Reader comments
'Twilighters' set to sink teeth into movie
49 comments | Read story
ew | 1:52 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
that is a creepy picture of Stephanie Meyer. Look closely at her hands. It
looks like she has claws or something. Is that on purpose??? Or did she just
get a really bad nail job done? Also, is she trying to look like a vampire?
She looks pasty.
Maury | 5:26 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Unfortunate in my view to rationalize this type of content because it's
only a book, first, and, second, it's written by someone who is LDS. Now,
in movie format it's a crazed run on this teen, sex-filled vampire version
of 90210 meets desperate housewives, but among teens... That's all we need.
It's soft porn... And, somehow, one that is ok per reasons spelled out
above. Weird.
Obsession | 6:10 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
The article says:
A self-described "thirtysomething mother of three," Clark might not seem like the typical fan of the Meyer books)
But I have heard of numerous twenty- and thirty- something mothers not only admit to this obsession but actually seem proud to announce that their little children would often stay in their pj's all day and only be given cold cereal to eat, as reading these books was way more important to their mothers.
A self-described "thirtysomething mother of three," Clark might not seem like the typical fan of the Meyer books)
But I have heard of numerous twenty- and thirty- something mothers not only admit to this obsession but actually seem proud to announce that their little children would often stay in their pj's all day and only be given cold cereal to eat, as reading these books was way more important to their mothers.
Comments continue below
To Maury | 7:06 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Have you even read the books? They are not sex-filled at all. When the main
characters finally do kiss there has been such a build up to it. No sex. ERNT!
You sound like a right-wing nut. I can't help but laugh, and for those of
us here at work, we've had a great time reading what you wrote. It's
HILARIOUS! We can't stop laughing. Thank you for being ignorant and so
off-base.
Anonymous | 7:16 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Twilight, like Harry Potter, has encouraged a generation of kids to read. If
only something could get kids away from drive-up fast food windows and
television and get them into a real life...
Excited | 7:27 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Hey Maury...Have you even read the books??? There is nothing porn about them!
To even compare these completely smut-less novels to a self-proclaimed
alduterous show is completey wrong. I feel sorry for you that you want to hind
behind your unfounded opinions and made such ignorant statements. You are
missing out!
Screen Age | 7:48 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
There is no need to label people or call them names.
Just as it it presumptuous to slam books you haven't read, it would likewise be foolish to defend a movie you hadn't seen just because you've read the books.
The reason the Potter movies were so true to the books is that JK Rowling had unusual control over the Potter movies, control that isn't usually granted to authors. For example, both the "Jason Bourne" and "Jack Ryan" movie series were not true to the books at all.
It remains to be seen if Stephenie Meyer had any such control over the movies, but reviewers are definitely writing that there is a sex scene in the movie... but they also write that it is tame enough to only "offend the Amish."
At any rate, bashing others for views you find amusing is a behavior others of us would likewise find amusing.
Just as it it presumptuous to slam books you haven't read, it would likewise be foolish to defend a movie you hadn't seen just because you've read the books.
The reason the Potter movies were so true to the books is that JK Rowling had unusual control over the Potter movies, control that isn't usually granted to authors. For example, both the "Jason Bourne" and "Jack Ryan" movie series were not true to the books at all.
It remains to be seen if Stephenie Meyer had any such control over the movies, but reviewers are definitely writing that there is a sex scene in the movie... but they also write that it is tame enough to only "offend the Amish."
At any rate, bashing others for views you find amusing is a behavior others of us would likewise find amusing.
Lalalaleeesa | 7:49 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Funny ... it's okay for grown men to play video games ad nauseum, obsess
over fantasy football, fantasy hockey, and fantasy baseball, fantasy NASCAR,
watch ESPN habitually, and scream and moan over college football games, but if a
grown woman gets into a book series and sees the movies, then she's a
neglectful mother. Can you say "double standard"?
Anonymous | 8:19 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
My wife has read the books, and is a fan. That is just fine with me. We each
have our own things we are fans of. I read them as well, to see if they were OK
for our teenage daughter. Because Bella is way overly obsessed in a stalker kind
of way with Edward, and the book is told first person through her...the book was
a bit creepy and disturbing. I quickly grew tired of hearing adjectives like
"angelic" describe a vampire.
But to say that there is no sex in the books...really? What about the part where Edward and Bella break the bed? Maybe some of you interpret this differently than I did.
But to say that there is no sex in the books...really? What about the part where Edward and Bella break the bed? Maybe some of you interpret this differently than I did.
Hey Maury | 8:20 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
If men like Maury would get a clue and read these books, they'd see why
women love them. "Edward Cullen" is the type of man we'd all love
to have --- he listens, is in tune with Bella's emotional needs, and is
totally respectful of her and doesn't cross the line. Is that sexy? YES!!!
But not by the male definition of sexy. Read and be elightened!
twilightmania | 8:47 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Read the books. They were fine. I don't get the obsession with Edward and
clan.
So bite me.
So bite me.
Down with Edward | 8:54 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Jacob is where it's at!!
Lighten up | 8:58 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
The part where they break the bed doesn't happen until the 4th book.....and
that's all you hear about their encounter. And they're married by
then. They never had any carnal relations of any kind before they got married.
And the author goes out of her way to not describe any details of their sexual
relations.
Last I heard it's okay for married people to have sex. Lighten up.
Last I heard it's okay for married people to have sex. Lighten up.
Cats | 9:01 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
There is no sex in the Twilight books until after Bella and Edward are married.
Even then, it's extremely subtle in the way it is presented.
One of the important features of the books is that Cullen is very respectful of Bella, a complete gentleman and insists that there be nothing improper between them until they are married.
These books are a wonderful example to young people of highly moral behavior. The Cullen family are determined to live lifes of character and high morality regardless of the fact that they are stuck being vampires. They don't live like other vampires. They believe in God, refuse to drink human blood and try to do good to everyone.
You need to read them to know what they are about. I really admire Stephanie Meyer for keeping to a high standard.
One of the important features of the books is that Cullen is very respectful of Bella, a complete gentleman and insists that there be nothing improper between them until they are married.
These books are a wonderful example to young people of highly moral behavior. The Cullen family are determined to live lifes of character and high morality regardless of the fact that they are stuck being vampires. They don't live like other vampires. They believe in God, refuse to drink human blood and try to do good to everyone.
You need to read them to know what they are about. I really admire Stephanie Meyer for keeping to a high standard.
Father of 5 | 9:02 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
After ignoring my daughters persuasive arguments to read the Twilight book, she
finally read the first few pages to me. I was hooked. I had her read some more,
then she read the first chapter, then the second. Soon I grabbed the book away
and have now read all three and can't wait to see the movie - for Family
Night even. The guys at work tease me, but yeah, I'm a Twilight fan and
proud of it!! Good fun!
Belle | 9:06 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Sex scene? I doubt it goes any farther than the book does - which is some face
stroking and kissing. Written very appealingly, but certainly not sex. If they
cross the line in the movie, they eliminate the chance for three more sequels -
and that's not going to happen!
Anonymous | 9:15 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I was able to see the movie on Tuesday with the press. There is no sex scene in
this movie. There is a kissing scene with a lot of build up, but if you consider
this sex, you have other problems to worry about!!!
Exactly, Cats! | 9:16 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I have a female acquaintance who doesn't like the Twilight series because
"there's not enough sex in them." Which is EXACTLY why I love
them and would recommend them to anyone. Meyers has proved what Hollywood has
forgotten, that "romantic" does not have to equal "sex."
Laughing at all of you! | 9:20 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
So...I saw the movie last night in a special screening and I have to say, they
couldn't have done a poorer job on the movie if they tried! It was low
budget, bad acting, and didn't capture the book at all. Unfortunetly, they
will trick all of you into spending your money to prove that I am wrong when in
reality, you will all wish you listened! 1/2 star out of 5 :(
Jacob | 9:26 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
The books are good read, and you see and hear more about sex on TV in one
evening then you do in all 4 books
JACOB RULES!!!!!!
JACOB RULES!!!!!!
Swede | 9:45 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I am 59 years old and a hopeless romantic, I have had a great life being married
and now widowed. I found the Twilight series very enjoyable as Mrs. Meyers has
written in the style of old-fashioned values of respect and morality. As I read
them I realized she was able to capture the feelings of first love that I
remember from so many years ago. The beautiful tenderness, the exhilaration of
a touch to the cheek, and the anticipation of that first kiss. To be able to
keep so many pages free from sexual content and still give the reader the feel
of reading a romance novel is to be applauded. I have discussed the books with
my daughter and she is not ready for her daughter (12) to read them and I agree.
I really feel they are meant for a little bit older audience.
Beth | 9:53 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I read the entire series. The plotline hooks you in and the books are a
fun/light read. However if you think that there is anything more worthwhile
than fun in these books then you're kidding yourselves. Bella is weak and
clingy, she has no life outside of Edward, no additional interests. Meanwhile,
Edward is bossy and controlling. Their relationship is founded on their intense
connection, which is a little bit difficult to believe because they have zero
common interests. When Edward leaves in book two Bella completely falls
apart.
If you are going to let your teenage daughters read them, because they're fairly morally clean, that's fine but I would make sure that you have a talk with them about what a HEALTHY relationship looks like.
The saga could have just ended at book 3. No one needs to hear what happens during the "Happily Ever After", they just need to know that it's there. The fourth book was just weird!
And come on, vampire sex never ends? Give me a break. If that isn't giving girls misconceptions about love and marriage I don't know what is!
If you are going to let your teenage daughters read them, because they're fairly morally clean, that's fine but I would make sure that you have a talk with them about what a HEALTHY relationship looks like.
The saga could have just ended at book 3. No one needs to hear what happens during the "Happily Ever After", they just need to know that it's there. The fourth book was just weird!
And come on, vampire sex never ends? Give me a break. If that isn't giving girls misconceptions about love and marriage I don't know what is!
Grandma of 6 | 10:03 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
To "Laughing at all of you", I am sorry you didn't enjoy the
movie. My Twenty-something daughters saw the movie on Monday night, they
already have pre-paid tickets to see it at least 4 more times. Loved it. They
have each read and reread the books so many times. If you don't like the
books, it is because you have never read them, I promise you will not be able to
put them down. Yes, they finally hooked me and I read them, and no I could not
stop till I finished all of them. This grandma really loved them. I will also
see the movie.
Ema | 10:11 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Some Twilight fans make me laugh so hard. I read all the books and am going to
see the movie, but I am very aware of the books' flaws, and definitely
don't think Edward is the perfect gentleman. I find him to be possessive
and not at all in tune with Bella's wants and needs, and most of the things
he does that are supposed to be romantic are actually creepy and stalker-ish
(sneaking through Bella's window and watching her sleep without her
knowledge, for example).
Also, for those saying how thoroughly "clean" these books are, read between the lines a little--Bella wanting Edward to "bite" her and him resisting despite his overwhelming need to indulge, is a very thinly veiled analogy for sex. And that's fine, but recognize it for what it is. And in the later books, Bella literally begs Edward for sex. Sure, they don't wind up doing it until they're married (and sex seems to be the main reason Bella agrees to marry him), but is begging for sex really moral behavior? I don't think so. It's just annoying.
Also, for those saying how thoroughly "clean" these books are, read between the lines a little--Bella wanting Edward to "bite" her and him resisting despite his overwhelming need to indulge, is a very thinly veiled analogy for sex. And that's fine, but recognize it for what it is. And in the later books, Bella literally begs Edward for sex. Sure, they don't wind up doing it until they're married (and sex seems to be the main reason Bella agrees to marry him), but is begging for sex really moral behavior? I don't think so. It's just annoying.
Vampire Bullies | 10:11 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Forget Twilight, this forum reads like "Mean Girls."
Good Insight | 10:18 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I agree with Beth. I have to opine that Stephenie Meyer must have an unmet
psychological need that keeps appearing as a theme in her books --- the love
martyr, the abandoned and love-lorn reject who triumphs when the man she obesses
over finally returns her affections. This doesn't teach young teenage girls
how to be healthy in relationships, as many of them DO obsess and pine after the
unattainable one to the point that it's psychologically detrimental. Hope
none of them jump off cliffs like Bella does, because there are no real-life
Edwards or Jacobs to catch them. This weird love martyr character resurfaces in
The Host, also by Meyer, and the character takes physical abuse from the one she
loves, repeatedly. A little much for me.
Hit the nail on the Head | 11:11 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Amen to Beth. I read all four and I agree with you 100%. While I enjoyed books
1-3 and thought they were a cute and somewhat fun love story, I too felt that
Bella needed to get her own life, Edward was too controlling and the 4th book
just weirded me out.
To Anonymous 8:19 am | 11:24 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
This is a question for Anonymous 8:19am: So did your wife think "breaking
the bed" books were good for your teenage daughter to be reading??
Anonymous | 11:31 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I read the first book and couldn't get past it any further. Sorry...Bella
was too frustrating to be in side her head.
Twilight is the Star Wars for girls and women. You serious Twilight fans who got your tickets long ago and are getting shirts to wear to the movie, etc...remember this next time you see a Trekkie or someone else who is a fan about something. Everybody apparently has their fan poison. :-)
Twilight is the Star Wars for girls and women. You serious Twilight fans who got your tickets long ago and are getting shirts to wear to the movie, etc...remember this next time you see a Trekkie or someone else who is a fan about something. Everybody apparently has their fan poison. :-)
What about the lies? | 11:52 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I read Twilight to see if I wanted my kids to read it. I was so disgusted with
the whole premise that I could barely finish the book. Teenagers are already so
clueless in life, so to give them a book where the main character is so shallow
and lets her "heart" rule her brain is dangerous. She lies throughout
the entire book and puts herself in life and death situations: this is every
parent's nightmare. I see the facination for the immature teenagers, but
all of you older women who are into this book must have pretty shallow lives as
well.
Get it over | 11:57 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I am just glad the movie is almost here. I have had to her my wife and
daughters go on about it for months. Looks like my son and I will be going to
the Bond movie this weekend...thank goodness!
What happened to him? | 11:58 a.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Is this Edward person really played by the same gut that played Cedric in the
Harry Potter movies?
What happened to him???
As Cedric, he was handsome. Here, he's just creepy.
What happened to him???
As Cedric, he was handsome. Here, he's just creepy.
JAMMER | 12:21 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Ok, I am a guy who has read 3 of the books with the purpose to see what my wife
was reading and to build a common bond. I haven't read the fourth but if
you your so scared about your teenagers reading about "sex", then you
need to walk through a jr high or high school. It will be all around them. Not
just in this book, but on TV, magazines, health class, etc. If you are affraid,
then maybe you need to man up and talk to your kids about it.
AK | 12:58 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
First I was surprised that a young LDS woman wrote these series of books. Her
description of the Pacific Northwest & Native Americans (however brief) was
very good. Never would have thought that with this topic--that an LDS female
would write them...maybe its because I grew-up a in a different era--when
females were more ????
Cats | 1:09 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Honestly, I am constantly amazed at how nasty people on these blogs are.
Look, Stephanie takes literary license and does some things in order to create some conflict and some twists and turns in the plot. And, clearly these books are, to a great extend, silly teenage romances. Of course, Bella isn't a completely believable character--none of them are. But, the books have a lot of imagination to them and present some good moral examples. Don't take the whole thing too seriously.
I actually didn't think the fourth book was the best. It was too long and actually pretty anti climactic. But, these books are wonderful for young people who are craving something of real romance and tenderness and getting nothing but degrading, destructive sexual content in most things they see around them.
Come on. Let's not always be so contrary and critical. Let's give Stephanie a break. She has tried to do something good and has, to a great extent, succeeded.
Look, Stephanie takes literary license and does some things in order to create some conflict and some twists and turns in the plot. And, clearly these books are, to a great extend, silly teenage romances. Of course, Bella isn't a completely believable character--none of them are. But, the books have a lot of imagination to them and present some good moral examples. Don't take the whole thing too seriously.
I actually didn't think the fourth book was the best. It was too long and actually pretty anti climactic. But, these books are wonderful for young people who are craving something of real romance and tenderness and getting nothing but degrading, destructive sexual content in most things they see around them.
Come on. Let's not always be so contrary and critical. Let's give Stephanie a break. She has tried to do something good and has, to a great extent, succeeded.
yea for $tephenie | 2:24 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Good job, Ms. Meyer. You set out to earn money when your family was in a tough
situation and you succeeded splendidly.
Despite the varying opinions on this board, what was written was intriguing enough to have you spend some money to read it. Remember our taxes pay for the hundreds of copies the library sytem bought.
Despite the varying opinions on this board, what was written was intriguing enough to have you spend some money to read it. Remember our taxes pay for the hundreds of copies the library sytem bought.
Silly | 3:26 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
First things first, ALL OF THE BOOKS ARE GREAT! These books were never made for
the young. They were made quote Myer,"For a older audiance" So if you
are not ok with a couple scenes between a husband and wife than dont even turn
on your T.V! These books are moral and have gained my respect for teaching
teenagers that there is always the temptation to do things but it their choice
to suffer the consequences good or bad.
Bad Writing | 4:34 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Bella commits the ultimate crime: she has no character development at all over
four novels. None whatsoever! If there was ever a wish-fulfillment story, this
is it. These books should be considered immoral and corrupting to young women on
that basis alone.
On the whole, though, I have to give Ms. Meyer credit. I never thought that someone would write a book that make Eragon look good.
On the whole, though, I have to give Ms. Meyer credit. I never thought that someone would write a book that make Eragon look good.
roger | 5:52 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
hope they're good
Anonymous | 6:15 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Wasn't this fantasy stuff unhealthy before it got mormonised? Harry potter
and the golden compass were the devils work, weren't they? Or was that just
on sunday.
KJB | 6:52 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
As silly as I think Twilightmania is, I have to admit that Lalalaleeesa has a
pretty good point...
FlyOntheWall | 7:16 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I am not LDS. I have not read the books. I read all these posts just about
everyday. Could I ask a question of the people here who are trashing Ms.Myer?
Why is it that you keep a tally of how many NFL football players are LDS...how
many politicians are LDS...how many successful businessmen are LDS, etc.? But
when a female writer who is LDS becomes a world known writer, beloved by the
public in general, you feel the need to ostracize her? I admire anyone who has
talent. The fact that she is LDS is only incidental. Mormon women everywhere
should be proud that Ms. Myer has broken the "glass Mormon ceiling".
A Father | 7:34 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I've read the books along with my daughter and neice. They were just ok.
I much preferred Harry Potter, Eragon, Chronicles of Narnia, etc. Just because
there is no explicit sex in the movie, I didn't appreciate the
author's obsession with the male physique. I'm in pretty good shape,
but I think if I were Meyer's husband, I'd have a complex. She's
obsessed with muscles, etc.
And it's not fair for women to compare men to Edward. He isn't real! And I actually thought he was a jerk sometimes. What he did in the second book was despicable.
But all that said, they are fine books. It's always nice when a new series comes out that I can read with my children. Anything to get the TV/video games turned off!
And it's not fair for women to compare men to Edward. He isn't real! And I actually thought he was a jerk sometimes. What he did in the second book was despicable.
But all that said, they are fine books. It's always nice when a new series comes out that I can read with my children. Anything to get the TV/video games turned off!
Random | 7:41 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Thank you, FlyOntheWall. Good point. We do keep a rather obsessive list,
don't we?
Random | 7:47 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I will admit, I have read the first book and I was hooked - but that
doesn't necessarily mean I liked the books. I am NOT a romantic in any way.
I will admit, however, that the books were incredibly well-written. I don't
want to find my Edward Cullen - I think I'll stick with my Prince Charming.
brandon | 7:57 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
I recall a time when we went to the movies as a family. Mom didn't want to
see Harry Potter because it glorified sorcery. We said "Okay, why
don't we go see this other one." She said "Hmmm, that looks
interesting, okay". What was the show? Lord of the Rings. No one should
lay a finger on Ms. Meyers. Every kid in our ward has read her books and loved
them. Good stuff.
Old Lady | 8:04 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
Please remember that these books are fiction and they are wonderful. I loved
them and can't wait to see the movie.
FlyOntheWall | 8:45 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
for Random@ 7:41
Thank you for your sense of humor. Not to be outdone on the "list obsession", I am Catholic and in the opening pages to our Bible there is a list of every Pope since Peter. Guess Mormons and Catholics both like their lists. Now if we could get the rest of these folks to lighten up just a little bit.
Thank you for your sense of humor. Not to be outdone on the "list obsession", I am Catholic and in the opening pages to our Bible there is a list of every Pope since Peter. Guess Mormons and Catholics both like their lists. Now if we could get the rest of these folks to lighten up just a little bit.
????? | 9:49 p.m. Nov. 20, 2008
wow some people need lives.....the people who obsess along with those who
criticise.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
Related content
- Mourners grieve for soldiers killed 4:42 p.m.
- Aggies beat Spartans in snowy Logan 4:22 p.m.
- Study: Costs rise under health bill 4:13 p.m.
- Williams to miss Cavs game, too 4:06 p.m.
- Weber St. gets past No. Arizona 4:01 p.m.
- In Asia, Obama pushing arms control 3:50 p.m.
- Texas rolls 47-14 over Baylor 3:48 p.m.
- Snowstorm hits Utah; 1 dead in crash 3:43 p.m.
- Montana wins Big Sky with win 3:43 p.m.
- Rep. bashes Dems over health care 3:41 p.m.
- Apostle's wife felt comfort in attack
- Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?
- Short-handed Jazz fly past Sixers
- D-Will home for daughter
- Bench proves fruitful for Y.
- Utes excited for 'dream' game
- Born of water and the spirit
- Snowstorm hits Utah; 1 dead in crash
- Woods Cross refinery to shut down
- GameDay in Fort Worth
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
353 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights199
- Senators want food tax restored164
- Will state consider gay rights law?147
- Letters: Strange breed in Utah129
- Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?123
- Utes remain silent about BCS120
- S.L. vote pending on gay protections113
- Pratt pleads not guilty to sex charges105
- Celtics crush Jazz104
If you are looking for a bird on the cheap, the following specials from...
How do you handle kids and contests? Our oldest daughter, 7, is of the...
Advertisement
Latest comments
Cheering for Utah or TCU isn't the point...the point is, Doug Robinson is one...
Aggies gotta be careful going to play Utah. Just because Idaho beat Utah...
Stop talking your trash, Utes. You are the fans who this year keep using:...
Bingham deserved to win that game. Alta could have played better for sure....
No. We only define trolls as the Cougar fans that come on here only for the...
Mathis, Its's Dave Mathews dude! Who are these guys? Where do they find...
Homeland Security was the biggest waste of tax payers's money. My heart...
why dont you have some class
They didn't make finals :(
If BYU would have lost this one, it would have been almost as bad as being...
Advertisements