By the numbers: Ejections in Utah high school sports

Published: Tuesday, April 8 2014 1:43 p.m. MDT

The Utah High School Activities Association and high school administrators are grappling with what to do about the high number of ejections from prep soccer games. The issues came to the attention of those who oversee high school sports two weeks ago when the number of ejections jumped to 51 in just three weeks of competition. The Deseret News talked to coaches, principals and UHSAA staff about the issue in a story published March 30.

The statistics kept by UHSAA officials show that boys soccer has had higher ejection numbers since the organization began recording those numbers almost two decades ago. There are a number of reasons. First, soccer rules are such that sometimes a player is ejected after receiving a second yellow card (referred to as a soft red card), and it’s an infraction that wouldn’t get an athlete ejected in another sport. The statistics are not separated into soft and hard red cards, but officials said the ejections are not completely explained by the unique rules of soccer. Some of the reason offered by those involved with the sport were:
  1. The aging official population, as well as the difference in the speed of the game for prep boys players. Over the years there have been issues with having enough qualified officials available for high school games, but the UHSAA has instituted a number of programs aimed at recruiting and retention. They’re investigating new training used by club soccer programs.
  2. The proximity of fans to the field of play. There is very little space between the fans and the sideline, which can lead to verbal exchanges that escalate emotions. Most acknowledge that fans at soccer games are also a much more negative influence than at other sports.
  3. Poor sportsmanship from players and coaches. The UHSAA has programs aimed at both punishing the offenders and rewarding those who behave, so this aspect has gotten better at a lot of schools. But most everyone acknowledges some schools still have sportsmanship issues that include bad behavior by the adults on the sidelines.
The numbers are most certainly alarming, but officials hope by addressing all of the contributing factors, they will be able to get a handle on the problem. Here is a look at the ejections, along with the number of ejections in other sports.

Twitter: adonsports EMAIL: adonaldson@deseretnews.com

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
bevery hills, UT

Games played in the afternoon on weekdays will never give way to the best possible officials in any sport. The pool to choose from is extremely small, a majority of those that would/could officiate have careers that won't allow for time off work at 3:30, 2-4 times a week. It is a joke to hear the UHSAA has done things to recruit more officials. They'll take what they can get and a pulse will qualify you.

Provo, UT

Wrestling--a contact sport where honor is important. I see for male sports of a contact nature it leads the way in regards to the best sportsmanship.

Brave Sir Robin
San Diego, CA

This data is absolute worthless garbage.

- It's not normalized for number of participants. There are a lot more players on a soccer team (11) than a basketball team (5). It stands to reason that there would be a lot more ejections in a soccer game.
- They're counting among soccer ejections players who pick up two yellow cards, which most often comes from too many regular old fouls. But they didn't count basketball players who foul out.

West Jordan, UT

I agree with the point that has been made that boys soccer player ejections may not be accurately represented here because of the yellow and red card system. That said, the data here is hardly useless. Boys soccer coach ejections are still basically 3 times what they are in football, which is also an emotional contact sport.

Don't kid yourself, there is still a huge problem with sportsmanship and anger control among adults associated with boys soccer.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments