Reader comments
Congress recesses in oil-cost stalemate
59 comments | Read story
Even if BIG OIL could drill, the price would be determined by the World Market, OPEC would cut production.
The only way to secure our FREEDOM AND NATIONAL SECURITY is to end the Oil Based Economy.
The required polices must be enacted NOW.
Mandate 20% of autos be natural gas in 2009, saves 1.8 Million Barrels Per Day)
Legislation mandating 60% of Autos be electric within 10 years (saves 5.4 Million Barrels Per Day)
MagLev Train System for shipping 50% of goods within 10 years (saves 2 Million Barrels per Day)
Stop subsidizing World Wide Price of Oil through the use of the US Military, $8 Billion per month to keep 40% of the World�s Daily Oil used flowing from the Middle East.
Use the $96 Billion war expense money to fund clean renewable energy power plants, in 4 years creating 200,000 megawatts, enough to power 60% of all homes in the USA. Free power, as the cost of the war pays for the construction.
VOTE ONLY FOR THOSE WHO PLEDGE TO END THE OIL BASED ECONOMY.
Converting the 60% of autos to electric would offset all the Government Estimates for offshore and ANWR by double. Our money would be spent creating a new future with American Technology, American Jobs, American Exports.
Do your research and stop believing the GOP propaganda from BIG OIL Concerns.
Plus by ending the oil based economy we can save $700 Billion dollars used to import oil, money that would stay in our economy!
Time for all REPUBLICANS to WAKE UP TO WHAT HAS HAPPENED TO THE GOP!
This way Republicans can offer Environmentalist that for every acre of Government land needed for renewable energy power plants, transmission line easements, MagLev Train rights of way, etc. the Environmentalist can set aside a permanent no disturb acre, say in ANWR, habitat sensitive, whatever�where ever, an acre for an acre.
Next Republicans need to press for ending our dependence on all oil, both foreign and domestic, then our Nation will be Secure and Free, as will the World.
Once the GOP stops pandering to BIG OIL, everything will fall in line.
Have been Republican since I was 18, and voted for Reagan with first vote. GOP has been hi-jacked and destroyed, time for a REVOLUTION.
AN AMERICAN ENERGY REVOLUTION
Friday America wanted Congress to debate the issue, take the artificial restrictions and barriers off the books. Instead they adjourned for a vacation. We pay while they play, much like Nero fiddling around while Rome burned.
What about the Utah delegation? Our own representative Jim Matheson was the swing vote that allowed the House to cut and run.
Good heavens! These turkeys have to know that the way to attack speculation is to drill... we have seen by Bush's action that even the announcement to drill will send the price of oil and gas crassion.
For this reason alone the culprits, Nancy Peloci and Hairy Reid, should be kicked out of office next election. These people are obviously ignoring the will of the people.
And it seems they are spending their windfall wisely .. buying Republicans. You do realize that oil drilled in the US isn't automatically ours right? We don't get first dibs .. it goes into the world market. You are being manipulated.
It's always someone else's fault.
As Oil Firms Seek Drilling Access, Exports Set Record
While the U.S. oil industry wants access to more federal lands to help reduce reliance on foreign suppliers, U.S.-based companies are shipping record amounts of gasoline and diesel fuel to other countries.
A record 1.6 million barrels a day in U.S. refined petroleum products were exported during the first four months of this year, up 33 percent from 1.2 million barrels a day over the same period in 2007. Shipments this February topped 1.8 million barrels a day for the first time during any month, according to final numbers from the Energy Department.
EDUCATED YOURSELVES
1. Currently you can purchase one natural gas vehicle, the Honda Civic. It is the only one available. And it costs thousands more than the gasoline version or even the hybrid Civic. That being said, natural gas refueling stations, particularly in Salt Lake, have difficulty keeping up with the demand (low delivery pressure) resulting in cars being only partially fueled. Utah has the second most numerous supply of natural gas refueling stations in the nation. How, pray tell, could our infrastructure possibly keep up with a mandated 2009 deadline?
2. Are you suggesting 20% of new car sales be natural gas in 2009 in Utah or across the nation? There are a lot of places that don't have natural gas refueling.
3. The 1.8 million barrels per day savings only occurs after a sizable portion of the US automotive fleet is replaced. How many years until we reach your goal of 20% replacement overall, and what do we do in the meantime with all the cars that currently use gasoline?
5. Electric autos are based upon either lead-acid batteries (that need to be replaced about every 3 years) or possibly lithium-ion batteries (that lose half their capacity two years after manufacture). The fundamental problem is that the electric grid is unable to supply the current demand for electricity, let alone the additional demand of 60% of all vehicles. How would you address that issue, particularly when they want to run new lines through your neighborhood and build a substation just down the street from your house? Are you OK with that?
6. Power plants cost roughly $2000 per kilowatt capacity (with solar and wind being more). Your call for 200,000 megawatts of new capacity (needed for all those electric cars) will require an investment of around $400 billion dollars, so it is going to take over 4 years worth of that war money to build the power supply. Out of that total demand, how much nuclear power are you willing to accept? (or are you happy with 150,000 wind turbines)?
Toyota, on the other hand, fearing that the big three would develop this technology, invested their own money, time, and resources to develop their own hybrid technology. The result: Toyota developed a hybrid car that could compete in the marketplace, based upon its own merits.
Would the American public purchase an all-electric vehicle today with no government subsidies if the vehicle presented a viable solution to their transportation needs. Of course!!!
It is time to put behind us the anger and name calling. We have 2 trillion barrels of oil in oil shale in Utah, but congress won't let it be developed. We can drill for more oil, easing the transition to economically viable alternatives.
Don't limit our options.
We made the transistion from horse power to steam power to oil power without government mandates and interference. Take off the shackles and let the free market work. It alone will solve this energy problem.
"WE get the government we deserve."
Hey, they were voted into office.
Poor politicians are voted into office by good people who didn't vote.
I wish my work had a summer recess...
NO we can mandate legislation forcing conversion of older vehicles or bad mileage vehicles, this cost less than $5K per car, around $2,500 for most.
Natural gas fueling stations are unnecessary for most commuter vehicles, as 80+ percent of Americans drive less than 40 miles per day, and you can get a fueling line in your garage if you home has Natural Gas.
Funny how we can enact legislation to force people to not do drugs, to ban CFCs, to regulate alcohol, to stop spitting on the sidewalk, to up end the US Constitution (for �National Security�), to infringe upon the right to bear arms, to infringe upon private property and development rights ALL FOR THE GREATER GOOD OF THE PUBLIC.
However, when it comes to ISSUE#1 to save our Nation, Environment, and Economy, we cannot impose upon the use of burning oil for transportation fuel.
Wonder why? Think Big Oil, Bush/Cheney, GOP controlled Congress!
I am a Republican that can see and admit the Truth --- time for more of you to do the same.
VOTE ONLY FOR THOSE WHO PLEDGE TO END THE OIL BASED ECONOMY.
Currently there are 10 US made electric cars to chose from $109K to $40K, by the end of 2010 many more will be available.
Instead of subsidizing BIG OIL/the Oil Based Economy, use the $400 Billion cost for 4 years of the Iraq war to build 200,000 megawatts of renewable energy power plants.
Point is AFFORDABLE SUSTAINABLE OIL within the USA IS GONE, we used ours up since WWII. Time to face facts admit the truth and do something.
Listen to Oil executives, T. Boone Pickens, swallow your pride (as a Republican) and admit Al Gore is correct, concede the Energy issue and get on with passing legislation that moves our transportation sector off oil within 10 years.
Necessity is the MOTHER OF ALL INVENTION, this is true whether a false or real necessity, a Government mandate for electric vehicles within 10 years will force the auto makers to invest and provide the solution, or open the field to VCs that will invest and provide the solution--- I would call the US Auto Market incentive enough for capitalism to work its magic, once the mandate is in place.
Who set the SECRET ENERGY POLICY FOR THE PAST 7.5 YEARS? Who had both houses of Congress? Who squandered our good economy, global good will, and opportunity to wean ourselves off oil?
What did the GOP do when the controlled the whole shebang? The let Newt make a pact, the went to war, they made a secret pact with Big Oil.
I lived in Las Vegas, NV during 2000 election, Bush was loosing due to his support for Yucca Mountain, two weeks before the election he signs a letter to people of Nevada saying �I oppose Yucca Mountain, and we will find another solution.� Then at the end a disclaimer �Unless the scientist can show through sound science Yucca Mountain is safe.�
Bush carried Nevada and its electorial votes, which even with the Florida rigging would have handed the White House to Gore, Nevada decided the election.
Low and behold two months later, Bush supports Yucca Mountain due to �Sound Science saying it is safe.�
Anyone who lies to get into office is going to be a poor and self interested leader.
I love the GOP and am proud to be a Republican --- I just know something has run a foul for the past 7.5 years and the GOP is not the GOP of the past.
Utah�s Republican representative have done nothing but toe the party line, and seek favor with the party. They seek to get some huge and economic windfall benefit to our State through our continued reliance on OIL, because of the shale oil deposits in our State. Why keep us slaves to something controlled by evil groups and individuals.
The fault of current GAS Prices rest squarely on the GOP, for they have used the past 7.5 years to try to break into ANWR, to ensure our reliance of OIL, to ensure the profitability of BIG OIL. The GOP has done nothing but lip service to the solution to our National Security, Economic well being, and our Energy Independence.
Correct, they regulate electricity, natural gas, and other public utilities, WHY NOT OIL?
MAYBE WE SHOULD NATIONALIZE BIG OIL, OR AT THE VERY LEAST REGULATE IT LIKE THE PUBLIC UTILITIES.
BY THE WAY, WHY NOT MANDATE ALL OIL RECOVERED FROM USA SOURCES BE SOLD ONLY IN THE USA?
Good heavens! These turkeys have to know that the way to attack speculation is to drill... we have seen by Bush's action that even the announcement to drill will send the price of oil and gas crassion.
IF YOU WANT TO SEE OIL PRICES FALL OFF THE FACE OF THE EARTH, just have congress pass legislation saving 9.2 Million Barrels Per Day---3 times more than ANWR and Outer Shelf combined.
SEE POST ST. GEORGE | 5:45 a.m. Aug. 2, 2008 ABOVE
You're off your meds again. Can you please site your sources? And not Daily Kos, or other leftwing wacko site.
Drill here. Drill now. Pay less.
Yes, if we start developing our oil resources now, it will take a few years - perhaps as few as two - to actually see it in the marketplace.
HOWEVER, if the US really showed a determination today to recover those resources, you'd see prices lower then a snake's tummy tomorrow.
Drill here. Drill now. Pay less.
Who has enough courage to vote out incumbents and get some fresh blood in congress that will actually listen and do? Political power, longevity in politics, lobbyists, etc are hurting our country. Taxes are too high, national government is drawing too much money to Washington where too many decisions (bad decisions) are being pushed upon us. National government is becoming too powerful.
My vote is for those who are sincerely interested in solving problems, limiting government, lowering taxes, eliminating bad programs that are bankrupting our country, and returning some powers to the states and local communities.
Lastly, you can hardly tell a Republican from a democrat anymore. Both spend like there is no tomorrow. Both love power more than serving the people. They seem to love themselves.
>>>IF YOU WANT TO SEE OIL PRICES FALL OFF THE FACE OF THE EARTH, just have congress pass legislation saving 9.2 Million Barrels Per Day---3 times more than ANWR and Outer Shelf combined. SEE POST ST. GEORGE | 5:45 a.m. Aug. 2, 2008 ABOVE<<<
If you want to legislatively mandate auto manufacture, you may as well nationalize all energy production.
There is substantial evidence that much of the recent price run-up is from futures speculation. Announcing drilling will drive futures traders out of the market reducing prices in the near term. Which, in turn, will spur the economy back to good numbers. Dems don't want to run the risk of this happening on Bush's watch. They are not averse to making us suffer until January.
The irony is that Peloci/Reid say they want to solve the problem by attacking speculation... But they can't see that announcing more drilling (and more nuke power, tar sands, shale oil, etc.) will accomplish just that. Bunch of dummies... or in bed with Al Gore and other nut-case environmentalists. Probably the latter.
Horse pukuky, you want sources? You have been given them. Some more:
Search Yahoo News: Bush pushes offshore drilling
"Bush acknowledged it would be years before any of the oil beneath the offshore waters could be pumped, but he said "lifting the ban would create new opportunities for American workers and businessmen.""
And he mean't BUSINESSMEN, oil corp business men to be exact .. they want to continue to rob the treasury even after they are gone.
"Most energy experts and the government's own research agency at the Energy Department have said drilling in the Outer Continental Shelf, which is now off-limits, would have no impact on current gasoline prices and probably would have none for years."
It's NOT our oil once we lease it to them, it becomes whomever pays the highest price for its oil. Stop being manipulated!! They continue their "fearmongering for dollars" that got us into a war that has benefited nobody but war profiters.
Yes less than a Year!!!!!!!!!!!
There is no conclusive evidence that man causes global warming in fact there is plenty of evidence that we have nothing to do with it. The sun works just like a light that can get brighter and darker. The sun right now is getting slightly brighter. Ask yourself what gives off more heat a dark dim light or a very bright light.
Pelosi is not saving the planet she is ruining the economy for nothing. In ten years when we all realize the the Earth has not warmed we should hold a post WWII like trial and punish Al Gore, Pelosi and all their friends. Of course the economy may be in ruin then and global warming will be the farthest thing from out minds. To prove a point the hottest year on record is 1934. If there was such a thing a global warming it would be 2007. 1934 would not even register. 1934 happened long before the world started using a tons of carbon to power homes and cars.
It is the point at which the sun is at its dimmest it will last that way for about 70 years and then it heats up for about 200-300 years. The Vikings were able to farm Greenland when the sun was at its hottest point.
We can't farm Greenland now, why? Becasue it is too cold.
Ask yourself were the Vikings burning fossil fuels to heat up the Earth so they could farm Greenland?
No!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Al Gore and Pelosi and any other greeny out there go to school and learn some real science. You have no idea what you are talking about.
It seems they are stuck in the past...which is why Congresses recent Rasmussen approval rating was 9%. They must be doing something right...
NO OFFENSE, but I like the mandate and getting off oil, much better than your supply side solution. It is time to go in a new direction, 30+ years since the 70�s oil embargo with no solutions shows BIG OIL is in it for profit and nothing else.
We need a solution that offers National Security, Long Term Economic Prosperity, Job Creation that cannot be outsourced overseas.
VOTE ONLY FOR THOSE WHO PLEDGE TO END THE OIL BASED ECONOMY.
Search Energy Information Agency Department of Energy petroleum products consumption, then go look up the estimates of 1.4 MBPD from ANWR drilling and 2 MBPD from Outer Shelf drilling.
YOU CAN DO THE RESEARCH AND EDUCATE YOURSELF, instead of faithfully following the GOP Propaganda. Not a hard thing to do.
Drill here. Drill now. Pay less.
"Search Yahoo News: Bush pushes offshore drilling
"Bush acknowledged it would be years before any of the oil beneath the offshore waters could be pumped, but he said 'lifting the ban would create new opportunities for American workers and businessmen. And he mean't BUSINESSMEN, oil corp business men to be exact .. they want to continue to rob the treasury even after they are gone.'"
Businessmen? Who would you suggest develop oil resource? Non-businessmen? China? Cuba? Who?
"Most energy experts and the government's own research agency at the Energy Department have said drilling in the Outer Continental Shelf, which is now off-limits, would have no impact on current gasoline prices and probably would have none for years."
Too funny. Bush lifted the Executive Department ban on drilling... And prices immediately took a nose dive. Why? It scared the pants off speculators and they bailed.
You will here it straight forward from an OILMAN. You people along with the GOP and Big Oil will destroy this Nation, if you insist on sending $700 Billion to other Countries, friendly or not.
$700 Billion could fund an AMERICAN ENERGY REVOLUTION that ends up with our Nation being self sufficient on renewable clean energy, with new industries and high paying jobs that can only be done by someone living in America.
VOTE ONLY FOR THOSE WHO PLEDGE TO END THE OIL BASED ECONOMY.
"Who set the SECRET ENERGY POLICY FOR THE PAST 7.5 YEARS? Who had both houses of Congress? Who squandered our good economy, global good will, and opportunity to wean ourselves off oil?"
Who controlled both houses of Congress for the last two years when oil/gas started sky-rocketing and the dollar took a nose dive?
All the brainwashed DRILL HERE DRILL NOW people please search Pickens Plan."
"Drill here, drill now" is to give speculators, who ran oil/gas up, a black eye. And it will. And it will bring speculation-driven prices down. Then we can move into Pickens' plan and beyond. We need to use all the energy resources that we can get out hands on right now and in the future.
Better to look at their gross margins. Gross profit divided by gross revenues. In "bad" times (when oil was at $20 a barrel, their margins are probably around 2-3%. In "good" times it may be as high as 8-9%. Compared to Microsoft which has gross margins in the 25-30% range.
People, 8-9% profit is not a lot of money, and these companies put out a heck of a lot of costs. Can you imagine if they were to be like Microsoft and get 25% profit, your gas would be very high. When it was $20 a barrel, we were the ones profiting and not the oil companies, and they are not doing much better than that now.
Many poor countries are using government subsidies to make oil products available for their citizens. The US economy is deeply in debt, and stalled. Government subsidies don't make sense right now.
We are finding ourselves paying the unavoidable consequences of failure of leadership for the last 20 years. We had an opportunity to be prepared for this challenge, yet we elected a congress that let big business dictate policy. Let's put the responsibility for this where it belongs -- on the electorate.
We need a national LESSONS LEARNED SEMINAR which leads to a national consensus on a pro-active energy policy.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Mitchell wants testimony excluded 1:36 p.m.
- Cleveland case expands overseas 1:27 p.m.
- Banks eye tight credit card terms 1:25 p.m.
- Prep girls soccer MVPs named 1:16 p.m.
- Iran accuses hikers of espionage 1:09 p.m.
- New bishop heads Lufkin LDS Church 1:03 p.m.
- Making health care better 1:03 p.m.
- Hall, Jorgensen honored by MWC 12:58 p.m.
- 'Start knocking heads' on healthcare 12:27 p.m.
- Pac-10 reinstates Oregon's Blount 12:25 p.m.
- TCU showdown has big implications
- Seniors helped BYU regroup
- Hope for single moms
- Lambert surprisingly tops news
- TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
- Bystanders framed for child porn
- Korver and Miles to be evaluated
- Utah Jazz Extra: Whose hot/not
- Newhouse Hotel, an explosive end
- TCU moves into 4th place in BCS
- Gay advocates trek to LDS office
241 - House passes health care bill
211 - Lobo suspended
176 - Cougars crush hapless Cowboys
153 - TCU showdown has big implications
134 - Utah Jazz fall apart against Kings
130 - Thousands protest health bill
106 - Provo company innovating engines
105 - RSL rallies to advance
103 - TCU 4th in AP poll; U. 16th, Y. 22nd
99
Why do so many people live so close to refineries in Utah and elsewhere?
NASA's Stardust probe continues to bring new knowledge about the nature...
Alta vs. Bingham: Wow, what a match-up? Bingham won the first meeting by four...
Police need to be trained more and have a better understanding of people with...
Just for the record, while as far as I am aware, there is essentially no...
One per year in the whole state? That's pretty good if you ask me.
Here's why I've grown weary of the endless attacks on talk radio. Each time...
The only D1 player on MC will be Kuresa and he will not be going to Utah...
He should be in jail right now.
When will the right wing realize its impossible for someone to put themselves...
(Yawn) . . . nobody is interested on hearing how MC supposedly 'outplayed'...
I played for Timpview a few years back when they beat MC 38 to 0 in the...

