BYU report card: Cougars respond with resolute win over Middle Tennessee

Published: Saturday, Sept. 28 2013 12:39 a.m. MDT

Overall Next List » 5 of 5 « Prev
BYU overcame several turnovers to at least approach the Texas game as their best collective performance of the young season — especially considering the Cougars were without Williams, star receiver Cody Hoffman (suspension) and several offensive linemen. The errors certainly give the Cougars something to work on as they prepare for the Aggies. Hill showed that he may not be as far away as thought from being an effective passer. The defense may have had its best performance in BYU’s four games.

  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Stockton, CA

The special award for perseverance needs to go to Adam Hine for continuing his kickoff return run for 90 years!!

Salt Lake City, UT

The fact that it was Middle Tennessee State should take each grade down at least 1/2.

Hyrum, UT

It's getting difficult to tell the BYU fans from the Utah fans in these comments to BYU articles. Such easy flowing negativity. The grade such fans deserve is D- at best.

River Falls, WI

I don't know how a team that registered five turnovers can get a B+ grade. I give them a C. Now that being said, I think we did see some improvement in key areas this game. Hill not only completed 14 passes, but he spread the field and didn't have nearly as many horrible throws. He could have had another 300 yard rushing night if he wanted. Hine amazingly looks NFL ready to me. I'd love to see what he could do as a running back instead of simply a kick return specialist. Alisa continues to disappoint and Lasike does what he's asked to (bruise). We won't know how good the receivers are until they get a few more throws but we're making progress there. The D, as always, looks solid. This was a good stepping stone victory.

DEW Cougars
Sandy, UT

I did wondered why QB Olsen didn't get inserted at all. Come coaches you can do better to let other guys 2nd/3rd strings to get the expierance.

What in Tucket?
Provo, UT

Hine will definitely be an asset. Brown was a pleasant surprise and will also help. I would keep Williams and Hine out against USU. Olsen should have come in sooner and had a chance to throw. He needs the work and may have to replace Hill at any time. He won't be ready. This was one chance to allow him a whole quarter. I think USU may have the edge next week, but BYU obviously has a chance.

Greenwood, IN

DEW,Why insert second stringers, when your first string offense is still trying to carve out an identity for itself?

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments