Reader comments
Foreclosure future grim for Utahns
161 comments | Read story
Too much credit card debt - file for bankruptcy and make it the bank's problem. Too much house - default and make it the lender's problem. Bad mortgage - cry and make it the federal government's problem. If you make dumb decisions, you need to face the consequences. How is anyone supposed to learn from their mistake if they are bailed out every time they make one? Political leaders spending time trying to figure out ways to spare these people the pain from the problems they've created themselves seems futile. The best service they could provide is staying out of the way, letting the situation unfold and focusing on controls that could be put in place to keep this from happening again.
I now have my answer: They can't.
The Government will cause more problems by trying to fix it & we will loose more freedoms & elected politicians will get bigger "We are smarter than you!" egos!
"Those who have caused the problems are the last ones to look for to solve the problems!"
Government needs to get out of the way & let those who "win" - win, & those who "loose" - loose. Quit trying to punish those who "win" by taking it away & redistributing it to those who "loose".
Cutting up a 1st place trophy & giving it to all participants does not make everyone a winner, it just makes more participants that don't want to put out a full effort anymore, since they will be getting a piece of 1st place.
AIMHO
(The smarter ones anyway)
Less is more will come to be known as the only way.
(for those paying attention)
Then people will once again embrace each other regardless of religious affiliation.
For those of you who are saving your money I hope you are saving it in a non-US currency because if you are saving it in US dollars its value is falling faster then RE values.
Read some books people it is never as simple as you think it is and so far there is no time travel so no one knows what will happen in the future.
To those that think it is impossible for house values to plummet SO far, you need to look at the rest of the country.
And whoever said it was Alan Greenspans fault is...well, not very smart. First off, before he stepped down from office (that's right he is no longer in charge of the federal reserve), he spoke quite a bit about the housing bubble. He warned everyone that it would burst. Not his fault that most of the country didn't listen.
Oh and both the lender and the borrower are to blame. The lender because they lent out too much money to people who don't realistically have the means to pay it back. The borrower because they didn't do the math and realize that they were overextending themselves.
When I was newly married and in college, my wife and I lived in a one-room apartment (not one bedroom, one ROOM) for $200 a month. After we graduated we looked forward to buying our first home. We decided to wait until we had enough money to put 50% down.
It took us two years - we were making almost $100k at the time. Do you know how hard it is to voluntarily stay in that situation when you're making that kind of money? Several times we asked ourselves "what are we doing here?"
But we stuck with it, bought our house, and thanks to our patience and sacrifice we're in a great situation today.
Teach your kids that a little sacrifice now will pay huge dividends later. And teach them to be patient - you can't have everything you want right away.
If they did, there would be a run on the banks like you and I have never seen before.
I didn't vote for them.
The administration we have today doesn't give a (blank) about you and me.
Second, you can not absolve banks and mortagage companies from responsiblity because they made lots of money offering loans that they were well aware were ticking time bombs should the economy change. They wanted to make money with no regard for longterm issues.
Third, we do need to allow the market to adjust. Homeowners will suffer and sometimes a lesson learned the hard way is the best way not to repeat it in the future. If they are bailed out then nothing will be learned.
Fourth, banks and mortgage companies should now be forced into more regulation since they have shown they can't regulate themselves since making money is more important than helping people make good decisions.
People getting into houses they can't afford and lenders not doing due diligence on the borrowers are also culpable in this mess. The markets really need to sort themselves out w/o gov't intervention. The more gov't gets involved, the longer it will take for any correction to run its course. SLC and surrounding areas were slow on the uptick and will be behind on the downside, but I believe it is coming. Denver has already started its slide. The coastal areas are even in worse situation (except San Diego, which has started to see a bottoming in the housing plunge). Not sure how far it will go, but it will fall more.
BTW, as noted, the Fed is not a gov't institution. It's a privately held central bank. There is some gov't oversight, but no direct gov't control. Seems a bit extra-constitutional to me.
Now, take the last 10 years of mortgages done in Utah, with a Lion's share being sub-prime, and not add the mortgages done the prior years and we get a more accurate reading of the situation.
Taking that approach and we can assume that the figure is more like 1 out of 4 or 5 of the last 10 years mortgages being foreclosed on. That's a disaster of huge proportions!
While the borrowers themselves will carry the brunt of the crisis, being blamed for overextending themselves, let's remember that the banks and mortgage lenders also could have said, "Sorry, but the home you're attempting to buy is actually out of your long-term debt-to-income ratio." The banks/mortgage lenders are equally responsible because they turned a traditionally conservative segment of the economy into a highly speculative 'paper wealth' driven market scheme, when it should have stayed a 'collateral' driven endeavor.
Yes! The lending institutions should take a hit/fall as hurtful as the borrowers are taking!
I hope I can somehow pay off the crushing burden of my student loans someday.
I hope my job doesn't get shipped overseas.
I hope I don't get stop-lossed again.
I hope the war is over by the time my son is grown.
I hope I don't lose my health insurance.
I hope reckless investment bankers haven't destroyed our entire economy.
I hope I can afford to heat my home next winter.
I hope we can make it through the next seven months of the Bush Administration.
I am a believer in free market economics, I believe the "American Dream" is founded on free market principles.
That being said, history has shown that the market CANNOT be trusted to regulate or police itself.
I DO NOT support the govornment giving handouts to try and stop a recession or bailing out companies that egaged in poor buisness paractices.
I ABSOLUTELY support govornment regulation of buisness and industry.
For those of you who say "they should have known better". I think that is a very cold way of viewing this situation. Often times the loans that people where being given where being sold to them like a used car, and the mortgage brokers were intentionally deceiving and preying on people they knew could not afford the product they where selling.
If America can avoid the socialist response of free handouts and enact some good legislation regulating the financial industry I think this can be a good thing. It's a good reality check and may help some people to realize that their home equity is not a disposable source of income. Unfortunately, I think that may be asking too much.
I THINK THE BANKS AND THE MORTGAGE BROKERS SHOULD GIVE THEIR COMMISSION BANK AND PUT AWAY.
Re: Wheat/Food Storage
Real Wealth is knowing you can feed your family in uncertain economic times. Yes, I feel real good knowing I don't have to beg my neighbor, church or government for food. Last I checked money does not taste real good and the dollar is going down in value and my wheat is increasing in value.
If you are serious, I feel sorry for you.
However, there are millions of people who have only a rudimentary understanding of mortgage instruments, let alone basic cost-of-money principles. When you involve two real estate agents, a mortgage broker or bank, an underwriter, and a title company, all who have an extremely high vested interest in the transaction taking place, you end up with normal-every-day buyers (and sellers) executing an unwise transaction due to the input of several parties with a potential conflict of interest. I saw this happen with my first house, decades ago, and learned a valuable lesson. Sometimes, however, these lessons are too costly from which to recover.
It is not only inaccurate, but a little cruelly stupid, to believe the responsibility lies only with the buyer here. There is plenty of responsibility and accountability to go around, but real estate agents, mortgage brokers, banks, underwriters, and title companies need to be held accountable for some of it. These fields drive entire sub-economies here and I don't hear a whole lot of people talking about it. This is not equitable.
Spend. Spend. Spend.
Max out all your credit cards.
Keep the American economy afloat.
Buy every new gadget that comes along.
All this gloom and doom talk is just more liberal lies.
Vote Republican (and don't forget to keep spending)
There are plenty of buyers in Utah. Problem is the prices have left them all behind. Equilibrium needs to be re-established. If that means lots of forclosures and price decreases, so be it. In the end, buyers can keep waiting for the prices they want. Builders and those on the verge of losing their homes don't have that luxury.
People with good income don't comlain, then it hits them... then they wonder why.
I am not some poor person screaming because I just couldn't get a good job.
I HAVE a good job and make enough money and I'm in a solid place right now. I recognize the problem today and it is mainly greedy business practices. Businesses want to make more money and don't want to have to pay out.
The news will usually have someone special guest to talk about the "crisis" just as a "set back" but we will move on and the real problem is in this market over here... or over there.... it's only REALLY happening to this crowd.. Just to make the middle class majority feel good to buy more time.
It is simple...nothing need change but businesses focus on working for it's employees as much as they do their customers. That is what will progress society. Anything other than that has always historically killed society and will continue to do so.
Focus on helping everyone or crumble in greed. It's as much a moral issue as a financial problem.
Greed destroys progress. Progress is happyness.
It feels so good to be right. To the Utah housing market, "how low can you go, how low can you go?"
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Roethlisberger sidelined 11:29 a.m.
- Police to talk to Woods 11:14 a.m.
- Louisville fires coach Kragthorpe 11:06 a.m.
- Houseplants can flourish 11:00 a.m.
- Russia: Bomb caused train crash 10:54 a.m.
- Clothing choices keep kids indoors 10:48 a.m.
- 9 bear cubs headed back to woods 10:41 a.m.
- Wis. police report 4 shot 10:38 a.m.
- Pot amaryllis now for holiday giving 10:34 a.m.
- Black Friday sales promising 10:28 a.m.
- Cave to be sealed with body inside
- Predicting the unpredictable: BYU wins
- Efforts to save a life praised
- Rivalry Week is highly profane
- BYU's old uniforms?
- Vegas, Poinsettia bowls or bust
- Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
- Glover gives Utes last-second upset
- Cougars turn back Wildcats'
- Hall's legacy measured today
- BYU would like friendlier rivalry
270 - Protests against Phoenix LDS temple
213 - Thunder rolls by Jazz
136 - Letters: Rushing to judge Palin
133 - Boys basketball rankings
130 - Editorial: Poor welcome for Palin
113 - Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies
109 - Letters: Trump card for believers
94 - Cave to be sealed with body inside
94 - Rivalry Week is highly profane
86
If you're shopping online for gifts, take care. While there are some...
I think BYU will win this game by at least a touchdown.
A person died while hiking the Angel's Landing hike in Zion. Shall we close...
@dave 7:57 a.m.: "Show me where public education became a right and I'll...
is Max Hall's Mom. -ManBearPig
People, get a clue about what this family is going through. This is not...
Utah by 43 points!!!
My child dropped out of school in Junior High and she now makes more than...
I couldn't agree more that you have the right to choose a religion or no...
Wow...BYU and UTAH fans alike who are calling OU "Joklahoma" need serious...
That was pretty funny Ernest T. Bass.

