Reader comments
'Idol' owes apologies
173 comments | Read story
hey | 3:51 p.m. May 26, 2008
paula is very smart. she just made a mistake. it wasnt a big deal. but
seriously.. who cares about david and david. The season is over! lets move on
please. lets focus on Next season now please. i felt season 7 still ended on a
high note, with awesome ratings. and i have a feeling idol is gonna be even
better next year!
sharon | 4:00 p.m. May 26, 2008
According to David A's voice couch DA or his father never met Naomi Judd. I
tryed for four hours to vote and didn't get in one time. You would think if
he got twelve millon less votes it would be easier the same things were being
said when Clay Achkin came in second. Also isn't TMZ part of the fox
network?
According to
david
According to
david
Comments continue below
Hey,, "Hey" | 5:05 p.m. May 26, 2008
I care about Season 7 and DA & DC. If Season 8 is going to be manipulated
and fixed like this one was, then I'm one less Fan. Maybe they can move to
Canada. I'm done with AI. They owe the Archuleta's an apology a lot
more than Simon owed an apology to David Cook for singing so lousy his last
competition night. Especially when we know who out sang the night......David
Archuleta.
Ryan the real problem. | 5:16 p.m. May 26, 2008
David A is a very sweet and innocent kid, I think that way over half of the
things said went over his head. I think that the show, which is suppose to be
for family had some subtle gay jokes between Ryan and Simon. Ryan was
constantly mauling David A, to the point that I wanted to puke, best thing for
David A is to get the tour done and stay the heck away from AI and Ryan.
Marti | 5:37 p.m. May 26, 2008
It's no coincidence that the rumon was first "leaked" on TMZ,
another FOX show. It's obvious it was a plant for the purpose of skewing
public opinion. But, then again, FOX has never shied away from skewing public
opinion, aka their "Fair and Balanced News" channel.
re:owl | 6:05 p.m. May 26, 2008
Well said, thanks.
re:owl | 6:12 p.m. May 26, 2008
Yeah owl...unfortunately for a sweet 17 year old boy........you are absolutely
right. He was just entertainment. Oh what fun that was, right?
Kate | 6:19 p.m. May 26, 2008
Man, y'all are so sour losers. Get over it! He lost not because of
unfairness but because people like David Cook better. That doesn't mean
David Archuleta isn't amazing.
Wow! | 6:23 p.m. May 26, 2008
You people really should get a life. American Idol is not real. I bet you get
into arguments over General Hospital to. Take some prozac and go away.
kate | 6:38 p.m. May 26, 2008
This isn't about who was better. DC was more seasoned, he deserved to win
over DA for that reason ONLY. This is about AI manipulation towards the
outcome. It was a fixed competition from the beginning by way of song choices,
criticism, scandal, and last minute pity apologies(Simon). I didn't
appreciate how AI promoted their ratings by slamming a perfectly respectable
family. They should have nipped that in the beginning instead of letting it go
on and on. I am no sour loser, I am truly irritatede at FOX for allowing this
manipulation to happen to a 17 year old strictly for ratings....THAT IS NOT MY
IDEA OF ENTERTAINMENT.. NO SOUR GRAPES HERE, BUT I DO BELIEVE IN INTEGRITY AND
AI DOESN'T HAVE IT ANYMORE
wow | 6:43 p.m. May 26, 2008
NO I am just a David Archuleta fan that feels ripped off and today is my day
off......can't mow the lawn for the rain.......so here I am. GH got boring
after Luke and Laura left.....any other intelligent suggestions?
Re: "ANONYMOUS YOU GO AWAY" | 6:47 p.m. May 26, 2008
Don't you know that if a person doesn't leave their name that its
automatic to get bold letters named "Anonymous"?
don't make it so obvious that you're still in high school. However, it is obvious that DN's is still in denial. Let's see more articles of the real winner David Cook! Hey let's report about Donnie Osmonds oil changes and how Jiffy Lube was unfair...etc. Or how High School High's cast put less mormons on the show...lets hear some real news.
don't make it so obvious that you're still in high school. However, it is obvious that DN's is still in denial. Let's see more articles of the real winner David Cook! Hey let's report about Donnie Osmonds oil changes and how Jiffy Lube was unfair...etc. Or how High School High's cast put less mormons on the show...lets hear some real news.
Re: <~~~anonymous mishap | 7:06 p.m. May 26, 2008
my bad, no I didn't know. live and learn.
But for intelligence: YEAH LET'S PLAY THE MORMON CARD........WOW DUDE WE GOT LOTS TO TALK ABOUT, HOW ABOUT BIGOTRY, RACISM, PURITANISM, POLITICS. You Sound definitely well rounded for intelligent debate.
But for intelligence: YEAH LET'S PLAY THE MORMON CARD........WOW DUDE WE GOT LOTS TO TALK ABOUT, HOW ABOUT BIGOTRY, RACISM, PURITANISM, POLITICS. You Sound definitely well rounded for intelligent debate.
Salt Lake Jo Jo | 7:14 p.m. May 26, 2008
He lost fair and square. He's just not that good of a musician when it all
comes down to it, and doesn't sing very well. And people out
there--IT'S JUST A SHOW. LIVE YOUR OWN LIVES. There are worse things
going on in this world (China, Myanmar, here in the U.S....) Spend some energy
doing something CONSTRUCTIVE.
Tiffy | 7:41 p.m. May 26, 2008
I believe we all understand there are more important issues going on in the
world today. However, this particular blog is in regards to the article written
by Mr. Pierce about "Idol Apology". China, Myanmar etc will have to
just be brought up on a different blog. I'll catch up with ya there.. But
for now let's stay on track and admit David Cook won fair and square. And
AI acted like a normal unscrupulous TV show without moral character backing it
up simply to get the best of rating. PS: Let's talk about Saving the Polar
Bears next. ooops, wrong blog again : )
Robert | 7:45 p.m. May 26, 2008
Oh, Puhleeze! Nobody owes anybody any apologies. Jeff Archuleta, well, like
someone has said...David is almost 18. Good. Almost nothing is more nauseating
than overbearing parents insinuating themselves, trying to act out vicariously
through their [talented] children. Just back off and disappear into the
background already. And, you think AI is going to apologize? Give me a break.
Nobody knew who David was from boo before they let him on the show.
And for everyone still crying their sloppy tears: The kid lost. Yes, he can sing, and sing good, too. But, apparently 12 MILLION voters--a devastating margin--thought the other guy was better. Get over it.
And for everyone still crying their sloppy tears: The kid lost. Yes, he can sing, and sing good, too. But, apparently 12 MILLION voters--a devastating margin--thought the other guy was better. Get over it.
Kathy | 8:10 p.m. May 26, 2008
What AI producers and Simon did to DA and his family is unforgivable. The only
reason my family and friends watched the show this year was because of DA. After
what they did to him, we are done with the show. It was obvious that they set
him up to loose the title to DC.If DC was so talented, then why did Simon have
to go campaigning for him few weeks before the finale?His appearance on Ellen
show was inappropriate.THe week before the finale they gave the song that was
meant for DA to sing to DC.Everything they did was so calculating and evil. DA
was robbed of the title and the career he could have had.The only reasons they
could give for wanting DC to win was the fact that DA is young, does not have
enough experience in life, and does not know how to give good interviews.Those
are dumb and stupid excuses to take away someone's career and future. If
they are not in favor of having someone so young to be an AI, then they should
have allowed DA to be part of the competition.We thought this show is about
singing competition.I guess we were wrong.
ForkInMeDONE | 8:17 p.m. May 26, 2008
It was obvious what producers were doing. I believe they are the ones who
started the rumors about Jeff. David is better off as second and then after his
album, I hope he cuts the ties so they (FOX and ASSOCIATES) can't ride his
coat tails any longer.
Archie is a legend in the making and I'll buy his albums all day long. I won't EVER watch Idol again. This show is what gives show business a bad name!
Archie is a legend in the making and I'll buy his albums all day long. I won't EVER watch Idol again. This show is what gives show business a bad name!
American Idol Hater | 8:20 p.m. May 26, 2008
American Idol is the WORST show on television. And I'm not just saying this
because I'm a bitter Utahn, because David Archuleta didn't win. I
watched as they manipulated Archuleta into what they wanted the nation to see
him as. They spread lies about his father. And when they came to the Energy
Solutions Arena, they treated the employees there like their little peons. I was
one of them, so I know. Down with American Idol and all of their mind game
manipulations. Down with the American Idol "Kingdom".
Bill Snyder | 8:25 p.m. May 26, 2008
Oh, and David Archuleta himself doesn't owe any of us an apology for making
us watch his obnoxious smirk on Tv every week? This kid is the 21st Century T.
Buff.
Paul Gibbs | 8:27 p.m. May 26, 2008
Come on, people. "American Idol" stopped being a springboard to a
recording career years ago. I wouldn't be surprised to see Taylor Hicks
begging for change on a street corner. Once that season finale airs, your 15
minutes of fame are over, whether you win or not. Archuleta got what every
"Idol" contestant got: national exposure that will keep him popular as
an entertainer in his home state. He's a talented, likable kid who
wasn't robbed of anything and probably never would have been a big star,
win or lose.
Paul Gibbs | 8:30 p.m. May 26, 2008
The only sad or disturbing part of this is how many people posting here probably
care more about who wins "American idol" than the Presidential
election.
CMS | 8:42 p.m. May 26, 2008
Ok then hear this...time will tell who should be declared the TRUE WINNER of
season 7 AI. Archie will out sell DC in every way. Concerts and Album sales
will voice the real winner.
I agree the entire show was taken exactly where the producers wanted it to go. Whats done is done but now it is up to the Davids. Let watch and take note to see which one of them is truely the winner of this contest. I am 52 years old and a big Archie fan. Growing up in the 70's I have had my fill of Cook sound. I am refreshed by a smooth simply voice like DA and with the right direction I have a feeling this kid could actually be 10 times what Kelly or Carrie are right now. David Cook I fear will not get his greatest desire and that is longevity (remember Taylor Hicks?). Lets see what Archies voice does in time, dare I say could it get better???
PS What about voting on Saturday morning when those younger fans wont have to be in bed by 9:00. Theres food for thought!
I agree the entire show was taken exactly where the producers wanted it to go. Whats done is done but now it is up to the Davids. Let watch and take note to see which one of them is truely the winner of this contest. I am 52 years old and a big Archie fan. Growing up in the 70's I have had my fill of Cook sound. I am refreshed by a smooth simply voice like DA and with the right direction I have a feeling this kid could actually be 10 times what Kelly or Carrie are right now. David Cook I fear will not get his greatest desire and that is longevity (remember Taylor Hicks?). Lets see what Archies voice does in time, dare I say could it get better???
PS What about voting on Saturday morning when those younger fans wont have to be in bed by 9:00. Theres food for thought!
Tiffy | 9:33 p.m. May 26, 2008
Paul....again......wrong blog.
This is the Mr Pierce article. But now that you mentioned it...due to THE incompetent presidential selection list we have available I vote "GOSH" DAVID ARCHULETA FOR PRESIDENT.............WITH JEFF ARCHULETA AS HIS RUNNING MATE AND HIS BEAUTIFUL MOTHER AS THE WHITE HOUSE MOTHER. Good Night All It's been real.
CMS: YOU'RE ACES, I'M WITH YOU ALL THE WAY.
This is the Mr Pierce article. But now that you mentioned it...due to THE incompetent presidential selection list we have available I vote "GOSH" DAVID ARCHULETA FOR PRESIDENT.............WITH JEFF ARCHULETA AS HIS RUNNING MATE AND HIS BEAUTIFUL MOTHER AS THE WHITE HOUSE MOTHER. Good Night All It's been real.
CMS: YOU'RE ACES, I'M WITH YOU ALL THE WAY.
West Jordan Pete | 9:36 p.m. May 26, 2008
Wa, wa, wa. My favorite lost and now I must cast blame. Grow up Scott.
Johnny Utah | 10:00 p.m. May 26, 2008
How about the Dnews issue an apology for perpetuating the rumors about
David�s father? There were many stories in this very paper
about the instances that Scott Pierce is writing about. Quit trying to point
blame where it doesn't belong.
K | 10:01 p.m. May 26, 2008
Winning the show has nothing to do with how much money the person will make
during their career in the entertainment industry.
The show should only be open to contestants who are 18 and older. If they can sing at 17, they can sing at 18, and they won't need mommy or daddy with them.
The show should only be open to contestants who are 18 and older. If they can sing at 17, they can sing at 18, and they won't need mommy or daddy with them.
DA is not Idol | 10:03 p.m. May 26, 2008
Once again, DA is not an idol. Did any of you see the Guitar Hero commercial
whith both Davids? Seeing DA in that was just sad. Very sad. DA said that he was
okay with being a loser and for Utah not to cry for him. Please agree with this
Utah and stop beating a dead horse. Idol owes no apologies, 12 million more
people voted for David Cook. 12 million! I for one will be buying Cook's
songs, while DA songs will be only sold in Utah's Deseret Book.
grumpolman | 10:11 p.m. May 26, 2008
They should rename the show "America Can't Judge Talent".
We'll see who really won when we see their CD sales.
Pippa | 10:20 p.m. May 26, 2008
There's a heck of a lot of nonsense here. David Cook was the most popular
finalist for a good month or so. They both performed well in the final, but DC
already had the momentum. He won fair and square, and by a considerable
margin.
Jeff Archuleta deserves no apologies. He was interfering to such an extent that a ban had to imposed, and that's documented fact. Then his 'team' went on a TV & radio phone-in offensive after David (Archuleta) performed poorly throughout the semi-final. They claimed that he was prevented from singing 'Longer' with a hip hop feel, but is that really a surprise after the awful performance he gave on 'With You'?
David Archuleta has a great voice (if you can get past the nasal tone), but 'nice kid' isn't enough. He's one dimensional, crushes the melody out of everything, and crashed and burnt every time he tried anything other than ballads. His style is adult contemporary, so the little girls will tire of that before long. He'll shine brightly for a time, but let's not be daft enough to predict longevity here. He'll be a distant memory by the time his fans have left school.
Jeff Archuleta deserves no apologies. He was interfering to such an extent that a ban had to imposed, and that's documented fact. Then his 'team' went on a TV & radio phone-in offensive after David (Archuleta) performed poorly throughout the semi-final. They claimed that he was prevented from singing 'Longer' with a hip hop feel, but is that really a surprise after the awful performance he gave on 'With You'?
David Archuleta has a great voice (if you can get past the nasal tone), but 'nice kid' isn't enough. He's one dimensional, crushes the melody out of everything, and crashed and burnt every time he tried anything other than ballads. His style is adult contemporary, so the little girls will tire of that before long. He'll shine brightly for a time, but let's not be daft enough to predict longevity here. He'll be a distant memory by the time his fans have left school.
Anonymous | 10:28 p.m. May 26, 2008
Only in Utah would we even be discussing this. What a waste of time. David
Archuleta is popular here for one reason..He is from Utah. If he was from
anywhere else NO one would care.
He didn't lose because of some vast conspiracy theory..He lost because more people preferred David Cook over him and voted for him. Simon Cowell has chosen many people over the years who have not won so to say that he is responsible is ridiculous.
There is way too much evidence against Jeff to say he is innocent of the accusations but like any accusation you have to make up your own mind.
There is a feeling here in Utah that if something goes wrong it is because of some vast conspiracy..
There is no conspiracy..
The winner of Survivor is from Utah..
Move on..
Get on with it
DA Lost and that is life..
He didn't lose because of some vast conspiracy theory..He lost because more people preferred David Cook over him and voted for him. Simon Cowell has chosen many people over the years who have not won so to say that he is responsible is ridiculous.
There is way too much evidence against Jeff to say he is innocent of the accusations but like any accusation you have to make up your own mind.
There is a feeling here in Utah that if something goes wrong it is because of some vast conspiracy..
There is no conspiracy..
The winner of Survivor is from Utah..
Move on..
Get on with it
DA Lost and that is life..
Anonymous | 10:59 p.m. May 26, 2008
You can blame the producers of Idol all you want, Mr. Pierce, but its the media
-- like your newspaper -- that published these "anonymous" rumors.
Where is your responsibility?
Besides, DC is a much better performer. I thought DA was boring as can be.
Where is your responsibility?
Besides, DC is a much better performer. I thought DA was boring as can be.
yea sure | 11:20 p.m. May 26, 2008
They began humiliating David early on because he was getting so many votes...
the rumors about his dad were awful... the final voting was very fishy...when so
many people are suspicious, you start thinking, where there's smoke,
there's fire. The Paula goof was interesting. I'm not from Utah.
I'm not taking A I seriously again and I wouldn't want my kid to try out for it. OK David C is a great guy, but I don't think he was the better singer.
I'm not taking A I seriously again and I wouldn't want my kid to try out for it. OK David C is a great guy, but I don't think he was the better singer.
the brighton goalie | 11:31 p.m. May 26, 2008
In Cooks defense, I think if Archuleta HAD one AI, his career would've
ended up like Clay Aiken's or Ruben's. Making one album and then
disappearing off the radar. His lack of ability to right his own stuff and the
fact he just sings wouldn't help. At least Cook does his own stunts. Today
there isn't as much of a demand for his style, someone like Cook has a
greater chance merely because of the genres he associates himself with. I think
America made the right choice in Cook and it'll be interesting to see what
he puts out.
To Anonymous | 11:33 p.m. May 26, 2008
There are many, many people who love David A who are not from Utah. Quit
bashing the beautiful state of Utah! I'm not from Utah. Quit bashing Jeff
A.
flarda | 11:33 p.m. May 26, 2008
I agree - David Archuleta was ROBBED!! He was the best singer by far. David Cook
was good - but not unique. David Archuleta is one of a kind and I believe he
will have a much bigger music career than Cook. I loved seeing his Dad in the
audience each night, full of smiles of pride. I hate that the rumors were
started about him. I'm sure that played a part in the outcome of American
Idol... right along with Simons big complements to David A causing the panicked
Cook fans to over vote. The outcome was shocking and seemed so rigged that I
doubt I will ever watch American Idol again. They need to change their voting
system to 1 vote per person for a more truthful outcome. And they most
definately need to apologize to Jeff Archuleta. He seems like a very nice man
who is always there for his son. He has to be a good man to have raised such a
fine yourg man as David.
Thank you | 11:42 p.m. May 26, 2008
The recent comments match what I wanted to say.
Thank you Pippa, and all the Anonymous's.
Please DN-please move on. DA accepted it and since the final word (according to DN) is DA, lets agree with him, It's about time people are speaking up to all these ridiculus articles about the loser of AI.
Thank you Pippa, and all the Anonymous's.
Please DN-please move on. DA accepted it and since the final word (according to DN) is DA, lets agree with him, It's about time people are speaking up to all these ridiculus articles about the loser of AI.
sb | 12:09 a.m. May 27, 2008
So David A didn't win AI, but who knows maybe somewhere down the road there
is something even better. He and many of the other contestants have talent.
Who knows what life holds for any of them. I wish all of them the best.
Jill | 12:17 a.m. May 27, 2008
A day late and a dollar short. Watching the Jeff Archuleta situation made me
sick. Clearly he is
an incredible father making great sacrafices for
the love of his son. It was cruel and unforgiveable
of AI and I will never watch the show again. I am
glad he did not win so he can be out from under AI
using him as "their boy". He can now move on to
bigger and better things. Also, to jerk the rug under a 17 year old who is singing his heart out
by making sure bad press of his father brings up
their ratings is egregious. AI is that hard up for
ratings. Maybe this is an example of WHY.
an incredible father making great sacrafices for
the love of his son. It was cruel and unforgiveable
of AI and I will never watch the show again. I am
glad he did not win so he can be out from under AI
using him as "their boy". He can now move on to
bigger and better things. Also, to jerk the rug under a 17 year old who is singing his heart out
by making sure bad press of his father brings up
their ratings is egregious. AI is that hard up for
ratings. Maybe this is an example of WHY.
CougarKeith | 1:12 a.m. May 27, 2008
1. Does it really matter?
2. Why does anyone really care?
3. Does anyone know any Iraq soldier who has been decorated lately? I would like to know about that!!!
2. Why does anyone really care?
3. Does anyone know any Iraq soldier who has been decorated lately? I would like to know about that!!!
Katheryn | 2:00 a.m. May 27, 2008
Let's put this into perspective: Twelve million votes equals 6,000 people
with 2,000 votes each. By texting for four hours with a GoPhone and dialing via
a landline, I estimate that I got in about 2,000 votes. David A's fan base
is very diverse, but an important part of it is made up of younger fans not able
to stay up until 1:00 a.m. I would not be surprised to learn that more people
actually voted for David A, but only got in a few votes each, not understanding
the organized effort by both Davids' fan bases to maximize the number of
votes. In the end, Simon's over-the-top praise for David A and his overly
critical take on David C's performances at the finale served his wish for
David C to win. How? 1) By lighting a fire under Cook's fan base. (All
season long, harsh comments by Simon translated into more votes for that
contestant.) 2) Lulling David A's fan base into complacency, thinking that
he had this one in the bag and therefore not voting for the full four hours. I
did not take the bait, but I was concerned that others would, and I was right.
You got it | 2:16 a.m. May 27, 2008
Mr. Pierce I think your absolutely right. American Idol does indeed owe Mr.
Archuleta an apology and you're one of the first to come out and directly
say it. Well done! I mean there's entertainment but when a person's
charcter of being gets put to question then that's inexcusable! Hey
let's face it they had their fav from the beginning and were willing to
black ball anyone else to get their choice the viewers vote. Cause I don't
think David C. can sing all that great - he yells some what - but when it came
to real talent he didn't have it. But there's one good thing with
David A. not winning this thing - he's not on contract with them anymore.
The ques. now is Will the AI producers be BIG enough to apologize. Ironic David
A. sang that song with One Republic. Simon apologized to Cook, but will AI
producers be willing to do the same?
Wow... | 6:42 a.m. May 27, 2008
1 - Simon showed his support for David C from about mid-season onward, though he
still told him when he gave a less than amazing performance. Randy showed his
support for David A throughout the entire season, and never gave him a bad
review, even when he hit bum notes and forgot his lyrics on at least 3 separate
occasions.
2 - David C had been winning the vote every week for at least 5 weeks, according to multiple sources. He'd been gaining supporters every single week, whereas David A had roughly the same number of supporters all season, and rarely fluctuated in his vote totals.
3 - David C proved he could sing Broadway just as well as rock, and that he could take a boring ballad and make it contemporary. David A proved he could sing Broadway and a boring ballad in the exact same style as everything else he sang on the show.
4 - David C had the #1 album on Amazon.com, as well as 8/20 of the top songs on iTunes for weeks. "Always Be My Baby" stayed as the #1 downloaded song in the country for 6 weeks.
The real winner Did win.
2 - David C had been winning the vote every week for at least 5 weeks, according to multiple sources. He'd been gaining supporters every single week, whereas David A had roughly the same number of supporters all season, and rarely fluctuated in his vote totals.
3 - David C proved he could sing Broadway just as well as rock, and that he could take a boring ballad and make it contemporary. David A proved he could sing Broadway and a boring ballad in the exact same style as everything else he sang on the show.
4 - David C had the #1 album on Amazon.com, as well as 8/20 of the top songs on iTunes for weeks. "Always Be My Baby" stayed as the #1 downloaded song in the country for 6 weeks.
The real winner Did win.
Hello???? | 7:54 a.m. May 27, 2008
This is an interesting microcosm into life in Utah. 30+ years ago I moved to
California to work and raise my family. Upon moving, I immediately realized the
rules had changed. I could no longer put my head in the sand and ignore the
real world. Somebody should have prepared David that "Hollywood"
happens. People don't all wear CTR rings on their fingers. David seems
mature and capable, it's the rest of you enablers who are at fault for your
ignorance to life. If it wasn't for American Idol, NOBODY would know where
Murray is.
record sales | 8:21 a.m. May 27, 2008
Whether we like David C. or David A. The real truth will be in the number of
record sales. Look at the seasons where the second of third place sold more
albums than the winner. What it comes down to is $. So buy the music of your
favorite. That will see who the real winner is.
I believe that David A. will be successful and be around a lot longer for not winnin AI.
I believe that David A. will be successful and be around a lot longer for not winnin AI.
Bonnie in PA | 9:46 a.m. May 27, 2008
To: Best performer THANK YOU!!! Finally, someone I agree with!! While I am not
saying David A. was awful- every week was the same! Some sappy song that sounded
exactly like the week before, sung with his eyes closed. ( I counted- the
average per song 12! - not including regular eye blinking) As for letting the
kid know he lost by 12 million votes- not cool. He will probably go far with a
little more maturity and time to develop some stage presence.
barc | 10:02 a.m. May 27, 2008
I'm not an archuleta hater or fan, but this article is on the verge of
ridiculous. People have gone on the record about David's dad (Naomi
Campbell), and while, yeah, it's sad, that's life and that's part
of being in the spotlight. If Archie can't deal with it in the American
Idol bubble, how can he deal when the AI team isn't protecting him.
To the author: Fix the chip on your shoulder, be a good sport about Cook's win, and stop the "we got wronged" complex. Doesn't mean you have to stop loving Archieboy. I think this article is on the verge of a high school editorial rant, but hey, it gets people to comment so maybe that was the purpose after all!
To the author: Fix the chip on your shoulder, be a good sport about Cook's win, and stop the "we got wronged" complex. Doesn't mean you have to stop loving Archieboy. I think this article is on the verge of a high school editorial rant, but hey, it gets people to comment so maybe that was the purpose after all!
Lela | 10:06 a.m. May 27, 2008
I don�t believe there were any losers. Both Davids are
talented in their own unique ways and they are both winners.
I especially admire David Archuleta for his beautiful music, humility and kindness. I believe that David Archuleta is much more intelligent and wiser than people credit him for. Despite of his youth, David Archuleta handled himself exceptionally well. He did not allow the press to affect his performances. With few exceptions, he consistently received excellent to outstanding reviews from the judges. He understands that education is important and has set this as a priority besides music. David Archuleta was a great sport when he graciously stated that he thought Cook deserved to win (bless his heart).
In view of all that was discussed here concerning the integrity of the American Idol producers, perhaps it was in David Archuleta�s best interest not to receive the American Idol contract. With David Archuleta�s winning attitude and work ethic, I�m sure that David Archuleta will be a huge success in all his endeavors. I wish David Archuleta the very best and I�m looking forward to buying his CDs.
I especially admire David Archuleta for his beautiful music, humility and kindness. I believe that David Archuleta is much more intelligent and wiser than people credit him for. Despite of his youth, David Archuleta handled himself exceptionally well. He did not allow the press to affect his performances. With few exceptions, he consistently received excellent to outstanding reviews from the judges. He understands that education is important and has set this as a priority besides music. David Archuleta was a great sport when he graciously stated that he thought Cook deserved to win (bless his heart).
In view of all that was discussed here concerning the integrity of the American Idol producers, perhaps it was in David Archuleta�s best interest not to receive the American Idol contract. With David Archuleta�s winning attitude and work ethic, I�m sure that David Archuleta will be a huge success in all his endeavors. I wish David Archuleta the very best and I�m looking forward to buying his CDs.
Don't agree with this article. | 10:18 a.m. May 27, 2008
Pierce- your as bad as what you blame on American Idol. Why are you trying so
hard to convince everyone that Jeff is such a wonderful person. I have no idea
who this guy is-and I doubt if you know him well either. I don't know him
and I've never met him-but I know what I have seen and I am not impressed!
His 15 minutes of fame is almost over.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
Related content
- NFL: Week 12 recap 12:50 a.m.
- '12 Days' bill would top $87K 12:35 a.m.
- Study finds autism therapy works 12:35 a.m.
- Boy shot following traffic stop 12:35 a.m.
- Sports on the air 12:24 a.m.
- Herbert builds his team of rivals 12:21 a.m.
- Corroon a step closer to governor 12:21 a.m.
- Monday on TV 12:18 a.m.
- Editorial: East, West and religion 12:17 a.m.
- A deficit commission? 12:17 a.m.
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
- BYU is champion of the state
- Cougars beat Utes in overtime
- Credit Coug defense for win
- Marriage definitions vary widely
- Field goals, penalties doomed Utes
- Cougar defense rose to occasion
- Banged up Jazz get best of Blazers
- Jones' joy for life remembered
- Fantasy is reality for BYU professor
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
869 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime473
- Max Hall issues apology145
- BYU is champion of the state137
- Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies117
- Cave to be sealed with body inside116
- Rivalry Week is highly profane90
- Hall's legacy measured today79
- Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal68
- Utes fall to Seattle U. at home65
As distressing as it was to see KUTV's longtime vice president/general...
Latest comments
I find it interesting that many of the same people who say that we can't...
None of these teams is going to be easy. They all have fine football...
Max, no apology was necessary, but the apology was polically correct. If...
Very good piece of writing, Amy. You summarized what many of us have been...
How is a top 25 finish make Utah a top twenty team? I think what the poster...
90% of the BYU & Utah fans have class, and Hall knows it. If you don't...
This might be my favorite article I've ever read from the Deseret News. Kudos.
Thank you for not giving up and don't give up now brother and sister...
Dr. Lois Lee's work with children who are victims of child sexual...
Look at the preview for Pixar's "Up". The whole move is summarized in...
Advertisements
1. Simon went to several talk shows mid-season to disclose his personal favorite which should be disallowed.
2. The Stage Dad stuff started at the critical time when only 3 were left and pressure intensified.
3. The Idol coach made David out to be an unspontaneous and programmed kid. Subtle reference to Mormonism??? Hmm
4. Producers choice for David was unappealing to all.
5. "Goshes" strung together and unedited for effect. The little, overwhelmed boy. Seacrest draped on the kid soliciously worrying about him being "OK", "overwhelmed", etc.
6. 6 of my votes on repeat dial were diverted to contestant #1. A double whammy. Times that by 1M and you get 12M.