Reader comments
Chris Hicks: Redford shows little class with LDS comment
261 comments | Read story
Jayce Cox | 12:09 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
I am so glad that I am not the only one seeing the upsurge of Anti-LDS bigotry.
That is simply all it is; Bigotry.
Peculiar Plastic People | 12:42 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Candor never seems polite when it is about you, but I thought Robert
Redford�s comments were okay in their tone. He did seem
out of touch on some of it.
Hicks was right to correct Redford that not every mormon male goes on a mission.
But Redford seems right about the plastic comment. There is fakeness in probably any large social structure. A lot of mormons in each Utah neighborhood I have lived in seem plastic in their delivery of niceties. But I don�t think it�s a bad thing...it is difficult to be sincerely nice all the time to everyone. It is better to be superficially nice, than to avoid others.
True that young mormon men often lack practice in considering the contrary points of view. I used to be one of those young mormon men. Now, I still see the good in the mormon church still, but I also see the plastic testimony deliveries. Not all mormons deliver their message plasticly, but many do. Still, I like the mormons. And I like Robert Redford...he isn�t fully in touch with what he said, but he did have a point at the end.
Hicks was right to correct Redford that not every mormon male goes on a mission.
But Redford seems right about the plastic comment. There is fakeness in probably any large social structure. A lot of mormons in each Utah neighborhood I have lived in seem plastic in their delivery of niceties. But I don�t think it�s a bad thing...it is difficult to be sincerely nice all the time to everyone. It is better to be superficially nice, than to avoid others.
True that young mormon men often lack practice in considering the contrary points of view. I used to be one of those young mormon men. Now, I still see the good in the mormon church still, but I also see the plastic testimony deliveries. Not all mormons deliver their message plasticly, but many do. Still, I like the mormons. And I like Robert Redford...he isn�t fully in touch with what he said, but he did have a point at the end.
Not Important | 12:57 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
I am a practicing Mormon man, who went on a mission. I wasn't offended at
all by his comments. So he thinks that we are fake, so what? Some of us are. If
he wants to have misconceptions about something he doesn't know much about
that is fine by me. Lumping him in the category of Richards and Gibson would be
a mistake.
I do think he is rather lazy when it comes to logical reasoning, but that is his prerogative. We all make exaggerations and generalizations that aren't warranted. He should keep in mind his influence and hold his reasoning to a higher standard, but his comments don't mean much. It also doesn't show little class. I think to say he has little class is doing the same thing you are crying out against, it is making a character judgement on a little information.
I do think he is rather lazy when it comes to logical reasoning, but that is his prerogative. We all make exaggerations and generalizations that aren't warranted. He should keep in mind his influence and hold his reasoning to a higher standard, but his comments don't mean much. It also doesn't show little class. I think to say he has little class is doing the same thing you are crying out against, it is making a character judgement on a little information.
Comments continue below
Jane | 1:03 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
For someone who is as "open" as Robert Redford, his comments are
narrow-minded and embarrassing. How long does someone have to live in Utah to
know that not all young Mormon men go on missions? Hello! And to categorize all
Mormon men as "plastic" shows his ignorance and uneducated tolerance.
Maybe he should move to Hollywood where all the cool, "real" people
live.
C. G. Rice | 1:11 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
It appears that Robert Redford managed some free advertising for his new movie
(Rated R) with his anti-Mormon comments. I like Robert Redford as an actor. I
cannot agree with his political opinions. And it is unfortunate he does not take
pride in producing a great movie with a rating other than "R". What a
waste of talent.
not sure... | 1:32 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The problem is no one likes stereotypes - unless they're positive. We
don't ALL do anything, no matter what the group, although let's face
the facts, if you don't go on a mission in the LDS church, it is hard to
fit perfectly in the culture ever afterwards.
I'm not sure what "plastic" means. On a scale of 10, this is rather mild. I think the scrutiny is good even though the lack of info is amazing. We deserve much of what we get because so many in Utah equate 'righteousness' with membership in the conservative wing of the GOP.
Take a self-test: how many of us are more concerned with church service stats rather than building real relationships with those we serve? Do we merely know all the scriptures and conference talks on "love" or are we able to really love those who don't love us and forgive freely and unconditionally?? Are we plastic (artificial) or real followers of Christ?
Now I will sit back and see how many respond to Redford's comments and other posters in anger and contention vs. those who think we can improve...
I'm not sure what "plastic" means. On a scale of 10, this is rather mild. I think the scrutiny is good even though the lack of info is amazing. We deserve much of what we get because so many in Utah equate 'righteousness' with membership in the conservative wing of the GOP.
Take a self-test: how many of us are more concerned with church service stats rather than building real relationships with those we serve? Do we merely know all the scriptures and conference talks on "love" or are we able to really love those who don't love us and forgive freely and unconditionally?? Are we plastic (artificial) or real followers of Christ?
Now I will sit back and see how many respond to Redford's comments and other posters in anger and contention vs. those who think we can improve...
Too Sensitive | 2:16 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
This article is way overblown. The only thing Redford was saying about Mormons
is that they are trained to articulate a message (which they are). The comment
about being plastic was specifically directed at Mitt Romney (and it's
largely true).
Take a couple deep breaths. The world's not out to get Mormons. And really, if you're looking at people much more blatant in their feelings about Mormons, don't look at liberals, look at evangelical conservatives.
Take a couple deep breaths. The world's not out to get Mormons. And really, if you're looking at people much more blatant in their feelings about Mormons, don't look at liberals, look at evangelical conservatives.
BAC | 2:19 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The free advertising for "Lions of the Lamb" didn't work very
well. It should have been renamed "Cubbies in the Den" , but RR is
persistent.
Re: Henry | 3:10 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Why do you feel the need to lump in Gays with Mormons? If your not LDS then
don't speak for the rest of us. It's clear, with your quote of left
winger Andrew Young that you feel guilty about something. Don't tell us
were all biased. Bottom line, I don't care one bit for Redford, but as an
LDS person, I wasn't offended.
Old Enough | 3:44 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Ref to the Catholic comment when JFK was running for President.
Yes, the people were scared to death that the US Presidency was going to be ran by the POPE and we would loose our freedoms.
Did not Happen then either.
Yes, the people were scared to death that the US Presidency was going to be ran by the POPE and we would loose our freedoms.
Did not Happen then either.
Shawn | 3:49 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Hey Henry, your knowledge of Romney and Muslims on his cabinet is so typical of
people who don�t read the details from more than one or two
sources. Being Muslim isn�t the issue. Population wise,
Muslims are too few in numbers to justify a cabinet position just because their
a Muslim. Romney never said he wouldn�t appoint a person
to the cabinet who also happened to be Muslim. Being Muslim is simply not the
selection criteria Romney will use; as it should be.
As for Reobert Redford or any entertainer, their political opinions simply do not matter even though they think they do. I for one simply will not pay to see any of their films as my way to voice my objection to their political wonderings.
As for Reobert Redford or any entertainer, their political opinions simply do not matter even though they think they do. I for one simply will not pay to see any of their films as my way to voice my objection to their political wonderings.
Who cares | 3:53 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Who cares what Robert Redford says? He's an actor. He couldn't even be
nice to the Mormon he married and professed to love. Maybe he was faking it when
he told her he did? I guess she finally saw the plasticness.
Nyron | 3:55 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
It is true we as male Mormons do a lot of the same things over and over.
Basically it is the concept of training. Do it until you get it right. I would
appreciate, Mr. R. doing more homework though.
SLM | 3:57 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
You guys are reading entirely too much into this. Redford's comments that
"every Mormon man" goes on a mission is clearly false, but it seems to
me to be a genuine misconception in his part. And I don't see anything
offensive or mailicious about the error. He said "all" Mormon men,
when really it is only "some." So what? Anyone who is offended by that
mistake is clearly choosing to be.
As for the "plastic" comment, I read that as being directed specifically at Romney, not Mormon men in general. Redford's point seems to be that Mormon missionaries have to learn the skill of sticking to their message (the Gospel) even with they have "blows" (verbal attacks, misinformation, and all the other challenges a missionary faces) coming at them. Not only is that not an insult, it even almost sounds like a compliment. And then he simply concludes that in Romney's case, his display of that skill is "plastic." You think Redford is the first one to suggest that a politician is phony? I think we're being hypersensitive here.
(Sidenote: in its original sense, "plastic" simply means malleable, shapable, not "artificial"... FYI)
As for the "plastic" comment, I read that as being directed specifically at Romney, not Mormon men in general. Redford's point seems to be that Mormon missionaries have to learn the skill of sticking to their message (the Gospel) even with they have "blows" (verbal attacks, misinformation, and all the other challenges a missionary faces) coming at them. Not only is that not an insult, it even almost sounds like a compliment. And then he simply concludes that in Romney's case, his display of that skill is "plastic." You think Redford is the first one to suggest that a politician is phony? I think we're being hypersensitive here.
(Sidenote: in its original sense, "plastic" simply means malleable, shapable, not "artificial"... FYI)
AZ Mike | 4:49 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Re: not sure...
Your statement, "if you don't go on a mission in the LDS church, it is hard to fit perfectly in the culture ever afterwards." is misguided at best. I have served in a Bishopric for seven years now with a "non-mission" Bishop and "non-mission" 2nd Counselor. They both fit perfectly into Mormon culture. Maybe your comment centers on the Utah Mormon culture?
Your statement, "if you don't go on a mission in the LDS church, it is hard to fit perfectly in the culture ever afterwards." is misguided at best. I have served in a Bishopric for seven years now with a "non-mission" Bishop and "non-mission" 2nd Counselor. They both fit perfectly into Mormon culture. Maybe your comment centers on the Utah Mormon culture?
WoW! | 5:08 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
I think the ones on here who are members and are looking within analytically are
really the one's who are the true members. There are pockets around the
state where such things as kidnapping have happened because of this plastic
attitude. Civil right have been trampled on and a people have been held back
because they didn't buy into the norm set by the dominant religion.
Opportunities have been wasted on both sides to come to some kind of civil
understanding. Character assasination and hurt feelings abound when the system
heavily favors one side without ever feeling true charity to others. Even
members who have made gallant efforts in mediation have often been looked upon
as a crusader who just aren't right. Honesty is such a lonely word , yet
those that go against what is percieved to be the norm are to be commended
because the minute I think I have heard all the rhetoric there is one that
actually cares and listens,will emerge causiing me to not generalize!So I deal
with a person one at a time!
To Henry Drummond | 5:31 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Henry,
Please don't follow suit with the rest of the media and misrepresent the comments of Mitt Romney about Muslims. He never said he would not have someone of the Muslim faith in his cabinet. All he said was that he wouldn't appoint someone to his cabinet based solely on their being a Muslim.
Please don't follow suit with the rest of the media and misrepresent the comments of Mitt Romney about Muslims. He never said he would not have someone of the Muslim faith in his cabinet. All he said was that he wouldn't appoint someone to his cabinet based solely on their being a Muslim.
Carole Knowles | 5:55 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
An actor calling LDS men plastic. Has he looked in the mirror lately?
Doug | 5:56 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
So Mr.Redford, you think when Christ tells us to "love thy neighbor has
thyself" and we decide to heed that advise and apply it in our lives, we
are plastic? And when God commanded Moses not to kill, steal or have any graven
images, and we decide to again incorporate those principles in our lives, we are
plastic? Or when growing up and our parents would teach, advise and counsel us
and we did as they asked, we are plastic? When we heed the advise and warnings
from an individual we consider a prophet, we are plastic? If that is plastic,
then I am proud to say I am plastic.
JC Naples, FL | 6:18 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The reason Redford's comments did not receive any attention is that he is a
marginalized has-been.
He is irrelevant to any topic of substance. He is like the 80 year-old grandfather with alzheimer's, he is tolerated, but ignored.
Sundance has ridden into the sunset folks.
He is irrelevant to any topic of substance. He is like the 80 year-old grandfather with alzheimer's, he is tolerated, but ignored.
Sundance has ridden into the sunset folks.
question | 6:19 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Robert redford? the name sounds familier. Wasn't he an actor in the
70's
SLC | 6:40 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Hicks is right. The problem is that Redford intended to criticize Romney, and
maybe Republican politicians in general, but found it perfectly acceptable along
the way to take a bigoted pot-shot at Mormons.
Mason | 6:44 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Robert Redford is just a washed up old useless liberal who has nothing going for
him so he resorts to what the hollywood left does, blame anyone who believes in
God as the problem. It would be nice if the God fearing people of Utah would not
support his useless Sundance festival, all the those films are about drugs, sex,
perversion, molestation, satan, gay-lesbian that would not have a chance in the
theatres nationwide, so they have this retarted festival for people to go and
view and think it is some miracle that worthless films exist. Mr. Redford age is
showing heavily, phyisically and MENTALally!!!!
every religion | 6:48 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
has the "plastic" and the sincere. My dad did not go on a mission but
now is a Stake President. People really dont care. But there are some
exceptions. It is because we are in such a unique culture and such a high LDS
population that you see such a number of people who claim to be offended or
their neighbor is mean to them cause they didn't go on a mission.
plastic vs substance | 6:49 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The mormon people have been so busy setting themselves apart and tooting their
own horns about how they are so holier-than-thou, that they freak out when
people notice.
Plastic vs the real deal is an accurate descriptive term.
Plastic vs the real deal is an accurate descriptive term.
don peay | 6:51 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Redford,at his Sundance "wilderness resort" has clear cut timber,
built mechanized ski lifts to acces the back country, damed up the north fork
river to create a hold pond, built houses and lodging in environmentall sensity
areas, constructed a dining lodge on top of a ridge for lunch, cleary within
view scape of the wilderness boundary, ALL ACTS clear within violation of the
Wilderness act.
Yet, he is Utah's leading advocate for Wilderrness designation.
Sundance is a nice place, but why can Redford do all things and it is OK, yet on all other public lands, he wants Wilderness ?
Clearly a true hypocrite, not worhty of much more discussion
Yet, he is Utah's leading advocate for Wilderrness designation.
Sundance is a nice place, but why can Redford do all things and it is OK, yet on all other public lands, he wants Wilderness ?
Clearly a true hypocrite, not worhty of much more discussion
He's no expert | 6:52 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Consider the source. Redford isn't an expert on Utah, only Sundance. He
isn't an expert in politics, just has a big mouth, and an outlet to whine.
He isn't an expert on Mormons, he just married one. He has no expertise in
any of these areas, so his comment on Utah, Politics or Mormons are his opinion,
and not worth anyone's time.
Redford is an expert at one thing... making really bad films. And he is one of the very best at is, bravo. If he would like to make comments on how to make miserably bad films, I know I would listen. The man is legend there.
Redford is an expert at one thing... making really bad films. And he is one of the very best at is, bravo. If he would like to make comments on how to make miserably bad films, I know I would listen. The man is legend there.
George | 6:58 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
To Chris Hicks: I thought this was a "news" paper. That article ran
on November 8th. You mention "slandering Mormons has gradually become a
national pastime". What do you expect, when you keep dragging old
whorthless articles back around as if it were news. Let it die a natural death.
Besides, who cares what Robert Redford says or thinks.
tld | 7:18 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
All in favor of censuring Robert Redford for his comments about Mormon men being
"plastic" please signify by raising your right hand.
Anonymous | 7:18 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
I like the last line...let's leave religion out of it. Yeah, right, like
that happens in Utah. Nope, that gorilla is in every room where politics is
discussed, and now and again it stinks. Like now.
I'm no fan of celebrity in any form but Redford is more or less on the money. It's a bit of a generalisation, to be sure, but it's true. A lot of mormons, especially men, have a 'defend the faith' script well memorised, able to argue fine points like injury lawyers. It seldom seems sincere or genuine.
In any case, maybe there's a message in here. The mainstream rebranding efforts of the church inc. haven't paid off yet. Up on the big stage, it seems that the costume is a little thin, and mormonism needs a bit more polishing before it is seen as absolutely mainstream. Call in the PR people.
I'm no fan of celebrity in any form but Redford is more or less on the money. It's a bit of a generalisation, to be sure, but it's true. A lot of mormons, especially men, have a 'defend the faith' script well memorised, able to argue fine points like injury lawyers. It seldom seems sincere or genuine.
In any case, maybe there's a message in here. The mainstream rebranding efforts of the church inc. haven't paid off yet. Up on the big stage, it seems that the costume is a little thin, and mormonism needs a bit more polishing before it is seen as absolutely mainstream. Call in the PR people.
Move On | 7:23 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Are we really still discussing this???
Let's move on. We're beating the rigormortis out of this horse.
Initial statements and reactions are fine -- as long as they match the ideals of patience, forgiveness, and turning the other cheek -- we so loudly proclaim. However, this is old, old news.
Why re-incite peoples anger now??
Unpleasant comment? Yes. But it is time to move forward.
I'm suprised this piece was published. It was written two weeks ago by 400 others who posted in response to Redford's comments.
Let's move on. We're beating the rigormortis out of this horse.
Initial statements and reactions are fine -- as long as they match the ideals of patience, forgiveness, and turning the other cheek -- we so loudly proclaim. However, this is old, old news.
Why re-incite peoples anger now??
Unpleasant comment? Yes. But it is time to move forward.
I'm suprised this piece was published. It was written two weeks ago by 400 others who posted in response to Redford's comments.
Marky | 7:29 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Lighten up. It's Robert Redford. Is there anything more artificial or
"plastic" than a man who makes a living by pretending to be something
or someone that he is not?
Who cares what he says or thinks about the Mormon religion? His day in the sun is just about over. As he continues to age and lose his boyish charm and looks, he will become increasingly irrelevant. At the other end of the spectrum is Joseph Smith. His relevance in the world continues to grow many years after his death.
Who cares what he says or thinks about the Mormon religion? His day in the sun is just about over. As he continues to age and lose his boyish charm and looks, he will become increasingly irrelevant. At the other end of the spectrum is Joseph Smith. His relevance in the world continues to grow many years after his death.
true blue | 7:34 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
To Henry Drummond,
Romney never said he wouldn't have a muslim on his cabinet, what he said was he didn't think it was necessary to have a muslim on the cabinet in order to understand islamic extremist.
Make sure you know the facts.
Romney never said he wouldn't have a muslim on his cabinet, what he said was he didn't think it was necessary to have a muslim on the cabinet in order to understand islamic extremist.
Make sure you know the facts.
Reality | 7:47 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
There is enough truth in what Redford is saying to merit attention to improving
our manners. For those who would like first hand experience attend a Sunday
preisthood meeting as a freethinking curious member and learn how easy you are
silenced and ostracized until you have learned the lesson of conformity.
Remain calm... | 7:58 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
We've had this argument already. Does the DNews have a quota for reader
comments and feel the need to reprint controversial stories to meet those
quotas?
A few comments are calm and well reasoned but most turn into mindless rantings from what seems to be the worst of our communities.
There is a reason they require your name and address to be printed in the editorials that make the actual paper. Being anonymous allows people to say and act in ways they never otherwise would.
Robert Redford spoke his mind. Do I agree with all of it? No. What he has to say in the long run has little to do with how I feel about myself and my religion though. I'm sure he has many good qualities and I will choose to think of him in that way. The rest we should just deal with and move on.
A few comments are calm and well reasoned but most turn into mindless rantings from what seems to be the worst of our communities.
There is a reason they require your name and address to be printed in the editorials that make the actual paper. Being anonymous allows people to say and act in ways they never otherwise would.
Robert Redford spoke his mind. Do I agree with all of it? No. What he has to say in the long run has little to do with how I feel about myself and my religion though. I'm sure he has many good qualities and I will choose to think of him in that way. The rest we should just deal with and move on.
kyle | 7:59 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
slow news day?
Lose the edge! | 8:01 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Redford's comment was in fact "lazy" and rushed and inaccurate
and it deserved to be corrected. BUT let's lose the "everyone's
out to get us" edge. I like Redford but this is a Hollywood celebrity
sharing an opinion - nothing more. It's not as if Boggs issued another
extermination order. The more we react, the more "plastic" we sound.
Roger | 8:09 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
I thought all young men were commanded to go on missions. In fact, that is why
I went. Saying Mormon boys aren't required to go on missions is like
saying Mormons aren't required to abstain from alcohol. Sure, some
don�t, but that doesn�t mean it
isn�t a commandment. If Jay Leno would have said,
�Mormons don�t have sex before
marriage� would you object and say that many in fact do,
and cite free agency as the reason?
Redford was correct: the *way* that Romney deflects blows and stays on message is plastic. It�s a speech pattern missionaries are taught. As a missionary, I spent an hour every day role playing �effective� and �ineffective� ways to express my feelings. �Effective� wasn�t defined as sincere, but rather as being clear and confident. The Missionary Guide would give an example of a missionary saying something like, �I think the church might be true; it�s the best thing I�ve come across so far!� If you were role playing in the MTC and said that, you�d be reproached for not displaying enough confidence, and would then practice saying something more effective, like, �I know the church is true.�
Plastic? You bet.
Redford was correct: the *way* that Romney deflects blows and stays on message is plastic. It�s a speech pattern missionaries are taught. As a missionary, I spent an hour every day role playing �effective� and �ineffective� ways to express my feelings. �Effective� wasn�t defined as sincere, but rather as being clear and confident. The Missionary Guide would give an example of a missionary saying something like, �I think the church might be true; it�s the best thing I�ve come across so far!� If you were role playing in the MTC and said that, you�d be reproached for not displaying enough confidence, and would then practice saying something more effective, like, �I know the church is true.�
Plastic? You bet.
Redford leave Utah -please | 8:17 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
A note to Bob Redford - leave Utah PLEASE! You only spend a couple of months
high atop your glorious perch at Sundance and then you fly back to your Malibu
beach house to be amoung your wonderful Holywood flakes. You never were a real
Utah resident anyway. Has anyone ever had a Redford sighting out in public -
other than some celeb event? No way. Bob is too good for the normal folks of
Utah many of which are ...gasp....MORMONS!!! This idiot knows next to NOTHING
about the LDS faith, its missionary program but like many of his uninformed
brethren in the acting business (Shawn Penn, etc..) he likes to open his mouth
alot and insert his foot. We really don't need or want you in Utah Bob.
Time to move on man!!
Am I Wrong? | 8:18 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The part of the article that stood out to me:"Mormons aren't robots.
One of the LDS Church's basic tenets is that people have been given free
will to choose for themselves."
My understanding is that one of the basic tenets of the LDS church is "obedience" - isn't that contradictory to "free will"? I also remember something about the LDS Church encouraging - "Do not question authority".
My understanding is that one of the basic tenets of the LDS church is "obedience" - isn't that contradictory to "free will"? I also remember something about the LDS Church encouraging - "Do not question authority".
willie | 8:23 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
from the comments posted, it appears that Mormons ARE thin skinned. "Oh
poor me, I'm being picked on because I'm peculiar" is the mantra
I see here. And Mormons wonder why they are picked on with great regularity. It
is because you bring it on yourself! Want to stop being thought of as weird,
judgmental and holi-than thou? Well, stop doing it.
JB | 8:25 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
There is no question the ramifications of anti-Mormon remarks are far less than,
say, an anti-Jewish (or pick your minority) remark. Look no further than the
UofU paper. I must admit, I felt complimented by Redford's remarks, until
the dig at the end. Nice. And his opinion, unfortunately, does matter than
most (to the "outside world") because he is likely the most famous
Hollywood celebrity in Utah (not that it says much). His remarks will take on
more authority, whether merited or not.
Will his opinion ever affect my life? No. Am I offended that my sincerety is called into question by many of the people in this forum because I am taught to be a good citizen and "love my neighbor"? Saddened, but I'll pull through.
Will his opinion ever affect my life? No. Am I offended that my sincerety is called into question by many of the people in this forum because I am taught to be a good citizen and "love my neighbor"? Saddened, but I'll pull through.
Tom in Evanston | 8:35 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Mr. Redford is certainly welcome to his opinions but like other intellectually
bankrupt, mean spirited inhabitants of Zion, why would he continue to live and
do business among us if he feels this way. It amazes me that so many folks who
live in the area stay here where they are constantly confronted with so many
things/behaviors that disgust them? Their actions bely the fact they like to be
around us "plastic" people. It's also interesting the comments
offered up on Robert's statements are not laced with vitriol or diatribe.
Maybe we should just turn the other cheek and love him to pieces...or not.
Anonymous | 8:35 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Redford Rules! The truth hurts! OUCH!!!!
Rich | 8:38 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
A bigot is a bigot. Some of you commenting on this article are bigots. Being
an ex-Mormon does not excuse your bigotry. It's easy to determine
who's a bigot. It's somebody who judges somebody they don't know
by a stereotype of the group to which they belong. Anybody who thinks that all
blondes are dumb is a bigot (and stupid as well). Are all Jews cutthroats in
business? Are all Mexicans lazy? Are all gays pedophiles? Are all ex-Mormons
immoral? As somebody who has lived outside of Utah, I've heard bigoted
comments about Mormons and others my entire life. Hearing them has helped me
recognize and reject stereotypes about many groups. Those of you who believe and
perpetrate stereotypes are bigots, whether you realize it or not. Stereotypes
hurt. Passing on a stereotype says a great deal about your ignorance, stupidity
and meanness.
Anti-bigot | 8:39 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The odd thing about a stereotype is that it usually results from a minority
rather than a majority. In fact, if you believe the opposite of a stereotype,
you'll usually get it right. Most Mexicans I know work very hard. Most
Catholic priests are moral. Most blacks are just as honest as anybody else (and
aren't very good at basketball, either). Ironically, anti-Mormon bigots
often blame Mormons of bigotry. How stupid they are to say such things as all
Mormons hate gays, or Mormons hate non-Mormons, or Mormons hate liberals, or
Mormons are racial bigots. I've known some Mormons who are bigots, but
most Mormons I've known are among the most loving, accepting people on
earth.
"Top 10 Class Act?" | 8:42 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
As a young man I used to enjoy Bob Redford's work on the big screen. I
have watched him become bigoted, bitter and cynical as he has aged. This is not
his first "comments" about mormons or other Utah issues. It is
interesting how he is another example of "biting the hand that feeds
him" from a people that is so willing to embrace him. I wonder how many
"Mormons" ski at his resort or support the other activities that go on
there each year? What good does it do to voice those negative opinions and
feelings openly? Maybe he should move to Hollywood where he can revel in his
glory as a ten act. Another layer of luster has been tarnished from one
"hollywoods golden boy's" image. Oh yeah, I forgot,this type of
behavior helps them in Hollywood right?
Reality | 8:43 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
Thanks, and congradulations to the Deseret News for its courage and fairness in
supporting an open forum for public expression of different views of
today's news. Other news papers should follow The Deseret News lead. Other
news papers require information on participants so that they build up an
information base of names that will be used to contact for commercial use. The
last thing I need is more junk mail or telephone calls. Again, thx DN>
Walter | 8:47 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
We should know by now that liberals have only one agenda and it is to promote
their own agenda, so when Redford makes senceless comments like that one, he is
only trying to get free publicity for his new movie, we shouldn't pay
attention to it
Joseph Mitchell | 8:47 a.m. Nov. 30, 2007
The article title speakes for it's self, and says it all!
Add your comment
Comments are monitored. Any comments found to be abusive, offensive, off-topic, misrepresentative, more than 200 words or containing URLs will not be posted.
Words Remaining
E-mail address: For internal use only. We may want to contact you to publish your comment (not your e-mail address) in the newspaper or for a separate story idea.
- NFL: Week 12 recap 12:50 a.m.
- '12 Days' bill would top $87K 12:35 a.m.
- Study finds autism therapy works 12:35 a.m.
- Boy shot following traffic stop 12:35 a.m.
- Sports on the air 12:24 a.m.
- Herbert builds his team of rivals 12:21 a.m.
- Corroon a step closer to governor 12:21 a.m.
- Monday on TV 12:18 a.m.
- Editorial: East, West and religion 12:17 a.m.
- A deficit commission? 12:17 a.m.
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
- BYU is champion of the state
- Cougars beat Utes in overtime
- Credit Coug defense for win
- Marriage definitions vary widely
- Field goals, penalties doomed Utes
- Cougar defense rose to occasion
- Banged up Jazz get best of Blazers
- Jones' joy for life remembered
- Fantasy is reality for BYU professor
- Hall mouths off about hate of Utah
869 - Cougars beat Utes in overtime473
- Max Hall issues apology145
- BYU is champion of the state137
- Man trapped in Nutty Putty cave dies117
- Cave to be sealed with body inside116
- Rivalry Week is highly profane90
- Hall's legacy measured today79
- Hall's pain reflects self-betrayal68
- Utes fall to Seattle U. at home65
The Wall Street Journal has reported that the holiday retail season...
When "Dancing With The Stars" began more than two months ago, 16 couples...
Comedian Brian Regan, who is scheduled to perform at Abravanel Hall on...
Latest comments
I find it interesting that many of the same people who say that we can't...
None of these teams is going to be easy. They all have fine football...
Max, no apology was necessary, but the apology was polically correct. If...
Very good piece of writing, Amy. You summarized what many of us have been...
How is a top 25 finish make Utah a top twenty team? I think what the poster...
90% of the BYU & Utah fans have class, and Hall knows it. If you don't...
This might be my favorite article I've ever read from the Deseret News. Kudos.
Thank you for not giving up and don't give up now brother and sister...
Dr. Lois Lee's work with children who are victims of child sexual...
Look at the preview for Pixar's "Up". The whole move is summarized in...
Advertisements