Ya Baby!! We rock!! And before all the Lakers fans get on here and start...
Did you see this quote from Klavan on Al Gore: " Al Gore is quite hilarious....
take this man seriously?
where she is Josh. Good grammar, clown. Of course he hired an attorney, after...
This just in, they have found a new food the lowers a womans sex drive by 95%...
Dennis, you answered your own question..why not try to be a really good...
I see Utah don't talk much about this hey?. I guess Utah loves it when...
What she doesn't realize is that when addressing a superior Officer, they are...
I've played violent video games since their conception. I'm not violent,...
With Korver back,CJ and Matthews shooting so well from outside, we now have a...


There are many in my ward who have husbands who are in Iraq serving our country, they work as policeman on the dayshift, and work at Wal-Mart on Sundays.
Some attend less than 40% of the time, but they are still members of the Church who care about their families. You are not required to explain to anyone.
Spouses attend when they can. As long as you attend and can bring the Spirit in your home for your family, that's what counts. Many people have very valid reasons for being gone. I know it's even tougher especially if you bring children.
We attend a fairly young family ward. We don't have any children of our own. We are always asked the question 'How many kids do you have?' in a ward that produces 15 - 20 babies a year.
People say things without thinking fist or just ask out of curiousity. We take it for the latter. When when we tell them we don't have any,they sometimes reply "I'm jealous". We then enjoy a lighter moment together. Alot of those children come and sit with us.
Keep going...it's worth it. Eternity is a long time to spend alone.