BYU football report card: Cougar special teams, red zone execution prove lackluster in loss to Washington

Published: Saturday, Dec. 28 2013 12:46 a.m. MST

Jeffrey D. Allred

SAN FRANCISCO — BYU came out flat and ended completely flat in a 31-16 loss to Washington Friday night at the Fight Hunger Bowl. The Cougars did almost all their good work in the second quarter, but that wasn't nearly enough against the solid, and more consistent, Huskies.

Grades are in for every position group regarding Friday's performance:

Email: bgurney@desnews.com Twitter: @BrandonCGurney

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Ed Grady
Idaho Falls, ID

B- for coaching? Are you kidding me? Mendenhall has become a Teflon coach - nothing sticks to him.

Rock Hill, SC

Really, B- for coaching? When you only use 6 of the allowed 15 practices you get an F. If not for this game, for the young kids on the squad that can get extra reps and practice in preparation for next year. To not even use half of the allowed practices you are either ignorant of the opportunity for development or you really don't care. Keep Mendenhall! Go Utes! Too bad we can't keep the automatic W for the next two seasons.


Just 6 of 15 allowed? I guess football is 5th to Bronco. Maybe he didn't want to watch the O-Line in practice, I wouldn't.

Delta, UT

I agree Ed. B- is very generous especially when you look at the 2nd half when coaches make adjustments and we get out scored 10-0. The defense was ok but could not get Washington off the field in several 3rd and long situations. Isn't that broncos department? Well I do think the cougs played hard and taysom hill is a warrior! Once again I am confused at the offensive plan? Lots of planned runs for the QB and only 12 for our RB. No screens or short passes to the RB and whatever happened to TE university? Do we even have a TE? Hoffman and van noy will be missed but I think both will make lots of money at the next level. Well I can't help it. I still love the cougars and will always root for them.

Horrible Stumper
Hyrum, UT

This is an Aggie fan that rooted for the Cougars to win this game. I don't see the Cougars week in and week out, but from what I have seen I felt that the Cougars were athletically the equal of Washington. I think Taysom is the real deal. After watching the Poinsettia Bowl I felt like Taysom is equal to or better than Jordan Lynch, who finished 3rd in the Heisman Trophy voting. But no matter how good of an athlete you are you have to be put in a position to perform to the best of your ability. BYU football players did not perform to the best of their ability, and unfortunately that is coaching. Coach Mendenhall did not put them in a position to win. I believe he is a great person, but if BYU is going to become the top 10 team they say they want to be, they need Bronco to step up his game.....or replace him. Decent season, but not where the rest of the state is use to seeing the Cougars. BYU should be able to compete against any PAC 10+2 team.

Fruit Heights, Utah

Other commenters got it right. The only way BYU gets to the next level and back to the glory days is with a new head coach, current one just not getting it done.

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments