Reader comments
Prop. 8 protest draws thousands in Salt Lake City
1,245 comments | Read story
So, which one is completely unnecessary, mom or dad?
No, this is not a "hateful" or "bigoted" or "intolerant" post, it's a very important point about homosexual marriage and how it affects children.
Do you homosexuals REALLY believe that kids are 100% A-OK without either a mommy or a daddy?
But even worse to me than the choice of acting upon homosexual urges is the choice to force society through judicial fiat or overturn of public referendum to accept your "private" deviant act as normal.
It should also be pointed out that the proposition passed by a very narrow margin. Also worth mentioning is the fact that around 62% of voters under 25 voted against the proposition while around the same percentage of those 60 and older voted for it. Come next time who will there be more of? My bet is on those under 25.
There. Did your heads explode? Good.
"As a Mormon I understand the position of the Church. But honestly I do not know the position of all the gays and lesbians. What are you looking for? Is the word marriage what your are trying to add to your relationship? Please use this forum to educate. Honestly if you do it with respect and civility many Mormons will listen to what you really want and feel."
Because the majority doesn't agree with them they need to resort to force, intimidation and lies and they have repeatedly tried to hijacked the civil rights movement which has nothing to do with this.
Blacks never asked for additional rights or for any change in the definition of any institution or law instead we only asked that we have the same access to the same thing for the same price or under the same terms and that we would not be denied based on our race.
Legal marriage doesn't discriminate based on race, gender or sexual orientation. A woman can marry. A man can marry. A gay person can marry. A straight person can marry. A white person can marry. A black person can marry and do so under same terms.
Not only is it important to boycott the tourism industry but to boycott some ot the church's other activities. In the spirit of free agency: You don't have to go on your mission if called. If you are a parent you do not have to send your child to a mission you do not have to pay for it. Do not go to the BYU for your education. Boycott the BYU. Do not attend their games. Do not donate to the Alumni Association.
The Sundance film event is small. Think big
"To Jason: Your tone was hysterical; source please of how tithing funds were used. You have none, but it sure is easy to make allegations isn't it?"
The LDS Church made an in-kind donation of $2,078.97 to pay for the travel arrangements of Church leaders who went to California for a meeting. The Church did not make any other donation to support Prop. 8.
"Your comments on churches tax exempt statud convince of one thing. You are not a tax attorney."
Of course he isn't since a single in-kind donation of $2,078.97 to a political cause doesn't affect a tax-exempt status. The Church is prohibited from donating to or endorsing political candidates.
"Exactly what rights have you lost?
"Wrong, the purpose of the courts are to see that justice is done, not legislate from the bench. Legislation is left for another branch of our government to do."
I agree. The Courts have no right to change the definition of marriage as it is legally defined but it does have the right to protect due process and equal protection which haven't been violated since gays are treated the same as straight people under the law.
And while liberal churches, who get invloved in MANY more politcal isues than the LDS Church does, will get to keep their tax exempt status, the LDS Church will be forced to give up theirs, simply because its views are not politcally correct enough.
Let freedom ring!!!!?
I knew it would come.
I was hoping it would come.
Thank you, for posting it.
lol
Second best laugh of the day. :o)
I am just baffled how people...complain when their opponents march on someplace that they hold to be sacred. Did they ever stop to think that the 18,000 legally married gay couples in California also believe their marriage vows to be sacred?"
"Sacred" in what sense of the word? Or is this yet another concept you want to redefine to suit your purposes? The main definition of sacred is:
1. Dedicated to or set apart for the worship of a deity.
2. Worthy of religious veneration.
Can someone explain to me how gays who obtain a "civil" license to "wed" consider such an act as "dedicated to God?" Isn't the entire point of civil marriage to leave God out of it?
We could hold a protest outside of their homes next Friday and outside of Bastian's home on Saturday. If they no longer want to reserve this issue to the ballot box than we can make it personal too. Instead of voting as civilized people do we will launch personal attacks on anyone who supported Prop. 8. So, John Doe, the average guy in Salt Lake, had better hope he's not on a list of donors to oppose it.
The Catholics are to big to attack, it's absolutely politicaly incorrect to attack blacks. It's easier to attack the small guy.
In other words, don't meddle in gays having a right to marry when you cannot show that "traditional" marriage is working anyway. You can be sure that gay couples who have a child are more likely to care for them because they have to do more to obtain them.
In other words, just live and let live, and don't throw your millions toward lies-infested propaganda that legislates morality.
Response to "Do you homosexuals REALLY believe that kids are 100% A-OK without either a mommy or a daddy?"
I wish everyone would keep their sexuality private. I worked with a gay man for five years and never knew it - it was a non-issue. However, there is another gay man I work with and every other sentence out of his mouth refers in some way to his homosexuality.
We don't hold hetero-only parades and events. Heteros don't talk in a "special" way to distinguish themselves. Heteros don't sue their former employers for wrongful termination based on them not being gay.
Gays - you are an extreme minority of the population. You are not being discriminated against. You can shop at the straight-stores, go to baseball games and concerts, sit in whichever seat you wish on the bus. You can't marry each other because you and your partner are of the same sex. That's the law of the land and you're going to have to live with it for now or find a new land. Nobody said you can't be gay. You're no worse off than you were before.
Your claim that laws are made because of experience is flawed. Just because laws are made doesn't mean that they are correct. Think about women's suffrage, segregation, Hitler's regime, etc.
And gays aren't asking for any special rights--just the rights to marry whom they choose.
(Response to "Being gay doesn't doesn't mean you get special rights. Thousands of years have defined marriage and now you want to change it. Laws are made because of experience. Nuff said.")
It's too bad Utah doesn't have fine enough soil to export any produce, so a boycott similar to that of the Florida Orange in the 1970's could take effect. Or is there something Utah does contribute that we could all live without (besides intolerance)?
I suggest all those that have hiring authority in their organizations do the same.
Last week we had a company wide layoff. I used the opportunity to get rid of several mormons that proudly displayed a triple combination or picture of Jesus in their office/cubical. I expect more layoffs to come and more mormons to go. :)
This is my own private way to fight the battle one person at a time.
Prop 8 protesters, keep it civil.
Prop 8 promoters, you've already vandalized the rights of numerous couples.
(Response to "Let's just hope that the Salt Lake City officials (unlike those in LA) have the guts to confront and prosecute those who deface the property of the LDS church during these "peaceful protests.")
I acknowledge your love of family and would never say homosexuals don't feel it. The question is whether we continue the legacy of love of family--of grandfathers, parents, children--or cut it off.
Tradition family is the clear, guaranteed, sure-fire, time-tested, unquestioned-for-millennia provider of the human need for love--love that requires sacrifice, duty, loyalty (to one's entire family--to FAMILY itself!) humility, unselfishness, submission, AND endurance THROUGH THE GENERATIONS.
It is the KNOWN course.
Nothing in society is more sure than this!
So for what would we put this, our very foundation, into question? For what better possible course would we risk teaching our children that there is a different--a better way--for anyone?
Because the mormons did not make it that far!
What are you going to do next? Stone an atheist to death? Burn some women at the stake? Maybe start a mormon inquisition? Bravo.
And if any of those triples got left behind, you really ought to spend an hour or two browsing and reading.
A more important day awaits all of us than the day we get hired or fired from some job.
MORMONS: You got your "one woman one man" definition of marriage protected in one of the most liberal states in America. Nice one.
GAY COMMUNITY: "The Church" has, by their involvement, made certain that people EVERYWHERE will be extremely vigilant the next time a stunt like this gets pulled. And it's likely prop 8 will eventually be ruled unconstitutional when it inevitably gets to the courts.
In the meantime, can we please remember that we are all US citizens entrusting our future well being in one another? Is it so much to ask?
The tone of the majority of these posts (from both sides) is disturbing. At best.
I hope you are a troll posting on the DN board because your company is going to have a lot of lawsuits coming their way. I have worked for many companies who are "diverse" and offer benefits to gay couples. It shows how petty you are if you are firing people based on their religion and not workplace performance.
Get over it and move on gay marriage supporters. We are tired of you tearing down every single institution that doesn't believe or support your beliefs and behavior. I doubt the DN has this many gay readers. The pro-gay marriage posts on this article are from a small group of individuals and others who hope the novice message readers get pulled into believing their is a mass movement in Utah sympathetic to gay marriage.
Your right to marry in California is a fluke due to judicial malpractice by judges who think they are smarter than everyone else in the state.
Polygamy is illegal in Utah. It is banned by the Utah State Constitution, which may be the only state constitution that contains such a ban.
Your comment is one of the most irrelevant ones I have read. The Utah State Constitution has banned plural marriage since it was first written in 1895.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Fantasy playoffs are here! 1:02 p.m.
- Doctor calls Mitchell 'naive,' 'inept' 1:02 p.m.
- Bluffdale police issue to be decided 12:46 p.m.
- Atom smasher catches 1st collisions 12:25 p.m.
- 5 Americans detained in Pakistan 12:18 p.m.
- Man defends self with scraper 12:11 p.m.
- Panel passes BCS playoff bill 12:08 p.m.
- Stocks turn mixed 12:06 p.m.
- Palin tickets still available 11:33 a.m.
- BYU devotional: 'God loves you' 11:24 a.m.
- Hot Rod behind mic for Lakers
- Snow brings big chill
- Cougars use depth to beat ASU
- Non-BCS schools not given fair shot
- Max Hall wants to look ahead
- Expert calls Mitchell delusional
- Panel passes BCS playoff bill
- Five players miss Jazz practice
- Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
- Jazz go up against 'the best'
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
283 - Letters: Global warming a lie
221 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
206 - BYU football: Bronco weighs in on Hall
174 - Cougars going back to Vegas
150 - Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
144 - Andersen apologizes for Jordan hoax
125 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
120 - Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
100 - Revive full food tax?
97
My wife Lisa and I would prefer never to argue. But that's not going to...
For the latest news in the health care debate and how it affects you...
Cold weather is keeping people away? That is a pretty big leap of logic. I...
My point is that there is NO REASON to mention the mans religion except to...
Who has time for dumb films which influence dumb ideas? This is the dumbest...
I miss hearing Hot Rod call games. I can't stand Bolerjack, he would be a lot...
"Fair, Balanced and objective" are ALWAYS the words I think of when I think...
She's the reason there isn't a republican in the white house. She and McCain...
I have never defended USU, as a matter of fact I can't stand their fans. The...
I wouldn`t pay ten cents to watch a team that most college and some high...
Who would you rather hang out with: people who always are whining about...
Why are people still posting here??? I thought the debate was OVER!...



