Reader comments
Gubernatorial debate mostly civil
36 comments | Read story
Jason has called for a federal detention facility in the west to house federal prisoners. Only those convicted of a crime would be housed in this facility.
He concurs with the Western Governor�s Association, which passed a resolution calling for the federal government to build a facility to house its own prisoners. Federal prisoners who are not violent criminals are often released because there is no prison space to hold them. The detention facility would house those who are convicted of federal crimes � whether or not these people are illegal aliens.
Jason has ALSO suggested that tent facilities similar to those in Arizona are good enough for our soldiers in Iraq and should be good enough for our federal prisoners here at home.
It is the MEDIA putting words in both Gov. H and Jason's mouths.
I did have to laugh though; Jason Chaffetz didn't say, "...round up illegal immigrants and put them in tent concentration camps surrounded with barbed wire," either. So, if Jon Huntsman and the WGA didn't say it and Jason Chaffetz didn't say it, then who did say it? Where can I find the source with that exact quote, outside of those trying to discredit Jason Chaffetz?
He has also underfunded medicaid during his tenure. Compared to other states we have a very poor record with funding medicaid. For every Million we spend the Feds matched it, sometime on a three to one ratio. So little could go a long way. Yet he wants affordable health care for everyone and it should be "a right, not a privilege?"
'Both men said affordable health care should be "a right, not a privilege."'
How can they justify the right to tell people what they may receive in return for their labor?
I think Springmeyer has a point about the Governor not standing up to the legislature.
He's ok in my book although I usually vote democratic.
Come on arc, you seem like a smart person. Don't lose your soul trying to save Jason's political career which at this moment is very much in doubt.
"It is the MEDIA putting words in both Gov. H and Jason's mouths."
Governor Huntsman clearly stated of Chaffetz's plan: "I think that on its face it�s an extreme idea," and "I heard somebody reference the Western Governor's model. I was involved with drafting that with (Arizona Governor) Janet Napolitano. We talked about a regional correctional facility to handle some of the overload that the states can't handle. Nobody talked about tent cities with barbed wire fences around it."
Jason Chaffetz stated "Now this isn�t some wild Jason Chaffetz plan, this is a concurrent resolution, a joint resolution, between Republican and Democratic Governors."
No one in their right mind would support such a sick position. Huntsman and every other Governor who was involved in drafting the Western Governor's proposal are correctly outraged to be associated with (in the Governor's words) an "extremist" position.
The media isn't putting words into Huntsman's mouth when he calls Chaffetz suggestion extremist. They are not putting words in his mouth when he says that tent cities with barbed wire was never part of the Western Governor's proposal. Unlike Chaffetz, the members of the Western Governor's Association aren't crazy lunatics.
"For the sake of journalistic integrity, I hope this author can come up with the transcript in which Chaffetz calls for "concentration camps surrounded with barbed wire." Let's be honest, even those running for office and those who are in office aren't dumb enough to say something like that."
It has nothing to do with journalistic integrity. It is completely appropriate and ethical to call it what it is. If it is a concentration camp you call it a concentration camp.
If it's a dungeon under a house than you call it a dungeon. We can call what Joseph Smith went through at "Liberty Jail" a jail or we can point out that he and those with him were kept in a dungeon. Just because those who put him in the dungeon didn't want to call it that wouldn't make it any less true.
If Chaffetz never used the word "prison" and always referred to it as a CITY would it make it any less of a prison? You people are really sick and I'm glad Huntsman denounced the claim that he's associated with it and I'm glad McCain did the same in 2000 when another nut proposed it.
"Catching arc in a lie or watching her flip-flop never grows old."
Lying is part of her character. To claim that Jason Chaffetz has not proposed creating a "tent city" to house illegal immigrants is a lie. To not call this proposal an effort to create concentration camps to house illegal immigrants and their families would be an injustice because even the Germans called their concentration camps prisons but that didn't make them any less a concentration camp.
"Only those who commit crimes will be in tent cities surrounded by barbed wire. Jason continually says 'fugitive aliens' will be imprisoned. That means women and children."
Concentration camps are dehumanizing, disgusting and immoral. Those who support them are evil. It's one thing to create regional correctional facilities to house criminal aliens who have been apprehended and convicted in our state criminal justice systems and another to create concentration camps.
"Come on arc, you seem like a smart person. Don't lose your soul trying to save Jason's political career which at this moment is very much in doubt."
This is why Huntsman and other Republicans don't support his plan. His proposal is evil and immoral.
"And I will for the first time vote Democrat. Not for Mr Springmeyer, but for Bennion Spencer. Jason Chaffetz scares me."
Ditto. This guy is out there. I don't want to see someone like him in Congress especially since he doesn't even live in my district yet he's running here.
I don't want to vote for Spencer but the more I learn about him the more I like him.
It seems that he is a social conservative and fiscal moderate. There are Republican candidates who agree with him so I'm going to vote for him.
According to the supporters of illegal aliens the State prison is also a concentration camp.
Your using ticky-tack arguments trying to keep this country from enforcing their laws.
"What difference does it make if Illegals who break the law are sent to state prison, or a Federal regional prison?"
I support regional correctional facilities to house those who are in the process of being deported. What I do not support is concentration camps where men, women and children are housed in tents with barbed wire fences. It's dehumanizing, disgusting and immoral.
"According to the supporters of illegal aliens the State prison is also a concentration camp."
Name a single person who thinks that prisons are the same thing as a concentration camp? Jon Huntsman who supports regional correctional facilities made it clear that he considers these so-called tent cities to be extremist.
"Your using ticky-tack arguments trying to keep this country from enforcing their laws."
This has nothing to do with enforcing the law which I want to see enforced as much as the next person but to suggest that we have to become soulless and evil to do so is wrong. Anyone who has lived through such camps know full well that they aren't prisons. Representative Honda of California lived in one as a child so he knows what it's like. Many others do too.
Even Jason's democrat opponent started this contest with requiring fines, English and a line of some sort on the way to being a citizen.
Well that was dropped off of his website when he started getting help from La Raza, JACL and Mr. Honda. Honda never even talked to Jason, nor saw anything Jason had written or listened to him. He based everything from La Raza. La Raza is hardly neutral.
The guy behind JACL's comments was someone that lived in Utah and had been president of the board of Alpine Country Club. What? Did Jason hit him with a Golf Ball?
Huntsman made the mistake of quoting the media, and not Jason. He has been notified of the error.
There are millions of people from around the world who seek to legally become a citizen of the United States of America.
Because these "tent cities" aren't prisons. Calling them prisons doesn't make them prison anymore than the U.S. calling the Japanese internment camps by other names such as Assembly Centers, Relocation Centers, Detention Centers and Internment Camps make them anything except internment camps. Some of us, rightly, call them concentration camps.
These "tent cities" are nothing more than your version of a concentration camp.
If you would like to call them something else that is fine but their purpose is clear. We didn't even force Japanese-Americans to live in "tent cities" surrounded by barbed wire fences.
"According to the supporters of illegal aliens the State prison is also a concentration camp."
If these tent cities came even close to the Japanese American internment camps, or to prisons we wouldn't be calling them concentration camps. We might call them something more benign like Relocation Centers and delude ourselves into believing that they are prisons.
"Your using ticky-tack arguments trying to keep this country from enforcing their laws."
That's what people said about those who opposed the internment camps. Wonder why?
It would not house children. Let me repeat that, it would not house children. Using families and the fear factor is ticky-tacky excuse to stop construction of a Federal holding center. I find the use of lies involving Children deplorable.
The State prison has walls and barbed wire. Thus according to pro-illegal organizations it also is a concentration camp.
No one has complained about Maricopa County in Arizona using tents to house prisoners.
Even worse, you have allowed our brave men and women the past 100 years to live in tents while defending this country. To object to a temporary facility to house illegals that break the law, while being processed, is a slap in the face to every man or woman who served this country, and lived in tents.
Huntsman never worked a day in his life. He cares very little about the problem because he can't identify with the poor and middle class Utah worker.
While I agree that Gov. Huntsman failed to catch the gotcha trap set about immigration by those wanting to twist Jason's comments, I will strongly disagree about your statement about Jon Huntsman Jr.
The first time I saw Jon and his wife to be, was over 30 years ago. I don't always agree with Jon Jr., but he has not had the "easy" life you think. Yes he was Jr. Class Pres. in high school.
His father is one of the most respected person I have ever met, and overall, he has reason to be proud of Jon Jr.
"Jason proposed solutions, and while not perfect, are better than his opponents."
Chaffetz' opponent, Spencer correctly proposes that we utilize technology to prevent the flow of illegal immigrants, crack down on employers who hire illegal immigrants and encourage lawbreaking and supports an employment verification system. Unlike, Chaffetz his plan doesn't include "tent cities."
"Honda never even talked to Jason, nor saw anything Jason had written or listened to him. He based everything from La Raza. La Raza is hardly neutral."
How do you know what Honda did or didn't do. I'm getting tired of you demonizing others so you can defend a man like Jason Chaffetz. All Honda had to do is log onto Chaffetz's website, or Google his name to read enough about Chaffetz.
To suggest that he would have relied solely on one organization is an insult to Honda who had to suffer under the hands of people like you. I will not let you insult him without responding. You are a horrible person and I would no more vote for you than I would vote for Chaffetz who is the same kind of person as you. For all we know you are Chaffetz.
A lot of people are using this distortion to further their ambitions.
Honda, Huntsman, La Raza to name a few.
The last I knew, that 2 to 5 minute conversation was still available to listen to.
My comments about Mr. Honda supporting a bill that will cost the tax payers $600,000,000.00 for immigrant and for employers to hire them was from his website, and also from the US thomas bill search site. That amount was to be spend over 6 years of time.
My comments re: the democrat candidate deleting English, fines and line for citizenship, before and after this broke, came directly from the candidates website. I had cut and pasted what was there, and I cut and pasted what was changed.
My comments are accurate, as long as they come from me.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Tiger opens with a 66 in Australia 1:18 a.m.
- Crash kills Utah County man 1:12 a.m.
- UCAT cheaper education option 1:12 a.m.
- Post office to be named for Rex Lee 1:11 a.m.
- Police probe synagogue vandalism 1:09 a.m.
- New charges added in fraud case 1:09 a.m.
- Mom takes plea deal in girl's beating 1:08 a.m.
- Drug trafficking operation busted 1:07 a.m.
- News yule writing contest starting up 12:59 a.m.
- Alpine District school honored 12:59 a.m.
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
- 'Love story' of crash victim ends
- Utah Jazz have a problem at point
- BYU football recruit turning heads
- Alta's Ohai is Ms. Soccer 2009
- Prep football: Felt's Facts Week
- 12 Utes return to Texas
- Cougars' defensive hoops clinic
- Long days for BYU interns
- Wyoming writer amazed by BYU
- House passes health care bill
287 - SLC council OKs gay rights policies
246 - TCU showdown has big implications
193 - Senators want food tax restored
157 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
155 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
119 - S.L. vote pending on gay protections
109 - Pratt pleads not guilty to sex charges
101 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
92
This week, I'm compiling my annual list of restaurants serving...
Beck, Hannity, and Limbaugh get the audience they deserve and vice versa. ...
I find the rule,very discriminitory. I am not gay, I don't understand what...
I understand we were outmanned last night. However, this effort was awful....
My advice to Jonathan is shoot it when they pass it to you as soon as you...
Maybe they should try drafting a shooting guard who can shoot from outside ....
The sad thing about it is that there are actually people out there that are...
Thank you TCU and BYU. Your wanting to beat Utah so bad has to drive you...
Play fes and koufos. Look to the future. It looks like we will have two...
Oh come on. Obama's a horrible president, but I couldn't care less which...
"We had the best soccer of any place in the state. There's no disputing...



As for illegal immigration they are both on the same page. They both have positions that make them enablers because they feel that the federal government, being unable to pass "Comprehensive Immigration Reform," (Commonly referred to as Amnesty) is the problem. Huntsman made it known to the Utah legislators that any serious restricts on illegal immigration in Utah would be vetoed. These were laws restricting the use of fraudulent IDs, restrictions on employment, and support of federal law enforcement.
Both Springmeyer and Huntsman are so bad, in my opinion, the only thing left to do is to vote for "SuperDell" Shanze (Libertarian) as a protest vote. Springmeyer may even get fewer votes than Superdell, if voters put a little thought into it.