Reader comments
Utah Utes, BYU football: Utes, Cougars ranked among top 20 in preseason poll
287 comments | Read story
Eye Dee Ten Tee (Buckeye) | 1:05 a.m. June 18, 2008
The Phil Steele Poll? Get real. Why not wait for the AP or USA Today poll to run
this story.
Anonymous | 1:16 a.m. June 18, 2008
Who's this guy? Utah ranked higher than byu? Utah ranked at all? What a
joke
Comments continue below
Right! | 1:29 a.m. June 18, 2008
An 11 and 0 BYU team will DEFINITELY be the underdog when they go to visit the 8
and 3 Utes at L.E.N. Stadium!
Anonymous | 2:20 a.m. June 18, 2008
Who is Phil Steele?
Never heard of him or his rankings.
Never heard of him or his rankings.
meh | 2:41 a.m. June 18, 2008
As with all that was said about the earlier polls, these mean nothing.
Ralph | 3:23 a.m. June 18, 2008
Nobody told Phil about the great Bronco Mendenhall and his quote of the year
"qwest for perfection." How could this be, Utes ranked ahead of BYU
next year? BCS is what every cougar fan dreams of, something the Utes already
accomplished. Could it be the year of the UTES returning to the BCS!!!!!!!
We'll see | 4:03 a.m. June 18, 2008
This will be great for the Utes...until two weeks into the season when they lose
5 in a row - it's the Whittingham way! Pre-season polls mean nothing.
Go Cougs!
Go Cougs!
BBKing | 4:35 a.m. June 18, 2008
Could you imagine a season in which both teams go into Rice Eccles
undefeated?!
I know, too much to ask, but that would be incredible. And if they did, starting the year higher in the polls like this that would mean that by the time they get to November both teams would certainly be in the top ten, and the winner would be guaranteed a BCS bid!
That would be world class football right here in Utah!
And of course, they have that charity golf game between Utah and BYU coaches that goes back to Lavelle Edwards and Ron McBride. The loser in Golf has won in football since Mendenhall and Wittingham have taken over.
So that means that BYU wins in November and goes BCS hunting. And Utah whips some chump PAC10 team in Las Vegas.
Getting ahead of myself but this could be a great season if both teams play consistent and stay focused.
Of course, go BYU!
I know, too much to ask, but that would be incredible. And if they did, starting the year higher in the polls like this that would mean that by the time they get to November both teams would certainly be in the top ten, and the winner would be guaranteed a BCS bid!
That would be world class football right here in Utah!
And of course, they have that charity golf game between Utah and BYU coaches that goes back to Lavelle Edwards and Ron McBride. The loser in Golf has won in football since Mendenhall and Wittingham have taken over.
So that means that BYU wins in November and goes BCS hunting. And Utah whips some chump PAC10 team in Las Vegas.
Getting ahead of myself but this could be a great season if both teams play consistent and stay focused.
Of course, go BYU!
Phil's Steele is in his head | 5:15 a.m. June 18, 2008
Let's see, a team that finished in the top 15 and returns 10 of 11 starters
on offense should be ranked lower than a team that finished where? Please, Phil
Steele shows his bias here. THere is no justifiable football reason to rank the
Utes ahead of the Cougs. On paper the Utes are certainly not as strong as BYU.
Oh yeah, and which team won the past two seasons in head to head competition and
won the conference? Switch the two around and Phil may be on to something, but I
wouldn't put the Utes in the top 25 of college football quite yet.
Let's see how they do at Michigan first.
DHK | 5:43 a.m. June 18, 2008
Phil Steele is an idiot. Ranking The yewts at all is stupidity let alone ahead
of the Cougars. He took an over dose of his medication.
Go cougars!!!!
Go cougars!!!!
What? | 5:44 a.m. June 18, 2008
For a team that returns almost all of it's offense from a team that
finished in the top 15 last year and BYU is ranked behind Utah? How many
starters are Utah returning?
Anyways, that would be cool if the rankings hold up. It makes for a great finale for the Mountain West Conference championship. Too bad two ranked teams will be playing for the championship on The Mountain.
Anyways, that would be cool if the rankings hold up. It makes for a great finale for the Mountain West Conference championship. Too bad two ranked teams will be playing for the championship on The Mountain.
Bandaid | 5:48 a.m. June 18, 2008
This ranking will last about 1 week (if that) when the U loses to Michigan and
BYU beats a pansy team. Yeah, it's a pansy team but it's a win. Utah,
however, will drop out of the top 25 and won't see it again for the rest of
the season.
This just in | 6:10 a.m. June 18, 2008
man has landed on the moon.
???? | 6:21 a.m. June 18, 2008
Who is this guy? Utah 14th? Does he watch football?
Anonymous | 6:19 a.m. June 18, 2008
That doesn't even make sense since BYU beat Utah last season and were #1 in
the conference
Utah?? | 6:32 a.m. June 18, 2008
The Utes couldn't wipe the boots of the top 20 teams. Who is even coming
back for Utah this year? BYU at least has their QB, best WR, best TE, best RB.
Utah is due to get a dose of reality at Ann Arbor as well while BYU plays
Washington and NE Iowa (not close). Look for BYU to win the MWC and Utah to be
3rd or 4th.
And how could LSU go from number 1 to number 14? Not much in this poll makes sense.
And how could LSU go from number 1 to number 14? Not much in this poll makes sense.
I bleed Red. | 6:39 a.m. June 18, 2008
I love my Utes, but 14? Come on. Who's Phil Steele, anyway?
The Entire Country | 6:47 a.m. June 18, 2008
Riiiiiiight!!!
Finally some respect for MWC!! | 6:47 a.m. June 18, 2008
Love to see both Utah schools garner a little respect nationally. Hope it is
that way come November.
How about a matchup with both the Cougs and the Utes undefeated and in the Top 10 battling for a place in a BCS bowl with combined victories over UCLA, Michigan, Washington, Boise, etc. The first two or three Saturdays of the season will be important for both squads. Would love to see the Utes go into the Big House and come away with a victory.
And what will be even sweeter is a Cougar win in RES that will burst the BCS dreams of the Kyle and the boys and propel the mighty Cougs back into national prominence.
All the best to both teams in the upcoming season!
How about a matchup with both the Cougs and the Utes undefeated and in the Top 10 battling for a place in a BCS bowl with combined victories over UCLA, Michigan, Washington, Boise, etc. The first two or three Saturdays of the season will be important for both squads. Would love to see the Utes go into the Big House and come away with a victory.
And what will be even sweeter is a Cougar win in RES that will burst the BCS dreams of the Kyle and the boys and propel the mighty Cougs back into national prominence.
All the best to both teams in the upcoming season!
Conversation Starter | 7:07 a.m. June 18, 2008
It's nice to see a couple of MWC teams ranked in a pre-season poll, but, as
I've said before, pre-season rankings are meaningless because nobody really
knows how good the teams are until they've played a few games.
Until then, it's just on-paper guess work.
I would like to know who Phil Steele is and his rationale for his rankings. Maybe we can get an update from a brave soul willing to shell out a few bucks to read Phil's magazine.
I would have ranked BYU about 14th and Utah about 20th. Ohio St. should be the pre-season #1.
Until then, it's just on-paper guess work.
I would like to know who Phil Steele is and his rationale for his rankings. Maybe we can get an update from a brave soul willing to shell out a few bucks to read Phil's magazine.
I would have ranked BYU about 14th and Utah about 20th. Ohio St. should be the pre-season #1.
JIMI | 7:07 a.m. June 18, 2008
nice ranks. lol love it!
keep cryin zoobs. its funny
keep cryin zoobs. its funny
BlueCoug | 7:14 a.m. June 18, 2008
Don't take the Utes lightly.
The Utes could surprise a lot of people this year, like they did against UCLA last season, or they could have another one of those up and down seasons where they drop a couple like the did against UNLV.
I'm waiting to see how they do against Michigan.
Regardless, they'll probably be BYU's toughest game this year.
I'll post my pre-season rankings in August when more people are tuned in to football.
The Utes could surprise a lot of people this year, like they did against UCLA last season, or they could have another one of those up and down seasons where they drop a couple like the did against UNLV.
I'm waiting to see how they do against Michigan.
Regardless, they'll probably be BYU's toughest game this year.
I'll post my pre-season rankings in August when more people are tuned in to football.
Nothing To Do | 7:21 a.m. June 18, 2008
Wow, there really is nothing to do but fantasize about sports right now...
50 days to the olympics...
74 days to college football...
Whatever will we do, but daydream and bicker for the rest of the summer?
Oh, there is always baseball or soccer. NAH!
50 days to the olympics...
74 days to college football...
Whatever will we do, but daydream and bicker for the rest of the summer?
Oh, there is always baseball or soccer. NAH!
Stupid Comments | 7:28 a.m. June 18, 2008
Look, now one knows who Phil Steele is is a fine comment, but to state that
because Bronco said "(Qwest?)quest for perfection" that such will be
true has got to be one of the most ignorant comments I've ever heard...
BYU has the easier schedule of the two teams which might add to such a quest, but remember getting out of the MWC undefeated will not be easy for any team this year. TCU, Utah & BYU all have good teams capable of upsetting anyone. Health is always an issue as well, look at the Utes, they had a great team last year but then lost several key players and ended up having a respectable year. So, having said that, if both teams stay healthy it will be a great game. Now before anymore of you BYU fans make such ignorant comments, please read, re-read and then post a comment that is not as ignorant as some of your hypocritical buddies.
GO UTES!!
BYU has the easier schedule of the two teams which might add to such a quest, but remember getting out of the MWC undefeated will not be easy for any team this year. TCU, Utah & BYU all have good teams capable of upsetting anyone. Health is always an issue as well, look at the Utes, they had a great team last year but then lost several key players and ended up having a respectable year. So, having said that, if both teams stay healthy it will be a great game. Now before anymore of you BYU fans make such ignorant comments, please read, re-read and then post a comment that is not as ignorant as some of your hypocritical buddies.
GO UTES!!
Ignorance | 7:30 a.m. June 18, 2008
You Cougar fans are really showing your ignorance here. Phil Steele puts out the
biggest Preseason College Football Magazines in the country, that is read
nation-wide by millions.
Why would Utah be ranked over BYU in these rankings? Several reasons, the first of which is the schedule. Utah has a realistic shot at beating a down Michigan team in the opener, and then has BYU and TCU at home this year.
Do you Cougar fans really think your team is that much better than a Utah team that has had a lead on you with a minute to go in the last minute for two consecutive years? Yes, the comebacks were amazing and you should enjoy them; but BYU has by no means dominated this matchup.
It also should be remembered that last year Utah lost it's best QB (BJ), best RB (Asiata), best WR (Casteel), best OL (Boone), best LB (Jianonni), and best DL (Long) for significant amounts of time to injury. Be honest with yourself zoobs; would the Cougs fair as well without Hall, Collie, Reynolds, Unga, Jorgenson, Nixon? Don't think so.
Both teams should be tough this year. Show some respect, not blind ignorance.
Why would Utah be ranked over BYU in these rankings? Several reasons, the first of which is the schedule. Utah has a realistic shot at beating a down Michigan team in the opener, and then has BYU and TCU at home this year.
Do you Cougar fans really think your team is that much better than a Utah team that has had a lead on you with a minute to go in the last minute for two consecutive years? Yes, the comebacks were amazing and you should enjoy them; but BYU has by no means dominated this matchup.
It also should be remembered that last year Utah lost it's best QB (BJ), best RB (Asiata), best WR (Casteel), best OL (Boone), best LB (Jianonni), and best DL (Long) for significant amounts of time to injury. Be honest with yourself zoobs; would the Cougs fair as well without Hall, Collie, Reynolds, Unga, Jorgenson, Nixon? Don't think so.
Both teams should be tough this year. Show some respect, not blind ignorance.
This is fun | 7:31 a.m. June 18, 2008
I doubt BYU or Utah should be in the top 20, but it sure is fun to see the BYU
fans melt down at the thought. Actually, it doesn't surprise me that Utah
is ranked ahead of BYU. They had a tough time due mainly to injuries and still
came back and had a good season. If they stay healthy... well that is always the
key. BYU is one injury away from the season Utah had last year. Injury or not,
my guess is that BYU will start off 1-2 and that will burst the bubble right
there. P.S. I am amazed that some BYU fans still haven't gotten over the
fact that Whittingham turned them down. Come on guys.
TMONEY | 7:33 a.m. June 18, 2008
How many Games did Notre Dame win last year. How could they possibly be in
someone's top 25. It doesn't lend much validity to this poll
Yewtes ranked at all | 7:38 a.m. June 18, 2008
Well if the Yewtes are 14th, then UNLV should be number 1, since they SHUTOUT, I
said SHUTOUT the hapless Yewtes who were "afraid" to tackel their
running back. Did I say UNLV SHUTOUT!!!! the hapless yewtes??
credibility | 7:57 a.m. June 18, 2008
I don't think anybody should be paying attention to this poll. Forget
where BYU and Utah are ranked, he has Notre Dame in the top 25 and how did they
do last year?????? Why did the Dnews print this???
Alma the Wiser | 7:59 a.m. June 18, 2008
Utah returns a balance of starters on both sides of the ball, with most of their
offense coming back. I
BYU only returns 3 defensive starters from a defense that was directly responsible for winning half of BYU's games last year.
Utah has a more favorable conference schedule than BYU. It is very possible that Utah will end up with a better record than BYU this year.
Utah 34 BYU 23
Go Utes!!
BYU only returns 3 defensive starters from a defense that was directly responsible for winning half of BYU's games last year.
Utah has a more favorable conference schedule than BYU. It is very possible that Utah will end up with a better record than BYU this year.
Utah 34 BYU 23
Go Utes!!
Zac | 8:10 a.m. June 18, 2008
Re: Stupid Comments, yours aren't much brighter. BYU actually has a
tougher schedule than your Little Red Ladies. Weber State ring a bell? Plus
all the best MWC teams at home. I know you like to bag on BYU because they are
playing N Iowa, but I like how all you Ute fans conveniently forget that you are
playing Weber State. And Michigan is breaking in a new coach and quarterback.
That should be a win. But here's to having two quality teams gutting it
out for the MWC Championship and the right to a BCS Bowl. GO MIGHTY COUGARS!!
grumpolman | 8:15 a.m. June 18, 2008
To say Utah has a tougher schedule when they are playing both Utah State and
Weber State is like saying my girls friend is beter looking because she has less
zits. Who cares about pre-season rankings it's the final rankings that
matter and they don't even matter that much.
RESPECT | 8:19 a.m. June 18, 2008
Good to see both schools getting some respect. Probably a little high for both
schools (I would say BYU #21, Utah #24), but at the end of the day, being
mentioned in one of the country's biggest preseason college football
magazines is an honor for both schools. All the BYU fans freaking out on here
should calm down. I'm seeing a BoM pride-cycle coming on in Provo if
you're not more careful. You are one big hit on Max Hall away from going
7-5. Be humble and respectful, and your team will have a great season.
grumpolman | 8:17 a.m. June 18, 2008
The cougars program is on the rise and the utes are going downhill, when the
cougs win in RES that is what really matters.
sob | 8:21 a.m. June 18, 2008
it would be interesting if the utes are favored over michigan at the start of
the year
Phil Steele | 8:37 a.m. June 18, 2008
For anyone acting ignorant and saying "who is Phil Steele?" SHAME ON
YOU if you consider yourself a real college football fan. Throughout the
country Steele is very well known and respected, and yearly publishes an in
depth magizine of College Football, viewed with much respect by millions of
fans, coaches, players, and AP writers you send in their AP top 25 ballots come
August.
RE: Zac | 8:42 a.m. June 18, 2008
Wow, talk about ignorant Cougar fan. Any half way intelligent football fan can
see Utah has a much more difficult schedule this year. And this is coming from a
BYU fan. Please think before you say something like that, and make the rest of
us look stupid.
Thanks | 8:42 a.m. June 18, 2008
Thanks D.N. for finally giving us something to fight about, the last few weeks
have been pretty dry.
However, regardless of how you feel, I would really like to hear the rational from this "expert" that nobody has heard of.
However, regardless of how you feel, I would really like to hear the rational from this "expert" that nobody has heard of.
andrewute1 | 8:49 a.m. June 18, 2008
byu fans- First of all, like it was said earlier, phil steel's magazine is
the best college football preseason magazing and is well respected around the
nation, that includes espn. I totally agree with the ranking, utah is the better
team! Yes byu won last year but if it was not for the 4th and 18 play utah would
have a 9 game winning streak going into the preseason. Utah gets back basically
everyone on offense, and has one of the best secondaries in the nation
returning. The truth is that byu gets a great offense back, but it really
hurting on defense. What happens one game if byu's offense struggles a
couple games, can the defense be there to pick them up like last year? We will
just have to see. . .
GO UTES!!
GO UTES!!
Dutchman | 8:53 a.m. June 18, 2008
I've got seven chair seats on rows 39 and 40 in Rice Eccles for my fall
football games. Can't wait to celebrate the victory over BYU and the
preacher Bronco in November!
Nate | 9:02 a.m. June 18, 2008
Not only is the Utah ranking ridiculous, but how in the world is Notre Dame in
the ranking? I think he just put a bunch of school names in a hat and pulled
them out at random.
General comment to all FANS | 9:08 a.m. June 18, 2008
BYU fans... relax... it's just a preseason poll.
Utah fans... it's a good sign, but it's just a preseason poll.
Geesh, don't y'all have jobs that you need to get to?
Cheers (as I have to get back to mine)
Utah fans... it's a good sign, but it's just a preseason poll.
Geesh, don't y'all have jobs that you need to get to?
Cheers (as I have to get back to mine)
Polls | 9:10 a.m. June 18, 2008
The only polls that matter are the USA today, AP coaches poll and the Harrison
poll. Because the coaches poll and the Harrison poll along with some computer
polls determine the BCS poll. Do yewet fans really think that they will be
ranked in either the AP poll or the Coaches preseason poll? Phil Steels polls
are made to sale magazines but they will have no influence on the AP and USA
today preseason polls. Utah will be an honorable mention in both of these
polls at the bottom of others receiving votes and BYU will be ranked in the top
25. Utah being ranked in this poll is laughable given the UNLV game last year
and looking at the ND ranking. And yes being ranked higher is an advantage if
you win your games. To make the BCS you need a final ranking of 12 in the BCS.
To have any shot at a national championship (which is only a pipe dream for a
MWC team) a MWC team would need a preseason ranking of probably 12 or higher and
still need teams ahead of them to lose. Cougars!!!
Phil Steele | 9:13 a.m. June 18, 2008
Before you ignorant cougs make yourselves look any more foolish, please google
Phil Steele. You will find that his preseason magizine is one of the largest and
most respected of it's kind. Out of curiosity, I researched the magazines
end of year accounting statement. 11.2 million in gross revenue from the
preseason football magazine alone. All of you saying that you have never heard
of him are just embarrasing yourselves. Millions do read the magazine, the
accounting numbers prove it. Please stop being ignorant Cougar fans.
Utah Rules | 9:15 a.m. June 18, 2008
The Utehs rule and we should be ranked in the top 10. Phil needs to do some
homework or something like such as.
Go Utehs, I need to get back to the counter to take some orders.
Go Utehs, I need to get back to the counter to take some orders.
hot air | 9:19 a.m. June 18, 2008
Being in the top 20 is common for the Cougs. I can see why the utes are so
excited, it's their first ranking all year.
By the way, 4 & 18 didn't win the game. It only got a first down. You still had a chance to win that game and you blew it. I don't know why utah thinks they are going to run into the BCS, they are the most hated team in the MWC. Every team saw onside kick when up by 40. The league is tired of you popping off when you've done no better than third place with Whitt. You run your mouth but never back it up. I.e. shut out at UNLV.
By the way, 4 & 18 didn't win the game. It only got a first down. You still had a chance to win that game and you blew it. I don't know why utah thinks they are going to run into the BCS, they are the most hated team in the MWC. Every team saw onside kick when up by 40. The league is tired of you popping off when you've done no better than third place with Whitt. You run your mouth but never back it up. I.e. shut out at UNLV.
Anonymous | 9:26 a.m. June 18, 2008
grumpolman,
BYU plays in Logan this year too. The polls mean nothing because both Utah and BYU will lose in Logan. Ok, maybe they wont. But a guy can dream. Go aggies!
BYU plays in Logan this year too. The polls mean nothing because both Utah and BYU will lose in Logan. Ok, maybe they wont. But a guy can dream. Go aggies!
Tokolosh | 9:29 a.m. June 18, 2008
This should create excitement that both teams are geting respect... instead the
supposedly great "football fans" of BYU are showing how disconnected
they are from the college football scene. If you discount this ranking because
you have never heard of Phil Steele then you are a college football idiot.
Preseason polls typically aren't worth much more than publicity but that
publicity can go a long way if the teams start off the season backing it up.
Especially when the pub comes from someone like Phil Steele. That carries a lot
of weight.
Anonymous | 9:34 a.m. June 18, 2008
Fans, you guys are ridiculous. If you don't know who Phil Steele is then
you aren't a college football fan. He has an annual college football
magazine that is one of the most informative. Rankings are guesses. The Celtics
weren't predicted to do much before the season but they came out on top.
Keep crying Cougar fans
Keep crying Cougar fans
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- 911 tapes of Woods' crash on Sun. 12:53 p.m.
- Zardari turns over nuclear authority 12:30 p.m.
- Landreth Seed Co. turns 225 12:18 p.m.
- Residents startle Provo burglars 11:57 a.m.
- Akron fires coach J.D. Brookhart 11:41 a.m.
- Canada engineers walk off job 11:35 a.m.
- Christmas shoeboxes for veterans 11:32 a.m.
- Roethlisberger sidelined 11:29 a.m.
- Louisville fires coach Kragthorpe 11:06 a.m.
- Houseplants can flourish 11:00 a.m.
- Cave to be sealed with body inside
- Predicting the unpredictable: BYU wins
- Vegas, Poinsettia bowls or bust
- Efforts to save a life praised
- Rivalry Week is highly profane
- Glover gives Utes last-second upset
- BYU's old uniforms?
- Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
- Cougars turn back Wildcats'
- BYU football: 5 keys to victory
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
271 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple214
- Thunder rolls by Jazz136
- Letters: Rushing to judge Palin134
- Boys basketball rankings130
- Editorial: Poor welcome for Palin113
- Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies110
- Cave to be sealed with body inside106
- Letters: Trump card for believers97
- Rivalry Week is highly profane87
It's finally time for the game that everyone has been waiting for all...
Its finally here, the big game. No matter what the circumstances are, it...
Carlos Boozer denied that playing so well against the Chicago Bulls held...
Latest comments
Please, please, please - GIVE IT A REST! Your whining and constant...
I do not know if there is gobal warming or not. I think that is the wrong...
"Non-religious shoving their beliefs down the throats of the rest of us?"...
I hope when I am in my seventies I no longer have mortgage and rent payments...
Good luck. Should be a fun game. Teams seem equal in total package even if...
Don't hate!!! BYU and Utah fans are the same - they all applied to BYU, no...
And you prefer a ruling oligarchy, who have produced nothing, created...
Why does the government need to aknowlege God? Does the government have a...
I don't think it matters what Kate Moss says... and those that are offended...
the honest truth: If this man was your loved one would you want people going...
Advertisements
Can't wait.