History of the rivalry: The top 15 BYU vs. Utah football games

Published: Monday, Sept. 16 2013 11:15 p.m. MDT

A rivalry is born: April 6, 1896 — Utah 12, BYA 4 Next » 1 of 15 « Prev
There's some dispute on when the rivalry actually began. BYU doesn't count any games before 1922, but Utah counts the six games when BYU was still Brigham Young Academy.

However, Utah is right to count those first six games as the genesis of the rivalry.

After all, passions ran high after Utah beat BYA 12-4. The first rivalry brawl followed the first rivalry game, according to BYUCougars.com.

The actual game didn't count for much as it was a spring scrimmage, but its aftermath sets this game apart in history.
Next » 1 of 15 « Prev
Comments
  • Oldest first
  • Newest first
  • Most recommended
Sparkley Briefs
New York, NY

For my money, the best game was the 1985 Guy Gibbs Bowl, with the all-time greatest play being Erroll Tucker's punt return that was called back on a dubious penalty. I know, the play didn't count, but Tucker bobbed, weaved, and ran circles around the coverage for about 150 yards before finding the end zone. BYU finally drove the wooden stake through the Utes' hearts with a 90 yard run by Lakei Hemulli late in the 4th. Just my opinion...

jdub1942
PROVO, UT

No 54-10?

No 2008 game that set up the biggest bowl win in the History of the State of Utah and the MWC?

metamoracoug
metamora, IL

Yeah, I admit I like the choice as #1 just because it's soooo funny to watch the Ute fans storm the field . . . three times.

LoveTheKittens
The Middle Of, UT

What about the Snow Bowl and the end of 'The Streak'? Utes 3 Cougs 0.

jbarr
North Ogden, UT

There are many college football rivalries that are much more intense that BYU-UTAH. It's even less of a rivalry since they are now in different conferences. I guess it's still kind of a rivalry. Kind of like UTAH-COLORADO.

VegasUte
Las Vegas, NV

Des News should have had 54-10 in there with a picture of the Arby's billboard!

metamoracoug:

Glad to see at least one cougar who finds humor in losing a third straight to their arch-rival in his team's "Superbowl"

Go Utes! Here's to four straight and eight of eleven in Provo!

gonefishn
Salt Lake City, UT

This list is silly, the headline is "top 15 BYU vs Utah football games" but only about half the games listed were all that great. For Instance; Jim McMahon's game is on this list because he blew out a bad team and showed up some fans?
Just make different lists like Best Games, Best Finishes, Biggest Personalities etc etc.

gdog3finally
West Jordan, Utah

2008 left out? whatever.

Uteology
East Salt Lake City, Utah

I agree that the 2008 was the best rivalry game.

Printing 50,000 preseason Quest t-shirts, only to get rolled over by your rival to accomplish your quest.... priceless!

to comment

DeseretNews.com encourages a civil dialogue among its readers. We welcome your thoughtful comments.
About comments