Scott G Winterton, Deseret News
Rep. Elizabeth Weight, D-West Valley City, discusses HB271, which would have precluded parents from defending themselves against child endangerment charges if they kick out a kid for being gay or transgender, during a hearing before the House Judiciary Committee at the Capitol in Salt Lake City on Monday, March 6, 2017. The bill stalled in a committee hearing Monday.
SALT LAKE CITY — A proposal that would have precluded parents from defending themselves against child endangerment charges if they kick out a kid for being LGBT stalled in a committee hearing Monday.
Lawmakers in a House committee meeting highlighted a wide array of concerns they had with the bill, including that it would push government regulation on families and that the legislation isn't needed.
HB271, sponsored by Rep. Elizabeth Weight, D-West Valley City, said she introduced the plan after learning from a Utah Division of Child and Family Services worker about the problem of LGBT youths in Utah getting kicked out of their homes.
Kristen Mitchell, who runs Youth Futures, one of the only youth homeless shelters in Utah, said about 35 percent of her shelter's residents are LGBT. But Mitchell said the reasons for being homeless aren't always related to sexual orientation.
Utah is the headquarters of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, which is among many faiths upholding theological opposition to same-sex relationships while attempting to foster an empathetic stance toward LGBT people.
The LDS Church created a revamped website on the topic last fall that told gay and lesbian members that attraction to people of the same sex is not a sin or a measure of their faithfulness and may never go away. But the church reminded them that having sex violates fundamental doctrinal beliefs that will not change.
The website, mormonandgay.lds.org, is designed to encourage compassion and acceptance for LGBT people and strike a softer tone on an issue that has led to criticism for the religion.
In addition to the LGBT community, Weight's bill also specified that parents couldn't use their kids' drug or alcohol use, friend groups or religious beliefs as defenses for kicking their child out of the house.
Despite widespread criticism from Republican lawmakers, it was House Minority Leader Brian King, D-Salt Lake City, who requested that HB271 not get a vote.
King said he recognized it was not going to pass, and he wanted to help the bill avoid getting "thrashed" by its opponents in order to encourage the sponsor to keep working on it.
comments on this story
"I think we need to make sure the parents know you can't just push a 15- or a 16-year-old child out of the nest and think that your responsibilities to them as their parent, in terms of support, financial responsibility, is over," King said.
Weight said LGBT can be a "red-flag word" in conservative Utah, but she plans to reintroduce the proposal next year.
"This seems to me like language that is very much needed to help protect LGBT children," said Neca Allgood, a Mormon from Syracuse who has a transgender child. "Homelessness is a particular problem for LGBT young people, and this language is part of what we need to do to help address that problem."