Quantcast

Among most polluted in U.S., N.Y. area awaits cleanup

Published: Saturday, March 2 2013 11:13 p.m. MST

In this Oct. 24, 2012 photo Phillip Musegaas, an environmental lawyer for Riverkeeper, leads a boat tour of Newtown Creek in New York. Just across the East River from Manhattan, within sight of the United Nations and shimmering midtown skyscrapers, tens of millions of gallons of pollution are awaiting cleanup in a neighborhood where working-class families have lived for generations and wealthier ones are moving in. Newtown Creek straddling Brooklyn and Queens is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press) In this Oct. 24, 2012 photo Phillip Musegaas, an environmental lawyer for Riverkeeper, leads a boat tour of Newtown Creek in New York. Just across the East River from Manhattan, within sight of the United Nations and shimmering midtown skyscrapers, tens of millions of gallons of pollution are awaiting cleanup in a neighborhood where working-class families have lived for generations and wealthier ones are moving in. Newtown Creek straddling Brooklyn and Queens is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press)

NEW YORK — Just across the East River from midtown Manhattan's shimmering skyscrapers sits one of the nation's most polluted neighborhoods, fouled by generations of industrial waste, overflow from the city's sewage system and an underground oil leak bigger than the Exxon Valdez spill.

It's easy to see — and smell — the filth in and around Newtown Creek, which runs through an area of working-class homes, warehouses and industrial lots straddling Brooklyn and Queens. The odor of petroleum mixes with the smell of sewage, particularly on rainy days when the city's treatment plants can't handle the volume and municipal pipes send trash and human waste straight into the creek.

Oily, rainbow-slicked water is filled with soda cans, plastic bottles, raw sewage and decaying food. Ditched vehicles are stuck in the mud on the banks. And what was once a creek teeming with fish, surrounded by marshland, is now a dull gray waterway that cannot sustain life.

This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows old city pipes that bring New York City's overflow sewage and wastewater to New York's Newtown Creek,  at an estimated rate of 1.5 billion gallons per year. During heavy rainstorms, when the city's waste treatment plants reach capacity, raw sewage and wet garbage spill into the creek thorough hundreds of pipes on its banks.(AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press) This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows old city pipes that bring New York City's overflow sewage and wastewater to New York's Newtown Creek, at an estimated rate of 1.5 billion gallons per year. During heavy rainstorms, when the city's waste treatment plants reach capacity, raw sewage and wet garbage spill into the creek thorough hundreds of pipes on its banks.(AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press)

"It's the byproduct of our society," says environmentalist John Lipscomb of the Riverkeeper clean-water advocacy group. "What was originally a watershed is now a sewage shed."

After generations of neglect, the first, small steps are being taken in a multi-pronged cleanup that could take at least a dozen years and cost hundreds of millions of dollars. But even the most hopeful officials acknowledge the watershed may never be clear of all pollutants.

There was a time when Newtown Creek was the city's industrial mecca. The Rockefellers operated the nation's first modern refineries on its banks in the late 1800s. Others quickly sprang up.

For much of the 20th century, the neighborhood teemed with commercial vessels and factories that made products as varied as fertilizers, chemicals, lumber and glue. Their oil and other hazardous waste was either dumped or leaked into the creek, bit by bit, accumulating at the bottom.

This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows  floating containment booms meant to keep oil slicks away from the banks of Newtown Creek in New York. Just across the East River from Manhattan, within sight of the United Nations and shimmering midtown skyscrapers, tens of millions of gallons of pollution are awaiting cleanup in a neighborhood where working-class families have lived for generations and wealthier ones are moving in. Newtown Creek straddling Brooklyn and Queens is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press) This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows floating containment booms meant to keep oil slicks away from the banks of Newtown Creek in New York. Just across the East River from Manhattan, within sight of the United Nations and shimmering midtown skyscrapers, tens of millions of gallons of pollution are awaiting cleanup in a neighborhood where working-class families have lived for generations and wealthier ones are moving in. Newtown Creek straddling Brooklyn and Queens is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press)

The first sign of the looming ecological disaster came on Oct. 5, 1950, when petroleum gases from the hidden spill seeped into the sewer and caught fire, causing an explosion that blew dozens of manhole covers three stories into the air, shattering windows in hundreds of buildings and ripping a street open. Three people were injured.

But decades would pass before the creek got any real attention.

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency declared Newtown Creek a Superfund site in 2010 — "one of the most polluted urban water bodies in the country," according to EPA regional administrator Judith Enck.

Today, the creek's bottom is lined with a 15-foot-thick layer of petroleum-based pollutants that scientists have dubbed "black mayonnaise." The ooze penetrated the shoreline and now sits on top of the water table dozens of feet under Brooklyn's gentrifying Greenpoint neighborhood. More than 300,000 people still live within a mile of the creek.

A factory towers above the banks of Dutch Kills, a navigable tributary of Newtown Creek. The creek is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields.   (Associated Press) A factory towers above the banks of Dutch Kills, a navigable tributary of Newtown Creek. The creek is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (Associated Press)

Scientists are using sonar to probe the muck in the 3.5-mile waterway in hopes of determining the best way to conduct the cleanup, which will be financed by six entities that inherited the pollution: Exxon Mobil, Texaco Inc., the Phelps Dodge Refining Corp., BP Products North America Inc., National Grid NY and the city of New York.

One method used at other Superfund sites is to dredge the sediment from barges carrying cranes with scoopers, then capping the bottom to block any residue of oil, pesticides, chemicals and other pollutants.

"The mud is so heavily saturated with oil you can smell it," says Phillip Musegaas, a Riverkeeper attorney who spearheaded several lawsuits linked to the pollution. "I've never seen anything like it."

A separate cleanup targets the Greenpoint underground oil spill, which covers the equivalent of about 55 football fields. By some estimates, the oil spilled there amounted to as much as 30 million gallons, dwarfing the 11 million gallons released by the Exxon Valdez tanker in Alaska in 1989.

This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows one of New York's 14 wastewater treatment plants, they city's biggest and newest, on Newtown Creek. During heavy rainstorms, when the treatment plants reach capacity, raw sewage and wet garbage spill into the creek thorough hundreds of pipes on its banks. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press) This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows one of New York's 14 wastewater treatment plants, they city's biggest and newest, on Newtown Creek. During heavy rainstorms, when the treatment plants reach capacity, raw sewage and wet garbage spill into the creek thorough hundreds of pipes on its banks. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press)

Exactly how so much oil spread through the ground is still a question, but one thing is certain, according to the EPA: The sources of the spill were dozens of oil refineries and storage tanks built along the banks of Newtown Creek starting in the 1860s. Their petroleum and waste discharges leaked or were dumped into both the soil and the water at a time when there was little regulation or oversight. Some may have come from ships carrying the oil.

Under terms of a 2010 settlement with then-New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo and a related agreement with Riverkeeper, Exxon Mobil agreed to pay $19.5 million for projects to benefit the area's environment. The question of who will pay for the creek's entire cleanup will be answered after preliminary EPA studies are done.

So far, 12 million gallons of oil have been extracted using pumps inserted into dozens of wells.

When the two cleanups are done — on separate timetables — there's still "the icing on the cupcake," as Musegaas calls about 11/2 billion gallons of wastewater that flows into Newtown Creek each year from the city's combined sewage and storm drain pipes.

This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows a cement factory on the banks of Newtown Creek in New York. Just across the East River from Manhattan, within sight of the United Nations and shimmering midtown skyscrapers, tens of millions of gallons of pollution are awaiting cleanup in a neighborhood where working-class families have lived for generations and wealthier ones are moving in. Newtown Creek straddling Brooklyn and Queens is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press) This Oct. 24, 2012 photo shows a cement factory on the banks of Newtown Creek in New York. Just across the East River from Manhattan, within sight of the United Nations and shimmering midtown skyscrapers, tens of millions of gallons of pollution are awaiting cleanup in a neighborhood where working-class families have lived for generations and wealthier ones are moving in. Newtown Creek straddling Brooklyn and Queens is home to a federal Superfund site the size of 55 football fields. (AP Photo/Mary Altaffer) (Associated Press)

The city is working to reduce stormwater flow into the sewer system, with a plan to gradually divert it to porous street pavements, green rooftops and rain harvesting equipment. Now, the rainwater pouring into street drains ends up in antiquated pipes that receive both wastewater and sewage, overwhelming treatment plants. The overflow goes into city rivers and creeks like Newtown.

"It's never going to be pristine, the way it was 500 years ago," says Walter Mugdan, an EPA official overseeing the Superfund site. "But we can make it dramatically cleaner than it is now."

On the creek, nature survives — just barely, with egrets perched along the bulkheads and grass pushing up from defunct docks.

The cries of seagulls fill the air as they swoop over a junkyard that sells scrap metal to China. There's a lumber yard nearby, plus warehouses storing fruit and produce that feeds the city.

Neo Tanusakdi, left, serves a meal at The Bunker restaurant in New York, Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2013.  Located in an industrial Queens neighborhood adjacent to Newtown Creek, a federal Superfund site, the restaurant's owners follow rigorous practices to keep the air and water clean for their customers, including purifying the water used to cook the food. (AP Photo/Kathy Willens) (Associated Press) Neo Tanusakdi, left, serves a meal at The Bunker restaurant in New York, Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2013. Located in an industrial Queens neighborhood adjacent to Newtown Creek, a federal Superfund site, the restaurant's owners follow rigorous practices to keep the air and water clean for their customers, including purifying the water used to cook the food. (AP Photo/Kathy Willens) (Associated Press)

On the Queens side, an immigrant Vietnamese family just opened a small Asian restaurant called The Bunker, where they've installed air- and water-purifying devices "to create a healthy haven here, an oasis from the pollution in the neighborhood," says chef Jimmy Tu.

Until the 1990s, the gritty neighborhood was filled with Polish, Russian and Italian immigrants and their families.

With Manhattan property prices skyrocketing, a luxury waterfront community called Greenpoint Landing will start rising this summer near the East River mouth of Newtown Creek, 10 residential towers with 5,000 apartments, a marina, a retail complex and a prime view of the city.

A short walk away is a hulking brick building where rope was once braided for ships. It's been turned into space for entrepreneurs and artists who are among a new breed of locals.

Aaron Myers, an employee of North Sculpture Company peers out his fourth-story window overlooking Newtown Creek, a federal Superfund site opposite midtown Manhattan's skyline in New York, Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2013.  A regional administrator for the federal Environmental Protection Agency, says Newtown Creek Aaron Myers, an employee of North Sculpture Company peers out his fourth-story window overlooking Newtown Creek, a federal Superfund site opposite midtown Manhattan's skyline in New York, Wednesday, Feb. 20, 2013. A regional administrator for the federal Environmental Protection Agency, says Newtown Creek "is one of the most polluted urban water bodies in the world." (AP Photo/Kathy Willens) (Associated Press)

Newtown Creek is the story of New York's rich and poor — and the changing times, says Karl LaRocca, a 39-year-old printmaker.

When the oil refineries were booming, "the rich people were all living farther away and using this for their industry," he says. "Now we've had this reversal where the waterfront is this desirable property, and that's why they're cleaning up."

Copyright 2015, Deseret News Publishing Company