Reader comments
BYU football: Quest still alive Cougars remain perfect, but it isn't easy
188 comments | Read story
Thank you. I hope this helps to clarify things.
Having said that, my concern is for future games, because I dont think you can win them playing the way you have. A win is a win however. 21-4 isnt that bad. A couple years ago we would have been extremely excited.
the yewts are one hit wonders with the urban legend
errr the urban meyer hotdog..... thats why BYU is known outside of Utah, unlike the wannabe's on the hill
see ya in novemeber
Yes, very unimpressive win...just like Oklahoma's trouncing of Texas or LSU's steam rolling victory over the Gators.....or here's one.........Missouri's total domination of Oklahoma State. Got to admit utey's find ways to make the ball that isn't round.....round.....at least in their eyes.
...Tinkerbell... would you quit with the fairy dust already...it's not nice to deceive utey's to actually believe the weird things they're saying during their brief stay in wonderland.
..........RISE AND SHOUT.........
Gee whiz....there's actually a true believer out there. Thank you for the accolades...but just so you don't look stupid. Boise State is more than 40 miles away and it's in the WAC and not the MWC and Ute, there are at least 2 L's waiting for you out there. The good news is one will be in a bowl game We'll mail our condolences from the BCS.
WHO CARES IF IT'S NOT A HUGE BLOWOUT. ALL THAT MATTERS IS THAT IT'S A WIN.
Every team is out to beat BYU. Every team will give us our best shot. To only hold them to 3 points is sensational!
Can't wait to see them play TCU!!
As for BCS--I think BYU has a good chance to get into a BCS bowl, but they will never be allowed to play for the National Championship. When BYU won The National Championship in 1984, the BCS was formed to make sure that didn't ever happen again. These guys want to make sure that no National Champion ever comes out of any conference other than the "big" conferences they control.
Having said that--I hope I'm wrong and BYU gets a chance again someday.
P.S. My self esteem isn't based on whether my college wins a game or not. I hope a few people on these blogs can stop living their lives vicariously through a team full of guys who most of them have never even met. Sports are ENTERTAINMENT. That's all. It's a lot of fun and I like to see BYU win, but my life doesn't hang on it.
IT'S ONLY A GAME PEOPLE!
Not much change in Sagarin rankings for the top 3 in MWC:
12. Utah (SOS 72)
13. BYU (SOS 121)
14. TCU (SOS 91)
Congrats to BYU for doing what was needed. You "arm chair QB's" need a life other than BYU....
BYU needs to do something quick to get that groove back, or else thursday night may be a little unsettling. Utah needs to figure something out offensively, and I would start with Johnson or their game in Albequerque in a few weeks will be unsettling.
As for UNM, they are finally 100% healthy with their star studed running backs. UNM put up the fight that everyone at the beginning of the season thought they would as a healthy team. That doesn't excuse BYU's offense for showing no sign of intensity or excitement. And is it just me, or does it appear they have gotten very conservative in play calling since the 2nd quarter of the USU game?
Offense? Overrated. Again, coaching. Why? How many times did Harvey touch the ball in the first half when UNM's running game was keeping the ball away from BYU's offense? Duh!
BYU has top-10 talent on the field. They just need top-10 talent in coaches' game planning--AND the ability to adjust DURING a game.
New Mexico plays such an exciting game. I turnes to the baseball games for some action. They are the full definition of a boring team.
I tried to figure out how far down the three top teams would fall, while elevating the teams that had big wins, and couldn't determine where they'd all fall. Pretty complicated when good teams at the top lose AND lost to teams just outside the top 10. If you win, you should go up. If you're at the top and lose to another top 10 team you shouldn't drop too much. Leaves BYU in a pickle.
I won't be surprised if the pollsters allow 2-4 teams below BYU to jump over them, knocking them out of the top 10 in the AP poll and to around 10 in the USA poll. However, a 3 on defense is pretty impressive, maybe reinforcing memories of our two shutouts. That could help us to maintain, or even move up, depending on how far they drop some of those top 3 that lost.
I'd be surprised if TCU doesn't make it into the top 25 in one of the polls. They're 6-1, with their only loss to Oklahoma.
Simply read the number of Utes on this article trying to belittle the Y win, and then go to the other one and try to find yourself any negative comments going towards the Utes that doesn't start with a Ute going after BYU...again....
Hey little brother on the hill. Mommy has some fruit snacks for you.
Ute fans are so insecure. I think if I jumped in front of one and said boo they'd have a heart attack.
Colorado State should have won that game. They had 2 perfect passes in the end zone that were dropped that would have put them up. TCU has a good pass rush defense, I'll give them that, but Colorado State moved the ball on them. Their backup quarterback is a good athlete, but shows lack of experience.
It'll be a tough game for BYU, especially on the road, but I think they'll pull it off by winning the turnover margin.
There are some good teams in the MWC that will bring their best game against BYU and if you're expecting BYU to blow out every team, then you're in for alot of disappointment.
CSU looked like a threat against TCU. I was impressed with the RB and their defense was fairly tenacious at times. We all know that TCU and Utah are good and don't count out Air Force and UNLV. As Bronco has said, the rest of the games on the schedule are going to be hard fought.
So, all you folks that are cracking on the Cougars for "not looking like a top 10 team" layoff and enjoy the wins and the ride!!
Lest you forget, utah still needs to play UNM. Expect an L if your offense can't play better. That UNM defense is the best one BYU has faced this year. Probably the best even after November 22.
They won by three scores! That's not just a win, it's domination. Would you feel better if they won 51-33? Because it's still 18 points. Watch some other games by top ten teams and you will see that they struggle too during their games. It was a solid game.
PS: Please don't boo Mendenhall. Do you want him to go away?
SEC85% (28-5)
Big 1279% (38-10)
ACC76% (32-10)
Big 1076% (31-10)
MWC68% (23-11)
NDame67% (4-2)
Big E65% (22-12)
avg60% (269-179)
Mid-Am51% (29-28)
WAC50% (17-17)
Indep48% (12-13)
Pac-1046% (13-15)
ConfUSA37% (16-27)
SunBelt28% (8-21)
Notice how far down the Pac-10 is because of the MWC's dominance over it. However, notice the MWC is barely above average! And, the MWC is barely above the Big East.
The SEC is obviously the cream of the crop, in spite of not having as man highly ranked teams as the Big 12 (which might change today).
For those who think only the BCS wins/losses are important in comparing conferences, you're discounting non-BCS wins over BCS opponents! And, that happens every year, even from teams not in these 12 conferences.
Now, in spite of these stats, I'll betcha the Pac-10 teams' SOS ratings on average are above the MWC teams'. Computer rankings are as useless as it comes. Polls aren't much better, but at least BYU won one using them!
"Now son, you need to stop worrying about what your big brother is doing and go out and find some friends"
Nations longest winning streak. Keep it up!!
NCS - Texas vs. Alabama
Fiesta - OU vs. BYU
Sugar - Florida vs. Ohio St.
Rose - Penn St. vs. USC
Orange - VA Tech vs. Big East Champ (who knows??)
TCU scores a touchdown on defense or special teams. Three BYU drives stall with field goals.
TCU 24 Utah 10
Utah's anemic offense scores a touchdown in the fourth quarter to cut into a 24-3 lead.
Go Horned Frogs!
Beat someone with a winning record and not a direction in it's name. No one out of Utah take BYU or Utah serious
Utah 14th
2. My concern about the Cougs over the past two games is that they are having trouble with sustained intensity or concentration. It's as if they are turing it on and off throughout the game. UCLA and even Wyoming to a lesser degree was a very consistent game from beginning to end. But against USU and NM it seemed that the Cougs didn't have their heads in the game on several series. But they did bring it when they had to - that last defensive stand was top 5 worthy. The challenge it appears with this team is to keep them up and focused for every drive. We will need that Thursday and as the season progresses.
3. I don't think we'll slip and may even move up a notch or two as 3 top ten teams lost. Sportscenter type of highlights are focusing on the nation-leading win streak and that's what most voters hear. Being stuck on the Mtn. may become an actual blessing regarding votes.
Look to BYU's defense to force 2 turnovers, one interception and one fumble. TCU has a good defense but BYU's O-line is the best pass protection in the country. You might see one sack at most by TCU, but Max makes good decisions in the pocket, so it's very difficult to get to him.
My prediction:
BYU 24
TCU 13
Stop this nonsense football lovers !
Consider the following;
The State of Utah has 2 teams in the NCAA I-A ranked in the top 15 , Weber State is ranked 22 among the 1-AA schools , Snow College is the 2nd ranked team in the nation among Junior Colleges.
That written, it is my opinion that we should be whooping it up for future " Blue Chip ", recruits who absorb the reality of positive exposure the state offers and for the high quality of football played here. That thought alone should prove to be for the overall good for football and the future of the game within the state of Utah for each school on every level and their fans.
Get out the smelling salts boys aand girls, we shoould strive to get along and be proud of the football programs offered here.
Bronco's thinking too much on the sidelines.
This is not a team that can rely on the defense to get lucky to win games. The slightest whiff of a single call in a game like this and they are finished.
The offense must dominate against TCU and Utah.
But the computers have already announced that an undefeated BYU or Utah team will not beat out an undefeated BSU team for the BCS.
Las Vegas bowl against Arizona. Whoopee.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- No fractures on Emery's foot 10:07 a.m.
- Reports: Modest but steady growth 10:02 a.m.
- Stocks hold gains after econ reports 9:59 a.m.
- Ontario Mormons' nativity scenes 9:41 a.m.
- Rabbis join NJ gay marriage debate 9:03 a.m.
- Afghan buildup on faster timetable 9:01 a.m.
- Salahi denies crashing W.H. party 8:58 a.m.
- Suspect in police slayings killed 8:55 a.m.
- Arrests made in Roy slayings 8:35 a.m.
- Bowden meeting with school officials 8:01 a.m.
- Hall reprimanded by MWC
- Utes won't respond to Hall
- Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
- 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
- Mitchell called intelligent, controlling
- Cougs begin bowl preparations
- Y. student vanished in China
- Max Hall issues apology
- Daughter: Mitchell fed me my pet
- BYU says Hall incident resolved
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
900 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime
481 - Hall reprimanded by MWC
386 - Max Hall issues apology
382 - Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
321 - Utes won't respond to Hall
264 - BYU is champion of the state
140 - Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
123 - Cave to be sealed with body inside
120 - BYU says Hall incident resolved
114
Is Angels Landing perhaps Utah's single most dangerous hiking trail? The...
The really pathetic thing about all this is that the most rabid fans on both...
Hall should be suspended, in his alleged apology he said he meant what he...
We will lose more respect??? Right...... The kind of respect that we have...
I am a Utah graduate and did my graduate work at the Y. Despite the latter,...
You know something, I fully agree, that a ample and easily available consumer...
CALLING everyone who is PERFECT...please STAND UP! Weird...nobody is moving....
I agree that today we tend to over-sanitize things to the point where people...
The person that died barged into Rahimi's home with a knife. Rahimi in my...
"Nice girl, but about as sharp as a sack of wet mice." – Foghorn...
I wonder what would happen if christians tried to do the same thing in saudi...



