Reader comments
Board to tackle merit pay for teachers
8 comments | Read story
First, if a quota is set, either in law or through the funding, I would see this as a big mistake. Out of say 50 teachers at a school, how can anyone decide how many should receive merit pay? Should it be 10? 25? 40? Setting it up on a district level is not really any better. As Bob points out, this would go only to a select few each year, leading to low moral among the rest. I would also say that it would lead to cronism, rather than to competency.
Second, what are the determining factors? Test scores are usually brought up. However, this is inherently problematic.
Tests are not administered in all subject matters. So if I teach German, and there is no German test, am I ineligible?
Students don't always stay with the same teacher all year. Just last week, I recieved two "new" students because they had misbehaved at their school. They were sent to mine. I haven't had much of a chance to teach them anything.
Tests don't measure student progress. They are designed to test what the students know (assuming that the student can be motivated to try on a test that doesn't have a direct impact on anything of importance to his short-term view). The tests are NOT designed to measure what the student has LEARNED during the school year. That would require TWO testing times so that we could administer both a pre-test and a post-test.
If test scores are to be used, we need to measure progress, not end results. We also need to factor in that some students are more cooperative than others. I have one upper level class. They are EXTREMELY cooperative in class, and then, they do their homework out of class. In my lower level classes, I have to work much harder during class to maintain a learning environment. Then, when I ask for their homework the next day, I don't receive nearly as many completed papers. In short, I don't teach them nearly as much. However, the huge gains made in the upper level course are EASIER for me to achieve. I must be a great teacher for them! We need to be real.
It also causes animosity between colleagues... people who should be working together toward a common goal. Why should I help you, work with you, share ideas, collaborate, cover your class, share resources, etc., just so you can beat me out to that extra carrot?!?
No... merit pay is BAD for teachers, and bad for kids.
So, other than testing, what other way is there to decide who deserves the merit pay? It comes down to evaluations by the adminstrators. I currently work at a school where I would trust the adminstrators to do a good job at this. However, not all adminstrators are competent. Additionally, any teacher who is left out of the money would then have a big incentive to either sabotage the adminstrator to make him/her look incomentent, or to simply move to a different school site. (After all, who wants to work under an incompetent adminstrator who doesn't recognize your worth?)
I would hope that erery teacher who recieves a satisfactory evaluation would be eligible for the merit pay. Besides, if I am doing my job well, shouldn't I get the merit pay? And if I am not doing my job well, shouldn't I either be given help to improve, or be encouraged to find a different profession?
So please, no quotas. Allow everyone at the site to receive the pay every single year, as long as they are doing a good job. That way, there is no in-fighting, no cronism, and no lowering of moral.
Just put it in my salary and let me make a decent living. I work two jobs, my wife works two jobs - just to get by. I have almost twenty years in education, two degrees above bachelors, and could make more starting out at the Post Office with a GED at this time in my career. (Okay, 12 mo's vs 9 mo's, i don't care, it's all divided the same. I still truggle all winter.)
If they want accountability, they need to put the accountability on the parents and students. Testing is a waste. I can teach to a test all year long if that is what you want. The accountability needs to be on parents not making excuses for their kids.
Any future teachers out there, let me tell you, there are better ways to make a living. Nobody gives teachers respect anymore. Do something that will make you some money, and that you won't have to take kids crap all day long.
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- Here are Max Hall's Top 10 wins 8:52 p.m.
- Falling-TV deaths remain a concern 8:45 p.m.
- Fed holds rates at record low 8:37 p.m.
- P&G cutting online coupon program 8:36 p.m.
- Banker charged with insider trading 8:35 p.m.
- Credit Suisse Group to pay $536M 8:34 p.m.
- Dems: estate tax repeal short-lived 8:31 p.m.
- Price index declined .3% 8:31 p.m.
- DAZ 3D and Gizmoz to merge 8:30 p.m.
- Barnes shareholder meeting set 8:29 p.m.
- Susan Powell notebook seized
- Will Chambers keep his promise?
- Josh Powell meets with WVC police
- Conan mocks Orrin Hatch, Mormons
- Star on field, in community
- Boozer plays at an All-Star level
- BYU singers compete in 'Sing Off'
- Jazz miss Harpring's toughness
- David Archuleta's different mission
- Thanks 'Tonight Show,' 'Big Love'
- Jazz stunned by Timberwolves
114 - Stay the course with our president
111 - Josh Powell meets with WVC police
109 - TV mom gives birth to 19th child
106 - Letters: 'Liberal conceit'
101 - Sources: Josh Powell hires attorney
100 - Letters: Explaining Palin
100 - Tethering of pets could spur charges
90 - Choir, guests unwrap musical magic
89 - Cougar seniors see a new Bronco
83
These days, more than half of adults actually want gift cards, those...
Some forms of beauty are fleeting, fragile as life itself, gone in a...
David Rankin, one of Utah's youngest and ablest astrophotographers has...
Compressed air energy storage (CAES) can also store solar energy for use at...
Rojo is a great guy off the turf with adults too!! I've met him a few times.....
I'm dissapointed by the "faithful". It sure is easy to judge David from...
And I hope Cougar fans look it over well. Max Hall is a winner and has given...
Words accurately (and wonderfully) expressing the spirit oh Hanukkah. The...
As I served as the Church's General Counsel Orient, it was my great privilege...
Yeah don't downplay Orem's boys. They beat Lehi too and they should be able...
I am so sorry for this family's loss - of their daughter and now their home....
I have always noticed that JPL usually has the last word said on most posts,...
Huh, so the market doesn't self regulate? I don't think I can sleep if the...


