Reader comments
Charles Krauthammer: History likely to recognize Bush's internal fortitude
23 comments | Read story
They make the assumption that the Truman historical model will apply to any other president.
Truman served in combat in WWI. He was a long term senator and was called to be Vice President. Left in the dark by Roosevelt he never the less finished the job of WWII and rebuilt Europe and Japan. The North Korean invasion was dropped in his lap and he committed the US to that vicious fight. He won a reelection everyone was sure we would not. Factual
accomplishments.
Unless George Bush has a secret list of his own hidden in his desk he will have to stand on the record that is all too obvious. Iraq, Katrina and now the disastrous response to the housing bubble collapse. These failures alone will condemn him to the basement of history.
This is something that the columnist, as a former practicing psychiatrist, would have recognized, were he not so enchanted to be given a personal audience with the Grand and Glorious Omnipotent Decider Guy.
I vividly recall a column written by Krauthammer a number of years ago in which he chastised those who claimed to understand the hidden logic of "history." Now he deploys the "history will redeem the Dear Leader" riff with the dutiful reverence we'd expect to see in a North Korean state-employed propagandist.
Bush's legacy is two failed and unnecessary wars, the evisceration of the Bill of Rights, and the demolition of the economy.
Fact: We haven't been attacked by terrorists on our soil since 9/11.
Fact: Bush removed the world's worst living tyrant from power, against the self-serving wishes of a few countries with under-the-table deals with hte monster.
Fact: The entire world's intel agencies were almost completely certain that Saddam had active nuclear, chemical and/or biological WMD programs underway.
Fact: Saddam had broken virtually every UN Resolution passed against him, even those promising removal from power if he did so. Bush was leading the way in COMPLYING with those Resolutions in taking Saddam out and liberating Iraq.
Fact: The current investment banking meltdown is directly traceable to the bad loans that the Democrats demanded, through law, that the financial industry make to supposedly discriminated groups. What we are seeing is the direct result of what happens when you force banks through socialist government meddling to make bad loans.
The Iraq War has created more enemies than it has destroyed. People who uesd to admire the USA now hold is in contempt- and are more sympathetic to the terroists than to the cause of freedom. The new Thomas Friedman book "Hot, Flat and Crowded" exlains how the US has let our foreign policy be misguided by our addiction to oil and this had empowered our enemies- and Bush has really fed into this.
It is also quite dubious that the government which remains when we leave Iraq will be sympathetic to the US at all- they side more with Iran than America currently. We pay our enemies in Iraq not to attack us. What will happen when we leave.
History will correctly judge Bush about the way most Americans do now- at the bottom of the trashheap.
2)Saddam and his execrable sons were willing to abdicate *before* the invasion through the mediation of the Arab League. Bush was aware of this, but determined to wage an illegal aggressive war anyway.
3)Every intel agency, including the CIA, was intensely skeptical of Bush's claims regarding Iraq WMD, but willing to take the word of the US President on the matter. A liar can't claim his lies were vindicated as truth simply because they were believed.
Leftist groupthink is almost as obnoxious as the Bushcult equivalent, but not as deadly. I'm not a leftist of any sort; I'm a philosophical constitutionalist and practical libertarian. Most importantly for this discussion I'm a lover of my country who is mortified by what that inbred little corporatist tool and his claque have done to it.
Any terrorist worth their salt uses an attack to accomplish an objective - not just for random mayhem. The purpose of the 9/11 attacks was to draw us back into the middle east and (hopefully) trigger an uprising that would overthrow the King of Saudi Arabia and overthrow the powers in the middle east that (tolerated and did business with) America. Osama's plan failed in that regard. We did fall right into the trap however.
I don't put a much stock into the fact we haven't been attacked again. The next attack will be nuclear and they just don't have that capability yet but they will and it's going to be ugly.
"Bush's legacy is two failed and unnecessary wars, the evisceration of the Bill of Rights, and the demolition of the economy."
But he saved your sorry butt from a terrorist attack since 9/11. Of course, that would also count as a negative Bush accomplishment.
The first unnecessary war, Afghanistan, will be in the Obama column (if elected). He's already taken on that mantle. The second, Iraq, is a win.
Bush's effort re the Bill of Rights was to make sure that terrorists could not get access to the benefits of our own Constitution and by so doing, finish us off in a bloodless war.
"Your facts are opinions. For example, the "bad loans democrats demanded through law" is a fantasy in your own mind. 80% of the bad loans were made by totally unregulated financial institutions and weren't forced by anyone to do anything."
You've never heard of the liberals' anti red-lining policy?
Massive debt - As I read the Constitution, the US Congress is in charge of the national budget/debt.
Two Wars - Here again, declaring war is the bailiwick of the US Congress. And they did. Read the joint resolution "Authorization to use Force in Iraq." The Afghanistan War was a NATO action.
South American takeover - Your only salient point. the Dumbocrats would have accomplished it much faster.
Nationalized health care - Hillary tried this and America rejected it. Why would Bush be stupid enough to try it again? Besides, most of the "Americans" with no health insurance are illegal aliens.
Richest portfolio - Robin Hood died a long time ago. Many say he never existed until the Dems came on the scene to redistribute wealth.
Third world - Wait'll Osama get in as pres. if you want to see third world in the US. The white House will be painted a different color and moved to Kenya.
Americans in prison - A large share of inmates are illegal aliens. Are you suggesting that Bush should have turned them loose?
Fact: 60 years had passed from Pearl Harbor to our latest attack on American soil. Celebrating how Bush has kept our country safe is pointless since attacks on American soil aren't very common.
Fact: So Saddam is gone, Osama Bin Laden, the man responsible for 9/11 is still alive.
Fact: U.N. Security Council just prior to the war, made reference to the aluminum tubes. But a report released by the Institute for Science and International Security in 2002 reported that it was highly unlikely that the tubes could be used to enrich uranium. Powell later admitted he had presented an inaccurate case to the United Nations on Iraqi weapons, and the intelligence he was relying on was, in some cases, "deliberately misleading."
Fact: We were misled into the Iraqi War.
Fact: Fighting wars with every little country that disagrees with us, has a different form of government, or has a dictator, is not smart. It is both expensive and unrealistic. We cannot continue to succeed as a world power if we continue to act as the lone policeman of the world.
Fact: Our current economic status is not the direct result of just one political party.
Truman was plagued by influence-peddling scandals during his administration. In the aftermath of the WWII, under Truman, inflation was rising 6 percent a month for a time.
The 'Truman Doctrine' to counter communism was directly responsible for both the Korean War and, later, Vietnam.
The 'Marshall Plan,' which rebuilt Europe, came not from Truman, but from George Marshall, then the Secretary of State, but before that the Secretary of Defense during WWII.
[During WWII, both Churchill and Stalin wanted Marshall to be the Supreme Allied Commander. But Roosevelt appointed Ike instead, because he couldn't bear to lose his most trusted advisor].
In other words, Truman was a mixed bag as President.
So, too, was Lincoln. Lincoln was the only president to suspend habeas corpus.
And, of course, Roosevelt put 110K Japanese in internment camps for 3 years.
We leave it to history to judge presidents because when you just lived it it's all a little too fresh for any of us to be very unbiased.
Fact: Muslim terrorists have promised many more attacks on American soil. Most people who know, report that they fully expected another terrorist attack within one year from 9/11.
Fact: If Obama is lucky enough to get Osama, another will rise to take his place. I personally don't think Obama will go after Osama. They could be related.
Fact: Saddam had WMD. The dead Kurds can supply proof. End of story.
Fact: Congress authorized the Iraq war.
Proof: The wars in Afghanistan and Iraq are against world-wide terrorism. Fact: Clinton's preemptive war in Serbia/Kosovo was to come to the aid ethnic Albanian Muslims.
Fact: Senator Chris Dodd, head of the Senate Finance and Banking Committee and Barney Frank, head of the House Finance and Banking Committee screwed up. They are responsible for policy and laws governing the finance industry.
Fact: So in other words, it's pointless to capture the most wanted man in the world since another will just take his place? Right...
Fact: Where are the weapons of mass destruction again? Prior to the war, weapons inspectors found no weapons of mass destruction. You could even look it up on Wikipedia, even Colin Powell(republican) admits that he misled Americans and Congress for the war.
Even if Iraq had and hid them(which no evidence of them having such weapons was found prior to the war), we've had plenty of time to find them!
Fact: Again, our current economic status is a mix of greedy corporations, poor regulation, bad investments, dumb Americans, loss of jobs overseas, wars, bad leadership, justto name afew.
Whether as a fool or knave he will be remembered. If as any kind of a hero, it will not be the first time that history books have told lies.
I don't support Obama either. We must free ourselves and our thinking from partisanship.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- 'Dinosaur Odyssey' an insight to life 8:44 p.m.
- Couple dies within 48 hours of other 8:44 p.m.
- E-mail illegally sent for Bridgewater 8:42 p.m.
- Smoky smell at hospital from welders 8:27 p.m.
- Panel recommends raising food tax 8:13 p.m.
- BYU football: What others are saying 7:45 p.m.
- Should districts pay union reps? 7:12 p.m.
- I-80 reconstruction finally done 6:55 p.m.
- Child porn case nets fed sentence 6:44 p.m.
- Groups celebrate Dobbs' CNN exit 6:43 p.m.
- House passes health care bill
333 - SLC council OKs gay rights policies
317 - TCU showdown has big implications
195 - Senators want food tax restored
158 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
155 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights
139 - Will state consider gay rights law?
137 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
131 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
119 - Letters: Strange breed in Utah
118
Maybe someone out there can help me understand how raising the state...
56% 3rd down conversions = Few punts. BYU leads the nation in 3rd down...
No one should be forced to pay for someone else's abortion. It's not a...
Who's the best coach in the nation? Kyle.
The State only requires the city to provide 20 psi min, not 50.
To the 6:06 commentator, In 1987 the Supreme Court ruled that religious...
There are no such things as Union Reps for teachers. Utah is a right to work...
Before we let Las Vegas have the water from Snake Valley ecosystem, everybody...
are you talking about the 528 "legal" perscription drugs deaths in Utah last...
How about solving TWO PROBLEMS at once. Put an additional "income" tax on...
Max Hall a disappointment? What's your QB rating? What's that you say, never...

