Reader comments
First look inside YFZ Ranch
554 comments | Read story
It's about the law to some of the stupid people who think it's about religion only.
Agree with CL; all abuse is wrong, whether under the "religious" guise or not.
Authorities investigated based upon a legal search. If there were mistakes, then let the legal system work. And yeah, before you start with your rantings, there are laws there specific to underage marriage and living in a "religious" compound does not exempt people from obeying those laws.
Apparently you all also forget that 16 year old boys are kicked out of the group as competition for females. You see a few tears and forget the big picture. The FLDS are about abuse and the cycle needs to be changed. This action was the start of that change unless you cry to leave the abusers alone which is what it does sound like.
It seems they "seized" the wrong people. They seized innocent kids and some of their mothers. That seems like kidnapping, and a violation of human rights. Go figure.
It is 16 and they are breaking the law!!
Stupid.
Why do they move there? Maybe because UTAH didn't want them and would go after them.
These people are stupid sheep who were following a doctrine that was renounced by the mainstream church. And marrying girls who are underage is against the law there, no matter how much you don't like it. Don't excuse it and act like the leaders of this sect are not horrible men.
Polygamy is being MARRIED to more than one person at a time. If these people were "married" spiritually (not by the laws of the state) in their temple, were they practicing polygamy? I think not. They were merely having sex with more than one person (not their spouse) at a time... Something you see in Hollywood and elsewhere all the time. One professional b-ball player reportedly has 9 kids with 8 different women. Go figure.
desire to live peaceful, quiet and dignified lives,
can we not allow them to do so. Must we compel all
to some "National Standard" of conformity?
Just food for thought,all of us might consider reading about "Perpetua", Roman History, 203 A.D.
city of Carthage.There is an interesting parallel with today. The story is very moving. Again follow the Constitution, it is amazing how well it works,
when it is followed. And if a true crime exists, then address that issue and that individual. But don't throw out the baby with the bath water.
It was the phone calls received and then the affidavit of a rape allegation and abuse that led them to get a warrant for search.
The kids and mothers are innocent, I'll agree with that. But their leaders are not.
Don't worry; all you people who think that the goverment went too far will feel justified when it turns out that none of the victims turn on their
"leaders" because they are too afraid.
If you think that is what CPS does when they remove children from potentially abusive environments, then you scare me. However this situation went down, it is about making sure that the kids are safe in their religious commune before returning them to their parents. All children have a constitutional right to be safe and free from abuse and neglect. Parents can�t abdicate their responsibility to their children and whether you like it or not, the government is required to remove children and investigate complaints of alleged abuse or neglect on their behalf.
Then charges can be filed.
Rape is rape I don't care who or where you are.
Instead, they could have identified a single case of abuse. Then another, then another. After several such cases came into the public eye, the entire public would be on the State's side. We are, after all, a national of precedence.
All they have done is to create a martyred group that they cannot possibly fend off all at once, and to solidify any beliefs--misconceived or otherwise--that these folks had about the 'outside' world.
This was just stupid.
Your point is exactly the same as mine. Religion or no religion, tears or no tears, bias or no bias, this is abuse. Plain, outright abuse.
What most people tend to whine, then, is "well, other people abuse girls toooooo . . ."
So that must make the FLDS abuse A-OK.
What's wrong with the FLDS is that they teach that this is NORMAL (like David said). It is NORMAL there for a husband to beat up his wife.
To Huh?--
Okay. I get it. So being "spiritually" married makes it all okay.
GARBAGE!
I can't believe you are trying to snake your way out of the truth like this.
-------
po�lyg�a�my [puh-lig-uh-mee]
�noun 1. the practice or condition of having more than one spouse, esp. wife, at one time.
-------
Does it say *by the laws of the state???*
Remember the proverbial "cloak of charity". Now, would be a great time excerise the use of it. I understand your frustration, but maybe you could just hang back awhile and let this situation work out and see who violated whom.
It is much easier to round-up the weak and defenseless and bully them into submission. If there are victims here, it IS the women & children. If there are victimizers, it IS the men!
"GET THE MEN!!" Incarcerate them, for safe-keeping, if they are a danger and a threat to their community's defenseless members.
Then exercise "due process". That's the way in any country that protects its citizens from abuse. We are all too familiar with countries that run counter to those standards. Now in America? So very sad.
No one would take my children with out me going too.... and from my understanding there are many women who went with their chilren...
Now look at your bible and point to the first polygamist...oh a murderer. Then we have Abraham with Hagar and still suffer the trouble that union caused.
Again it is about crimes that are consistent with the group.
The issue is not the long history of Polygamy as you say it is, but what has happened in Eldorado Tx, over the past ten days. Your bias shows brother or sister. The issue is how CPS handled this matter, and how or if they violated citizens of the U.S. Civil Liberty's. I agree there's abuses, but again, the focus should be on what is unfolding in Texas.
Your comments are unsubstantiated and vague at best. There is no proof of abuse yet. You've heard the media talk about 16 yr old girls being pregnant. That's not against Texas law buddy.
The Mennonites are not like the FLDS.
These pedophiles (men and women)are brainwashing children and raising their own little sex slaves.
It's time to turn on the lights and expose the injustices committed against the women and children of this closed community. The weak and cowardly male members (improper to call them men) of the FLDS group need to be rounded-up and prosecuted for their pedophilia.
Where are these men now? Why do we not hear anything about them?
Raising girls to have babies as soon as they reach puberty, what barbarism under the guise of religion!
Yeah, right!!! the LDS church has the ability to project its whims upon any other person or organization. These folks have not been a part of the LDS church for over a hundred years. Church discipline would never work.
These folks are also not in the same vein as Wahabists or other Islamic fundies. They are not murderbombing anyone. They seem fairly peaceful.
There are allocations of abuse. I think Texas will work it out, but to expect the LDS church to is silly and exceptionally immature.
Whoa friend. They are not married. By the law of the land anyway. Their marriages are spiritual... in their temple.
And what scares me is conduct that you would typically find in Nazi Germany.
Then charges can be filed.=== Joice
They are all related. Their DNA all matches.
Don't put ideas into their heads.
-------
Does it say *by the laws of the state???**
Then, of course, you'd want Hollywood raided. Or perhaps the Bunny Ranch.
One woman came back from a trip to found her kids gone... stolen.. kidnapped... By the government no less.
I agree it might have been a much better idea to take the men away instead...but hindsite is always better.
My question is how do you claim to love your children but yet allow them to be sexually abused by the gross old men...pretators. Does not matter which religion it is...catholic, Baptist, Morman whatever....ABUSE IS ABUSE...any way you look at it.
They want to be apart, which is THEIR RIGHT.
The Constitution is DEAD.
It was killed in action by the Texas Rangers on orders from the Texas law enforcement.
If you want to see the FLDS open up, then stop using Nazi tactics and strategy.
Come on guys! This is nothing but pure old CHILD ABUSE with adulterers, porn pevies, slavery and fornication. There is nothing religious going on in those polygamist cults. Some of us know this.
We have a term for that that can't be published here.
I don't give a whit about what their religious practices are, it's about whether it's proven they broke the law and damaged the innocent. The complaints are about rape and abuse. They have to investigate that. We'll see what happens in court. And let it play out before all the anti government ranting continues. I can't imagine the logistical nightmare of who the mothers are, what the names are, how many children, who are the fathers, etc etc.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- AOL ends ties with Time Warner 9:25 a.m.
- Senate to confront abortion in debate 9:10 a.m.
- EPA: Greenhouse gases harmful 9:08 a.m.
- 'Openness' workshop closed to public 9:00 a.m.
- Thousands protest in Iran 8:47 a.m.
- Stocks push higher as dollar rises 8:41 a.m.
- Messy Monday morning commute 8:22 a.m.
- U.N. climate conference opens 7:55 a.m.
- Blast outside Iraqi school kills 8 7:53 a.m.
- Today on TV 12:49 a.m.
- BYU and Utah's bowl games
- BYU professor remembered
- Cougars going back to Vegas
- Y., U. to learn bowl destinations
- TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
- Utah/BYU rivalry can be more civil
- The forgotten ship: USS Utah
- Utes excited to go to San Diego
- Bring the true spirit of Christmas
- Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
- Letters: Liberal because LDS
259 - Y. profs: Beck not all-knowing
222 - Hate not limited to 1 in-state rivalry
189 - Aggies shoot past Cougars
179 - TCU to play Boise in Fiesta Bowl
144 - N.Y. Senate rejects gay marriage
131 - George lost in rivalry hatefest
114 - Ed Smart 'appalled' at testimony
98 - Harpring's NBA career is over
95 - Cougars going back to Vegas
92
Trolley Square's annual Holiday Open House will feature visits with...
That does it — I'm having an affair! Thanks to Tiger Woods, David...
First, a big thank you to all who posted questions here for me to ask...
RE: Anthony Brown Please don't kill yourself. You are loved. Your family...
at all. I would rather see Boise St. and TCU play each other than one of...
Thank you Sherry Young! You are a delight! What a beautifully written...
"Pay Lay Ale"???? Are you aware that language is part of the temple ceremony...
Blame the refs? Lame. Real lame. Give me a break. What comments would you...
Wayne Howard started it. St. Urban I perpetuated it. Tate, Scalley, et.al....
God bless you Carma Wadley! What a delightfully outstanding article on the...
To "Marxist global warmers? | 8:55 a.m." here are some peer-reviewed articles...
MWC, Prepare to get owned by the WAC. Also, BYU Fans, have fun watching...
I figured it out. It's all Bronco's fault. Young's a Cougar and president...




There are laws in that state about underage marriage whether you like it or not. Look it up."
Marriage age in Texas once was 14. That's one reason why FLDS move there. Then Texas upped it to 16. Fourteen was apparently OK for Texans but not for FLDS.