Tom Smart, Deseret News
PROVO — Over roughly 15 years, Provo resident John Wright has become an expert in treatment options for tumors.
When his youngest child, Natalie, was 2, the engineer and his wife noticed she was drooling a lot and had trouble swallowing. An MRI revealed that she had a walnut-sized tumor above her brain stem. Five days later, doctors removed most of the tumor but some pieces were inoperable and remained in the stem.
Over the next decade and a half, Natalie underwent two more operations. Her second surgery left her without the ability to swallow and without sight and hearing on her left side. She was also required to use a tracheostomy tube for four years.
Wright said cancer patients usually have three options for treatment: surgery, chemotherapy or radiation. Most children do not receive radiation because it may affect parts of their bodies that are still developing.
But early on, Wright became aware of proton therapy as a fourth option, a type of radiation that targets a specific spot instead of treating the wide area that X-ray radiation would. With only two facilities in the nation using it at the time, this was not an option for their family.
"As a dad, you kind of look for what are your choices," he said. "Each time you just hope that you’re trying to do the best you can.”
In 2014, the Wrights learned that Natalie's tumor had again grown. The growth of proton therapy clinics allowed Natalie to be treated at the Rady Children's Hospital at Scripps Proton Therapy Center in San Diego, which opened earlier this year. Natalie, 17, finished her final treatment last week.
“It was kind of the first time I actually understood, you know, the process of getting the tumor out," she said. "I was a little scared at first because, you know, I was kind of used to the neurosurgery process."
Natalie said she felt good overall through the six-week treatment. The tumor is still there, but Natalie, her parents and her doctor are hopeful they have stopped its growth. It will take up to five years for the family to find out whether proton therapy stopped the tumor's growth.
Natalie has a low-grade astrocytoma, or pressure tumor, just above her brain stem. Its growth can affect nerves that regulate her ability to swallow or move the left side of her body. Proton therapy pinpointed the tumor specifically, minimizing the risk that other tissue in her brain would be damaged.
Her physician, Andrew Chang, compared the difference between X-ray and proton therapy radiation to the difference between shooting a shotgun and a target rifle at a circle on the paper. Both will reach the area within the circle, but one is more focused in its impact.
"When we give radiation to a patient, the patient's body doesn't care if that radiation's coming from standard X-ray radiation or if it's coming from proton radiation. The body will react the same," he said. "The only difference would be that with the proton radiation I'm able to pinpoint that radiation better and not give as much or any radiation to those areas where I don't need to give that radiation to."
Although the proton therapy is beneficial for some, especially those with tumors near their brain stem or spinal cord, doctors say it is too soon to tell whether it is as effective or more effective than X-ray radiation in most other cases.
"The problem with proton therapy is in some ways it's still experimental," said Matthew Poppe, a radiation oncologist at Huntsman Cancer Institute.
- Missing oilfield worker's body found near Vernal
- Jenna Kim Jones: The new, cool face of Mormonism
- Was pregnancy rumor a factor in killing of...
- Chris and Sally Mart create a refuge for...
- We were there: See Deseret News front pages...
- Two men charged with vandalizing LDS church...
- Researchers: Patients have only themselves to...
- Friend says wrong-way driver 'wasn't in his...
- Utahns not as strongly opposed to... 80
- Love not attending Salt Lake City... 58
- Federal government extends same-sex... 37
- Autopsy shows man posed no threat to... 24
- Jenna Kim Jones: The new, cool face of... 20
- Police arrest 3 suspected of... 15
- Risque video shoots trigger... 14
- Housing recovery slowest since World... 12