With the warmth of summer, big national and international issues like tea party election results, prisoner exchanges and greenhouse emissions are heating up. But in Utah, we’re dealing with much more prosaic matters — issues, nonetheless, that elicit strong emotions.
Concerned about air quality, Salt Lake City Ralph Becker wants to cancel the city’s traditional fireworks displays for the July 4 and July 24 holidays. Is this just silly, or does Becker have a point?
Pignanelli: “[Independence Day] ought to be solemnized with pomp and parade, with shows, games, sports, guns, bells, bonfires, and illuminations, from one end of this continent to the other.” — John Adams
July 4 is the greatest holiday on our calendar-beyond patriotic reasons. No presents-so it's guilt free. Active participants wear shorts and T-shirts. There's always a concert and fireworks.
So when learning of Becker’s idea to eliminate fireworks for air quality reasons, I joined the army of opposition. How dare the bicycle-obsessed mayor sacrifice a grand tradition of this country? Soon, I realized the true genius of Becker’s action. During the horrible inversion months, Wasatch Front residents demand that officials remedy the problem, but with out inconveniencing them. This is an impossible situation. The mayor is making a statement: if the state truly wants greater quality air throughout the year, then we must alter our lifestyles. So the bigger issue is not sacrificing fireworks, but the willingness to dramatically reduce the amount of time residents spend in activities that emit pollution.
Webb: I decline to get fired up over this matter. I’m a boring old guy, so I’m not much interested in fireworks, unless I attend with my grandchildren in their own cities. Becker does have a point. Pollution levels explode during fireworks shows. I have written many times that air pollution is caused by a million little actions each of us take every day. Every time we turn on a light or drive down the road we’re contributing our bit to pollution. It will take a million little actions to significantly reduce pollution. So cancelling fireworks isn’t a big deal, and isn’t going to solve the big problem, but it’s an important symbolic gesture.
Utahns are witnessing a surprising event — the American Civil Liberties Union (sort of) defending the Days of ’47 Parade Committee. The Salt Lake City Council was considering sending a letter asking the Committee to reverse its decision disallowing Mormons Building Bridges (supporting gay rights) to participate in the parade. The ACLU told the City Council sending an official letter to influence a private event would be improper. Is this the end of days? Is the Committee or the Council out of line?
Pignanelli: There is merit in the axiom "Everyone is Irish on St. Patrick's Day." All revel in the contributions made by immigrants from Ireland (I am half Irish which made for interesting family dynamics during childhood). A similar adage applies in Utah where "Everyone is Mormon on Pioneer Day". Regardless of their faith, all true Utahns are proud and grateful for the founding of this state. Also, almost every gay/lesbian LDS adherent I know is enormously honored by his or her Mormon heritage. Therefore, any group willing to build a tasteful and entertaining float that highlights this history should be welcome — especially since parade audiences must endure numerous boring politicians.
Webb: The ACLU supports liberal causes 99 percent of the time, but every once in a blue moon it defends the legal prerogatives of conservatives, just for the fun of it. The parade committee is correct and consistent in its policy not to allow advocacy organizations in the parade. It would be a mess if groups advocating for gun rights, gay rights, animal rights, off-road access, wilderness areas and other environmental causes, all expected a presence in Utah’s biggest parade. If you allow one in, you must allow all. Keep the parade free from ideological causes.
Students in Wasatch County are complaining that yearbook editors manipulated photos to remove tattoos and cover bare shoulders. However, news reports indicate the alterations and adherence to the dress code were not consistent. Is this a last stand in the culture wars or a hopeless gesture?
Pignanelli: Apparently, altering yearbook photos occurs throughout the state. This begs the question: have school administrators watched basic network television in the last five years? What passes for "safe" primetime viewing is more shocking than bare shoulders and tattoos. This front in the culture war ended long ago.
Webb: Nothing wrong with reasonable dress standards if they are applied consistently, and students and parents are fully aware of the rules, including for yearbook photos. But altering photos seems draconian, especially if it isn’t done skillfully and tastefully. Better to ask the students to come back later wearing appropriate clothing for a reshoot. If these things are handled arbitrarily or inconsistently, students and parents have a legitimate complaint.
Republican LaVarr Webb is a political consultant and lobbyist. Previously he was policy deputy to Gov. Mike Leavitt and Deseret News managing editor. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org. Democrat Frank Pignanelli is a Salt Lake attorney, lobbyist and political adviser. Pignanelli served 10 years in the Utah House of Representatives, six years as minority leader. His spouse, D'Arcy Dixon Pignanelli, is a state tax commissioner. Email: email@example.com.
Copyright 2017, Deseret News Publishing Company