Reader comments
Second-season 'American Idol' finalist from Utah to give weekly show update
13 comments | Read story
Carmen Fan | 11:33 a.m. Jan. 25, 2008
Great article Carmen. I'm excited to hear more about your experiences.
Your amazing and beautiful. Your song "Nothin' Like the Summer"
is one of my favorite songs too.
Nancie | 11:59 a.m. Jan. 25, 2008
Sorry, I entered "Idol Land" at the end of Season 2, just in time to
see Reuben crowned and weep over Clay not making it (so I thought!) So I
didn't get to follow Carmen's journey ~ but I am now watching Idol
Rewind and hopefully will hear Carmen sing!
Heather | 12:12 p.m. Jan. 29, 2008
Love to hear your take on things girl! You always remain so positive and
refreshing!
Comments continue below
Steve - Re: Nancie | 1:29 p.m. Jan. 29, 2008
Nancie, don't worry... you didn't miss much. Carmen gave quite a
lackluster performance during her time on the show (which is why she didn't
win). The person to keep an eye on now this season for us Utah fans is David
Archuleta (from Murray, Utah). Last we saw him he made it on to the Hollywood
round and hopefully he'll make the top/final 24 and go on to crack the top
12 or 10. If he does, count on the Utah media to make him their
spokesperson/"go to person".
Heather | 10:45 a.m. Jan. 30, 2008
Wow for someone who doesn't like Carmen you sure spend a lot of your time
going out of your way to spread negative information about Carmen. Maybe you
should just wait until David makes the top 24 and then spend your efforts
supporting him.
My guess is people are reading these reviews because they want to hear input about this season, something which contractually David is not allowed to give.
My guess is people are reading these reviews because they want to hear input about this season, something which contractually David is not allowed to give.
Steve - Re: Heather | 12:37 p.m. Jan. 30, 2008
I'd rather hear commentary from either those who won it or who were widely
popular (meaning across the country, not just in Utah)... as in Clay Aiken,
Melinda Doolittle, Blake Lewis, Chris Daughtry, or Katharine McPhee. Heck
I'd even like to hear the insights of Sanjaya (what it was like to put up
with all he got from the media... which I found unfair).
Anonymous | 2:59 p.m. Jan. 30, 2008
Well first off all I'm in North Carolina. So that already throws a kink in
your theory. Secondly, Clay Aiken is on Broadway and has not watched the show
since season 3. Chris Daughtry hasn't watched the show either and is
currently on tour with Bon Jovi, Katharine is filming movies. No clue what the
other two are doing, but scheduling plays a part. I'll just copy and paste
what I responded on the other story.
Why does she continue to do it so many years after her season? Simply, put she's a well spoken intelligent girl who can provide better insight than most of the other Idol contestants who do not have the same eloquence with words. She went to BYU in the hopes of doing Broadcast Journalism, so obviously this type of thing, is something she enjoys and has proven to be very good at doing.
She keeps a kind of neutrality that is desired in the news industry.
I must say I find it highly hypocritical that you say the media was unfair to Sanjaya, when you are acting the same way in regards to Carmen. Posting as many negative things about her as you can.
Why does she continue to do it so many years after her season? Simply, put she's a well spoken intelligent girl who can provide better insight than most of the other Idol contestants who do not have the same eloquence with words. She went to BYU in the hopes of doing Broadcast Journalism, so obviously this type of thing, is something she enjoys and has proven to be very good at doing.
She keeps a kind of neutrality that is desired in the news industry.
I must say I find it highly hypocritical that you say the media was unfair to Sanjaya, when you are acting the same way in regards to Carmen. Posting as many negative things about her as you can.
Steve - Re: Anonymous | 5:53 p.m. Jan. 30, 2008
But, I'm being honest here... not joking at all... I actually did like
Sanjaya more than Carmen.
The only reason FOX 13 and now the Deseret News are still latching on to Carmen is because she's from Utah, if she wasn't you can safely bet they never would have turned to her in the past or now.
The only reason FOX 13 and now the Deseret News are still latching on to Carmen is because she's from Utah, if she wasn't you can safely bet they never would have turned to her in the past or now.
Heather | 11:36 a.m. Jan. 31, 2008
You may have liked Sanjaya better than Carmen. Thats your right. The
hypocritical part is not in that, but in that you think it wasn't ok for
people to bash Sanjaya in the media, and yet its ok for you to bash Carmen.
I would agree with the latter comment, if she were only used for idol reviews in Utah, but she's not. She does work Nationwide. Last time I checked MSNBC wasn't run out of Utah. She's being latched onto outside of the state because as I said before, she's good at what she does. Your own personal feelings about the girl aside, what did she say in the article that frustrated you to the point that you didn't want to hear from her. If you can point out anything, maybe I'll understand your critique, but it seems as though you are frustrated about something else and taking it out on Carmen.
I would agree with the latter comment, if she were only used for idol reviews in Utah, but she's not. She does work Nationwide. Last time I checked MSNBC wasn't run out of Utah. She's being latched onto outside of the state because as I said before, she's good at what she does. Your own personal feelings about the girl aside, what did she say in the article that frustrated you to the point that you didn't want to hear from her. If you can point out anything, maybe I'll understand your critique, but it seems as though you are frustrated about something else and taking it out on Carmen.
Steve - Re: Sanjaya & Heather | 12:34 p.m. Jan. 31, 2008
What Sanjaya got from the media and people across the country is far worse than
anything I've said about Carmen... the level of negativity thrown at him
was amazing and shameful at the same time. There were even comedy skits and
jokes about him. So what I've said about Carmen doesn't even come
close to what he faced. I've actually been quite civil.
Nothing in Carmen's article frustrated me, it's the fact that she's being asked to do a column and interviews with FOX 13 all the time which I dislike. My frustration lies in the media desire to keep turning to her after so many years have passed since she was on the show. I'd like a fresh outlook from another contestant... I'm sure there are others just as articulate as her they can talk to.
Nothing in Carmen's article frustrated me, it's the fact that she's being asked to do a column and interviews with FOX 13 all the time which I dislike. My frustration lies in the media desire to keep turning to her after so many years have passed since she was on the show. I'd like a fresh outlook from another contestant... I'm sure there are others just as articulate as her they can talk to.
Heather | 2:41 p.m. Feb. 1, 2008
I didn't say what you said about Carmen was as bad as what Sanjaya endured.
But people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. That's
all I'm saying. I'm not a fan of Sanjaya, but I'm not going to
comment on any project he might have in the future trying to detract from his
abilities or encourage an interested person to look elsewhere for
entertainment.
If Carmen's reviews infuriate you so much and you insist on getting angry with the media outlet, perhaps you should simply stop reading them. I'm not a big fan of Kim Caldwell, but I don't complain that she has a show on TV Guide. I simply choose not to tune in to hear her opinions.
If Carmen's reviews infuriate you so much and you insist on getting angry with the media outlet, perhaps you should simply stop reading them. I'm not a big fan of Kim Caldwell, but I don't complain that she has a show on TV Guide. I simply choose not to tune in to hear her opinions.
Louise | 9:37 a.m. Feb. 13, 2008
Hi Carmen i just want to let you know that Melinda Doolittle did releases her
first single song on i tunes yesterday she amazing. It is a new version for her
fan who want more new about her new CD will be release June 2008 and they have a
radio show one a month on Melindafan.net who are all the backups of her. Thank
you
Louise | 9:33 p.m. May 24, 2008
Hi Melinda Did postponed her album at the end of the summer, she did talk in a
interview she will have also a album for the Holiday. New website
www.mdstreetteam.com come join us
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
Related content
- Aggies beat Spartans in snowy Logan 4:31 a.m.
- TCU 55, Utah 28 4:24 a.m.
- BYU 24, New Mexico 19 4:21 a.m.
- Jazz game at a glance 3:00 a.m.
- Real Salt Lake: Game at a glance 3:00 a.m.
- Stanford ends Y's soccer season 2:20 a.m.
- Jazz hope D-Will returns soon 2:19 a.m.
- Snow, SUU lose 2:18 a.m.
- Toone saves day for Wildcats 2:15 a.m.
- Win in New Mexico good for Y? 2:15 a.m.
- Apostle's wife felt comfort in attack
- BYU happy to escape with victory
- Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?
- Crash on snowy road kills woman
- GameDay in Fort Worth
- D-Will home for daughter
- Short-handed Jazz fly past Sixers
- Utes excited for 'dream' game
- Bench proves fruitful for Y.
- Collie featured in Sports Illustrated
- SLC council OKs gay rights policies
358 - Editorial: Mormons and gay rights200
- BYU happy to escape with victory197
- Will state consider gay rights law?148
- TCU creams U.135
- Can BYU root for (ick) Utah Utes?130
- Letters: Strange breed in Utah129
- Utes remain silent about BCS120
- Pratt pleads not guilty to sex charges106
- Celtics crush Jazz104
Singer Thurl "Big T" Bailey, formerly of the Utah Jazz, will perform a...
Advertisement
Latest comments
Not good at crosses Too short Too unreliable right... Did anyone...
for later. after the rivalry game then we can say we know who is better....
So Great!!! So Proud - Love RSL - Bring Home The CUP!!!!!
mr cannon's bold assertation that the purpose of the first ammendemnt as...
Great great great game!!!! Nicky Rimando is a god! We're the most complete...
I had the game on DVR and just watched it. That was the most exciting game...
financially cannot this year, but I will watch loyally, how great to hear...
This is hardly surprising. Bennett has a remarkable arrogance which is also...
I guess that is why "they play the game" as Herman Edwards would say.. ...
What was the score of the LSU vs LA tech game? Alot closer than you'd like to...
Advertisements