Reader comments
Theology: LDS god is in harmony with the Bible
395 comments | Read story
Isaiah 44:6 (King James Version)
6Thus saith the LORD [Jehovah] the King of Israel, and his redeemer the LORD [Jehovah] of hosts; I am the first, and I am the last; and beside me there is no God [Elohim].
No God beside Jesus.
Isaiah 45:5 (King James Version)
5I am the LORD [Jehovah], and there is none else, there is no God [Elohim] beside me: I girded thee, though thou hast not known me:
Jesus none else, no God beside Jesus.
Psalm 100:3 (King James Version)
3Know ye that the LORD [Jehovah] he is God [Elohim]: it is he that hath made us, and not we ourselves; we are his people, and the sheep of his pasture.
Again Jesus is God. Jehovah is Elohim.
And didn�t Thomas say to Jesus �My Lord (Jehovah) and my God (Elohim).� John 20:28
This is truly crazy stuff.
Peter Martin,
I tend to recall that President Hinckley is the prophet today, not Joseph Smith. If he states that he doesn't know a lot about the subject, then I would believe him - I'm also quite sure he is familiar with the doctrine. I think the key word here is know. Much of what we "know" are things that we simply have faith about - our understanding of God and doctrines have changed as we have learned more, but it still doesn't mean that we know. Religious belief should be based on faith given our limited understanding of what really is. Religious belief based on knowledge doesn't have the staying power against convincing evidence. Religious belief based on faith can withstand convincing evidence because within the concept of faith there exists the idea that you are humble enough to accept new understanding. Unfortunately, the argument on this thread tends to be about knowledge and an unwillingness to accept the thoughts and opinions of others.
-Sasha bill
Just because you do not know does not mean that others do not know. I am 70 years old. I have spent a life serving God and my fellow men
Anyone who examines the Book of Mormon in light of history, archeology, subject and context, and DNA evidence of Native Americans will quickly develop serious doubts as to its veracity and the credibility of Joseph Smith himself.
Take one example - why have there been so many re-writes of the Book of Mormon when the source material (golden plates) have vanihsed? Every time evidence is uncovered casting doubts on the book, they re-write the book. Convenient is not the same as credible.
Take a serious look at LDS teachings and you too will see that Mormonism, like Islam, Hinuism, and others is not Christian.
As for Sunday school, be careful. Jesus said "But if anyone causes one of these little ones who believe in me to sin, it would be better for him to have a huge millstone hung around his neck and to be drowned in the open sea."
I understand people passionately clinging to their beliefs because it is in our nature to resist change, but folks - look at the facts. Examine the history, the archeology and the context of the Book of Mormon. You will see that it doesn't add up.
Most of all - compare the teachings of the Bible with LDS doctrine - and you will come to one conclusion. Mormonism is no more "Christian" than Islam. In fact, Mormonism is closer to Islam than it is to Christianity.
The truth is what it is. Those who seek the truth will find it.
for Governor of Michigan and later ran for the Republican Nomination in 1968,
for President, that his Mormon faith did not enter into the campaigns at all
Why now is it (the Mormon faith) becoming an issue? What are the evangelicals
afraid of?
Thank you,Mr. Card, for taking the time to share your views with the public. I have forwarded this to many friends and family.
Get over yourself and realize that it's not "true" for me, not for lots of people in the world and never will be!
And also realize that when you "hang out" on a newspaper website, you are in a public place where there are lots of individuals (religious and non religous) that will make comments.
DNA evidence has conclusively proven that the accounts of the history of the Native Americans, as recorded in the Book of Mormon, is false."
That is bunk...What they have shown is that a marker is shown to be in European Jews doesn't show up in American Indians.
The BOM never said the American Indian was Jewish!
What they don't have is samples from the other Israelite tribes...Since they have no way of identifying the other tribes....Specifically Mannaseh samples to show that tribe never made it to the Americas...So what have they PROVEN?
They have shown that the American Indian is related to peoples in Siberia...However they can't prove that there weren't other nations on the other side of the pond that mixed their DNA into the DNA of the American Indian, because you need samples of every nation and group...Even groups that have died out to prove it.
The DNA could just as easily moved the other direction...From the Americas to Siberia...The scientists are just too sure of the Siberian Land bridge theory to accept any other theory that would contradict their "pet doctrine" of pre-colombian American colonization.
Most of all - compare the teachings of the Bible with LDS doctrine - and you will come to one conclusion. Mormonism is no more "Christian" than Islam. In fact, Mormonism is closer to Islam than it is to Christianity."
Islam is part of the Abrahamic religion heritage.
Suprise they share some of the same beliefs!
Even the Muslims believe the Jesus was a prophet...They just don't believe he was the divine
Son of God...However the LDS believe in the Godhead...If any of the religions are closer to Islamic thought that would have to be Orthodox Christianity because they cling to the only "one" God idea, but instead of Allah...They cling onto the Triune God being the one true God.
Even Muslims have some truth in their beliefs...Mohammed was exposed to Jewish and Christian thought because of his homeland's proximity to Israel...So if we have some beliefs that are similar...Because we are Christian(We believe that Jesus was the SON OF GOD!)and they are Islamic....Christianity is an Abrahamic religion...It should share some beliefs...Suprised?
Some have to look for anything to soothe their concsiences as to why they don't believe the LDS!
"For your information, I spend some time with newspaper writings (not with LDS people). I'm not against you, (or with you) and I don't personally care what you believe. I do, however, care when your church pushes it's agenda on other people and makes arrogant claims. One of these claims is that that your "truth" is the "best truth".
Get over yourself and realize that it's not "true" for me, not for lots of people in the world and never will be!"
If you don't carewhat we believe....Why do you care that we believe that we are the restoration of Jesus Christ's church?
The Catholic church believes that they are the only true church because they think they are the church Jesus established on the earth and it wasn't taken from the earth!
The Evangelicals believe they are true "BodyOfChrist/Church". They don't believe one denomination is true church. Litmus Test-Christ/Faith/NotWorks/Bible believing church they're OK. Because we believe in the BOM...To them we are non-christian cult...Thus not part of their "True Church"...What about non-Christian religions...What do the Evangelicals say about them?
Arrogance? No just Biblical? NOT THE TRUE CHURCH? WHY BELIEVE IT?
My reality of "God" is every bit as valid as yours.
Goodbye, and God Bless
Also have a Merry Yultide (Christmas)
"One thing you will not hear is a Christian bearing their testimony about Christ being their Elder Brother. This is one thing that I cannot simply cannot understand. How so many people can so lightly to bring Christ down to their level. The scriptures and teachings of the Church are clear that Christ is our creator, the creator of our earth and is our God and Savior and is the God of the Old Testament."
As LDS I don't ever remember bearing that as part of my own testimony...
Christ as Saviour, Creator, etc.? Yes...He was the Creator and more!
However we also believe in the universal spiritual brotherhood of man because we believe in the Fatherhood of God... Who taught this? Jesus when he prayed and taught, the Apostles in their epistles, etc.
In our relaionship to God what does the Bible teach? God and Christ as Creators and Heavenly Father=Our Father which art in heaven?
Have you ever seen/said a prayer prayer in Bible that began with these words?
Are those just words? Truth?
It's ironiic which words in Bible religions take as literal(ONE/GOD)One's they don't(God/Fatherhood)!
His death and resurrection were witnessed by many - hundreds. It is documented by those present and those who investiagted it. Even atheist historians today acknowledge that many people (not just one) believe to have seen the risen Christ.
No so with Joseph Smith. Joseph was a man with a very shady past who claims he alone had a vision and he alone received and translated the tablets. None of this can be verified - we have to take the word of one person. All the "evidence" (the tablets) is gone. Does this really match with other ways God expressed himself in the Bible? No.
The evidence - scientific and spiritual - is clear. Mormons are well-intended, but misinformed; faithful, but to the wrong God. This is why so many educated Mormons have left the church.
Creeds saying Father and Son are one in substance...According to Orthodox thought God is a unchanging and eternally spirit that fills the universe...Christ was born,crucified in the flesh, and ressurected with a body of flesh and bones ocupying a fixed amount of space! This creedal doctrine of oneness thus denies the birth, death, and ressurection of Christ!
2 John 7 For many deceivers are entered into the world, who confess NOT that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh. This is a deceiver and an antichrist.
Again the creeds deny the Father AND the Son by their being one God.
1 John 22 Who is a liar but he that denieth that Jesus is the Christ? He is antichrist, that denieth the Father and the Son.
23 Whosoever denieth the Son, the same hath not the Father: [but] he that aacknowledgeth the Son hath the Father also.
In fact Christ couldn't be the Saviour and hung on the cross in the flesh...been left alone on the cross in the flesh by the Father if they were 'one in substance'. Read Father taking the Bitter Cup from the Saviour, etc, etc, etc, into infinitum!
LDS doctrines take the God of the Bible, add some attributes and subtract some attributes, and call the result "God". The fundamental question therefore is: Is this new, Mormon God still the God of the Bible, or is He something different?
After studying the Bible, Book of Mormon, Pearl of Great Price, and Doctrines and Covenants, I believe Mormons worship a God different from the God of the Bible. Numerous theologians agree, though clearly many of the LDS faithful see things differently.
Mormons have for years tried to position themselves as "Christians" too, but this assertion is consistently rejected by Christians because the two camps define "Christian" markedly differently.
A boat, a car, and an airplane are not the same thing despite the fact that they are all "transportation". They differ in form, function, and result. They cannot all get to the same destinations equally.
Likewise Mormonism and Christianity do not lead to the same place, because the heart of the matter is that they follow different Gods. Mr Card's assertion to the contrary is therefore incorrect.
We are careful to teach them in Primary and Sunday School...That's why we teach them to obey the commandments and to have faith and believe in the true nature Jesus and Heavenly Father and the Holy Ghost...And all that's promised in the Gospel through the atonement.
Do you carefully teach children to not sin or just accept Jesus in a prayer as their Saviour and faith only saves them not gospel principles like faith in God, obedience to commendments and necessary ordinances ie; baptism, etc. are necessary?
QUIETLY attend one of our Primary meetings...We teach them very well to avoid sin, etc.
If each religion worships their own Jesus, then it's pretty clear that someone is wrong. Jesus didn't say "I am a way..." or "Someone a lot like me is the way.."
Different Jesus = different results.
The Mormon Jesus and the Christian Jesus are not the same. Read the source materials and decide.
The three members of the Godhead/Trinity (the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost) each has, in some sense, an individual existence.
(Mormons, that's what you believe when you reference the First Vision, which had the Father and the Son appearing as two distinct "personages." Other Christians, that's what you believe when you accept the Athanasian Creed's warning against "confusing the persons" of the Trinity; i.e., the Son is not the Father.)
The three members of the Godhead/Trinity also have, in some sense, a unified existence.
(Mormons, that's what you believe when you accept D&C 20's statement "Which Father, Son, and Holy Ghost are one God." Other Christians, that's what you believe when you accept the Athanasian Creed's warning against "dividing the substance" of God.)
There should be no argument between Mormons and other Christians that the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost have both an individual existence and a unified existence. The only argument is precisely *how* these divine Persons are individual, and how they are also united as one God.
Anyone who gets worked up over any of this has way too much time on his hands.
"LDS doctrines take the God of the Bible, add some attributes and subtract some attributes, and call the result "God"."
TC subtract at least two attributes...Two other identities...You blend 3 separate personalities into 1 and call that God!
"The fundamental question therefore is: Is this new, Mormon God still the God of the Bible, or is He something different?"
I am suprised that you would call your god a "HE"...
Since according to your doctrine Jesus is also GOD, and the HG. Fathered(?) by the HG...In truth your creedal based God is eternally a spirit w/o body parts. Couldn't have hung on the cross because remember Jesus is God and is the same substance(A spirit because he is God who is eternally a spirit) as God.
"A boat, a car, and an airplane are not the same thing despite the fact that they are all "transportation". They differ in form, function, and result. They cannot all get to the same destinations equally."
Then we're the airplane/starship and you're the car?
We're headed, if we remain worthy, to the Celestial kingdom...Ironically your doctrine of your heavenly destination sounds more like the terrestial?
The Trinatrian belief is a non-biblical belief. It isn't defined anywhere. In fact it wasn't even a christian belief until three to four hundred years after Christ! I'll just sit back and waith for your "God is a Spirit" quote and then I'll teach you the meaning of that passage so that it doesn't contradict the passages above.
My education is in molecular biology, but it really doesn't take a scientist to figure this out. DNA tags are "tattoed" you might say - for thousands of years. If the Native Americans tested - as many were from Alaska to the tip of South America - had ANY lineage to ANYONE of Isrealite or middle-eastern descent, the markers would have been easily found. They were not there. This is not because they were "dilluted" - it is only because they do not exist.
No Native Americans are descendants of any Isrealite tribe - and there is no way to get around the evidence that supports this fact. You can ignore it, re-frame it, or change the subject....but you cannot refute it.
I remember in the mid 1970's many people claimed that we didn't really land someone on the moon - despite evidence to the contrary. Many today believe there was no "Holocaust" - despite the evidence. Sometimes people just believe things - despite the evidence.
Biblical truths how arrogant are we to imply that one person or another is going to Hell. How arrogant are we to assume that. How cruel would our God have to be to send a group of people down into that fiery furnace that is promised for the sinners because they do not espouse to that fractured house known as Christianity.
"Jesus said to him, "I am the way, and the truth, and the life; no one comes to the Father but through Me."
If each religion worships their own Jesus, then it's pretty clear that someone is wrong. Jesus didn't say "I am a way..." or "Someone a lot like me is the way.."
Different Jesus = different results.
The Mormon Jesus and the Christian Jesus are not the same. Read the source materials and decide."
Why didn't Jesus say nobody comes to me except through me?
Yes our Jesus is Jesus...Not some 3 in 1 ... 1 in 3 sunstanceless spirit. In fact we believe in the Father and the HG also. Just like the BIBLE says we should! We believe we should be perfect, and become 'one like' the Father and Son...Are we to believe that we become "one like" the Hindus do with their God in Nirvahna?
Their beliefs Biblical? More than TCs?
Is Jesus schiztophrenic? He would be today if he preached he was Father/Son/HG!
We believe JESUS when he said he was SENT by the FATHER, and that the HG testifies of the FATHER and the SON.
"I can't praise a deity who sends people to eternal misery just because they didn't know what was right, or because they were too young to know what they were supposed to believe and do."
God the Father's plan works!!!
LDS doctrine is that everyone get's the chance to hear and decide if they want to accept the gospel no matter when or where they lived or what they believed when they lived!
Everyone is ressurected because of Jesus being ressurected...Overcoming the fall for everyone!
Jesus is the Saviour of the world...Especially those that believe!
One God in three persons. It can be difficult to wrap your mind around, but remember - we're talking about God here - not some human being. Our finite minds cannot fully comprehend the infinite. God has no such limitations.
As to "We're headed, if we remain worthy, to the Celestial kingdom" - that's not Biblical. Did the man on the cross next to Jesus remain worthy? No - but he went with Jesus to paradise (a translation for heaven). Why? Faith and faith alone.
Salvation is through faith in Christ alone - not of works. This frustrates many people because we want to have a role in our salvation, but this cannot be the case. It is God alone by His gift of grace to all those who have faith in Christ.
"God made Him (Jesus Christ) who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in Him we might become the righteousness of God" (II Corinthians 5:21).
'I can't praise a deity who sends people to eternal misery ...' I hope you're not referring to Mormon doctrine. If so, this is absolutely false. On my mission to Southern Germany, I had the harrowing experience of teaching a middle aged woman in a town which was almost entirely Catholic. Many years after the fact, she could still hardly contain her emotions over the fact that a premature baby she had had which died before being baptized was burie with another body with being named because, she was told, it was automatically damned. LDS doctrine, on the other hand provides that children born before the age of accountability are saved in the Celestial kingdom and that *everyone* is going to have every possible chance to accept the full truth either here or in the afterlife. In the final 'judgement' all the conditions of each indivual's life will also be fully taken into account. We are warned that 'the first shall be last and the last shall be first' and there there will be a lot of surprises about who ends up where.
It seems that if Mormons want to be seen as Christian by Christians, they would adopt as much of the Christian language and culture as possible.
The Bible is clear - salvation does not require baptism. Baptism serves only as a public testimony of our faith; an act simulating Christ's death (going under the water) and risen life (coming out of the water). It is through baptism that we tell the world we are His.
God is a God of mercy and justice - He will do the right thing always. Scripture points to the fact that those who go to hell are those who reject Him.
Even the DNA scientists believe we all decended from the same parents(Lucy the missing link?).
She lived in Africa close to ME?
You found her markers in the study that was done?
Spainiards found evidence of ME(Christianity!) influence in the religions of the Americas....
Decalougue(Ten Commandments)Stone in Hebrew...
You will dismiss this evidence because it doesn't fit into the simple view that people only came across the Siberian Land Bridge.
I'm curious if you are TC...Because the DNA disproves the Bible too...
Isaiah 43:5 Fear not: for I am with thee: I will bring thy seed from the east, and gather thee from the west;
6 I will say to the north, Give up; and to the south, Keep not back: bring my sons from far, and my daughters from the ends of the earth;
I remember being told in the 1970s by scientists that we were having another ICE AGE!
Paul was caught up to third heaven....talks of Celestials bodies and terrestial in corinthians...
Jesus talks of many mansions...
Of course gracers want to believe in only one reward...It fits well into the concept that man is not literally a son of God...not heirs like Jesus...a lesser salvation...We're just going to be angels playing harps for eternity...
Hebrews 1: 5 For unto which of the angels said he at any time, Thou art my Son, this day have I begotten thee? And again, I will be to him a Father, and he shall be to me a Son?
This not only refers to Jesus but to heirs of salvation.
Hebrews 2:9 But we see Jesus, who was made a little lower than the angels for the suffering of death, crowned with glory and honour; that he by the grace of God should taste death for every man.
The same is said of man! What's Jesus's afterlife like?
BTW-Jesus was made a little lower than the angels?
How can the Almighty Triune GOD be made a little lower than angels? Who watching the store?
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- New layoffs at USA Today 8:07 p.m.
- Execs make case for online fees 8:07 p.m.
- Duncan plans scaled-back facility 8:06 p.m.
- Most Utahns unhappy with Obama 7:55 p.m.
- Utah delegation split on plans 7:44 p.m.
- Teen girl killed in Kaysville crash 7:09 p.m.
- Plenty of H1N1 vaccine available 6:38 p.m.
- Obama orders 30,000-troop boost 6:37 p.m.
- 2 arrested in Roy double slaying 6:33 p.m.
- Working on new HIV/AIDS vaccine 6:32 p.m.
- 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
- BYU says Hall incident resolved
- Max Hall: a fixture in rivalry lore
- 'Grandfamilies' a growing trend
- Witness: Mitchell wanted attention
- Mitchell called intelligent, controlling
- MWC '09 season in review
- Jazz win 6th in 7 games
- Jazz ready to be without Harpring
- Daughter: Mitchell fed me my pet
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
901 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime
482 - Hall reprimanded by MWC
401 - Max Hall issues apology
387 - Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal
344 - Utes won't respond to Hall
273 - BYU says Hall incident resolved
228 - 2 citations issued at Y.-U. game
154 - BYU is champion of the state
142 - Religion in politics is tiresome
128
My husband was teaching his 6th-grade class in Salt Lake last year when...
LOL i hate both schools Go Aggies
...not proud of Max Hall's comments. In his classless and hateful comments,...
Is it any surprise after his stimulus plans to "prevent unemployment from...
...and neither will Whit. That is, unless he changes schools. Urban Meyer...
Utahn? Eagar has been in Salt Lake or Utah Co for a total of, like...
78B-1-137. Witnesses -- Privileged communications.(3) A member of the...
To: wait... | 6:08 p.m. Dec. 1, 2009 [I thought that Obama said he would...
Me too. God gave me a brain and my education just does not allow me to buy...
When this blows over, I think that next year, the Classy Utah fans will be a...
Actaully there is plenty of eveidence, ALL the new testmanet writers...


1 Kings 8:60 (King James Version)
60That all the people of the earth may know that the LORD [Jehovah] is God [Elohim], and that there is none else.
Thus Jesus is God.
Deuteronomy 4:35(King James Version)
35Unto thee it was shewed, that thou mightest know that the LORD [Jehovah] he is God [Elohim]; there is none else beside him.
Thus Jesus is God
Deuteronomy 4:39 (King James Version)
39Know therefore this day, and consider it in thine heart, that the LORD [Jehovah] he is God [Elohim] in heaven above, and upon the earth beneath: there is none else
Thus Jesus is God